Association between personality type, affective distress profile and quality of life in patients with psoriasis vs. patients with cardiovascular disease.

Common chronic conditions, such as cardiovascular diseases and psoriasis, are associated with increased psychological distress. Health-related quality of life and personality type in patients with these two diseases were evaluated, including the patient's ability to respond truthfully or his/her tendency to be introverted or extroverted. The subjects (n=63) responded to questionnaires including: SF-36 questionnaire, Eysenck test and the questionnaire of the affective distress profile designed to assess the subjective dimension of functional negative emotions, dysfunctional negative emotions and positive emotions. Psoriasis patients had significantly higher average scores of physical functions and limitations brought on by emotional problems. Emotional instability was common for both types of patients and anxiety was associated with a low level of education. Overall, we believe that it is necessary to include items evaluating the patients' affective profile and personality in the assessment protocols of these diseases. These items could help the clinician in identifying possible factors that signal worsening of the disease or of non-response to treatment. Copyright: © Porumb-Andrese et al.

Introduction

Human personality and its connections to various somatic disorders represents a research subject that has recently been drawing attention and is a reoccurring theme in many clinical trials. The skin is closely related to the mind and is considered as the ‘organ of expression’ of the human body. However, this correlation can be thought of in a different way as well; through its visibility, any major lesion from the skin can bring emotional, psychological and/or social changes. We mention the association between anxiety or depression and acne vulgaris, psoriasis or bullous pemphigoid (1,2), the link between lifestyle factors and atopic dermatitis (3) or the association between stress hormones and cutaneous pathophysiological processes, such as melanoma (4–6). In addition, at molecular level, high levels of oxidative stress parameters were found in psoriasis (7).

Thus, a new concept, psychodermatology, is a concept that focuses on the diagnosis and treatment of psychiatric disorders associated with cutaneous manifestations, as well as combating social isolation associated with such disorders (8).

Health is defined as the state of complete physical, mental and social well-being, not just the absence of disease or infirmity (World Health Organization 2006, www.who.int). Thus, health is linked to the quality of life and is referred to as ‘health-related quality of life (HRQL)’. It is an increasingly common term used in clinical practice to assess the impact of various illnesses on patients' quality of life.

According to the American Psychiatric Association (www.psychiatry.org), personality disorders define those types of mental disorders in which thinking, feeling and behavior follow a rigid, unhealthy pattern, deviated from the cultural norms of society.

One of the personality traits, neuroticism, appears to be correlated with a wide range of cardiovascular events, such as higher levels of blood pressure or atherosclerosis (9). Even more, the British Health and Lifestyle Survey concluded that neuroticism is associated with a higher mortality risk in coronary heart diseases (10).

An interesting report utilizing the General Practice Research Database found that risk factors for CVD occurred more frequently in psoriasis patients compared with the general population (11). Because cardiovascular disease (specifically hypertension and heart failure) and skin diseases (psoriasis) are associated with psychological changes (12), we hypothesize that HRQL in those patients is influenced by some characteristics of personality. The aim of this study was to investigate if personality traits may add some differences between the two groups and influence the course of the diseases.

Patients and methods

Participants

This was a cross-sectional and comparative study, performed among patients attending their scheduled follow-up visit to the psoriasis care unit and cardiovascular unit at Iași University Hospital (Iași, Romania). The present study was approved by the Clinical Research Ethics Committee of The Clinical Emergency County Hospital ‘Sf. Spiridon’ (Iași, Romania) and the Ethics Committee of University of Medicine and Pharmacy ‘Gr. T. Popa’ (Iași, Romania). Written informed consent was obtained from each patient prior to publication. The participation in the study was voluntary. The patients (n=63): 35 patients with psoriasis (PSO group) and 28 patients with cardiovascular diseases (CV group) were enrolled from March 2017 to December 2017; they provided their written informed consent to participate in this study. Regarding the procedure to collect data, simple random sampling technique was used to select the participants. They were informed about the purpose of the study and also that their responses will be used in a scientific study. The tests were performed in a separate room and the inclusion criteria were: a diagnosis of moderate to severe plaque-type psoriasis/hypertension or cardiac failure for at least one year and an age of over 18 years.

The exclusion criteria consisted of the diagnosis of other important diseases (neoplasia, psychiatric disorders), pregnancy, lactating women, under 18 years of age. In addition, for the PSO group, any systemic treatment and any cardiovascular diseases constituted further exclusion criteria. No patients with the inability to understand the questions in the questionnaire were included. In total, 66 patients were excluded, 44 due to exclusion criteria, 20 who refused to participate and 2 due to incomplete data from questionnaires.

