Amand Führer 1 . Show Affiliations »
Abstract
AIM OF THE STUDY: Medicine has been criticized for over-emphasizing biological aspects of health and disease while neglecting social determinants. However, the last decades witnessed the rise of a strand of medical theorizing that proposed a biopsychosocial perspective on health and disease. This article investigates from ethnographic perspectives the extent to which contemporary biopsychosocial medicine succeeds in providing medical care to asylum-seekers in order to grasp societal influences on health and illness. METHODS: A mix of ethnographic methods including narrative interviews, semi-structured interviews and participant observation was used. RESULTS: Using examples of legal restrictions in patients' access to care and language barriers, the ethnographic material showed that physicians regularly failed to take asylum seekers' health-related life-world scientifically into account. Instead, they routinely improvised solutions or deferred responsibility for finding solutions to other agents. CONCLUSIONS: Approaches employed in the social sciences - especially in medical anthropology - could help alleviate these difficulties that result in sub-standard care, and should therefore be integrated into medical teaching and postgraduate education. Concurrently, theoretical and methodological gaps that might also concern other groups of patients might be closed. © Georg Thieme Verlag KG Stuttgart · New York.
AIM OF THE STUDY: Medicine has been criticized for over-emphasizing biological aspects of health and disease while neglecting social determinants. However, the last decades witnessed the rise of a strand of medical theorizing that proposed a biopsychosocial perspective on health and disease. This article investigates from ethnographic perspectives the extent to which contemporary biopsychosocial medicine succeeds in providing medical care to asylum-seekers in order to grasp societal influences on health and illness. METHODS: A mix of ethnographic methods including narrative interviews, semi-structured interviews and participant observation was used. RESULTS: Using examples of legal restrictions in patients' access to care and language barriers, the ethnographic material showed that physicians regularly failed to take asylum seekers' health-related life-world scientifically into account. Instead, they routinely improvised solutions or deferred responsibility for finding solutions to other agents. CONCLUSIONS: Approaches employed in the social sciences - especially in medical anthropology - could help alleviate these difficulties that result in sub-standard care, and should therefore be integrated into medical teaching and postgraduate education. Concurrently, theoretical and methodological gaps that might also concern other groups of patients might be closed. © Georg Thieme Verlag KG Stuttgart · New York.
Entities: Chemical
Mesh: See more »
Year: 2019
PMID: 31770778 DOI: 10.1055/a-1026-6190
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Gesundheitswesen ISSN: 0941-3790