Literature DB >> 31806609

Opportunities for improving patient experiences among medical travellers from Canada's far north: a mixed-methods study.

Kate Kerber1, Fariba Kolahdooz1, Meeka Otway1, Melinda Laboucan1, Se Lim Jang1, Sue Lawrence1, Suzanne Aronyk1, Matthew Quinn2, Stephanie Irlbacher-Fox3, Crystal Milligan4, Sabrina Broadhead5, Debbie DeLancey3, Andre Corriveau5, Sangita Sharma6.   

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: This paper explores patient experiences and identifies barriers and opportunities for improving access to healthcare for patients from the Canadian north who travel to receive medical care in a Southern province.
DESIGN: A mixed-methods, cross-sectional study involved one-on-one interviews, focus group discussions and key informant interviews. PARTICIPANTS: 52 one-on-one interviews with Northwest Territories (NWT) patients and patient escorts and two focus group discussions (n=10). Fourteen key informant interviews were conducted with health workers, programme managers and staff of community organisations providing services for out-of-province patients. A Community Advisory Board guided the development of the questionnaires and interpretation of results.
RESULTS: Respondents were satisfied with the care received overall, but described unnecessary burdens and bureaucratic challenges throughout the travel process. Themes relating to access to healthcare included: plans and logistics for travel; level of communication between services; clarity around jurisdiction and responsibility for care; indirect costs of travel and direct costs of uninsured services; and having a patient escort or advocate available to assist with appointments and navigate the system. Three themes related to healthcare experiences included: cultural awareness, respect and caring, and medical translation. Respondents provided suggestions to improve access to care.
CONCLUSIONS: Patients from NWT need more information and support before and during travel. Ensuring that medical travellers and escorts are prepared before departing, that healthcare providers engage in culturally appropriate communication and connecting travellers to support services on arrival have the potential to improve medical travel experiences. © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2019. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.

Entities:  

Keywords:  healthcare access; healthcare services; medical travel; northern Canada; patient experience

Mesh:

Year:  2019        PMID: 31806609      PMCID: PMC6924833          DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-030885

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  BMJ Open        ISSN: 2044-6055            Impact factor:   2.692


To our knowledge, this study is the first to explore the experience of medical travel from Northern Canada to an urban centre from the perspective of patients, patient escorts, healthcare providers, and support staff. The mixed-methods design allowed the merging of data from different perspectives and findings will be of interest to other healthcare jurisdictions serving remote and isolated populations. This study was able to document culturally relevant and patient-centred solutions to improve travel preparation and communication that would have a positive impact on patient experience and reduce healthcare costs. The majority of respondents reported receiving outpatient, schedulable services and findings may not be generalisable to inpatients with acute or emergency care needs. Further research is required to implement and test patient-led solutions, and to identify and address pretravel barriers to healthcare access.

Background

In Canada’s universal healthcare system, services are provided across a vast geography, in the context of decentralised management by provincial and territorial authorities, and based on principles of universality, comprehensiveness, portability, accessibility and public administration.1 For residents of rural and remote areas of Canada, the majority of primary care services are met close to home in communities and regional centres. Remote communities in Canada’s north are served through a nurse-based primary care model supported by periodic physician visits, and increasingly, telehealth services. However, certain health conditions require travel to more specialised services that are only available in larger centres, sometimes outside the province or territory. Only 3% of specialists live in rural or remote areas of Canada, where over 18% of the population resides.2 Out-of-province and out-of-territory medical travel in Canada comprises a small percentage of the total care provided, but it can be physically, financially and emotionally challenging for patients, families and communities, and it comes with a significant public sector cost.3 The government of Northwest Territories (NWT) provides medical travel benefits for NWT residents with a valid healthcare card, and administers the federally funded Non-Insured Health Benefits (NIHBs) Programme that covers registered First Nations and Inuit. NWT has the highest total health expenditure per capita in Canada.4 NWT relies on four main territorial healthcare facilities, with specialised diagnostic and treatment services accessed outside the territory in Alberta, Saskatchewan and British Columbia. In 2016–2017, the NWT Department of Health and Social Services (DHSS) spent US$32.5 million for residents to access medical services outside NWT, an increase compared with previous years, accounting for 7% of the total DHSS spending.5 The NWT DHSS released a revised medical travel policy in 2015 and accompanying guide in 2017.6 The medical travel policy covers return airfare, interfacility ambulance services for emergency medical evacuations, and some support for meals, accommodation and ground transportation. Under certain circumstances, NWT covers for a non-medical escort to travel with and assist the patient.6 7 Improving access to and experience with healthcare services has inherent value to health system users, and is associated with important clinical processes and outcomes,8 especially in relation to chronic disease prevention and management,9 10 adherence to medical advice11 and treatment plans.12 Recently, attention related to delivering better preventive and primary care close to home,13 medical travel for pregnancy14 and postnatal services,15 and reducing the cost of medical travel16 has increased, but with little focus on the experience of interprovince/territory medical travel. This research aimed to identify barriers to accessing quality healthcare for medical travellers and potential opportunities for improving care. We applied a mixed-methods research design, sequentially merging quantitative information from medical travellers and escorts from NWT, with qualitative analysis of travel experiences, and key informant interviews with front-line health workers, programme managers and staff of community organisations providing services for out-of-province patients.

