Literature DB >> 31650504

Epidemiology, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Atopic Dermatitis in the Developing Countries of Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Middle East: A Review.

Yuri I Lopez Carrera1, Anwar Al Hammadi2, Yu-Huei Huang3, Lyndon J Llamado4, Ehab Mahgoub5, Anna M Tallman6.   

Abstract

Atopic dermatitis (AD), the leading cause of skin-related burden of disease worldwide, is increasing in prevalence in developing countries of Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Middle East. Although AD presents similarly across racial and ethnic groups as chronic and relapsing pruritic eczematous lesions, some features of the disease may be more or less prominent in patients with darker skin. Despite a similar presentation, consistent diagnostic criteria and consistent treatment guidelines are lacking. Because of these and other challenges, adherence to treatment guidelines is difficult or impossible. Previous studies have stated that many patients with AD receive ineffective or inappropriate care, such as oral antihistamines, oral corticosteroids, or traditional medicines, if they are treated at all; one study showed that approximately one-third of patients received medical care for their dermatologic condition; of those, almost three-quarters received inappropriate or ineffective treatment. In addition, other challenges endemic to developing countries include cost, access to care, and lack of specialists in AD. Furthermore, most of the available diagnostic criteria and treatment guidelines are based on European and North American populations and few clinical trials report the racial or ethnic makeup of the study population. Drug pharmacokinetics in varying ethnicities and adverse effects in different skin physiologies are areas yet to be explored. The objective of this review is to describe the diagnosis, treatment, and management of AD in developing countries in Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Middle East; to discuss the differences among the countries; and to establish the unmet needs of patients with AD in them. The unmet medical need for treatment of AD in developing countries can be addressed by continuing to train medical specialists, improve access to and affordability of care, and develop new and effective treatments.Funding Pfizer Inc.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Africa; Asia; Atopic dermatitis; Developing countries; Latin America; Middle East; Unmet medical need

Year:  2019        PMID: 31650504      PMCID: PMC6828917          DOI: 10.1007/s13555-019-00332-3

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Dermatol Ther (Heidelb)


Introduction

Atopic dermatitis (AD) is a chronic, relapsing-remitting skin disease characterized by pruritic eczematous lesions [1], and it is the leading cause of skin-related burden of disease globally [2]. The pathogenesis of AD is multifactorial and includes genetic factors, which have been shown to vary across racial groups [3-5]. The pathogenesis of AD also depends on environmental factors; as a result, there are wide variations in epidemiology from country to country [5, 6]. Although it seems to have leveled off in developed countries, AD prevalence appears to be increasing in developing countries [7], likely because of increasing urbanization, pollution, Western diet consumption, and obesity [6]. Among 13- to 14-year-old adolescents in the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) Phase 3, AD prevalence for Africa and Latin America was high at 12–14% and 6–10%, respectively, whereas for Asian-Pacific countries, the Eastern Mediterranean region, and the Indian subcontinent values were lower at 3–6%; among 6- to 7-year-old children, AD prevalence for Asian-Pacific countries, Africa, and Latin America was high at approximately 10%, whereas values for the Eastern Mediterranean region and Indian subcontinent were lower at 3–5% [8]. Likewise, prevalence in the first 2 years of life was also high at 7–27% in Asian-Pacific countries, including South Korea [9], China [10], Singapore [11], Malaysia [12], and Taiwan [13-15]. This review presents the diagnosis, treatment, and management of AD in developing countries in Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Middle East. We discuss the differences in epidemiology, diagnosis, and treatment among the countries to establish the unmet needs of patients with AD living in these countries. This article is based on previously conducted studies and does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors.

Clinical Presentation

Overall, AD presents similarly across racial and ethnic groups as chronic or relapsing pruritic eczematous skin lesions; however, some features may be more or less prominent in patients with darker skin. Erythema is often less obvious in patients with darker skin and may appear reddish-blue or purple (violaceous) rather than red [5, 16]. Perifollicular accentuation, papulation, scaling, lichenification, and pigmentary changes may also be more prominent in patients with darker skin [5, 16, 17]. In addition, Asian populations demonstrate greater helper T cell (Th) 17/Th22 polarization than other populations, leading to a phenotype that combines features of AD and psoriasis [5, 18]. The pattern of lesions may also vary, with patients who have darker skin tones being more likely to present with lesions on extensor surfaces rather than the typical pattern of predominantly flexural lesions [5, 16, 17, 19, 20]. Differences in age of onset, disease severity, and genetic susceptibility may occur across racial and ethnic groups. The prevalence of AD in adults appears to be greater among some Asian populations, potentially because of higher rates of disease onset in adulthood [16, 20–23]. Although their prevalence of the two most common filaggrin (FLG) mutations leading to AD (R501X and 2282del4) is lower, patients of African descent appear to be at greater risk for severe AD [16, 17]. Other studies have reported the prevalence of different FLG mutations in Asian patients (S1695X, Q1701X, Q1745X, Y1767X, Q1790X, S2554X, S2889X, S3296X, 3222del4, S1515X, Q2417X, and K4022X) and Middle Eastern patients (S417S and D1921N, among others) [24, 25]. Pruritus may be more severe in patients with darker skin [17, 19, 26, 27]. It must be noted, however, that many of the available data on differences in clinical presentations are based on data from patients of African descent living in the US or Europe, not in developing countries.

