Rachel M Kirpes1, Daniel Bonanno2, Nathaniel W May1, Matthew Fraund2, Anna J Barget1, Ryan C Moffet2, Andrew P Ault1,3, Kerri A Pratt1,4. 1. Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, United States. 2. Department of Chemistry, University of the Pacific, Stockton, California 95211, United States. 3. Department of Environmental Health Sciences, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, United States. 4. Department of Earth & Environmental Sciences, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, United States.
Abstract
The Arctic is experiencing the greatest warming on Earth, as most evident by rapid sea ice loss. Delayed sea ice freeze-up in the Alaskan Arctic is decreasing wintertime sea ice extent and changing marine biological activity. However, the impacts of newly open water on wintertime sea spray aerosol (SSA) production and atmospheric composition are unknown. Herein, we identify SSA, produced locally from open sea ice fractures (leads), as the dominant aerosol source in the coastal Alaskan Arctic during winter, highlighting the year-round nature of Arctic SSA emissions. Nearly all of the individual SSA featured thick organic coatings, consisting of marine saccharides, amino acids, fatty acids, and divalent cations, consistent with exopolymeric secretions produced as cryoprotectants by sea ice algae and bacteria. In contrast, local summertime SSA lacked these organic carbon coatings, or featured thin coatings, with only open water nearby. The individual SSA composition was not consistent with frost flowers or surface snow above sea ice, suggesting that neither hypothesized frost flower aerosolization nor blowing snow sublimation resulted in the observed SSA. These results further demonstrate the need for inclusion of lead-based SSA production in modeling of Arctic atmospheric composition. The identified connections between changing sea ice, microbiology, and SSA point to the significance of sea ice lead biogeochemistry in altering Arctic atmospheric composition, clouds, and climate feedbacks during winter.
The Arctic is experiencing the greatest warming on Earth, as most evident by rapid sea ice loss. Delayed sea ice freeze-up in the Alaskan Arctic is decreasing wintertime sea ice extent and changing marine biological activity. However, the impacts of newly open water on wintertime sea spray aerosol (SSA) production and atmospheric composition are unknown. Herein, we identify SSA, produced locally from open sea ice fractures (leads), as the dominant aerosol source in the coastalAlaskan Arctic during winter, highlighting the year-round nature of Arctic SSA emissions. Nearly all of the individual SSA featured thick organic coatings, consisting of marine saccharides, amino acids, fatty acids, and divalent cations, consistent with exopolymeric secretions produced as cryoprotectants by sea ice algae and bacteria. In contrast, local summertime SSA lacked these organic carbon coatings, or featured thin coatings, with only open water nearby. The individual SSA composition was not consistent with frost flowers or surface snow above sea ice, suggesting that neither hypothesized frost flower aerosolization nor blowing snow sublimation resulted in the observed SSA. These results further demonstrate the need for inclusion of lead-based SSA production in modeling of Arctic atmospheric composition. The identified connections between changing sea ice, microbiology, and SSA point to the significance of sea ice lead biogeochemistry in altering Arctic atmospheric composition, clouds, and climate feedbacks during winter.
With rapidly declining Arctic sea ice
extent and increasing open
water,[1] sea spray aerosol (SSA) emissions
are predicted to be increasing.[2] Notably,
even wintertime coastal sea ice in the Arctic is drastically decreasing
as a result of sea ice freeze-up delays in the Bering, Chukchi, Barents,
and East Greenland Seas.[3] Thick multiyear
sea ice is being replaced by thinner first-year ice, which is more
susceptible to fracturing and forming leads, open areas of water surrounded
by ice.[4] During Arctic winter, fresh (nascent)
SSA comprises a significant aerosol fraction: up to 40% and 25% of
supermicron and submicron aerosol mass,[5] and up to 90% and 50% of supermicron and submicron aerosol number,
respectively.[6] While wintertime SSA was
previously thought to primarily be transported long distances to the
Arctic,[5] recent work showed that leads
contribute to local Arctic SSA emissions year-round.[7]SSA composition reflects the surface seawater,[8,9] which
is expected to be altered by changing marine productivity in the warming
Arctic.[10] In the open ocean, SSA particles
are primarily generated by wave breaking processes resulting in bubble
bursting at the ocean surface, creating film and jet drops that form
SSA.[11] Wind-driven wave breaking processes
also produce SSA in leads, at lower concentrations than in open water
