Lian Li1, Jiawei Wang1, Yachao Li1, D Christopher Radford2, Jiyuan Yang1, Jindřich Kopeček1,2. 1. Department of Pharmaceutics and Pharmaceutical Chemistry, Center for Controlled Chemical Delivery , University of Utah , Salt Lake City , Utah 84112 , United States. 2. Department of Biomedical Engineering , University of Utah , Salt Lake City , Utah 84112 , United States.
Abstract
Monoclonal antibody therapy has offered treatment benefits. Nonetheless, a lack of efficacy still exists, partially because monovalent binding of antibodies to specific receptors fails to translate into an active response. Here, we report a pretargeting-postassembly approach that exploits the selective Watson-Crick base pairing properties of oligonucleotides and multivalently tethers receptor-prebound antibodies to albumin at the cell surface. We demonstrate that this two-step self-assembling strategy allows sequential actions of receptor binding and clustering that broadens and strengthens the functions of antibodies. We show that anti-CD20 obinutuzumab (OBN) modified with one morpholino oligonucleotide (OBN-MORF1) maintains the feature of naked OBN antibody upon CD20 binding, and results in actin redistribution, homotypic adhesion, and lysosome-mediated cell death. Consecutive treatment with albumin grafted with multiple copies of a complementary morpholino oligonucleotide (HSA-(MORF2)x) hybridizes with surface-attached OBN-MORF1, manipulates CD20 clustering, and engages additional signals to induce calcium influx and caspase-related apoptosis. With the two types of different mechanisms collaborating in one system, the simple design exerted a notable survival extension of mice bearing disseminated B-cell lymphomas.
Monoclonal antibody therapy has offered treatment benefits. Nonetheless, a lack of efficacy still exists, partially because monovalent binding of antibodies to specific receptors fails to translate into an active response. Here, we report a pretargeting-postassembly approach that exploits the selective Watson-Crick base pairing properties of oligonucleotides and multivalently tethers receptor-prebound antibodies to albumin at the cell surface. We demonstrate that this two-step self-assembling strategy allows sequential actions of receptor binding and clustering that broadens and strengthens the functions of antibodies. We show that anti-CD20 obinutuzumab (OBN) modified with one morpholino oligonucleotide (OBN-MORF1) maintains the feature of naked OBN antibody upon CD20 binding, and results in actin redistribution, homotypic adhesion, and lysosome-mediated cell death. Consecutive treatment with albumin grafted with multiple copies of a complementary morpholino oligonucleotide (HSA-(MORF2)x) hybridizes with surface-attached OBN-MORF1, manipulates CD20 clustering, and engages additional signals to induce calcium influx and caspase-related apoptosis. With the two types of different mechanisms collaborating in one system, the simple design exerted a notable survival extension of mice bearing disseminated B-cell lymphomas.