Measures

The SF-36 questionnaire, developed by New England Medical Center in the Medical Outcomes Study, contains 36 items that assess the physical and mental health of the subject. This questionnaire has been used, so far, to evaluate HRQL in patients diagnosed with glaucoma, asthma, chronic obstructive bronchopneumonia, allergic rhinitis, spinal trauma, morbid obesity and psoriasis. SF-36 improves the information obtained from the questionnaires referring strictly to the medical condition and offers a wider perspective on the impact of a certain disease on the quality of life (13–16).

The Eysenck test contains questions on how the patient acts, behaves or experiences certain feelings. Thus, this test can detect the patient's ability to respond truthfully, highlighting as well his/her tendency to be introverted or extroverted. The Eysenck test was used in clinical trials that highlighted neurotic changes, but it was also used in detecting changes in personality in dermatological conditions, such as acne vulgaris, as well as in other conditions, including insomnia or coronary artery disease (17–19).

Because temperament and personality traits have both universal and regional characteristics, we have also chosen to use the questionnaire of the Profile of Emotional Distress (PED), a specific tool designed for the Romanian population (20). This questionnaire was designed to assess the subjective dimension of functional negative emotions, dysfunctional negative emotions and positive emotions. The basic idea of this model is that at the root of emotional and behavioral problems there are dysfunctional and irrational beliefs about oneself, the world and life. The scale includes 39 items and allows the calculation of a general distress score, a negative emotion score, a positive emotion score, and scores for ‘worry’, ‘anxiety’ and ‘depression’ (dysfunctional). In this study, we calculated the general score of distress and the score of dysfunctional negative emotions.

Statistical analysis

Data was loaded and processed using statistical functions in SPSS 18.0 (PASW statistics). The Skewness/Kurtosis test (>-2 P-value <2) was utilized to test the normality of the set of values used to examine a continuous variable. The ANOVA test was used to analyze the dispersion of the dependent variable, intra- and intergroup. After applying the ANOVA test, Bonferroni (post-hoc Bonferroni) correction was performed. This correction reduces the type I error rate when testing multiple hypotheses. When calculating the significant difference between two or more groups, based on the distribution of the value series, the significance threshold of 95% was applied to the quantitative tests: Student's t-test, paired samples t-test and Chi-square test. In addition, the Kruskall-Wallis test was used to compare ordinal variables from three or more groups, but it was used for specific/predictive balance plotting at the ROC curve, which served as a prognostic factor. P<0.05 was considered to indicate a statistically significant difference.

Results

The age of the patients varied from 18 to 86 years, the mean was 53.95±16.30 years. In both study groups there was a high educational status (31.4% in the PSO group vs. 50% in the CV group) without significant difference (P=0.488). The dominant occupational status in both study groups was that of an employee (48.6% in the PSO group vs. 57.1% in the CV group, P=0.266). ROC curve confirmed that the socio-demografic characteristics are not a predictive method of evaluating the quality diagnostic in patients with psoriasis in comparison with control group (Fig. 1).

Figure 1.

ROC curve in patients with psoriazis.

The SF-36 values, which represent physical functions on a scale from 0 to 100, had no significant difference in the mean scores of the study groups (42.43 in the PSO group vs. 38.04 in the CV group, P=0.557). This indicates that physical functions were reduced in both groups. In a comparative study of mean scores of SF-36, limited physical health did not reveal significant differences (56.98 in the PSO group vs. 55.16 in the CV group, P=0.332). Approximately 43% of the patients with psoriasis and 45% of those with cardiovascular disease had limitations in daily physical function caused by their physical health status.

In comparing the mean scores of SF-36, a limitation due to emotional problems did not reveal significant differences (74.29 in the PSO group vs. 83.93 in the CV group; P=0.079). In approximately 25% of the patients with psoriasis and 16% of those with cardiovascular disease, emotional problems had led to limitations in physical activity.

The energy/fatigue range recorded a slightly higher average score in patients with psoriasis (63.43 in the PSO group vs. 59.64 in the CV group, P=0.281), yet 37%-40% of the patients in the two study groups reported a decrease in vitality due to health problems.

In comparison, the mean scores of SF-36 show that social functions revealed significant differences (75.71 in the PSO group vs. 86.16 in the CV group, P=0.05). In approximately 24% of the patients with psoriasis and 14% of those with cardiovascular disease, the way they perceived their health during the previous month greatly impacted social interactions. In approximately 40% of the patients in both study groups, the pain recorded in the last 4 weeks reduced the quality of life (60.86 in the PSO group vs. 60 in the CV group, P=0.872).