due to the reduced fetch.[7,12−14] Supermicron SSA particles (>1 μm; 2 μm number mode)
are primarily inorganic salts but can also contain organic matter.[11] These inorganic salts are hygroscopic, with
a high efficiency of forming cloud droplets.[11] Submicron SSA particles (<1 μm; ∼200 nm number mode)
can be significantly enriched in organic matter (>50%, by mass)
in
comparison to bulk seawater.[9,15] SSA organic coatings
can inhibit heterogeneous reactions of trace gases, inhibiting particulate
chloride depletion, and impacting trace gas budgets and atmospheric
composition.[16] However, recent work has
shown that surfactant coatings on SSA can actually enhance certain
reactions.[17] Laboratory studies with ambient
seawater also show suppression of SSA hygroscopicity by certain organics,
potentially altering cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activity.[18,19] Enhanced cloud ice nucleation efficiency is observed for Arctic
seawater, suggesting a contribution of SSA to cloud ice formation.[20−22] Despite important climate implications for cloud formation and phase,
and associated longwave radiative forcing,[23] limited knowledge exists regarding ambient SSA organic coatings
and the transfer of marine biogenic organics to the particle phase,[8] particularly for Arctic winter.While previous
studies have primarily focused on marine biological
activity during the Arctic summer, recent work has shown that microalgal
growth is initiated prior to the spring phytoplankton bloom period
and under extremely low light conditions under sea ice,[24,25] including during sea ice covered periods.[26,27] The sea ice algae and bacteria present produce exopolymeric substances
(EPS) as a cryoprotectant,[28,29] with phytoplankton
releasing it extensively.[30] Production
of EPS is critical to sea ice algae survival through the winter.[31,32] Indeed, EPS have been observed in winter in both sea ice[27,33] and seawater.[33] In the high Arctic, aerosols
produced from laboratory bubbling experiments in the summer pack ice
showed enrichment of EPS-derived polysaccharides relative to the seawater
surface microlayer (SML),[34] with microgels
and EPS-derived compounds also observed in the ambient aerosols.[35] However, there is a critical knowledge gap in
our understanding of wintertime aerosol sources and composition in
the changing Arctic,[6] particularly with
increasing open water.[3] Therefore, atmospheric
particles were collected near Utqiaġvik, Alaska, in January
andFebruary 2014 for individual particle measurements of morphology,
elemental composition, spatial distribution and quantity of organic
material, and organic functional groups associated with marine biogenic
compounds. This novel detailed characterization of individual SSA,
and associated organic material, significantly improves our knowledge
of Arctic SSA and connections to sea ice microbiology at a time of
year when few aerosol measurements exist.
Results and Discussion
SSA Production
from Open Leads
Atmospheric particles
were collected at Utqiaġvik, Alaska, an Arctic coastalsite
during January andFebruary 2014. The sampling site was located ∼5
km inland and ∼60 km downwind of the sea ice leads (Figure ). A total of 1691
individual particles (0.32–0.56 and 1.0–1.8 μm
aerodynamic diameter, da) from six sample
periods (January 24–27 andFebruary 26–27, 2014) were
analyzed by computer-controlled scanning electron microscopy with
energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (CCSEM-EDX) to determine individual
particle morphology and elemental composition. Nearly all (86% of
submicron and >99% of supermicron particles, by number) of the
collected
particles were identified as SSA (Figure S1), consistent with our previous measurements during this study.[6] For the samples herein, 75%, by number, of SSA
particles were classified as nascent, based on the presence of Na
and Cl in ratios similar to seawater.[6] An
additional 25%, by number, of the SSA particles were classified as
partially aged based on the simultaneous enrichment of S and/or N
and depletion of Cl, relative to seawater, and consistent with long-range
transport.[6] Given local Arctic production
of nascent SSA,[7] the sources and composition
of the nascent SSA are the focus of this study.
Figure 1
Observations of open
leads and wintertime SSA composition. (a)
MODIS satellite imagery from February 26, 2014 (NASA Worldview) shows
open leads near Utqiaġvik, Alaska. Locations of the town, NOAA
Observatory, and aerosol sampling location are shown. The black line
shows 8 h of a NOAA HYSPLIT backward air mass trajectory (February
26, 2014 20:00 AKST; 50 m altitude at the sampling site) passing over
the closest open leads before arriving at the site. The air mass traveled
∼60 km from open leads to the northeast. (b) CCSEM-EDX average
individual sub- and supermicron SSA particle elemental mole ratios
compared to literature values for seawater.[40] Error bars denote 95% confidence intervals.
