| Literature DB >> 31806609 |
Kate Kerber1, Fariba Kolahdooz1, Meeka Otway1, Melinda Laboucan1, Se Lim Jang1, Sue Lawrence1, Suzanne Aronyk1, Matthew Quinn2, Stephanie Irlbacher-Fox3, Crystal Milligan4, Sabrina Broadhead5, Debbie DeLancey3, Andre Corriveau5, Sangita Sharma6.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: This paper explores patient experiences and identifies barriers and opportunities for improving access to healthcare for patients from the Canadian north who travel to receive medical care in a Southern province.Entities:
Keywords: healthcare access; healthcare services; medical travel; northern Canada; patient experience
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31806609 PMCID: PMC6924833 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-030885
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Self-reported characteristics of study participants, n=52
| N | % | |
| Age group (years) | ||
| 18–24 | 2 | 3.8 |
| 25–44 | 11 | 21.2 |
| 45–64 | 27 | 51.9 |
| 65+ | 12 | 23.1 |
| Gender | ||
| Male | 29 | 55.8 |
| Female | 23 | 44.2 |
| Ethnicity | ||
| First Nations | 20 | 38.5 |
| Inuit | 10 | 19.2 |
| Métis | 4 | 7.7 |
| Non-Indigenous | 18 | 34.6 |
| Education (highest level attained) | ||
| Less than high school diploma | 19 | 36.5 |
| High school diploma | 10 | 19.2 |
| Some postsecondary | 5 | 9.6 |
| Postsecondary degree or diploma | 18 | 34.6 |
Figure 1A medical travel journey.
Figure 2Satisfaction with most recent healthcare visit.
Figure 3The main difficulty related to medical travel.
Themes arising from interviews with key informants, medical travellers, patient escorts, and focus group discussions
| Opportunities to improve access and experience | Participant quotes | Proposed solutions | |
| Access to services | (1) Improve information and logistics prior to travel | It’s like traveling to a foreign country, like hearing that you’re going to go to India tomorrow. You wouldn’t even be worried about the procedure; you’d be worried whether all of the things that you’ve heard are true. What will I eat? Do I have the right clothes? And the airport security? That even makes me nervous. (key informant, 305) |
Increase awareness and distribution of existing medical travel information. Provide information to travellers and medical travel staff on various medical travel scenarios, and what to expect on arrival. Develop user-friendly communication methods and materials regarding itinerary and flight options. |
| You come inside at the [local university hospital] and there’s a big rush. You need to ask someone where reception is…. Some of the reception areas [in the hospital] are bigger than most health centres in the communities. And that’s intimidating, especially to older people, Elders. An Elder doesn’t want to get lost. (focus group, 352) | |||
| (2) Increase effective communication between services | The people who are in charge of the medical travel have the power to decide if you are going or not for medical.…If the medical travel staff say no, then you don’t get sent out…I was told by the Doctor that I needed to go for MRI and I ended up not going and it was never explained why I didn't end up going. (focus group, 351) |
Enhance connections between healthcare providers, administrators and community organisations providing care and support to medical travellers to raise awareness about the various services available. Spread awareness among local service providers about medical travel and the services available in home communities and in medical travel destinations. | |
| [My community’s] problem is the doctors kept changing month to month. It was confusing patients. One would send for this test; one would send for that test. There was no steady [person]. So when the doctors [in Edmonton] ask, ‘you got a physician back at home?’ you laugh. (focus group, 352) | |||
| (3) Reduce jurisdictional and bureaucratic barriers | Homecare is not reciprocally billed, and palliative care is not an insured service, and long-term care access is not assured by the contracts that we currently have. … [If a patient from the North is] down here and needs long-term care access, our only resource is to repatriate them to the nearest hospital, and they start the process from the North. This becomes a problem…but we do try to cobble together some things. (key informant, 120) |
Clarify protocol for out-of-province patients with frontline staff and healthcare providers. Ensure jurisdictional issues do not become barriers to patient care. | |
| …[S]ome of the healthcare professionals get very disgruntled with you if you don’t have a [provincial health] card…[We hear,] ‘No you can’t get in to see this particular person because you don't have Alberta healthcare.’ (key informant, 607) | |||