Diagnostic Criteria

Hanifin and Rajka diagnostic criteria [28] and the UK Working Party’s diagnostic criteria [29] have both been used to diagnose AD in Chinese [30, 31], Taiwanese [32], Indian [33], and South African [34] patients (Table 1). However, in a survey of Southeast Asian dermatologists, all Indonesian respondents (100%) were familiar with the UK Working Party’s diagnostic criteria, whereas respondents from Malaysia (73%), Singapore (75%), or Thailand (90%) were more familiar with the Hanifin and Rajka criteria, but less than half of the Filipino and Vietnamese respondents (5–39%) were familiar with either set of criteria [35].
Table 1

Diagnostic criteria for developing countries

SourceDeveloping country populationCriteriaMajor featuresMinor features
Hanifin and Rajka [28]Indian hospitalized, pediatric patients [33]≥ 3 major PLUS ≥ 3 minor

Pruritus

Typical morphology (flexural lichenification or linearity in adults, facial and extensor involvement in infants and children)

Chronic or chronically relapsing dermatitis

Personal or family history of atopy

Xerosis

Ichthyosis, palmar hyperlinearity, or keratosis pilaris

Immediate (type I) skin test reactivity

Elevated serum IgE level

Early age of onset

Tendency toward cutaneous infections or impaired cell-mediated immunity

Tendency toward nonspecific hand/foot dermatitis

Nipple eczema

Cheilitis

Recurrent conjunctivitis

Dennie-Morgan infraorbital folds

Keratoconus

Anterior subcapsular cataracts

Orbital darkening

Facial pallor or erythema

Pityriasis alba

Anterior neck folds

Itch when sweating

Intolerance to wool and lipid solvents

Perifollicular accentuation

Food intolerance

Course influenced by environmental/emotional factors

White dermographism or delayed blanch

UK Working Party [29]Chinese patients of all ages [30, 31]; Taiwanese adults [32]; hospitalized Indian pediatric patients [33]; Xhosa-speaking South African children aged 3–11 years [34]Major PLUS ≥ 3 minorItchy skin condition (or parental report of scratching or rubbing in a child)

History of flexural involvement (including cheeks in children < 10 years)

Personal history of asthma or hay fever (or history of atopy in first-degree relative in children < 4 years)

History of a general dry skin in last year

Visible flexural eczema (or eczema involving the cheeks/forehead and extensor surfaces in children aged < 4 years)

Onset < 2 years of age (not used for child aged < 4 years)

Liu et al. [22]Chinese adults and adolescentsMajor PLUS ≥ 1 minorPersistent or recurrent symmetrical dermatitis for > 6 months

Personal or family (first-, second-, or third-degree relative) history of atopy

Elevated total serum IgE level, positive allergen-specific IgE, or eosinophilia

Kang and Tian [31, 36]Chinese patients of all ages

Both major

~ OR ~

First major PLUS ≥ 3 minor

Chronic or chronically relapsing pruritic dermatitis (inflammatory eczematous lesions on face and extensor surfaces in infants/children, lichenification of flexural and extensor surfaces in adolescents/adults)

Personal or family history of atopy

Onset < 12 years of age

Xerosis, ichthyosis, or palmar hyperlinearity

Allergic conjunctivitis, food intolerance, immediate skin test reactivity, eosinophilia, or elevated serum IgE level

Tendency toward cutaneous infections or impaired cell-mediated immunity

Facial pallor, white dermographism, or delayed blanch

Periorbital darkening, perifollicular accentuation, or tendency toward nonspecific hand/foot dermatitis

Wisuthsarewong and Viravan [37] and Wanitphakdeedecha et al. [38]Thai adolescents and adults aged ≥ 13 yearsMajor PLUS ≥ 2 minorHistory of flexural dermatitis