Observations of open
leads and wintertime SSA composition. (a)
MODIS satellite imagery from February 26, 2014 (NASA Worldview) shows
open leads near Utqiaġvik, Alaska. Locations of the town, NOAA
Observatory, and aerosol sampling location are shown. The black line
shows 8 h of a NOAA HYSPLIT backward air mass trajectory (February
26, 2014 20:00 AKST; 50 m altitude at the sampling site) passing over
the closest open leads before arriving at the site. The air mass traveled
∼60 km from open leads to the northeast. (b) CCSEM-EDX average
individual sub- and supermicron SSA particle elemental mole ratios
compared to literature values for seawater.[40] Error bars denote 95% confidence intervals.SSA production from open leads is supported by the presence of
nearby open leads on all sampling days; the closest upwind leads were
within 4 h of atmospheric transport time to the sampling site, according
to satellite and local sea ice imagery, combined with backward air
mass trajectories (Figure , Figure S2). In recent years,
open leads have persisted throughout the winter near Utqiaġvik.[7,36−39] Consistent with lead-based SSA production at elevated wind speeds
(>4 m s–1),[7,12−14] all samples were collected during periods of wind speeds greater
than or equal to 4 m s–1 (average wind speeds of
6–12 m s–1), and four samples were collected
during sustained periods of high wind speeds (6–17 m s–1) (Table S1). While nascent
SSA particles were observed in all samples, the samples with the greatest
number fractions of nascent SSA relative to partially aged SSA had
the greatest near-surface (<70 m above sea level) air mass transport
over the ice-fractured Arctic Ocean.[6] All
samples had air mass back trajectories influenced by the central Arctic
Ocean, as shown in previous work.[6] Average
elemental mole ratios of S/Na and Cl/Na for individual sub- and supermicron
SSA particles were similar to seawater ratios (Figure ), as discussed in the Supporting Information.[40] These
elemental ratios have been observed previously for laboratory-generated
SSA[9] and are consistent with aerosol production
from the nearby open leads.[7,13] Based on the low concentrations
of sulfur- andnitrogen-containing trace gases in the winter Arctic,[41] nascent SSA in the sub- and supermicron size
ranges could be transported from these leads with little influence
from multiphase aging reactions altering particle chemical composition.
At high wind speeds, blowing snow and frost flowers have also been
hypothesized to result in lofted SSA.[42,43] However, the
measured sub- and supermicron SSA elemental ratios are not consistent
with simultaneously measured sea ice surface snow or previous measurements
of frost flowers (Table S3),[44] as discussed in the Supporting Information. Particles produced by sublimation of blowing snow
or aerosolization of frost flowers are suggested to be distinguished
from nascent SSA based on chemical composition, characterized by sulfur
depletion compared to seawater, due to mirabilite precipitation impacting
brine migration through frost flowers and snow above sea ice.[44−46] However, during this study, there was no dependence of individual
SSA S/Na mole ratios on wind speed (Figure S3), a trend which would be expected for a wind-dependent blowing snow
or frost flower source. This is consistent with recent work demonstrating
that frost flowers are unlikely to produce aerosol under high wind
conditions.[47,48]Overall, the measured individual
SSA particles were closest in
composition to seawater and the measured tundra surface snow (Table S3), as discussed in the Supporting Information. This is in part due to the high variability
in the measured values of the tundra surface snow (Table S3), but it is also consistent with SSA deposition to
the tundra snowpack following transport from the upwind sea ice region
containing leads. The submicron SSA particles showed calcium andmagnesium
enrichment above the seawater ratio (Figure and Table S3),
consistent with the presence of EPS as assembled gels bound by divalent
cations (Ca2+; Mg2+).[49,50] As discussed in the following sections, the observed organic coatings,
size-dependent trends in C/Na ratios, and organic composition further
support the presence of EPS and a wave-breaking seawater source for
the observed SSA. Overall, the measured nascent SSA composition is
consistent with SSA production from local open sea ice leads, rather
than blowing snow, as previously observed through multiyear bulk aerosol
measurements at Utqiaġvik from fall–spring.[7] Our observation herein further highlights the
year-round nature of SSA emissions in the Alaskan Arctic from open
water, including leads.