Methods

Setting

This study took place in Edmonton, the provincial capital of Alberta, and closest major urban centre to NWT, with a population of 1 million people. Medical travellers are provided accommodation in a boarding facility and transportation to local medical appointments. If patient volume is high, accommodation is provided at local motels.

Study design

Through the mixed-methods design, we collected data in different ways.17 Integrating qualitative and quantitative findings identified themes of access to and experiences with health services and potential solutions. The qualitative key informant interviews were conducted during August to September 2017 and informed the development of the questionnaire administered with medical travellers. Questionnaires were reviewed by the Community Advisory Board, and pilot tested before use. Focus group discussions with medical travellers and escorts provided additional context for the one-on-one interview data. Across all sources, more weight was placed on the open-ended narratives provided by participants. Interviews and focus group discussions were conducted during November to December 2017.

Data collection

MO, a female community liaison, and KK a female PhD student, conducted all key informant interviews. SLJ, SA, SL, all female research assistants, with KK and MO conducted one-on-one interviews. All data collectors received training specifically for this project. The study aims and objectives were explained to participants by the data collector prior to commencing. The interviewers did not have an ongoing relationship with the participants, but all members of the data collection team spent significant time with staff and residents at the boarding facility building trust, sharing daytime and evening meals, playing games, crafting and sharing information about the potential outcomes of the project.

Key informant interviews

Front-line health workers, programme managers and staff of community organisations providing services for out-of-province patients were purposively sampled, with a snowball sampling strategy until saturation was reached after 14 interviews. Two female interviewers trained in study procedures conducted the interviews in private offices. Data collection consisted of face-to-face, semistructured interviews 30–60 min in length. Interviews were audio recorded and later transcribed.

One-on-one interviews

Medical travellers and non-medical escorts residing at the boarding facility were invited to participate. Individuals who were residents of NWT and had attended at least one medical appointment in Edmonton were eligible. The sample size was based on the number of medical travellers from NWT in a 1-month period, accounting for an 80% response rate. In total, 43 patients and nine escorts participated. The interviewer-administered questionnaire consisted of sociodemographic characteristics, self-reported health status and experiences with the health system and medical travel. The interviewer transcribed open-ended responses verbatim. Patient escorts were invited to participate if the patient was unavailable. Escorts responded to questions relating to travel and experience, but did not provide information related to specific health concerns of the patient. Interviews were conducted in private offices or unoccupied meeting rooms and took between 22 and 71 min to complete.

Focus group discussions

Ten patients and escorts explored issues in more detail in two semistructured focus group discussions, advertised locally through word of mouth and posters. The discussions took place in the evening in a residence common area, and were approximately 60 min in length. One team member facilitated the discussion and one took field notes. Discussions were audio recorded and later transcribed.

Data analysis

Data were entered on a tablet using an online questionnaire developed with REDCap V.8.1.1.18 Quantitative data were analysed using Stata V.14.19 KK and SA transcribed audio files. Transcripts were analysed using NVivo Pro V.12 to code and categorise the data using conventional content analysis.20 In the analysis, access was defined as the ability of people to obtain appropriate healthcare resources to preserve or improve health.21 Experience with health services and healthcare providers was defined as the range of interactions between individuals and the healthcare system, including care provided by doctors, nurses and auxiliary staff.