Duration > 6 months

Visible flexural dermatitis

Visible dry skin

Korean Atopic Dermatitis Association [39]Korean children aged 4–12 years

Both major

~ OR ~

1 major PLUS ≥ 4 minor

Relapsing–remitting itchy rash in past 12 months

Itchy rash on antecubital/popliteal fossae in past 12 months

Personal or family (father, mother, brothers, or sisters) history of atopy

Intermittent itch, wrinkles, or darkening around the eyes in past 12 months

Intermittent itch or oozing around the ears in past 12 months

Intermittent chapping or oozing around the lips in past 12 months

Intermittent itch, thickening, or darkening around the neck in past 12 months

Intermittent itch, oozing, or thickening in infragluteal folds in past 12 months

Intermittent itch or oozing around wrist/ankle joints in past 12 months

Unusually dry skin in past 12 months

Itch when sweating in past 12 months

South African Childhood Atopic Eczema Working Group [40]South African childrenMajor PLUS ≥ 3 minorPruritus

Flexural dermatitis

Previous flexural dermatitis

Dry skin

Other atopic disease

Onset < 2 years of age

IgE immunoglobulin E

Diagnostic criteria for developing countries Pruritus Typical morphology (flexural lichenification or linearity in adults, facial and extensor involvement in infants and children) Chronic or chronically relapsing dermatitis Personal or family history of atopy Xerosis Ichthyosis, palmar hyperlinearity, or keratosis pilaris Immediate (type I) skin test reactivity Elevated serum IgE level Early age of onset Tendency toward cutaneous infections or impaired cell-mediated immunity Tendency toward nonspecific hand/foot dermatitis Nipple eczema Cheilitis Recurrent conjunctivitis Dennie-Morgan infraorbital folds Keratoconus Anterior subcapsular cataracts Orbital darkening Facial pallor or erythema Pityriasis alba Anterior neck folds Itch when sweating Intolerance to wool and lipid solvents Perifollicular accentuation Food intolerance Course influenced by environmental/emotional factors White dermographism or delayed blanch History of flexural involvement (including cheeks in children < 10 years) Personal history of asthma or hay fever (or history of atopy in first-degree relative in children < 4 years) History of a general dry skin in last year Visible flexural eczema (or eczema involving the cheeks/forehead and extensor surfaces in children aged < 4 years) Onset < 2 years of age (not used for child aged < 4 years) Personal or family (first-, second-, or third-degree relative) history of atopy Elevated total serum IgE level, positive allergen-specific IgE, or eosinophilia Both major ~ OR ~ First major PLUS ≥ 3 minor Chronic or chronically relapsing pruritic dermatitis (inflammatory eczematous lesions on face and extensor surfaces in infants/children, lichenification of flexural and extensor surfaces in adolescents/adults) Personal or family history of atopy Onset < 12 years of age Xerosis, ichthyosis, or palmar hyperlinearity Allergic conjunctivitis, food intolerance, immediate skin test reactivity, eosinophilia, or elevated serum IgE level Tendency toward cutaneous infections or impaired cell-mediated immunity Facial pallor, white dermographism, or delayed blanch Periorbital darkening, perifollicular accentuation, or tendency toward nonspecific hand/foot dermatitis Duration > 6 months Visible flexural dermatitis Visible dry skin Both major ~ OR ~ 1 major PLUS ≥ 4 minor Relapsing–remitting itchy rash in past 12 months Itchy rash on antecubital/popliteal fossae in past 12 months Personal or family (father, mother, brothers, or sisters) history of atopy Intermittent itch, wrinkles, or darkening around the eyes in past 12 months Intermittent itch or oozing around the ears in past 12 months Intermittent chapping or oozing around the lips in past 12 months Intermittent itch, thickening, or darkening around the neck in past 12 months Intermittent itch, oozing, or thickening in infragluteal folds in past 12 months Intermittent itch or oozing around wrist/ankle joints in past 12 months Unusually dry skin in past 12 months Itch when sweating in past 12 months Flexural dermatitis Previous flexural dermatitis Dry skin Other atopic disease Onset < 2 years of age IgE immunoglobulin E Some population-specific diagnostic criteria have been proposed (Table 1). Liu et al. [22] proposed criteria for the diagnosis of AD in Chinese adults and adolescents that are based on only two features—persistent or recurrent symmetrical AD for > 6 months with one or both of the following: (1) personal or familial history of atopy and/or (2) elevated total serum immunoglobulin (Ig) E level, positive allergen-specific IgE, and/or eosinophilia. In an earlier iteration, Kang and Tian [36] proposed criteria for diagnosis in Chinese patients (regardless of age) based on the presence of two basic features (chronic or chronically relapsing pruritic dermatitis and personal or family history of atopy) or the first basic feature plus ≥ 3 minor features (onset before 12 years of age; xerosis, ichthyosis, or palmar hyperlinearity; allergic conjunctivitis, food intolerance, immediate skin reactivity, eosinophilia, or elevated serum IgE level; tendency to cutaneous infections or impaired cell-mediated immunity; facial pallor, white dermatographism, or delayed blanch; periorbital darkening, perifollicular accentuation, or tendency to nonspecific hand and foot dermatitis). Wisuthsarewong and Viravan [37] proposed and Wanitphakdeedecha et al. [38] validated criteria for the diagnosis of AD in Thai patients older than 13 years based on a history of flexural dermatitis plus ≥ 2 of the following: duration > 6 months, visible flexural dermatitis, and visible dry skin. The Korean Atopic Dermatitis Association [39] proposed the Reliable Estimation of Atopic Dermatitis of ChildHood (REACH) diagnostic criteria for South Korean children 4–12 years of age based on the presence of 2 major features (remitting-relapsing itchy rash in the past 12 months, itchy rash on antecubital/popliteal fossae in the past 12 months) or 1 major feature and ≥ 4 minor features (personal/family history of atopy; itchy rash around/on the eyes, ears, lips, neck, infragluteal folds, wrist/ankle joints; or itch when sweating in the past 12 months; unusually dry skin in past 12 months). Last, the South African Childhood Atopic Eczema Working Group [40] proposed criteria for South African children based on the presence of pruritus plus ≥ 3 of the following: flexural dermatitis, previous flexural dermatitis, dry skin, other atopic disease, and/or onset before 2 years of age. The American Academy of Dermatology has published diagnostic criteria as well [41]. These are largely based on the Hanifin and Rajka criteria [28].