Abundance of Organic Material in SSA
Carbon was observed
in over 98% of the nascent SSA particles, by number, and was typically
observed as a coating on the salt particles (Figure a,b). Individual SSA particles with similar morphology and organic
coatings were previously observed during spring in the Norwegian Sea.[51] Previous bulk aerosol measurements at Utqiaġvik
also showed organic mass to be correlated with sea salt during winter.[52] We demonstrate through single-particle analyses
that these organics are present as sea salt coatings. The individual
nascent SSA particles contained substantial amounts of carbon, with
average atomic percentages of carbon of 15 ± 8% and 6 ±
5% for submicron and supermicron SSA, respectively. These particles
were also significantly enriched in carbon relative to seawater, with
C/Na ratios of 0.52 ± 0.07 and 0.30 ± 0.05 for submicron
and supermicron SSA, respectively, compared to 0.01 for seawater (Figure ).[40] Significant supermicron SSA C/Na enrichments (0.8 ±
0.3) have also previously been observed in the Antarctic during winter.[53] Analysis of 150 SSA particles by scanning transmission
X-ray microscopy with near edge X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy
(STXM-NEXAFS) showed over 90%, by number, contained organic carbon
(detected as the −COOH functional group), consistent with the
CCSEM-EDX results (Table S2). Notably,
no organic gel-like particles[54] without
inorganic salts were observed. For all particles measured here (>100
nm), all submicron organic carbon was either coating SSA particles
(Figures S1 and S4), consistent with midlatitude
SSA studies,[9] or internally mixed with
anthropogenic secondary sulfate.[6] Given
the calcium enrichment in the wintertime submicron SSA and thick organic
coatings, these results are consistent with assembled gel coatings
surrounding inorganic sea salt cores.
Figure 2
Organic coatings observed on wintertime
sea spray aerosol (SSA)
particles. (a) SEM image with a 3 μm scale bar shown and (b)
EDX spectra of a representative SSA particle with a cubic salt core
(blue) and organic coating (green). *Al and Si signal contributions
are from the sampler holder and substrate, respectively. (c) Average
relative elemental (mole) fractions for all 773 submicron and 918
supermicron nascent SSA particles (CCSEM-EDX). (d) Representative
STXM-NEXAFS image showing organic volume fraction spatial distribution
within individual SSA particles, with a 5 μm scale bar shown.
(e) Histogram of 150 individual SSA particle organic volume fractions
(STXM-NEXAFS).
Organic coatings observed on wintertime
sea spray aerosol (SSA)
particles. (a) SEM image with a 3 μm scale bar shown and (b)
EDX spectra of a representative SSA particle with a cubic salt core
(blue) and organic coating (green). *Al andSisignal contributions
are from the sampler holder and substrate, respectively. (c) Average
relative elemental (mole) fractions for all 773 submicron and 918
supermicron nascent SSA particles (CCSEM-EDX). (d) Representative
STXM-NEXAFS image showing organic volume fraction spatial distribution
within individual SSA particles, with a 5 μm scale bar shown.
(e) Histogram of 150 individual SSA particle organic volume fractions
(STXM-NEXAFS).The average individual SSA organic
volume fractions for each sample
ranged from 0.41 to 0.47 (Table S2), with
little variation across the time periods and particle size ranges
analyzed. As shown in Figure , the majority of SSA particles (71%, by number) had organic
volume fractions between 0.3 and 0.5, consistent with organic volume
fractions (0.2–0.5) observed for SSA produced in midlatitude
algal bloom mesocosm experiments.[18,55] Notably, 26%
of the SSA particles analyzed by STXM-NEXAFS had organic volume fractions
of 0.5 or greater. Particles with lower organic volume fractions (<0.2)
were inorganic salts with thin organic coatings, whereas particles
with higher organic volume fractions (>0.2) had thick organic coatings
around inorganic salt cores (Figure ). Based on the average individual SSA particle measured
organic volume fraction of 0.45, the average coating thickness was
calculated to be ∼0.04 and ∼0.13 μm for the median
submicron (0.44 μm) and supermicron (1.4 μm) particle
aerodynamic diameters analyzed, respectively.For comparison
to the wintertime SSA described herein, SSA particles
were also collected at the same site near Utqiaġvik during
September 2015, when the nearest sea ice was >400 km upwind. Meteorological
conditions, including wind speeds, were similar during the winter
(Table S1) and summer[56] studies. To compare the enrichment of organics in SSA between
winter and summer, individual SSA particle carbon/sodium (C/Na) ratios
were determined by SEM-EDX for ∼150 particles. Overall, the
winter SSA particles had statistically greater C/Na ratios (range
0.2–1.2; median 0.6) compared to the summer SSA particles (range
0.1–0.3; median 0.2) (Figure a). The higher carbon content observed in the winter
SSA is consistent with the measured ratios of organic coating thickness
relative to the salt core diameter, as determined by SEM-EDX, which
showed statistically thicker coatings for winter compared to the summer
SSA particles (Figure b). The coating thickness to salt core diameter analysis of the winter
SSA is in agreement with the thick organic coatings observed by STXM-NEXAFS
(Figure d,e). 78%
of winter SSA particles had coating to core ratios greater than 0.4,
compared to the summer SSA samples, which showed 57%, by number, to
have coating to core ratios of 0.1 or less (Figure b). Together these measurements show that
the organic coatings of winter SSA particles, sampled near Utqiaġvik,
Alaska, were much thicker than the organic coatings on the summer
SSA particles, indicating an important unique source of SSA organic
content during winter. This is consistent with previous work, showing
through bulk measurements that organic mass was higher in the winter
near Utqiaġvik and correlated with sea salt aerosol.[52] Given the lack of nearby sea ice in the summer
near Utqiaġvik, we suggest that sea ice algae, bacteria, and
phytoplankton contribute to the thick SSA organic coatings observed
in winter when these microorganisms use EPS in great quantities as
a cryoprotectant.[27−31] Therefore, the molecular composition of the winter SSA organic content
was investigated to probe this hypothesis.