Despite the
considerable success
of monoclonal antibodies for cancer therapy, the therapeutic outcomes
are sometimes less satisfactory.[1] Although
many antibodies antagonize specific cell-surface receptors, the monovalent
or divalent binding does not always elicit sufficient blockade of
pro-oncogenic downstream pathways.[2−4] In many cases, it also
requires those antibody-binding receptors to assemble into oligomeric
complexes.[5−7] In fact, ligand-induced receptor clustering is critical
for magnifying apoptosis,[8−11] and can be driven by multivalent constructs of antibodies
attached to nanoparticles or polymers.[12−14] In this aspect, antibody
functionalization of nanovehicles requires a defined structure with
control over composition, valency, and conjugation site to ensure
batch to batch reproducibility.[15] During
synthesis, it is crucial to avoid the loss of antibody targeting ability
and minimize the interference of its biological activity.[16] In addition, the inevitably enlarged size and
the use of synthetic biomaterials might raise concerns when advancing
into clinical trials. Yet, an easy, universal methodology for efficient
antibody assembly at the cell surface is missing but highly demanding.To this end, we proposed that a two-step pretargeting–postassembly
approach that separates the functions of cell binding and antibody
multimerization might be a cure. In this approach antibodies work
independently, binding to the cell before they are triggered to self-assemble
into multimers and are further endowed with increased vigor and additional
functionalities. We tested this hypothesis by exploiting the selective
Watson–Crick base pairing properties of oligonucleotides and
using human serum albumin (HSA), a natural transport protein with
long circulatory half-life, good biocompatibility for clinical practice,
and multiple chemical conjugation sites,[17] to cross-link anti-CD20 antibodies.Anti-CD20 antibodies are
used to treat all common B-cell hematologic
malignancies, but the overall response rate is low.[18,19] Type I rituximab (RTX) binds between two CD20 tetramers resulting
in accumulation in lipid rafts (cholesterol rich domains), calcium
influx and caspase activation.[20] CD20 clustering
by RTX itself is weak, but can be favored by its Fc interaction with
Fcγ receptor on immune effector cells. However, a great proportion
of patients are refractory to RTX due to the inactivity of effector
cells.[20] This catalyzed the development
of type II antibodies, such as obinutuzumab (OBN), which, in contrast,
do not induce CD20 clustering, but instead bind within one CD20 tetramer
with the conformation compatible with homotypic adhesion regions,
leading to lysosome disruption and direct cell death.[21] The mechanisms of RTX and OBN are complementary, but they
compete for overlapping CD20 epitopes, making their combination antagonistic.[22]Here, we report development of a single
platform that triggers
two types of mechanisms of cell death induction, namely, those of
type I and II anti-CD20 antibodies, and coordinates them to function
collaboratively. To this end, OBN was modified with a morpholino oligonucleotide
1 (OBN-MORF1). After OBN-MORF1 pretargeted surface CD20, human serum
albumin (HSA) grafted with multiple copies of complementary morpholino
oligonucleotide 2 (HSA-(MORF2)) was applied
as an actuator for CD20 clustering upon MORF1-MORF2 hybridization.
Morpholino oligonucleotides, denoted as MORFs, have DNA bases attached
to an altered backbone of methylenemorpholine rings linked through
phosphorodiamidate groups. In comparison to DNA molecules, complementary
MORFs also form double helices by Watson–Crick base pairing
(hybridization), but their charge-neutral phosphorodiamidate backbone
endows them with much stronger binding affinity than DNA, and makes
them more biocompatible and nuclease resistant, which ensures in vivo stability and safety. We hypothesized that following
OBN-MORF1 binding to CD20, receptor cross-linking bridged by HSA-(MORF2) would impose type I properties to type II
antibodies and create a therapeutic that combines effects of both
antibody types, producing greater antitumor activity (Scheme ).
Scheme 1
Pretargeting–Postassembly
Approach That Assembles OBN Antibodies
at Cell Surface
Without compromising the original
effects of (i) actin remodeling, (ii) lysosome disruption, and (iii)
ROS production afforded by naked OBN upon direct cell binding, clustered
OBN after HSA-mediated multimerization simultaneously induces additional
effects of (iv) receptor cross-linking, (v) calcium influx, (vi) caspase
activation, which confers complementary mechanism to enhance apoptosis.
Pretargeting–Postassembly
Approach That Assembles OBN Antibodies
at Cell Surface
Without compromising the original
effects of (i) actin remodeling, (ii) lysosome disruption, and (iii)
ROS production afforded by naked OBN upon direct cell binding, clustered
OBN after HSA-mediated multimerization simultaneously induces additional
effects of (iv) receptor cross-linking, (v) calcium influx, (vi) caspase
activation, which confers complementary mechanism to enhance apoptosis.