Treatment Guidelines

Treatment guidelines are available for Asian-Pacific countries overall [42, 43] and Taiwan [44], Singapore [45], South Korea [46-48], and India [49-51], specifically; Latin America overall [52] and Mexico [53, 54] and Argentina [55] specifically; South Africa [40, 56, 57]; and the Middle East [58] (Table 2). Unfortunately, no treatment guidelines could be identified for other countries in Africa or the Middle East. It is not clear whether emerging market-specific criteria are preferred by physicians. One survey of South Korean physicians found that 97% of pediatric allergists preferred the South Korea-specific allergy guidelines, whereas dermatologists preferred the South Korean, European, and American dermatology guidelines about equally [59].
Table 2

Treatment algorithms for developing countries

SourceStep-up therapy
Basic treatmentFirst lineSecond lineThird line
Asia–Pacific [42]

Emollients

Trigger avoidance

TCI

Proactive/intermittent TCS

TCS

TCI

Rescue therapy (TCS, wraps/soaks, antibiotics)
Taiwan [44]

Emollients

Trigger avoidance

Patient education

Rescue therapy (TCS, antihistamines)

TCI

Proactive/intermittent TCS

NB-UVB phototherapy

Short-term oral corticosteroid

NB-UVB/UVA1 phototherapy

Infection control

Systemic immunosuppressant

Potent TCS

Phototherapy

Alternative medicine

Psychotherapeutic approach

Singapore [45]

Gentle skin care

Emollients

Mild TCS

TCI

Moderate TCS

Antimicrobials for secondary skin infections

Wet dressings

Potent TCS

Antimicrobials

Phototherapy

Systemic immunosuppressant

South Korea [46, 47]

Emollients

Trigger avoidance

Patient education

Proactive treatment for patients with persistent/frequent flares (intermittent TCI/TCS, psychologic support)

TCI

TCS

Antihistamines

Wet dressings

Infection control

Systemic immunosuppressant

Short-term oral corticosteroid

Phototherapy

Allergen-specific immunotherapy

Biologics

Latin America [52]

Skin care

Emollients

Irritant avoidance

Proactive treatment as needed

If patient is sensitized (trigger avoidance, exclusion diet)

TCS

TCI

If patient has allergic sensitization (allergen-specific immunotherapy)

Antihistamines

Oral corticosteroid

Phototherapy

Cyclosporin

Other oral immunosuppressants
South Africa [56]

Emollients

Appropriate general measures

Patient education

TCS (if not effective or contraindicated, TCI is alternative)

Proactive/long-term TCI

Sedating antihistamines

Rescue therapy (potent TCS)

Potent TCS

Oral corticosteroid

Phototherapy

Systemic immunosuppressant

Psychotherapeutic intervention

Middle East [58]

Emollients

Patient education

Trigger avoidance

Proactive TCI

TCS for flares

NB-UVB narrow band ultraviolet B, TCI topical calcineurin inhibitor, TCS topical corticosteroid, UVA1 ultraviolet A1