Figure 3
Comparison of SSA organic
coatings observed in winter and summer.
(a) Box and whisker plot (90th/10th percentiles, 75th/25th percentiles,
and medians) of C/Na ratios determined for individual SSA particles
in winter and summer. C/Na distributions for winter and summer SSA
particles were significantly different (Kolmogorov–Smirnov
test, p = 2.0010 × 10–27).
(b) Histogram of measured organic coating to salt core diameter ratios
determined from SEM images for winter (77 particles) and summer (82
particles) SSA particles on aluminum foil substrates. A two-sample
Kolmogorov–Smirnov test showed that the two distributions were
not from the same underlying population (p = 5.28
× 10–14).
Comparison of SSA organic
coatings observed in winter and summer.
(a) Box and whisker plot (90th/10th percentiles, 75th/25th percentiles,
and medians) of C/Na ratios determined for individual SSA particles
in winter and summer. C/Na distributions for winter and summer SSA
particles were significantly different (Kolmogorov–Smirnov
test, p = 2.0010 × 10–27).
(b) Histogram of measured organic coating to salt core diameter ratios
determined from SEM images for winter (77 particles) and summer (82
particles) SSA particles on aluminum foil substrates. A two-sample
Kolmogorov–Smirnov test showed that the two distributions were
not from the same underlying population (p = 5.28
× 10–14).
Molecular Characterization of SSA Organic Content
To
determine the chemical composition of the SSA organic coatings, 88
submicron and 212 supermicron individual SSA particles were analyzed
with Raman microspectroscopy. Similar organic composition was observed
for the sub- and supermicron SSA particles, and for all sampling periods.
The organic compound classes present included saccharides (monosaccharides,
polysaccharides, and lipopolysaccharides), short-chain fatty acids
(anddicarboxylic acids), surfactant long-chain fatty acids (and lipids
and phospholipids), and amino acids, with representative individual
SSA spectra shown in Figure a. Raman peak assignments and χ2 fitting
with SML standards are given in the Supporting Information (Table S4 and Figure S7).[19] Fluorescence microscopy confirmed the presence of fluorescing biological
organic material[57] in the individual wintertime
SSA particles (Figure S5).