Patient and public involvement

This research was part of a 4-year mixed-methods implementation research study on access to health services called Caring and Responding in Edmonton: The CARE Project. The inclusion of the experience of medical travellers came at the request of community partners and government of the NWT. A 60+ member Community Advisory Board, including representatives from NWT and staff involved in medical travel, helped guide the development of the questionnaires, interpretation and dissemination of results. Results were presented to the Community Advisory Board in May 2018, in a specific Northern gathering in November 2018, and in NWT in January 2019. Engagement is ongoing with medical travellers and healthcare providers to improve patient navigation, communication and experience through the intervention phase of The CARE Project. Respondents were informed about the purpose of the study and provided written informed consent prior to participation.

Results

Background characteristics and details of medical travel

Table 1 summarises background characteristics of respondents. The shortest direct distance travelled to Edmonton was 725 km, and the furthest was 2030 km as the crow flies, with much greater actual travel distance. Figure 1 and box 1 illustrate the medical travel journey.
Table 1

Self-reported characteristics of study participants, n=52

N%
Age group (years)
 18–2423.8
 25–441121.2
 45–642751.9
 65+1223.1
Gender
 Male2955.8
 Female2344.2
Ethnicity
 First Nations2038.5
 Inuit1019.2
 Métis47.7
 Non-Indigenous1834.6
Education (highest level attained)
 Less than high school diploma1936.5
 High school diploma1019.2
 Some postsecondary59.6
 Postsecondary degree or diploma1834.6
Figure 1

A medical travel journey.

In remote Northern communities, the development and preservation of local skills and knowledge provide strength and resiliency. Connecting with land, culture and traditions is an important component of health and wellness in Northwest Territories (NWT) and beyond. However, when more complex health needs arise, residents may have to leave home for care. There is no ‘typical’ medical travel journey. For the most medical travel, residents will need to see the visiting healthcare provider first, and some communities only have access to a doctor for three or four days every five weeks, resulting in potentially lengthy wait times. When a doctor refers a patient for travel, the patient is sent to the nearest regional centre, such as Inuvik or Yellowknife. Flight schedules vary, and most communities are not serviced by daily flights. The logistics of Arctic air travel are complex and conditions can include blowing snow, extreme wind and whiteout. Special equipment and training is required for aircraft and crew and for patient care, and there is a significant risk of weather delays all year round. This means that a single short appointment could result in a week away from home. Following regional travel, and depending on the severity of the health concern and the treatment needed, the patient may end up being referred to a facility located thousands of kilometres south. The cost of accommodation, food, most medical and travel costs are covered by the government of NWT or the federal government, and supplementary health insurance programmes. However, medical travellers can be out of pocket for incidental costs, and may have to pay up front for prescription drugs. A non-medical escort may accompany the patient, but frequently, adult patients travel alone. Regular frustrations of travel such as flight delays or scheduling changes, lost luggage, unfamiliar signage and adjusting to new accommodation, can become overwhelming during medical travel. The steps depicted are not uncommon, with one individual needing to travel over 5000 km for a single health concern, resulting in weeks away from home. A medical travel journey. Self-reported characteristics of study participants, n=52 People from the most remote communities experienced increased burdens, and mobility or illness made the journey more challenging. Some people are on oxygen or in a wheelchair…You spent two days traveling and you are here for a half hour appointment. Then sometimes…it could take them a few days to get home because of weather. And then it’s supposed to be one night in Yellowknife and it ends up being five or six. (key informant, 603) The average stay in Edmonton was nine days, and 77% of respondents were first-time visitors to the boarding facility. Nineteen per cent had been staying for over two weeks, with 75 days being the longest stay. The majority of respondents were satisfied with the care received (figure 2). The single biggest challenge reported was making arrangements for children, pets and other household responsibilities while away (figure 3). This was particularly true for patients without definitive return dates. One respondent described: ‘The last time we were here, we didn't know that we’d be here for two months’ (medical traveler, 3522).
Figure 2

Satisfaction with most recent healthcare visit.

Figure 3

The main difficulty related to medical travel.