Treatment algorithms for developing countries Emollients Trigger avoidance TCI Proactive/intermittent TCS TCS TCI Emollients Trigger avoidance Patient education Rescue therapy (TCS, antihistamines) TCI Proactive/intermittent TCS NB-UVB phototherapy Short-term oral corticosteroid NB-UVB/UVA1 phototherapy Infection control Systemic immunosuppressant Potent TCS Phototherapy Alternative medicine Psychotherapeutic approach Gentle skin care Emollients Mild TCS TCI Moderate TCS Antimicrobials for secondary skin infections Wet dressings Potent TCS Antimicrobials Phototherapy Systemic immunosuppressant Emollients Trigger avoidance Patient education Proactive treatment for patients with persistent/frequent flares (intermittent TCI/TCS, psychologic support) TCI TCS Antihistamines Wet dressings Infection control Systemic immunosuppressant Short-term oral corticosteroid Phototherapy Allergen-specific immunotherapy Biologics Skin care Emollients Irritant avoidance Proactive treatment as needed If patient is sensitized (trigger avoidance, exclusion diet) TCS TCI If patient has allergic sensitization (allergen-specific immunotherapy) Antihistamines Oral corticosteroid Phototherapy Cyclosporin Emollients Appropriate general measures Patient education Proactive/long-term TCI Sedating antihistamines Rescue therapy (potent TCS) Potent TCS Oral corticosteroid Phototherapy Systemic immunosuppressant Psychotherapeutic intervention Emollients Patient education Trigger avoidance Proactive TCI TCS for flares NB-UVB narrow band ultraviolet B, TCI topical calcineurin inhibitor, TCS topical corticosteroid, UVA1 ultraviolet A1 All of these treatment guidelines largely reflect the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) [41, 60–62], the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology (AAAAI)/American College of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology (ACAAI) [63], and European guidelines [64, 65], with skin care and hydration, trigger avoidance, topical anti-inflammatory drugs [topical corticosteroids (TCSs) or topical calcineurin inhibitors (TCIs)] as first-line treatment for mild-to-moderate AD; short courses of systemic corticosteroids and phototherapy as second-line treatment for moderate-to-severe AD; and systemic immunosuppressive therapies or biologics if further treatment is necessary for severe AD. However, some do differ in their recommendations regarding TCI use—the Middle Eastern [58] and Latin American guidelines [52], and one of the Mexican [54] (but not the other Mexican [53] or Argentinian [55] guidelines) recommend TCIs as first-line treatment, whereas one of the South African guidelines [57] is silent on this, and the rest recommend TCIs as second-line treatment. Regarding oral antihistamine use, one of the Mexican [54], one of the South Korean [47], and one of the South African [57] guidelines recommend them for pruritus relief; however, the rest only suggest the use of oral antihistamines in the context of other atopic comorbidities or for their sedating effects. Some guidelines also specifically address issues with AD management in tropical and subtropical regions, including the occlusiveness of ointments/emollients and the practicality of wet wrap therapy in hotter, more humid climates [42, 52, 66].

Guideline Adherence/Pharmacologic Treatment Utilization

Adherence to treatment guidelines was quite good regarding topical treatment of AD in surveys of physicians in Southeast Asia; however, adherence to systemic treatments was not as high. The use of emollients for clearance and maintenance was high (98–100% and 86–100%, respectively) among dermatologists surveyed from the Philippines, Thailand, Malaysia, and Singapore but was significantly less likely among dermatologists from Vietnam or Indonesia [35]. The use of topical anti-inflammatory therapies was also quite high, with 91–100% of respondents prescribing TCSs [35, 59]. The majority (86–90%) of respondents from Singapore, Thailand, and South Korea had used TCIs; however, few (9–24%) of the respondents from Indonesia, Malaysia, or Vietnam had used them, mostly because of a lack of access to these medications (55–67%) [35, 59]. The use of oral antihistamines (86–100%) and oral corticosteroids (67–100%) was quite high [35, 59], despite the lack of recommendations for their use or against it. Single-center studies conducted in India and Pakistan showed that most patients are treated with emollients (95%) and topical anti-inflammatory therapies (75%, nearly all TCSs) [20, 67, 68] in accordance with guidelines. However, 75% of patients received antihistamines [20] and 25–78% received oral corticosteroids, although they were prescribed on a short-term basis [20, 67]. Although treatment guidelines caution against chronic use of systemic corticosteroids, they are used this way quite frequently in Latin America [52].