Figure 4
Marine-derived organic
compound types observed in individual wintertime
SSA particles. (a) Raman spectra of four representative individual
SSA particles matching marine-derived saccharides (χ2 = 0.013), amino acids (χ2 = 0.011), short-chain
fatty acids (χ2 = 0.003), and long-chain fatty acids
(χ2 = 0.0005), respectively. (b) Number fractions
(and associated standard errors) of 300 individual SSA particles containing
saccharides, amino acids, short-chain fatty acids, and/or long-chain
fatty acids. Each SSA particle Raman spectrum was allowed to be fitted
to up to two organic compound types, following the method of Cochran
et al.[19]
Marine-derived organic
compound types observed in individual wintertime
SSA particles. (a) Raman spectra of four representative individual
SSA particles matching marine-derived saccharides (χ2 = 0.013), amino acids (χ2 = 0.011), short-chain
fatty acids (χ2 = 0.003), and long-chain fatty acids
(χ2 = 0.0005), respectively. (b) Number fractions
(and associated standard errors) of 300 individual SSA particles containing
saccharides, amino acids, short-chain fatty acids, and/or long-chain
fatty acids. Each SSA particle Raman spectrum was allowed to be fitted
to up to two organic compound types, following the method of Cochran
et al.[19]Saccharides and short-chain fatty acids were the most commonly
observed marine biogenic organic compound classes present in the SSA
particles, with 49% of individual SSA particle Raman spectra containing
at least one saccharide (Figure b). Saccharides observed, particularly xylose, fucose,
andglucose, are major components of EPS.[34,51,54] The monosaccharides observed are similar
to that of the SML, as well as bulk ambient aerosol and aerosols produced
from laboratory bubbling experiments in the summer high Arctic pack
ice.[34,35] In prior studies during spring over the
Norwegian Sea, individual SSA particles with organic coatings were
characterized by STXM-NEXAFS as having a prominent carboxylic acid
peak (as observed here), which was attributed to polysaccharides from
the SML.[51] Saccharides have also previously
been observed in bulk Arctic aerosol samples during spring over the
Norwegian Sea,[58,59] summer in the Canadian[60] and high[35] Arctic,
and winter near Utqiaġvik.[52]Similar to saccharides, long-chain fatty acid surfactants and amino
acids were also commonly observed in the winter SSA coatings. 32%
of individual SSA particle Raman spectra contained at least one short-chain
fatty acid, while long-chain fatty acids and amino acids were present
in 21% and 9% of SSA particles, by number, respectively (Figure ). Amino acids andfatty acids have previously been observed in the SML of open leads
in the summer high Arctic[61,62] and in bulk ambient
aerosols during spring–summer in the Canadian Arctic[60,63] and during spring–fall at Svalbard.[64,65] Notably, all SSA particles containing amino acids also contained
saccharides, and most particles (75%, by number) containing one short-chain
fatty acidalso contained a saccharidesignature. Only 33% of particles
matching saccharides did not contain any other organic type. For the
particles containing surfactants, including long-chain fatty acids,
40% matched only long-chain fatty acids, while the other 60% also
contained short-chain fatty acids or saccharides. Since saccharides,
amino acids, andfatty acids are EPS components,[34,51,54] the presence of these compounds together
in the individual SSA organic coatings is consistent with incorporation
during the bubble bursting aerosol formation process due to enrichment
in the SML of sea ice leads.
Atmospheric Implications
In this
study, we identified
abundant wintertime SSA thickly coated by marine biogenic organic
carbon, with signatures consistent with EPS produced as a cryoprotectant
by sea ice algae and bacteria. This study was conducted soon after
polar sunrise, in line with recent unexpected evidence of sea ice
biological activity under low light conditions in the Arctic.[24,32,66] The measured SSA chemical composition
is consistent with Arctic lead-based aerosol production, illustrating
the connections between sea ice fracturing, marine biological activity,
EPS, and SSA production in the winter Arctic. This finding further
highlights the year-round nature of Arctic SSA emissions and identifies
a need for further studies of wintertime sea ice microbiology in the
Alaskan Arctic. The observed SSA particles were similar in composition
to seawater and demonstrated a size dependence in organic enrichment
and coatings, as previously observed for particles produced via bubble
bursting at the ocean surface. Open sea ice leads enriched in EPS
are identified as leading to organic enrichment in wintertime SSA.
Alternative hypotheses for SSA production, including blowing snow
and frost flowers,[42,43] were determined to be unlikely
sources, based on the individual particle composition, and the consistency
of the observed size-dependent trends and composition to those in
lower latitude SSA.[8,9] To our knowledge, Arctic chemical
transport modeling has not yet included leads as a possible SSA source,
but our findings, combined with those from the summertime High Arctic
pack ice,[12,13] demonstrate the need for consideration of
lead-based SSA production in future modeling studies.The Arctic
is currently changing at an unprecedented rate,[1] with winter warming events rapidly increasing.[23] Resulting sea ice loss is expanding first year
sea ice,[1] which is prone to fracturing
and expected to result in increasing SSA emissions.[2] Notably, delayed sea ice freeze-up in the Bering, Chukchi,
Barents, and East Greenland Seas is dramatically decreasing sea ice
extent in these regions[3] and increasing
marine biological activity,[10,25,32] impacting SSA emissions and organic content. SSA organic coatings
can reduce reactivity toward trace gases, such as nitric acid, thereby
impacting atmospheric composition[16] and
Arctic haze formation.[67] Organic coatings
can also reduce SSA hygroscopicity[19] and
CCN efficiency[18] and may contribute to
cloud ice nucleation,[20] which impacts cloud
formation in the often CCN-limited Arctic.[68] Cloud-aerosol feedbacks are especially important in the Arctic winter
when there is little to no direct solar radiation; clouds trap longwave
radiation near the surface and contribute to warming, with increasing
sensitivity to clouds projected for the fall–winter.[23,69] Therefore, additional studies are critical to quantify and upscale
the details of, and connections between, changing Arctic microbiology,
EPS production, SSA production, atmospheric composition, and cloud
feedbacks in the winter.