Results and Discussion
Synthesis and Characterizations
To synthesize antibody-MORF1,
whole antibody of RTX and OBN were partially reduced to selectively
expose the thiol groups in the hinge region leaving the Fab′
region available for receptor binding, followed by the thiol–ene
reaction with maleimide-functionalized MORF1 (Figure A). Similarly, multivalent HSA-(MORF2) was generated via the thiol–ene
reaction between freshly reduced MORF2 (3′-primary terminated
with thiol group) and maleimide-functionalized HSA (Figure B). The conjugates with defined
structures were confirmed by the single peaks that shifted toward
smaller elution volumes in size-exclusion chromatography as molecular
weight increased with successful attachments of morpholino oligonucleotides.
These conjugates were further characterized using bicinchoninic acid
protein assay determining antibody or HSA concentrations, UV–vis
spectrophotometry determining MORF concentrations, gel electrophoresis,
and mass spectroscopy; see Table and Supporting Information Figures S1–S3.
Figure 1
Illustration of synthesis and size-exclusion
chromatography characterization
of (A) antibody (RTX or OBN)-MORF1 conjugates and (B) HSA-(MORF2) conjugates as determined on Superdex 200
10/300 GL column eluted with PBS (pH 7.2) at flow rate 0.4 mL/min
and UV wavelength 280 nm. (C) Dynamic light scattering of the two
conjugates and their mixture (equimolar MORF1/MORF2) in pH 7.4 PBS.
(D) Hypochromic effect upon hybridization between the two conjugates
when they were mixed in different ratios, as measured by the optical
density at 260 nm in PBS pH 7.4 or 0.1 N HCl solution.
Table 1
Conjugate Characterization
conjugate
MORF
valence
Cy5/antibody
Cy3/HSA
RTX-MORF1
1.15
–
–
RTX-MORF1-Cy5
1.12
1.74
–
OBN-MORF1
1.21
–
–
OBN-MORF1-Cy5
1.18
1.65
–
HSA-MORF2
1.2
–
–
HSA-(MORF2)5
5.4
–
–
HSA-(MORF2)10
9.4
–
–
HSA-(MORF2)15
16.6
–
–
HSA-(MORF2)10-Cy3
11.4
–
1.46
Illustration of synthesis and size-exclusion
chromatography characterization
of (A) antibody (RTX or OBN)-MORF1 conjugates and (B) HSA-(MORF2) conjugates as determined on Superdex 200
10/300 GL column eluted with PBS (pH 7.2) at flow rate 0.4 mL/min
and UV wavelength 280 nm. (C) Dynamic light scattering of the two
conjugates and their mixture (equimolar MORF1/MORF2) in pH 7.4 PBS.
(D) Hypochromic effect upon hybridization between the two conjugates
when they were mixed in different ratios, as measured by the optical
density at 260 nm in PBS pH 7.4 or 0.1 N HCl solution.As illustrated in Figure C, both OBN-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2)10 were
initially
less than 10 nm in diameter, whereas their mixture at 1:1 MORF1:MORF2
ratio resulted in substantial increase in size (∼40 nm), indicating
their self-assembly. To validate that MORF1-MORF2 biorecognition triggered
the hybridization of the two conjugates, “hypochromic effect”,
in which hydrogen bonding between complementary bases in MORFs decreases
the resonance of the aromatic rings,[23] was
evaluated. As shown in Figure D, the optical density at 260 nm of their mixture in phosphate
buffered saline (PBS, pH 7.4) dropped to a minimum when MORF1 and
MORF2 were in equimolar amounts. Meanwhile, incubation in 0.1 N hydrochloric
acid (HCl) that destroyed the MORF1-MORF2 interaction prevented the
“hypochromic effect”, and resulted in the collapse of
OBN-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2)10 aggregates. In addition, the
efficient hybridization between these two conjugates via specific biorecognition between MORF1 and MORF2 was further confirmed
by gel electrophoresis (Supporting Information Figure S3).