Utilization of Traditional/Herbal Remedies

The Asian-Pacific, Taiwanese, and South Korean guidelines recommend that patients be advised about the lack of high-quality evidence to support the use of traditional/herbal remedies [42–44, 47]. Accordingly, a majority of Southeast Asian dermatologists surveyed do not recommend the use of these alternative treatments [35]. However, in many developing countries, traditional medicine continues to play an important role in meeting healthcare needs [69]. In surveys of South Korean patients with AD, approximately 70% reported using complementary alternative medicine (i.e., bath therapy, dietary therapy, health supplements, massage, traditional Chinese medicine, topical applicants) [70, 71]. In Brazilian AD and Nigerian dermatology populations, the prevalence of use was only slightly less at 64% and 65%, respectively [72, 73]. In areas of limited resources, these remedies are often more accessible and less expensive than pharmacologic treatments; however, their efficacy may be limited and is largely unproven. In fact, only 32% of South Korean users believed that their AD had improved with complementary alternative medicine [71]. A recent Cochrane review failed to find sufficient high-quality evidence to support the use of Chinese herbal medicine [74], and 76% of allergists and dermatologists surveyed in South Korea believe that the lack of evidence for complementary alternative medicine was a barrier to proper AD management. Although traditional/herbal remedies are often perceived as being safer than pharmacologic treatments, they are not without some concerning potential side effects, including liver and kidney toxicity, and are more often subject to contamination [5, 75]. However, the greater use of these alternative treatments observed in older children with longer-standing disease [72, 76, 77] and children with more atopic comorbidities/higher IgE levels—although this difference was not significant [76, 77]—may reflect frustration with pharmacologic treatments or fear of using higher doses of pharmacologic treatments for more severe/recalcitrant disease. In fact, approximately one-third of traditional Chinese medicine users (31–36%) use it in combination with corticosteroids or other “Western medicine” [76, 77], possibly in an effort to reduce the need for TCSs [78] (see the Challenges in AD Management section for more information on TCS misuse).

Challenges in AD Management

Some challenges in AD management are universal. Thus far, no cure exists for AD, and treatment is targeted at symptom management. Currently available treatments for severe AD are costly and require subcutaneous injection (e.g., dupilumab [79]) or associated with significant adverse effects (e.g., systemic corticosteroids [80]). Topical corticosteroids, the mainstay of treatment for mild-to-moderate AD, require complex dosing regimens (i.e., low potency for the face and neck, higher potency for other body areas) [81], are associated with significant adverse effects when used chronically [82], and can lead to hypopigmentation in darker skin [5, 16]. These problems have led to corticosteroid phobia among many patients with AD and underuse and/or nonuse of prescribed TCSs [40, 59, 70, 83]. However, in India, most TCSs are available over the counter, which has led to misuse [84, 85]; efforts are underway to curtail this practice by making TCSs available by prescription only [86]. Other challenges are more specific to developing countries. Limited/ineffective healthcare systems [59, 87] and a lack of specialists with training in the management of AD [59, 88] are among the major challenges. In addition, regional differences in availability (Table 3) [89-120] present a challenge, as does the cost of AD treatment [121, 122], especially for newer, more effective treatments [123-125]. Lower socioeconomic status can also have a negative impact on access to care and adherence to treatment [17, 121], and the differences in clinical presentation and symptoms for patients with darker skin tones and different ethnic origins mentioned above may lead to delayed diagnosis and, in turn, more severe disease at diagnosis.
Table 3

Approved monotherapy products in developing countries

TCS
HydrocortisoneDesonideMometasone furoateFluticasone propionateTriamcinolone acetonideBetamethasone valerateBetamethasone dipropionateClobetasol propionate
East Asia
 China [89]
 Hong Kong [90]
 Indonesia [91]
 Malaysia [92]
 Philippines [93]
 Singapore [94]
 South Korea [95]
 Taiwan [96]
 Thailand [97]
 Vietnam [98]
South Asia
 Bangladesh [99]
 India [100]
 Pakistan [101]
Latin America
 Argentina [102]
 Brazil [103]
 Chile [104]
 Colombia [105]
 Mexico [106]
 Peru [107]
 Venezuela [108]
Africa
 Egypt [109]
 Morocco [110]
 Nigeria [111]
 South Africa [112]
 Tunisia [113]
Middle East
 Jordan [114]
 Lebanon [115]
 Oman [116]
 Qatar [117]
 Saudi Arabia [118]
 Turkey [119]
 United Arab Emirates [120]

All information accessed in 2019

PDE4 phosphodiesterase 4, TCIs topical calcineurin inhibitors, TCS topical corticosteroids