Methods
Atmospheric particles were
collected near Utqiaġvik (Barrow),
AK during January 24–27 andFebruary 26–27, 2014, at
a tundra site ∼5 km inland (71.17° N, 156.38° W),
at a sampling height ∼1.5 m above ground level. Sample collection
times and meteorological parameters, measured at the NOAA Barrow Observatory
located 5 km upwind across flat tundra, are provided in the Supporting
Information (Table S1). Particles were
collected using a 10-stage rotating micro-orifice uniform deposit
impactor (MOUDI, model 110, MSP Corp.) sampling at 30 L min–1 through a 10 μm cut point cyclone (URG-2000-30EA). Particles
were impacted on silicon substrates (Ted Pella, Inc.) andaluminum
foil substrates (MSP Corp.) for analysis by SEM-EDX, quartz substrates
(Ted Pella, Inc.) for analysis by Raman microspectroscopy, and transmission
electron microscopy (TEM) grids (Carbon Type-B Formvar film copper
grids, Ted Pella, Inc.) for analysis by STXM-NEXAFS. Samples were
stored frozen at −15 °C prior to analysis. Particles collected
on two MOUDI stages with 50% size cuts of 1.8 and 0.56 μm da, respectively, were analyzed in this work.For comparison to the winter SSA SEM-EDX analysis, atmospheric
particles were collected at the same location during September 15–16
and 23–24, 2015. Samples were collected for ∼8 h each
using a three-stage microanalysis particle sampler (MPS, California
Measurements, Inc.) with aluminum foil substrates (MSP Corp.) on stages
1 and 2 (2.8–5.0 and 0.50–2.8 μm, respectively)
and TEM grids (Carbon Type-B Formvar film copper grids, Ted Pella,
Inc.) on stage 3 (0.07–0.40 μm). Additional sampling
details are described by Gunsch et al.[56]Individual particle analysis by computer-controlled SEM-EDX
(CCSEM-EDX)
was conducted using an FEI Nova 200 nanolab SEM/FIB operating at 15
kV accelerating voltage with a secondary electron detector. X-ray
spectra from elements with atomic numbers greater than Be (Z > 4) were detected with an EDX detector (EDAX, Inc.).
For each substrate collected during the six winter sample periods,
∼75–150 particles were analyzed by CCSEM-EDX to measure
individual particle morphology (particle projected area, average diameter,
and perimeter) and relative abundance of the following elements: C,
N, O, Na, Mg, S, Cl, K, Ca, Ti, Fe, andZn.[70] EDX has previously been shown to quantitatively reproduce SSA elemental
ratios.[9] Carbon was below the detection
limit on the Si wafer without particles, indicating that substrate
contamination from C was not present in the particle spectra (Figure S6). EDX can be slightly less sensitive
to C, N, and O, compared to heavier elements, such that the C, N,
and O percentages reported here represent lower limits.[70] Particle types present were determined by k-means clustering of the EDX spectra using a previously
established method.[71]SEM images
of particles collected on aluminum foil substrates were
used to measure individual SSA particle coating to core ratios for
77 winter particles from January 24, 2014, as well as 82 summer SSA
particles collected at the same sampling location on September 16,
2015.[56] SEM images of each sample were
analyzed using ImageJ to determine the inorganic (bright core) and
organic (dark coating) areas of each individual SSA particle (Figure S8). The coating (primarily organic) to
core (primarily inorganic) ratio was calculated by dividing the inorganic
core area by the organic coating area.Individual particles
were analyzed by Raman microspectroscopy using
a Horiba Scientific Labram HR Evolution spectrometer coupled with
a confocal optical microscope (100× numerical aperture (N.A.)