Satisfaction with most recent healthcare visit. The main difficulty related to medical travel. Respondents described the impact of delays between obtaining approval and receiving care: ‘By the time [the patient] found out that he had cancer, it had metastasised already. Medical information took forever to reach us’ (patient escort, 3524). The perceived consequences of not being proactive were severe: ‘You really have to be up on your care. As some of my friends who did not push, now they are dead’ (medical traveler, 3527).

Factors influencing access to care

Five main themes were derived from the data (table 2): (1) medical travel logistics, (2) level of communication between services, (3) clarity around jurisdiction and responsibility for care, (4) cost of services and (5) having an escort or advocate.
Table 2

Themes arising from interviews with key informants, medical travellers, patient escorts, and focus group discussions

Opportunities to improve access and experienceParticipant quotesProposed solutions
Access to services(1) Improve information and logistics prior to travelIt’s like traveling to a foreign country, like hearing that you’re going to go to India tomorrow. You wouldn’t even be worried about the procedure; you’d be worried whether all of the things that you’ve heard are true. What will I eat? Do I have the right clothes? And the airport security? That even makes me nervous. (key informant, 305)

Increase awareness and distribution of existing medical travel information.

Provide information to travellers and medical travel staff on various medical travel scenarios, and what to expect on arrival.

Develop user-friendly communication methods and materials regarding itinerary and flight options.

You come inside at the [local university hospital] and there’s a big rush. You need to ask someone where reception is…. Some of the reception areas [in the hospital] are bigger than most health centres in the communities. And that’s intimidating, especially to older people, Elders. An Elder doesn’t want to get lost. (focus group, 352)
(2) Increase effective communication between servicesThe people who are in charge of the medical travel have the power to decide if you are going or not for medical.…If the medical travel staff say no, then you don’t get sent out…I was told by the Doctor that I needed to go for MRI and I ended up not going and it was never explained why I didn't end up going. (focus group, 351)

Enhance connections between healthcare providers, administrators and community organisations providing care and support to medical travellers to raise awareness about the various services available.

Spread awareness among local service providers about medical travel and the services available in home communities and in medical travel destinations.

[My community’s] problem is the doctors kept changing month to month. It was confusing patients. One would send for this test; one would send for that test. There was no steady [person]. So when the doctors [in Edmonton] ask, ‘you got a physician back at home?’ you laugh. (focus group, 352)
(3) Reduce jurisdictional and bureaucratic barriersHomecare is not reciprocally billed, and palliative care is not an insured service, and long-term care access is not assured by the contracts that we currently have. … [If a patient from the North is] down here and needs long-term care access, our only resource is to repatriate them to the nearest hospital, and they start the process from the North. This becomes a problem…but we do try to cobble together some things. (key informant, 120)

Clarify protocol for out-of-province patients with frontline staff and healthcare providers.

Ensure jurisdictional issues do not become barriers to patient care.

…[S]ome of the healthcare professionals get very disgruntled with you if you don’t have a [provincial health] card…[We hear,] ‘No you can’t get in to see this particular person because you don't have Alberta healthcare.’ (key informant, 607)
(4) Reduce the financial burdenWhile back home all the medication was paid for, here we have to wait for reimbursement. I don't understand that some medications you have to pay [for] and not some others. (medical traveler, 3505)

Ensure that medical travellers are aware of coverage restrictions and policies and have access to funds locally.

Communicate potential for out-of-pocket costs associated with care and medications and provide financial support options for medical travel.

Sometimes [patients] need to do prep work for appointments, and then they get here and they have to buy this stuff, and have no money, and it’s not covered. But if they don’t get the prep work they don’t get the procedure. (key informant, 305)
(5) Provide opportunities for facilitated appointmentsThe information form I was given [at my consultation] said, ‘please consider having someone with you post-op.’ I felt like that wasn't fair because I didn't get to consider that. Medical travel wouldn't allow [an escort]. (medical traveler, 1501)

Clear communication and adherence to the medical escort policy.

Expand the number and scope of patient navigators who can facilitate continuity of care and support throughout a patient’s stay, from arrival, to hospital and/or clinics and back.

Document and disseminate best practices of healthcare navigators.