Approved monotherapy products in developing countries All information accessed in 2019 PDE4 phosphodiesterase 4, TCIs topical calcineurin inhibitors, TCS topical corticosteroids Other challenges arise from the fact that most diagnostic criteria and guidelines have been developed for European and North American populations, and very few clinical studies of dermatologic treatments (11%) conducted outside/not exclusively within the US even report the racial or ethnic makeup of the study population [126]. Although approximately 60% of US-based studies do include such information [126, 127], the applicability to developing countries is, of course, limited because of differences in environment, etc. The efficacy and safety of several treatments have been assessed in patients living in developing countries (including tacrolimus for patients in China [128], South Korea [129], Thailand [130], and Bangladesh [131]; TCSs for patients in Singapore [132], India [133], and Bangladesh [131]; and methotrexate for patients in Egypt [134]). In one analysis, results from clinical studies of tacrolimus conducted in eight Asian countries (China, Indonesia, South Korea, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore, Taiwan, and Thailand) were pooled and found to be similar to those observed for studies conducted in the US and Europe [135]. However, differences between racial groups in drug pharmacokinetics and skin physiology may affect treatment response (although to a lesser degree than other factors, such as age and skin barrier function), and the potential for these differences to affect outcomes remains largely unexplored [5].

Conclusions

Globally, a substantial unmet medical need exists in AD management. This need is magnified in developing countries by many of the factors discussed above and may lead to inadequate or inappropriate treatment. In fact, 15% of patients in one community-based study in Singapore reported receiving no treatment [136]. In another study, only 36% of patients in an area of North India with limited resources sought medical care for their dermatologic condition, and 69% received inappropriate or ineffective treatment according to the authors [137]. Increased training of primary care physicians and specialists, changes in healthcare systems to improve access and affordability of care, and the development of new and more effective treatments will help reduce this unmet need. In addition, innovations in healthcare delivery such as teledermatology [138, 139] and task sharing/shifting [140] may also improve patient care. Patient and caregiver education may also improve AD treatment adherence and clinical outcomes as well as patient and family quality of life in developing countries [141-145].
  95 in total

Review 1.  Chinese medicinal materials and their interface with Western medical concepts.

Authors:  Kelvin Chan
Journal:  J Ethnopharmacol       Date:  2005-01-04       Impact factor: 4.360

2.  Comparative efficacy of Hanifin and Rajka's criteria and the UK working party's diagnostic criteria in diagnosis of atopic dermatitis in a hospital setting in North India.

Authors:  D De; A J Kanwar; S Handa
Journal:  J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol       Date:  2006-08       Impact factor: 6.166

3.  The proactive treatment of atopic dermatitis with tacrolimus ointment in Korean patients: a comparative study between once-weekly and thrice-weekly applications.

Authors:  B Y Chung; H O Kim; J H Kim; S I Cho; C H Lee; C W Park
Journal:  Br J Dermatol       Date:  2013-01-31       Impact factor: 9.302

Review 4.  Adverse effects of topical glucocorticosteroids.

Authors:  Ulrich R Hengge; Thomas Ruzicka; Robert A Schwartz; Michael J Cork
Journal:  J Am Acad Dermatol       Date:  2006-01       Impact factor: 11.527

5.  [Mexican consensus on the diagnosis and treatment of atopic dermatitis in adolescents and adults].

Authors:  Catalina Rincón-Pérez; Désirée Larenas-Linnemann; Marco Antonio Figueroa-Morales; Jorge Luna-Pech; Linda García-Hidalgo; Alejandra Macías-Weinmann; Javier Gómez-Vera; José Fernando Barba-Gómez; Juan José Matta-Campos; Esther Guevara-Sangines; Fermín Jurado-Santacruz; Adriana López Tello-Santillán; José Antonio Ortega-Martell; Nancy Pulido-Díaz; Liliana Guadalupe Serrano-Jaén; Mirna Toledo-Bahena; Guadalupe Villanueva-Quintero; José Luis Mayorga-Butrón
Journal:  Rev Alerg Mex       Date:  2018

6.  Atopic dermatitis guideline. Position paper from the Latin American Society of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology.

Authors:  Jorge Sánchez; Bruno Páez; A Macías; C Olmos; A de Falco
Journal:  Rev Alerg Mex       Date:  2014 Jul-Sep

7.  Filaggrin gene polymorphisms in Iranian ichthyosis vulgaris and atopic dermatitis patients.

Authors:  Bita Hassani; Anna Isaian; Mansoureh Shariat; Hasan Mollanoori; Soheila Sotoudeh; Vahid Babaei; Arghavan Ziaali; Shahram Teimourian
Journal:  Int J Dermatol       Date:  2018-09-23       Impact factor: 2.736

8.  A practical algorithm for topical treatment of atopic dermatitis in the Middle East emphasizing the importance of sensitive skin areas.

Authors:  Ashraf M Reda; Ayman Elgendi; Ahmed Ismail Ebraheem; Mohammed S Aldraibi; Mohammed Saleh Qari; Magdy Mohammad R Abdulghani; Thomas Luger
Journal:  J Dermatolog Treat       Date:  2018-11-21       Impact factor: 3.359

9.  Diagnostic agreement between a primary care physician and a teledermatologist for common dermatological conditions in North India.