0.9 Olympus objective), Nd:YAG laser (50 mW, 532 nm), and CCD detector
using a 600 groove mm–1 diffraction grating. Individual
particle Raman spectra were collected over the 550–4000 cm–1 range, with a spectral resolution of ∼1.8
cm–1, according to a previously established method.[72] Raman spectra of 88 submicron (0.32–0.56
μm da stage) and 212 supermicron
(1.0–1.8 μm da stage) sampled
SSA particles, identified based on morphology using the optical microscope,
were compared to Raman spectra of ∼50 standard organic compounds
(Table S4), including saccharides, short-chain
fatty acids, long-chain fatty acids, and amino acids representative
of species present in the marine SML.[19] Linear combinations of up to two model Raman spectra (e.g., 69%
galactose + 31% succinic acid) were fitted to ambient SSA Raman spectra
following the method of Cochran et al.[19] Therefore, each particle spectrum could match to up to two organic
compound types, for example, sucrose + fucose (saccharide + saccharide)
or galactose + succinic acid (saccharide + short-chain fatty acid).
Model linear combinations and ambient SSA spectra were compared by
calculating χ2 values over the 800–1800 and
2600–3600 cm–1 ranges. This analysis provides
a value between zero (spectra are identical) and one (spectra have
no correlation). Particle spectra matching each organic compound type
were characterized by unique peaks corresponding to specific organic
functional groups in the 850–1650 and 2700–3500 cm–1 regions (Table S5).[53] Further discussion of peak assignments and χ2 best fit analysis is included in the Supporting Information. The organic compounds corresponding
to the best χ2 fit (smallest value) between model
linear combinations and the ambient SSA spectrum are reported.STXM-NEXAFS analysis was conducted on approximately 150 particles
total from the 1.0–1.8 and 0.32–0.56 μm size ranges
from two periods (January 26 11:00–17:15 AKST andFebruary
26–27 19:45–8:30 AKST). Beamline 5.3.2.2 at the Advanced
Light Source at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley, CA)
was used for STXM-NEXAFS analysis in a He filled chamber (∼200
Torr) of individual particles over the carbon K-edge (278–320
eV), following the method of Moffet et al.[73] The pre- and postedge optical densities at the carbon K-edge were
used to determine the inorganic and organic portions of particles.[73] X-ray absorption at 288.6 eV, corresponding
to the −COOH functional group, served as an indicator of organic
carbon.[73] The thicknesses of inorganic
(NaCl) and organic portions were determined using the optical densities,
calculated atomic cross sections for organic (adipic acid) and inorganic
(sodium chloride) components, and assumed densities (ρOC = 1.35 g cm–3, ρNaCl = 2.16 g
cm–3).[18] The organic
volume fraction for each particle was calculated as the thickness
of the organic portion over the total thickness of organic and inorganic
portions.[18,55]
Safety Statement
No unexpected or
unusually high safety
hazards were encountered in this work.
Authors: Andrew P Ault; Thomas M Peters; Eric J Sawvel; Gary S Casuccio; Robert D Willis; Gary A Norris; Vicki H Grassian Journal: Environ Sci Technol Date: 2012-04-04 Impact factor: 9.028
Authors: Theodore W Wilson; Luis A Ladino; Peter A Alpert; Mark N Breckels; Ian M Brooks; Jo Browse; Susannah M Burrows; Kenneth S Carslaw; J Alex Huffman; Christopher Judd; Wendy P Kilthau; Ryan H Mason; Gordon McFiggans; Lisa A Miller; Juan J Nájera; Elena Polishchuk; Stuart Rae; Corinne L Schiller; Meng Si; Jesús Vergara Temprado; Thomas F Whale; Jenny P S Wong; Oliver Wurl; Jacqueline D Yakobi-Hancock; Jonathan P D Abbatt; Josephine Y Aller; Allan K Bertram; Daniel A Knopf; Benjamin J Murray Journal: Nature Date: 2015-09-10 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Mónica V Orellana; Patricia A Matrai; Caroline Leck; Carlton D Rauschenberg; Allison M Lee; Esther Coz Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2011-08-08 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Patricia K Quinn; Douglas B Collins; Vicki H Grassian; Kimberly A Prather; Timothy S Bates Journal: Chem Rev Date: 2015-04-06 Impact factor: 60.622
Authors: Farshid Mashayekhy Rad; Javier Zurita; Philippe Gilles; Laurens A J Rutgeerts; Ulrika Nilsson; Leopold L Ilag; Caroline Leck Journal: J Am Soc Mass Spectrom Date: 2018-07-17 Impact factor: 3.109
Authors: Adam Milsom; Adam M Squires; Isabel Quant; Nicholas J Terrill; Steven Huband; Ben Woden; Edna R Cabrera-Martinez; Christian Pfrang Journal: J Phys Chem A Date: 2022-09-28 Impact factor: 2.944