Regarding personality traits in psoriasis, for patients with an introvert personality the average scores of physical functions and limitations brought on by emotional problems were significantly higher according to the Eysenck questionnaire scores (Table I).

Table I.

Association between of the quality of life and neuroticism.

	PSO group			CV group
Domain SF-36	Emotionally stable	Neuroticism	P-value	Emotionally stable	Neuroticism	P-value
S1. Physical functions	33.95±28.80	52.50±31.73	0.079	39.09±33.82	37.35±22.30	0.871
S2. Limitations due to physical health	55.07±7.66	59.26±7.50	0.113	55.05±8.12	55.23±5.45	0.945
S3. Limitations due to emotional problems	65.79±21.85	84.38±20.61	0.015[a]	72.73±17.12	91.18±16.79	0.009[a]
S4. Vitality	66.84±15.29	59.38±12.89	0.132	66.36±8.09	55.29±13.28	0.020[a]
S5. Emotional stability	54.21±10,04	54.69±11.03	0.894	55.91±10.20	54.41±8.08	0.669
S6. Social functions	66.45±22.07	86.72±21.15	0.009[a]	76.14±19.73	92.65±17.15	0.027[a]
S7. Pain	72.63±19.10	46.88±17.78	0.001[a]	25.01±7.54	13.48±3.27	0.417
S8. Perception of general health status	65.26±12.64	65.00±10.95	0.948	61.82±7.51	57.65±9.70	0.238
Total score	71.81±3.72	74.33±5.13	0.101	72.39±4.71	72.28±3.14	0.939
Right regression model	y=0.723–0.005 S1+0.021		0.701	y=−2.991+0.004 S1+0.021		0.011[a]
	S2-0.012 S3+0.005			S2-0.005 S3+0.008
	S4-0.010 S5+0.008			S4+0.008 S5-0.006
	S6-0.001 S7+0.006 S8			S6+0.008 S7+0.049 S8

PSO, psoriasis; CV, cardiovascular diseases.

P<0.05, indicates statistically significant difference.

In cardiovascular patients with introvert personality, the mean scores of limitation domains due to emotional problems and social functions were significantly higher (Table I).

In patients with extrovert personality, the mean scores in the vitality domain and the perception of their general condition were significantly higher (Table I).

In patients with psoriasis, who were also emotionally stable, the mean pain level was significantly higher. In patients with cardiovascular disease who were also emotionally stable, the mean vitality scores were significantly higher (Table I).

P-values for Student's t-test for PSO vs. CV groups: i) P<0.001; ii) P<0.01 iii) P<0.05 no significant data were collected.

In patients with psoriasis and high or very high grade of dysfunctional negative emotions, the mean scores in the physical function domain were greater (18 and 39.62 vs. 57.86 and 65; P=0.023) and limitations due to emotional problems (53.33 and 67.95 vs. 90.48 and 83.33; P=0.002) were significantly higher. The mean pain level was significantly higher in patients with low or average dysfunctional negative emotions (72 vs. 65.38; 50 and 40; P=0.042) (Table II).

Table II.

Association between the quality of life and dysfunctional negative emotions in two study groups.

	PSO group					CV group
Domain SF-36	Low	Medium	Higher	Very high	P-value	Low	Medium	High	Very high	P-value	F ANOVA test PSO vs. CV
S1	18.00	39.62	57.86	65.00	0.023[a]	10.00	44.00	42.89	0.00	0.016[a]	F=0.349 P=0.557
S2	50.37	57.69	58.33	66.67	0.207	50.00	55.19	55.26	68.52	0.096	F=3.515 P=0.066
S3	53.33	67.95	90.48	83.33	0.002[a]	66.67	80.00	89.47	50.00	0.046[a]	F=0.026 P=0.872
S4	68.00	66.92	55.71	60.00	0.035[a]	63.33	66.00	56.32	80.00	0.137	F=3.745 P=0.133
S5	56.00	54.62	54.29	60.00	0.875	53.33	56.00	54.47	65.00	0.700	F=1.184 P=0.281
S6	57.50	73.08	86.61	100.0	0.038	66.67	82.50	53.68	80.00	0.030[a]	F=3.188 P=0.079
S7	72.00	65.38	50.00	40.00	0.042	83.33	80.00	66.00	53.68	0.026[a]	F=0.993 P=0.323
S8	78.00	64.62	62.14	60.00	0.101	63.33	64.00	57.89	50.00	0.334	F=0.054 P=0.817
Global score	69.26	72.97	74.57	77.78	0.076	68.52	73.52	72.61	72.22	0.307	F=0.362 P=0.550

PSO, psoriasis; CV, cardiovascular diseases.

