Strategies for Delivering Value-Based Care: Do Care Management Practices Improve Hospital Performance?

EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY: Value-based payment has the potential to rein in the volume incentive inherent in fee-for-service payment by holding providers accountable for the quality of patient care they deliver. Success under the new payment structure will depend on how effectively key organizational reforms are embraced by providers in the implementation of quality improvement processes for care delivery. This study examined the relationship between implementation of care management processes (CMPs, the specific tactics that enable the practice of value-based care) and hospital performance under value-based payment. Using the American Hospital Association's Survey of Care Systems and Payment and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' Hospital Compare, we estimated the relationship between hospital implementation of CMPs and performance as it relates to spending, patient satisfaction, readmission reduction, value-based purchasing, and clinical care outcomes. We found that hospitals increased implementation of CMPs from 2013 to 2014, which has led to modest changes in performance. We concluded that care coordination is associated with greater improvements in hospital performance. However, the long-term effects of resulting changes in care delivery may differ from the short-term effects. Thus, study findings underscore the importance of continued evaluation of care management practice as a strategy for optimizing delivery of high-quality, efficient patient care.