| (4) Reduce the financial burden | While back home all the medication was paid for, here we have to wait for reimbursement. I don't understand that some medications you have to pay [for] and not some others. (medical traveler, 3505) |
Ensure that medical travellers are aware of coverage restrictions and policies and have access to funds locally. Communicate potential for out-of-pocket costs associated with care and medications and provide financial support options for medical travel. | |
| Sometimes [patients] need to do prep work for appointments, and then they get here and they have to buy this stuff, and have no money, and it’s not covered. But if they don’t get the prep work they don’t get the procedure. (key informant, 305) | |||
| (5) Provide opportunities for facilitated appointments | The information form I was given [at my consultation] said, ‘please consider having someone with you post-op.’ I felt like that wasn't fair because I didn't get to consider that. Medical travel wouldn't allow [an escort]. (medical traveler, 1501) |
Clear communication and adherence to the medical escort policy. Expand the number and scope of patient navigators who can facilitate continuity of care and support throughout a patient’s stay, from arrival, to hospital and/or clinics and back. Document and disseminate best practices of healthcare navigators. | |
| With the traveling, I would like to see them change the policy with escorts and long term [travel].…I have to travel all by myself because my escort would have to pay her own travel fees. They should allow an escort to come with you regardless if [the escort is] only staying for a week but you are staying for 4 weeks. I have to fly home by myself and it’s not easy. (medical traveler, 2501) | |||
| Experience with providers | (1) Increase cultural safety and awareness | There is blatant discrimination and racism all the time. And I don’t think people talk about that enough. As a society we push it under the carpet and we don’t realize how traumatizing that is to a person. People just don’t know about Aboriginal culture and people are not looked at as being on the same level as other people in the country…once you’ve been on the receiving end of that discrimination you just kind of give up. (key informant, 305) |
Promote the uptake of Northern Indigenous cultural awareness and cultural safety classes for healthcare providers, front-line staff and auxiliary staff. Increase community-specific content included in cultural training to provide more information on the specific cultural context for Northern patients. Provide outreach opportunities to promote hands-on experiences and cultural learning directly with community members. |
| [My care would be improved by] doctors understanding where I am coming from: a small town, a long distance, culturally. (medical traveler, 8506) | |||
| (2) Facilitate respectful and patient-centred care | I understand it gets busy and stuff like that but we’re still human. Each person should still be treated respectfully in any manner. (key informant, 142) | ||
| Not everybody thinks the same, believes the same or practices the same. So it's having that respect and starting out from a blank page and saying, ‘let’s get to know you.’ …That's part of the relationship. (key informant, 302) | |||
| (3) Expand access to medical translation and understanding | [The language service does not] have Slavey or Tłı̨chǫ or Inuinnaqtun, Gwich’in. …But how often do we need a Slavey translator? Most people who come who need a translator are Elders anyway and so they would be coming with an escort. The [Government of NWT] tries to ensure that the escort is comfortable doing this. Sometimes they get someone who is really not suitable. Like you get a 16-year-old coming down with their grandfather with cancer of the rectum. (key informant, 120) |
Ensure that health providers know how to access translation services, including which languages are available through telephone translation. Engage local trained navigators or advocates to support medical communication. Provide travel information as well as health information materials for medical travellers in Indigenous languages. | |
| The language barrier, not so much for me, but other people from Délįne, there’s no one who speaks the language. Even the people escorting, their education level isn’t that high. So now you have two people lost, trying to find their way to an appointment. My wife’s aunt got lost here for a day and a half. She went to an appointment but never made it because she couldn’t find it…There’s a language barrier especially for the old ones. The Elders have the hardest time of all. (focus group, 352) | |||