P<0.05, indicates statistically significant difference.

In patients with psoriasis and low or medium grade dysfunctional negative emotions, the mean scores of vitality (68 and 66.92 vs. 55.71 and 60; P=0.035) and pain (72 and 65.38 vs. 50 and 40; P=0.042) were significantly higher (Table II).

In patients with cardiovascular problems, the following statistically significant differences in mean values of SF-36 scores were noted, in terms of dysfunctional negative emotions: physical functions associated with an average emotional level (10 and 44 vs. 42.9 and 42.89; P=0.016), limitations due to emotional problems associated with a level of medium-high dysfunctional negative emotions (66.67 and 80 vs. 89.47 and 50; P=0.046), social functions associated with an average or high emotional level (66.67 and 82.50 vs. 53.68 and 80; P=0.039) and pain associated with a level of low dysfunctional negative emotions toward the environment (83.33 and 80 vs. 66 and 63.68; P=0.026) (Table II).

In patients with psoriasis, introversion and neuroticism have been associated with a high (71.4%) and very high level (100%) of dysfunctional negative emotions (P=0.023) (Table III).

Table III.

Association between dysfunctional negative emotions and PED scores (introversion, extroversion, neuroticism).

	Dysfunctional negative emotions
	PSO group				CV group
PDA	Low (%)	Medium (%)	High (%)	Very high (%)	Low (%)	Medium (%)	High (%)	Very high (%)	P-values for Kruskal-Wallis test PSO vs. CV
Introversion	80.0	15.4	71.4	100.0	0.0	0.0	52.6	0.0	0.001[b]
Ambivert	20.0	76.9	21.4	0.0	100.0	60.0	47.4	100.0	0.001[b]
Extroversion	0.0	7.7	7.1	0.0	0.0	40.0	0.0	0.0	0.423
P-value[a]		0.023[b]				0.014[b]
Emotionally stable	100.0	53.8	35.7	0.0	66.7	80.0	26.3	0.0	0.713
Neuroticism	0.0	46.2	64.3	100.0	33.3	20.0	73.7	100.0	0.075
P-value[a]		0.005[b]				0.031[b]

P-values for Kruskal-Wallis test. PED, Profile of Emotional Distress; PSO, psoriasis; CV, cardiovascular diseases.

P<0.05, indicates statistically significant difference.

Of the patients with psoriasis 59.1% had high levels of distress presenting neurotic features.

Eysenck test

The ability to manipulate responses was noted in 31.7% of the subjects, slightly more frequent in the group of patients with psoriasis (40% PSO group vs. 21.4% CV group, P=0.272) and there was no significant sex difference in the study groups who were inclined to lie or conceal the truth.

Approximately 60% of single patients with psoriasis have the ability to manipulate the responses while 75% of patients with cardiovascular disease have reserved responses (P=0.05). Comparing the two study groups, the responses marked in the lie domain are not significantly associated with educational status.

Furthermore, 40% of single patients with psoriasis and 50% of patients with cardiovascular diseases were introvert, 85.4% of widowed patients with psoriasis and 50% of cardiovascular patients were introvert and no extravert personality types were noted among widowed patients (P=0.312).

Neuroticism was noted in 52.4% of the subjects, slightly more frequent in the group of patients with cardiovascular disease (60.7% in the CV group vs. 45.7% in the PED group, P=0.235). Moreover, all patients with elementary education, no matter which study group they were a part of, presented elements of neuroticism.

Affective distress profile

Sadness/depression

Functional PDA scores ranged from 6 to 28, registering a slightly higher average in patients with cardiovascular disease (16.07 in the CV group vs. 13.60 in the PSO group, P=0.057), while the functional PDA score varied from 8 to 31, registering a significantly higher mean in patients with cardiovascular disease (17.86 in the CV group vs. 14.40 in the PSO group, P=0.024).

Concern/Anxiety

Functional PDA score ranged from 8 to 28, recording a significantly higher mean in patients with cardiovascular disease (19.04 in the CV group vs. 15.80 in the PSO group, P=0.016) and the functional PDA score ranged from 6 to 36, also registering a significantly higher mean in patients with cardiovascular disease (14.0 in the CV group vs. 11.60 in the PSO group, P=0.039).