Two-Step Binding at Cell Surface
In this general approach,
cell-surface multimerization of antibodies requires two sequential
steps: (i) specific receptor binding via antibody
targeting, and (ii) multivalent attachment to HSA via MORF1-MORF2 hybridization. Thus, to demonstrate the self-assembly
of antibody-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2) at
surface CD20, a coculture of CD20 positive Raji-GFP (expressing green
fluorescent protein) and CD20 negative DG-75 cells were consecutively
exposed to Cy5-labeled RTX-MORF1/OBN-MORF1 and Cy3-labeled HSA-(MORF2). As shown in Figure A, majority of Raji-GFP cells were dual stained
with Cy3 and Cy5, while DG-75 cells had minimum fluorescence, demonstrating
that the system is highly CD20 specific. Moreover, a profoundly stronger
signal of Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), which was
generated by the close proximity of Cy5 to Cy3, was observed in Raji-GFP
cells than DG-75 cells, indicating that the first step of receptor
binding is the prerequisite for the next step of surface biorecognition
between antibody-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2).
Figure 2
(A) The highly specific self-assembly of antibody-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2) at the surface of CD20 expressing Raji B
cells. A coculture of CD20 positive Raji-GFP cells and CD20 negative
DG-75 cells with 1:1 ratio were exposed to 0.5 μM Cy5-labeled
RTX-MORF1 or OBN-MORF1 for 1 h. Afterward, cells were washed to remove
the unbound conjugates and further incubated with Cy3-labeled HSA-(MORF2)10 (0.5 μM MORF2) for another 1 h. Fluorescence of Cy5,
Cy3, and their FRET signal in different cells (distinguished by GFP
expression) was analyzed by flow cytometry. Confocal microscopic images
of antibody-MORF1-Cy5 pretreated Raji cells after consecutive treatment
with HSA-(MORF2)10-Cy3 in the (B) absence or (C) presence
of excessive free MORF2 (20 μM). Red: Cy5; Green: Cy3; Blue:
nuclei.
(A) The highly specific self-assembly of antibody-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2) at the surface of CD20 expressing Raji B
cells. A coculture of CD20 positive Raji-GFP cells and CD20 negative
DG-75 cells with 1:1 ratio were exposed to 0.5 μM Cy5-labeled
RTX-MORF1 or OBN-MORF1 for 1 h. Afterward, cells were washed to remove
the unbound conjugates and further incubated with Cy3-labeled HSA-(MORF2)10 (0.5 μM MORF2) for another 1 h. Fluorescence of Cy5,
Cy3, and their FRET signal in different cells (distinguished by GFP
expression) was analyzed by flow cytometry. Confocal microscopic images
of antibody-MORF1-Cy5 pretreated Raji cells after consecutive treatment
with HSA-(MORF2)10-Cy3 in the (B) absence or (C) presence
of excessive free MORF2 (20 μM). Red: Cy5; Green: Cy3; Blue:
nuclei.To visualize the self-assembly
on cell surface, Raji B cells were
pretreated with OBN-MORF1-Cy5 or RTX-MORF1-Cy5, followed by sequential
exposure to HSA-(MORF2)10-Cy3. As expected, the cell membrane
was decorated with a substantial colocalization of Cy3 and Cy5 fluorescence
(Figure B). In addition,
when antibody-MORF1-Cy5 pretargeted cells were further incubated with
a mixture of HSA-(MORF2)10-Cy3 and excessive free MORF2,
the binding of HSA onto cells was drastically reduced (Figure C), indicating the cell-surface
tethering of antibody to HSA via MORF1-MORF2 interaction.