With the traveling, I would like to see them change the policy with escorts and long term [travel].…I have to travel all by myself because my escort would have to pay her own travel fees. They should allow an escort to come with you regardless if [the escort is] only staying for a week but you are staying for 4 weeks. I have to fly home by myself and it’s not easy. (medical traveler, 2501)
Experience with providers(1) Increase cultural safety and awarenessThere is blatant discrimination and racism all the time. And I don’t think people talk about that enough. As a society we push it under the carpet and we don’t realize how traumatizing that is to a person. People just don’t know about Aboriginal culture and people are not looked at as being on the same level as other people in the country…once you’ve been on the receiving end of that discrimination you just kind of give up. (key informant, 305)

Promote the uptake of Northern Indigenous cultural awareness and cultural safety classes for healthcare providers, front-line staff and auxiliary staff.

Increase community-specific content included in cultural training to provide more information on the specific cultural context for Northern patients.

Provide outreach opportunities to promote hands-on experiences and cultural learning directly with community members.

[My care would be improved by] doctors understanding where I am coming from: a small town, a long distance, culturally. (medical traveler, 8506)
(2) Facilitate respectful and patient-centred careI understand it gets busy and stuff like that but we’re still human. Each person should still be treated respectfully in any manner. (key informant, 142)
Not everybody thinks the same, believes the same or practices the same. So it's having that respect and starting out from a blank page and saying, ‘let’s get to know you.’ …That's part of the relationship. (key informant, 302)
(3) Expand access to medical translation and understanding[The language service does not] have Slavey or Tłı̨chǫ or Inuinnaqtun, Gwich’in. …But how often do we need a Slavey translator? Most people who come who need a translator are Elders anyway and so they would be coming with an escort. The [Government of NWT] tries to ensure that the escort is comfortable doing this. Sometimes they get someone who is really not suitable. Like you get a 16-year-old coming down with their grandfather with cancer of the rectum. (key informant, 120)

Ensure that health providers know how to access translation services, including which languages are available through telephone translation.

Engage local trained navigators or advocates to support medical communication.

Provide travel information as well as health information materials for medical travellers in Indigenous languages.

The language barrier, not so much for me, but other people from Délįne, there’s no one who speaks the language. Even the people escorting, their education level isn’t that high. So now you have two people lost, trying to find their way to an appointment. My wife’s aunt got lost here for a day and a half. She went to an appointment but never made it because she couldn’t find it…There’s a language barrier especially for the old ones. The Elders have the hardest time of all. (focus group, 352)
Themes arising from interviews with key informants, medical travellers, patient escorts, and focus group discussions Increase awareness and distribution of existing medical travel information. Provide information to travellers and medical travel staff on various medical travel scenarios, and what to expect on arrival. Develop user-friendly communication methods and materials regarding itinerary and flight options. Enhance connections between healthcare providers, administrators and community organisations providing care and support to medical travellers to raise awareness about the various services available. Spread awareness among local service providers about medical travel and the services available in home communities and in medical travel destinations. Clarify protocol for out-of-province patients with frontline staff and healthcare providers. Ensure jurisdictional issues do not become barriers to patient care. Ensure that medical travellers are aware of coverage restrictions and policies and have access to funds locally. Communicate potential for out-of-pocket costs associated with care and medications and provide financial support options for medical travel. Clear communication and adherence to the medical escort policy. Expand the number and scope of patient navigators who can facilitate continuity of care and support throughout a patient’s stay, from arrival, to hospital and/or clinics and back. Document and disseminate best practices of healthcare navigators. Promote the uptake of Northern Indigenous cultural awareness and cultural safety classes for healthcare providers, front-line staff and auxiliary staff. Increase community-specific content included in cultural training to provide more information on the specific cultural context for Northern patients. Provide outreach opportunities to promote hands-on experiences and cultural learning directly with community members. Ensure that health providers know how to access translation services, including which languages are available through telephone translation. Engage local trained navigators or advocates to support medical communication. Provide travel information as well as health information materials for medical travellers in Indigenous languages.

Medical travel logistics

Of respondents who reported difficulties, 5.0% identified that travel to an unfamiliar city was the most challenging. The city’s size and range of services was described as overwhelming, especially in comparison to Northern communities. The ability to navigate complicated logistics had an impact on access to care. Respondents noticed limited information provided before travel, and unclear process of determining itineraries. As one traveller explained, ‘[Before travel we need] more information, more understanding. Give information to patients in plain, understandable words’ (medical traveler, 5502).

