| Literature DB >> 31728216 |
Mohammed K Alkhalifah1, Fareed S H Almutairi1.
Abstract
Compartment syndrome is a surgical emergency that could be resolved by a fasciotomy. However, performing substantial skin incisions may lead to life-threatening complications. This narrative review aimed to present the available methods of wound closure and preferential factors for using each technique. Viable and non-infected wounds were most often treated by gradual approximation techniques, such as the simple or modified shoelace technique, the prepositioned intracutaneous suture or several commercially-available mechanical devices. In addition, applying negative pressure therapy was found to be feasible, particularly when combined with approximation techniques. Skin grafting was reserved for severely-dehiscent wounds while other non-invasive approaches were considered for other subsets of patients with inadvisable surgical interventions. Treatment decision should be made in view of the patient's condition, ease of application, availability of resources, cost of treatment and aesthetic outcomes. © Copyright 2019, Sultan Qaboos University Medical Journal, All Rights Reserved.Entities:
Keywords: Compartment Syndrome; Fasciotomy; Negative-Pressure Wound Therapy; Wound Closure Techniques
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31728216 PMCID: PMC6839671 DOI: 10.18295/squmj.2019.19.03.004
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Sultan Qaboos Univ Med J ISSN: 2075-051X
Summary of studies investigating skin-grafting and dermal approximation techniques for primary wound closure after fasciotomy
| Author and year of study | Location of study | Study design | Indication for fasciotomy | Type of treatment and sample size | Material used | Mean time to primary wound closure in days ± SD | Type of complication |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bussell | Switzerland | Retrospective | Ischaemia, fractures and systemic diseases | • VAC (n = 19) | - | 9.37 ± 4.67 | • STSG (n = 1) and WI (n = 1) |
| • Temporary synthetic skin replacement (n = 9) | • Epigard® (Biovision GmbH, Ilmenau, Germany) | 4.89 ± 2.32 | • None | ||||
| Krticka | Czech Republic | Retrospective | Fracture | • VAC (n = 42) | • SF = 125 mmHg | 11 | • STSG (n = 7), WI (n = 4), osteomyelitis (n = 2) and muscle necrosis (n = 3) |
| • Control (n = 21) | • Combined dressing fabric | 17 | • STSG (n = 10), WI (n = 7), osteomyelitis (n = 3) and muscle necrosis (n = 9) | ||||
| Lee | USA | Case series | Complicated wounds | • VAC (n = 2) | • VAC with instillation and dwell dime (SF = 125 mmHg) | - | • None |
| Saziye | Switzerland | Retrospective | IRI | • VAC (n = 7) | • SF = 75–125 mmHg | 11 ± 8–13 | • STSG (n = 2) |
| • Conservative dressing (n = 8) | • Gauze dressings | 15 ± 12–20 | • WI (n = 3) | ||||
| Weaver | USA | Retrospective | Fractures and soft tissue injuries | • VAC (n = 22) | - | 14.7 | • No information available |
| • STSG (n = 82) | - | 12.2 | • No information available | ||||
| Zannis | USA | Retrospective | Fractures and soft tissue injuries | • VAC (n = 68) | • SF = 125 mmHg | 7.1 | • STSG (n = 29) |
| • Wet-to-dry dressings (n = 74) | • Normal saline-soaked dressings | 9.6 | • STSG (n = 35) | ||||
| Branco | Brazil | Case report | Open fracture | n = 1 | • Elastic suture system | 7 | • None |
| Erdös | Austria | Case series | CS due to fractures and contusion of soft tissues | n = 24 | • Elastic vessel loop with stables and VAC | 11.9 | • STSG (n = 3) |
| Lee | South Korea | Case series | Necrotising fasciitis | n = 8 | • Elastic vessel loop with stables and VAC | 16 | • STSG (n = 2) |
| Matt | USA | Retrospective | Fractures and soft tissue injuries | n = 24 | • Elastic vessel loop with stables and VAC | 16 | • STSG (n = 4) and WI (n = 2) |
| Murakami | Japan | Case report | Soft tissue injury | n = 1 | • Elastic vessel loop with stables and VAC | 7 | • None |
| Saini | India | Prospective | Fractures and soft tissue injuries | n = 19 | • Silk sutures | 8.31 | • WI (n = 1) |
| Sawant and Hallet | UK | Technique description | - | - | • Elastic vessel loop with stables | - | • No information available |
| Zorrilla | Spain | Retrospective | Fractures and soft tissue injuries | n = 20 | • Elastic vessel loop with stables | 8.8 | • None |
| Fowler | USA | Case series | Fractures and soft tissue injuries | • Shoelace (n = 49) | • Elastic vessel loop with stables | 19.2 | • STSG (n = 9) and WI (n = 3) |