Surface Assembling of Antibodies Amplifies Apoptosis
We
next evaluated whether clustering CD20-bound antibodies by albumin
further amplified apoptosis (Figure ). We coined the term “clustered OBN/RTX”
(cOBN/cRTX) to describe the consecutive treatment composed of OBN-MORF1/RTX-MORF1
followed by HSA-(MORF2). As shown in Figure A, HSA-(MORF2)10 alone did not contribute to cytotoxicity, as compared with
the untreated group. Although RTX binds between two CD20 tetramers,[20] its capability to bivalently cross-link CD20
was insufficient and only led to moderate apoptosis. Clustered RTX-MORF1
by multivalent HSA-(MORF2)10 (cRTX) resulted in an increased
level of early apoptosis because of the amplification of surface CD20
cross-linking. Meanwhile, even binding within one CD20 tetramer,[22] OBN itself could trigger potent apoptosis (especially
late apoptosis). By comparison, the addition of RTX (RTX+OBN) antagonized
the efficacy of OBN, most likely due to the mutual interference during
competing for binding their overlapping CD20 epitope.[22] In contrast, cell-surface clustering of OBN-MORF1 by HSA-(MORF2)10 (cOBN) further enhanced the OBN-triggered induction of apoptosis,
leading to substantial cell death significantly higher than all controls.
Figure 3
(A) Apoptosis
induction in Raji cells untreated or treated with
RTX, cRTX, OBN, cOBN, or combination of RTX and OBN. (B) Effects of
valency of HSA-(MORF2) on cRTX/cOBN mediated
apoptosis induction. (C) Comparison of whole antibody and Fab′
fragment after multivalent attachment to HSA-(MORF2)10 to
induce apoptosis. (D) CD20 binding assay comparing maximum binding
of RTX-MORF1, OBN-MORF1, Fab′(RTX)-MORF1, and Fab′(OBN)-MORF1
to Raji cells. *P < 0.05, n.s., not significant,
by Student’s t test.
(A) Apoptosis
induction in Raji cells untreated or treated with
RTX, cRTX, OBN, cOBN, or combination of RTX and OBN. (B) Effects of
valency of HSA-(MORF2) on cRTX/cOBN mediated
apoptosis induction. (C) Comparison of whole antibody and Fab′
fragment after multivalent attachment to HSA-(MORF2)10 to
induce apoptosis. (D) CD20 binding assay comparing maximum binding
of RTX-MORF1, OBN-MORF1, Fab′(RTX)-MORF1, and Fab′(OBN)-MORF1
to Raji cells. *P < 0.05, n.s., not significant,
by Student’s t test.To gain insight into the influence of the conjugates’ structure
on apoptosis induction, we investigated the effect of HSA-(MORF2) valence, and compared the whole OBN antibody
with its Fab′ fragment. Figure B shows the multivalency of HSA-(MORF2) is essential for cRTX and cOBN-augmented apoptosis.
In contrast to HSA-(MORF2) conjugate,
which functions as cross-linking effector and largely relies on MORF2
multivalence, OBN-(MORF1)3 conjugate with higher MORF1
valence showed slightly decreased induction of apoptosis as compared
with monovalent OBN-MORF1, after HSA-(MORF2)10 cross-linking
(Supporting Information Figure S4). This
might be explained in the following way: Once one MORF1 recognizes
MORF2, the extra MORF1 motifs on the same antibody are more
prone to hybridize and consume the MORF2 motifs on HSA-(MORF2) conjugate, which decreases the ability of
HSA-(MORF2) to accommodate other OBN-(MORF1); consequently, the cross-linking effect
of CD20 receptors is compromised, resulting in decreased apoptosis
induction.Notably, multivalent cross-linking of Fab′
fragment from
OBN (Supporting Information Figure S5)
was not effective to further enhance apoptosis (Figure C). This suggests the importance of binding
orientation toward CD20 and the elbow angle of OBN to elicit direct
cell death.[22] Consistent with numerous
studies,[22,24] the maximum binding to CD20 showed that
OBN occupied only half of the number of CD20-binding sites as RTX
(Figure D). This could
be explained by the inter-CD20 tetramer binding of type I RTX, resulting
in two antibodies bound per tetramer, and intratetramer binding of
type II OBN, resulting in only one antibody bound per CD20 tetramer.