Communication between services

Limited communication between various levels of care and from decision makers could impact care. Respondents noted that healthcare providers in Edmonton are not always aware of the care that is available in the patients’ home communities. Continuity of care is a challenge given that remote and isolated communities rely on visiting healthcare providers from Southern centres, and there is a high turnover among providers.

Jurisdiction and responsibility for care

Reciprocal billing and aligning policies and procedures in the different health jurisdictions were described as recurrent obstacles. Medical travellers and non-clinical programme staff were unclear about what services were covered, and what to do when patients were turned away. Refusing or delaying services to patients that did not have an Alberta health insurance number was reported by travellers and patient escorts. The process of getting proof of NIHB Programme benefits was frequently noted as a challenge.

Direct and indirect costs

While some respondents appreciated the range of costs associated with medical travel that were covered, and around two-thirds of respondents had access to supplemental health coverage, 23% identified access to funds as a barrier in accessing needed care, and one-third of them cited lack of coverage for medications as the main gap.

Non-medical escorts and facilitated appointments

Having a companion to attend appointments and act as a support and advocate, particularly someone who is familiar with the patient’s home community and Edmonton was reported to increase access and positive care experiences. While navigator services exist at larger facilities, few local programmes are specific to Northern Indigenous cultures, and not all respondents were aware of these services.

Factors influencing the experience of care

Three themes affecting experience with healthcare providers and related solutions emerged from the data (table 2): (1) cultural safety and awareness, (2) respect and caring and, (3) medical translation.

Cultural safety and awareness

Respondents described the benefit of welcoming and safe healthcare environments that provide high-quality, trauma-informed and culturally appropriate care. Healthcare providers and staff that exhibited cultural competence were described as providing better support to patients. Respondents shared past experiences of discrimination towards Indigenous patients and expressed concern about a lack of understanding in the healthcare system about the cultural and historical context of different communities. To increase empathy related to medical travel, one respondent suggested, ‘taking health providers through what it must be like to come to a new place, [with] traffic lights, and people, and noise, and trees’ (key informant, 605).

Respect and caring

Especially for people travelling alone, or facing traumatic circumstances, respondents described how providers could offer extra respect and caring for patients who are far from home. One respondent recounted the story of a young woman who had an emergency evacuation from a small community during a high-risk pregnancy. She travelled with nothing and could not get a bag of her own things sent down; thus, she relied on donations of toiletries and clothing.

Medical translation

Communicating medical information with providers was mentioned as a challenge for numerous respondents, especially for the 17% whose primary language was not English. Respondents described some benefits and drawbacks of professional translator services compared with having an escort in the appointment.