Authors:  Binod Kumar Patro; Jaya Prasad Tripathy; Dipankar De; Smita Sinha; Amarjeet Singh; Amrinder Jit Kanwar
Journal:  Indian Dermatol Online J       Date:  2015 Jan-Feb

10.  Topical corticosteroid misuse: the Indian scenario.

Authors:  Arijit Coondoo
Journal:  Indian J Dermatol       Date:  2014-09       Impact factor: 1.494

View more
  10 in total

1.  Dermatological Conditions in SKIN OF COLOR-: Managing Atopic Dermatitis.

Authors:  Archana M Sangha
Journal:  J Clin Aesthet Dermatol       Date:  2021-03-01

Review 2.  Algal Lipids as Modulators of Skin Disease: A Critical Review.

Authors:  Tiago Conde; Diana Lopes; Wojciech Łuczaj; Bruno Neves; Bruno Pinto; Tatiana Maurício; Pedro Domingues; Elżbieta Skrzydlewska; M Rosário Domingues
Journal:  Metabolites       Date:  2022-01-20

3.  Model learning analysis of 3D optoacoustic mesoscopy images for the classification of atopic dermatitis.

Authors:  Sojeong Park; Shier Nee Saw; Xiuting Li; Mahsa Paknezhad; Davide Coppola; U S Dinish; Amalina Binite Ebrahim Attia; Yik Weng Yew; Steven Tien Guan Thng; Hwee Kuan Lee; Malini Olivo
Journal:  Biomed Opt Express       Date:  2021-05-27       Impact factor: 3.732

4.  Epidemiologic features and burden of atopic dermatitis in adolescent and adult patients: A cross-sectional multicenter study.

Authors:  Gloria Sanclemente; Natalia Hernandez; Daniela Chaparro; Liliana Tamayo; Angela Lopez
Journal:  World Allergy Organ J       Date:  2021-12-06       Impact factor: 4.084

Review 5.  Patient-reported outcome (PRO) instruments for disease severity and quality of life in patients with atopic dermatitis: a systematic review of English and Chinese literature.

Authors:  Aihua Li; Minlu Zhang; Yating Yang; Joshua Zhang; Xiaoping Xie; Xiaoxian Li; Hui Zhang
Journal:  Ann Transl Med       Date:  2022-08

6.  Genetic polymorphisms in serine protease inhibitor Kazal-type 5 and risk of atopic dermatitis: A meta-analysis.

Authors:  Yunling Li; Yin Li; Wei Li; Xiaoxuan Guo; Sha Zhou; Huiwen Zheng
Journal:  Medicine (Baltimore)       Date:  2020-07-10       Impact factor: 1.817

7.  Cannabinoid Receptor 2 Modulates Maturation of Dendritic Cells and Their Capacity to Induce Hapten-Induced Contact Hypersensitivity.

Authors:  Evelyn Gaffal; Andrea M Kemter; Stefanie Scheu; Rafael Leite Dantas; Jens Vogt; Bernhard Baune; Thomas Tüting; Andreas Zimmer; Judith Alferink
Journal:  Int J Mol Sci       Date:  2020-01-11       Impact factor: 5.923

8.  Atopic dermatitis.

Authors:  Elena Galli; Bianca Cinicola; Rossella Carello; Silvia Caimmi; Giulia Brindisi; Giovanna De Castro; Anna Maria Zicari; Maria Angela Tosca; Sara Manti; Alberto Martelli; Mauro Calvani; Claudio Cravidi; Gian Luigi Marseglia; Fabio Cardinale; Michele Miraglia Del Giudice; Carlo Caffarelli; Marzia Duse
Journal:  Acta Biomed       Date:  2020-09-15

Review 9.  The Association Between Intestinal Bacteria and Allergic Diseases-Cause or Consequence?

Authors:  Pei Han; Jian-Qing Gu; Li-Sha Li; Xue-Yan Wang; Hong-Tian Wang; Yan Wang; Christopher Chang; Jin-Lyu Sun
Journal:  Front Cell Infect Microbiol       Date:  2021-04-15       Impact factor: 5.293

Review 10.  Potential of Tamanu (Calophyllum inophyllum) Oil for Atopic Dermatitis Treatment.

Authors:  Amadeus Pribowo; Jyothsna Girish; Marsia Gustiananda; Rakrya Galih Nandhira; Pietradewi Hartrianti
Journal:  Evid Based Complement Alternat Med       Date:  2021-12-26       Impact factor: 2.629

  10 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.