| • VAC (n = 7) | • VAC device (Kinetic Concepts, Inc., San Antonio, Texas, USA) | 23.7 | • STSG (n = 4) and WI (n = 2) | ||||
| Johnson | USA | RCT | Traumatic injuries | • Shoelace (n = 5) | • Elastic vessel loop with stables | 7.6 | • No information available |
| • VAC (n = 9) | - | 12.9 | • No information available | ||||
| Kakagia | Greece | RCT | Fractures and soft tissue injuries in the leg | • Shoelace (n = 25) | • Silastic vessel loop with stables | 15.1 ± 3.8 | • WI (n = 4) |
| • VAC (n = 25) | • SF = 125 mmHg | 19.1 ± 6.1 | • STSG (n = 6) and WI (n = 6) | ||||
| Chiverton and Redden | UK | Case series | Fracture of the lower limb | n = 6 | • Prepositioned intracutaneous suture | - | • Broken suture (n = 1) |
| Dahners | USA | Technique description | • Running near-near-far-far suture | - | • None | ||
| Janzing and Broos | Belgium | Case series | - | n = 5 | • Prepositioned intracutaneous suture | 9 ± 3.5 | • Second operation (n = 2). Traction under anaesthesia because of pain in one patient and another patient required additional sutures |
| Van der Velde and Hudson | South Africa | Prospective | - | n = 11 | • Bootlace nylon suture and VAC | 7.5 | • Skin necrosis (n = 1), broken suture (n = 1) and vacuum leak (n = 1) |
| Harrah | USA | Technique description | IRI | n = 6 | • Plaster strips | - | • None |
| Weissman | Israel | Case series | - | n = 4 | • Plaster strips | 21 | • Hypertrophic scar (n = 1) |
SD = standard deviation; VAC = vacuum-assisted closure; STSG = spilt-thickness skin grafting; WI = wound infection; SF = suction force; IRI = ischaemia-reperfusion injury; CS = compartment syndrome; RCT = randomised controlled trial.
A summary of case series that employed dermal approximation techniques using dynamic mechanical devices/tools
| Author and year of study | Device name | Number of patients | Treatment duration in days | Advantages | Disadvantages | Complication |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barnea | Wisebands device | 16 | 1–15 | Providing a feedback control to safeguard when excessive skin tension is applied | Expensive and not readily available | Sepsis (n = 1), pain (n = 1) and scar (n = 1) |
| Janzing and Broos | Marburger system | 5 | 9 | Materials needed for intracutaneous sutures are readily available | Expensive | Skin necrosis (n = 2) and skin grafting (n = 2) |
| Medina | Silver Bullet Wound Closure Device | 8 | 5–10 | Simple and efficacious | Daily tightening, numbness and tenderness of the scar | Pain (n = 2), scar (n = 3) and numbness (n = 2) |
| Ozyurtlu | V-Loc wound closure device using barbed sutures | 5 | 8.6 | Knotted sutures to prevent wound pulling back, faster tightening procedure and use of absorbable sutures | Rupture or lockups of the sutures | Necrosis (n = 1) |
| Taylor | Anchors | 5 | 6–14 | Equal distribution of tension forces | Expensive and not readily available | None |
| Eid and Elsoufy | Paediatric urinary catheters and staples | 17 | Average of 4.2 tightening sessions | Readily available and inexpensive | Point-loading | Skin necrosis (n = 5) |
| Govaert and van Helden | Ty-raps | 13 | 4–23 | Stiff and very strong | Not readily available | Skin grafting (n = 1) |
| Kenny | Rubber bands | 17 | No information available | Readily available and used for large wounds | More than one application may be needed and qualitative assessment of the required tension | Skin grafting (n = 1) |
| Mittal | Dermotaxis | 25 | 12 | Easy to use and no point-loading | K-wire cut-out | Skin grafting (n = 2) |
| Pasha | Pasha device | 9 | 5–8 | Simple, cheap and user friendly | Not readily available | WI (n = 1) |
| Ravinder | Dermotaxis using Ravinder | 100 | 8–15 | Can be used in wounds with exposed bones | K-wire cut-out | Skin grafting (n = 12) |
| Rijal | Circular rubber bands plus longitudinal gauzes | 3 | 8 | Inexpensive and provides evenly distributed point-loading | Rubber band breakage and not suitable for active bleeders | None |
| Suliman and Aizaz | Plastic bands | 5 | 4–12 | Simple, inexpensive and readily available | Risk of infection | Hypertrophic scar (n = 1) and WI (n = 1) |
| Walker | A silicon sheet fixed with a running Prolene suture | 69 | 11.9 | Safe, painless, provides constant wound control and easily removed | Risk of infection | STSG (n = 17) |
WI = wound infection; STSG = spilt-thickness skin grafting.