Discussion

In this study, medical travellers, escorts and support workers were interviewed in the context of a larger project on improving access to healthcare for underserved populations. While Canada’s population distribution is unique, jurisdictions within Australia, USA, Norway, Finland and Greenland have similar geographies that depend on medical travel from remote and isolated communities, and present opportunities for learning. In this population, effective and transparent travel preparation, efficient communication across all phases of care and cultural knowledge were found to be central to ensuring both access to care and a positive patient experience. Many medical travellers reported satisfaction with the care received, while also reporting significant stress involved with managing travel logistics across different health jurisdictions. With direct flights from only one NWT community, the first leg involves travelling to the nearest larger centre in NWT, which can add a day or more to the trip, with no designated facility or support for infirm travellers. This ‘multilocality’ of individuals moving between home and distant care facilities can become a long-term feature of people’s lives,22 creating disruptions to personal, family, community and cultural obligations.14 Medical travel can create additional challenges for an already vulnerable person in a health crisis. Almost all NWT residents are required to travel to access advanced medical care at some point.23 Such travel is further complicated by complex policies affecting healthcare delivery for Indigenous populations.23 Detailed policies surrounding medical travel and NIHB aim towards standardisation, but are not applied uniformly. This may reduce the ability to respond to shifting patient needs in dynamic situations, such as long-distance travel during a period of illness or injury.22 Access to information and communication across jurisdictions were particular areas of concern. Electronic health records between NWT and Alberta have allowed for more efficient sharing of patient information, but barriers to full utilisation of the system exist and important medical information does not always travel with patients to other jurisdictions.24 25 Medical travellers paid out-of-pocket for incidentals and some prescriptions and procedures, and some could not access social assistance benefits or bank accounts away from home. Interjurisdiction coordination has been a long-standing challenge, with negative consequences for health outcomes.22 Patient escorts were described as an important source of support and advocacy. Family members can support decision-making and adherence to treatment plans,23 but are not always the best escorts.26 Even with changes to the patient escort policy,22 26 respondents echoed that challenges still exist, such as unreliable escorts and inconsistent policy application. For patients alone, a local trained navigator or advocate could help with medical communication, providing emotional and cultural support.27 Communication predeparture and during the course of travel and treatment should use different formats and media to reach a larger audience with targeted information. Participants called for more culturally appropriate care and cultural knowledge within the healthcare system. Challenges with cross-cultural health communication and health literacy can be particularly harmful.23 28 29 Respondents described the care and support provided by an Indigenous clinic, cultural helpers and a local Northern support unit staffed by healthcare professionals with experience living in remote settings, as extremely valuable. However, not all travellers were aware of or able to connect to services and resources. Recently, culturally relevant services have been shown to improve the experience of Indigenous patients requiring medical relocation for dialysis in South Australia,30 and have been identified as especially important for palliative care and cancer services provided away from home in Northern Territory, Australia.31 32 Respondents described the impact of negative healthcare experiences, including not feeling listened to or respected or discriminated against, on health-seeking behaviours. The unequal patient–provider power dynamic in healthcare, particularly within a colonialist historical context, is well described.33–35 Relying on patients to advocate for their health and needed services, underestimates the complex power relationships involved. Eight of the 94 summary recommendations arising from Canada’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission specifically pertain to health.36 Greater understanding of how residential schools, forced relocation and systemic discrimination have shaped Northern communities in Canada, and how to use that knowledge to change healthcare service delivery is still needed. The barriers to medical travel can be overwhelming, leading to delays in receiving care, or an avoidance of care-seeking altogether,37 resulting in poorer outcomes and higher costs for aggravated health conditions.38 One study of medical travel in Arctic regions of Nordic countries estimated that the number of service hours per Northern patient is 2–3 times higher than urban populations.39 Continuity of care remains a challenge in the North; with only 31.1% of Indigenous territorial residents seeing a regular doctor, compared with 76.4% of Indigenous people outside the territories.40 One systematic review of the impact of distance to healthcare services on health outcomes in Northern settings found worse health outcomes among patients living further away from healthcare facilities and concluded that distance should be a consideration in discussions of treatment options.37 To our knowledge, this study is the first to explore the experience of medical travel from the perspective of outpatients, escorts, providers and support staff in an urban centre in Canada. The mixed-methods design allowed the merging of rich data from multiple different perspectives. One limitation of this study is the measurement of patient experience during the medical travel process, and not in the home community following the medical travel journey, which may have provided additional insight into continuity of care. Additionally, while patient travel escorts provided some context for hospitalised patients, respondents were mainly individuals receiving outpatient services, and the study findings may not be generalisable to inpatients with greater acute care needs. Finally, this study conducted interviews at the point of care and did not include individuals living in remote and isolated communities who were not able to get the required appointments, referrals or the paperwork to travel. Given the potential for delayed or deferred care-seeking, further research is needed to assess the barriers to healthcare access among Northern residents who are not able to access medical travel. The experience of patients travelling a long distance for an extended period away from home is important to understand in order to provide quality care within Canadian provincial health systems, and will be relevant for other jurisdictions serving remote and isolated communities. The majority of medical travellers from NWT were satisfied with the care received. However, many also encountered serious challenges with medical travel, including significant delays in accessing and receiving care. Patients outside of their home jurisdiction are a unique and potentially vulnerable population that could benefit from increased access to and continuity of care. Healthcare providers and policy-makers may not be aware of the complexity of the medical travel experience and the stress involved with managing travel logistics across different health jurisdictions. More effective and transparent travel preparation and efficient communication across jurisdictions and with patients could help to improve the experience of medical travel for residents of the far north.
  25 in total

1.  Exploring Aboriginal people's experience of relocation for treatment during end-of-life care.

Authors:  Pam McGrath
Journal:  Int J Palliat Nurs       Date:  2006-03

2.  Research electronic data capture (REDCap)--a metadata-driven methodology and workflow process for providing translational research informatics support.