Patients with psoriasis are experiencing less dysfunctional emotions than patients with cardiovascular disease. This is associated with a higher level of distress experienced by patients with cardiovascular disease compared to patients with psoriasis, as shown by the results below:

i) Functional negative emotions: In the psoriasis group, 37.1% of the patients had an average level of functional negative emotions and 37.2% were high and very high, while in the group with cardiovascular disease, 60.7% of patients had high and very high levels of functional negative emotions (P=0.011) and ii) dysfunctional negative emotions: In the psoriasis group, 40% of the patients had a high level of dysfunctional negative emotions and 37.1% had a medium level of dysfunctional negative emotions, while in the group with cardiovascular disease, 67.9% of the patients had a high level of dysfunctional negative emotions (P=0.045).

Positive emotions

The PDA score for positive emotions ranged from 19 to 58, showing a slightly higher average in patients with psoriasis (37.66 in the PSO group vs. 36.43 in the CV group, P=0.615).

Total PDA

The total PDA score ranged from 61 to 139, with a significantly higher mean in cardiovascular patients (103.39 in the CV group vs. 93.06 in the PSO group, P=0.008).

The overall PDA score in 73% of patients was very high with a significantly higher percentage in patients with cardiovascular disease (85.7% in the CV group vs. 62.9% in the PSO group, P=0.039).

Discussion

The main findings of the present study are: i) Regarding personality traits, neuroticism was present in all patients with elementary education, regardless of the study group they were in and anxiety was associated with a low level of education as well and ii) regarding HRQL, in the PSO group, we noted a greater impact of diagnosis on social interactions. In approximately 40% of the patients in both study groups, pain recorded in the last 4 weeks reduced the quality of life and daily physical functions were reduced by physical health in approximately 40% in both groups.

The role of stress in modulation of skin inflammation, the quality of life in patients with psoriasis and the psychological changes associated with this condition have been extensively studied and the results have shown differences in ethnicity, sex or other stress factors (smoking) (21–23). The severity of the disease or its duration is not of the utmost importance, but rather the social impact of the lesions. If the lesions are located in visible areas, they have a greater effect on the quality of life of the patient, even if their size is small (24,25). Most studies used an HRQL assessment method in psoriasis patients with the Dermatology Quality of Life Index (DLQI) questionnaire in association with the Psoriasis Area Severity Index (26–28). However, it has been observed that there is no direct link to the severity of lesional extension, which is mainly assessed by PASI and the degree of psychological impairment of the patient (25). The correlation of PASI with HRQL differs greatly depending on the patient's temperament (29).

Emotion regulation is a process by which emotions are modulated both consciously and unconsciously (30) and depression is frequently considered a disorder that occurs because of a dysfunction of emotion regulation strategies (31). Our results show that patients with psoriasis experience a lower degree of dysfunctional emotions than patients with cardiovascular disease. It could be interpreted as an association with a higher level of distress experienced by patients with cardiovascular disease in a strict relation with their disease.

These ideas highlight the fact that the psychic component plays a much more important role than previously thought and its importance should be reevaluated; our results support this idea. In our case, the patient's health in the month prior to assessment prevented social engagement. Furthermore, in approximately 40% of the patients in both study groups, pain reduced quality of life over the last 4 weeks.

Patients with psoriasis and introverted personality tend to limit physical activity and are more emotionally vulnerable, which may exacerbate the effects of the disease and therapeutic compliance or even aggravation of the symptoms. It is precisely because of the patient's personality structure, quality of life and emotional stability that there is a need for additional psychological support in these patients.

Our result revealed elements of neuroticism in all patients with psoriasis who had elementary studies, while in those with higher education only 45.5% presented high scores on neuroticism. We found that anxiety was associated with a low level of education and similar conclusions have also been drawn in studies from other countries (32).

We can consider that emotional instability may constitute a personality trait and is common for both patients with psoriasis and patients with cardiovascular disease; a personality trait that is found in personality type A, but also personality type D.

We believe that it is necessary to include items evaluating the patients' affective profile in the assessment protocols of these diseases, since that could help the clinician in identifying possible factors that signal worsening of the disease or of non-response to treatment.

This study used three different tests, which made comparing the results more difficult. Since testing has only been done once, the perception of quality of life, affective perception of the patient may change over the course of the disease and the treatment. Last, but not least, self-administered testing can influence the test results due to the desire to impress the tester or other patients. Considering that psoriasis is a chronic condition accompanied by exacerbations and remissions, it is also necessary to evaluate patients at the time of maximum symptoms.

In conclusion, the present study shows interesting relations between personality traits, such as emotion instability or neuroticism, and physical problems; also in addition, it shows an association between these diseases and the quality of life.