Authors:  Paul A Harris; Robert Taylor; Robert Thielke; Jonathon Payne; Nathaniel Gonzalez; Jose G Conde
Journal:  J Biomed Inform       Date:  2008-09-30       Impact factor: 6.317

3.  Is the quality of the patient-provider relationship associated with better adherence and health outcomes for patients with HIV?

Authors:  Mary Catherine Beach; Jeanne Keruly; Richard D Moore
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2006-06       Impact factor: 5.128

4.  The experience of relocation for specialist treatment for Indigenous women diagnosed with vulvar cancer in East Arnhem Land.

Authors:  Pam McGrath; Nicole Rawson
Journal:  J Psychosoc Oncol       Date:  2013

5.  Northwest Territories leads Canada in electronic medical record coverage.

Authors:  Paul Webster
Journal:  CMAJ       Date:  2017-11-27       Impact factor: 8.262

6.  Canada's evacuation policy for pregnant First Nations women: Resignation, resilience, and resistance.

Authors:  Karen M Lawford; Audrey R Giles; Ivy L Bourgeault
Journal:  Women Birth       Date:  2018-02-10       Impact factor: 3.172

7.  Quality monitoring of physicians: linking patients' experiences of care to clinical quality and outcomes.

Authors:  Thomas D Sequist; Eric C Schneider; Michael Anastario; Esosa G Odigie; Richard Marshall; William H Rogers; Dana Gelb Safran
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2008-08-28       Impact factor: 5.128

8.  Air ambulance and hospital services for critically ill and injured in Greenland, Iceland and the Faroe Islands: how can we improve?

Authors:  Björn Gunnarsson; Niels S Kieler Jensen; Tummas I Garði; Helga Harðardóttir; Lilja Stefánsdóttir; María Heimisdóttir
Journal:  Int J Circumpolar Health       Date:  2015-06-10       Impact factor: 1.228

9.  Distribution of health literacy strengths and weaknesses across socio-demographic groups: a cross-sectional survey using the Health Literacy Questionnaire (HLQ).

Authors:  Alison Beauchamp; Rachelle Buchbinder; Sarity Dodson; Roy W Batterham; Gerald R Elsworth; Crystal McPhee; Louise Sparkes; Melanie Hawkins; Richard H Osborne
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2015-07-21       Impact factor: 3.295

Review 10.  Are differences in travel time or distance to healthcare for adults in global north countries associated with an impact on health outcomes? A systematic review.

Authors:  Charlotte Kelly; Claire Hulme; Tracey Farragher; Graham Clarke
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2016-11-24       Impact factor: 2.692

View more
  4 in total

1.  Barriers to colonoscopy in remote northern Canada: an analysis of cancellations.

Authors:  Heather Smith; Nicole Brunet; Alisha Tessier; Robin Boushey; Craig Kuziemsky
Journal:  Int J Circumpolar Health       Date:  2020-12       Impact factor: 1.228

2.  Experiences of Inuit in Canada who travel from remote settings for cancer care and impacts on decision making.

Authors:  Janet Jull; Amanda J Sheppard; Alex Hizaka; Gwen Barton; Paula Doering; Danielle Dorschner; Nancy Edgecombe; Megan Ellis; Ian D Graham; Mara Habash; Gabrielle Jodouin; Lynn Kilabuk; Theresa Koonoo; Carolyn Roberts
Journal:  BMC Health Serv Res       Date:  2021-04-13       Impact factor: 2.655

3.  Patient healthcare experiences in the Northwest Territories, Canada: an analysis of news media articles.

Authors:  Rhiannon Cooper; Nathaniel J Pollock; Zander Affleck; Laura Bain; Nanna Lund Hansen; Kelsey Robertson; Susan Chatwood
Journal:  Int J Circumpolar Health       Date:  2021-12       Impact factor: 1.228

4.  Global health radiology planning using Geographic Information Systems to identify populations with decreased access to care.

Authors:  Rahul Sachdev; Shan Sivanushanthan; Natalie Ring; Anne-Marie Lugossy; Ryan W England
Journal:  J Glob Health       Date:  2021-12-11       Impact factor: 4.413

  4 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.