Interestingly, Fab′(RTX)-MORF1 and Fab′(OBN)-MORF1 showed similar CD20 binding curves (Figure D), suggesting converting whole
OBN antibody to Fab′ abrogated that specific conformation,
and the type II specific functions were lost. In contrast, clustered
cOBN triggered higher apoptosis than naked OBN, indicating CD20 cross-linking
might give additional mechanism to type II antibody to kill B cells.
cOBN Combines Type I and Type II Effects
CD20 redistribution
in lipid rafts is a typical characteristic of type I anti-CD20 antibody,
which subsequently triggers calcium influx and a series of downstream
pathways.[25] We are aware of discrepancies
in the literature on the existence of lipid rafts.[26,27] The results below are discussed using the term “lipid rafts”
but could also be interpreted using “cholesterol rich membrane
domains”.As shown in Figure A, a great proportion of RTX bound on cell
surface and redistributed within lipid rafts. A further increment
in lipid raft colocalization occurred when cells were treated with
cRTX, because cRTX augmented surface CD20 cross-linking. Unlike type
I RTX, OBN induced strong homotypic cell aggregation, massively accumulated
at cell–cell contact sites, and did not substantially translocate
into lipid rafts, which are typical type II characteristics.[21] Of note, cOBN not only induced homotypic cell
aggregation but also substantially colocalized with lipid rafts, indicating
cOBN had characteristics of both type I and type II anti-CD20 antibodies.
As shown in Figure B, before HSA-(MORF2)10 stimulation, RTX-MORF1 mediated
moderate calcium influx while OBN-MORF1 did not induce calcium influx.
This is because RTX binds between CD20 tetramers resulting in redistribution
in lipid rafts, and OBN binds within one tetramer without involvement
of CD20 cross-linking.[22] Interestingly,
after HSA-(MORF2)10 stimulation, a significant rise in
calcium concentration occurred for both RTX-MORF1 and OBN-MORF1, which
could be explained by the multivalent binding by HSA-(MORF2)10 recognition and subsequent surface CD20 clustering. To further
investigate whether CD20 cross-linking and caspase activation were
involved in cRTX/cOBN-induced apoptosis, Raji cells were pretreated
with β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) to deplete cholesterol[28,29] or pan caspase inhibitor Z-VAD-FMK, followed by the various treatments. Figure C shows CD20 clustering
and caspase activation were engaged in RTX and cRTX treatments, but
not involved in OBN treatment. Notably, cOBN exploited both type I
and type II mechanisms and gave additional apoptosis induction as
compared with OBN.
Figure 4
Apoptotic pathways including (A) CD20 redistribution in
lipid rafts,
(B) calcium influx, and (C) caspase activity after Raji cells were
treated with RTX, cRTX, OBN, or cOBN. *P < 0.05,
n.s., not significant, by Student’s t test.
Apoptotic pathways including (A) CD20 redistribution in
lipid rafts,
(B) calcium influx, and (C) caspase activity after Raji cells were
treated with RTX, cRTX, OBN, or cOBN. *P < 0.05,
n.s., not significant, by Student’s t test.cOBN also maintained typical type II characteristics,
resulting
in the enrichment of F-actin at cell surface and cell–cell
adhesion sites (Figure A), pronounced intercell homotypic adhesion (Figure B), and disrupted lysosomes (Figure C), while cRTX’s influence
was weak and limited. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are generated
downstream of OBN-induced actin cytoskeletal reorganization and lysosome
membrane permeabilization, and play a central role in inducing potent
cell death.[30] RTX could also contribute
to ROS production by causing mitochondrial depolarization.[31] Thus, ROS production is related to the shared
downstream pathways by both type I and type II antibodies. As demonstrated
in Figure D, RTX only
mediated modest ROS production as compared with the untreated control,
while cRTX greatly increased the level of ROS generation due to the amplified
CD20 clustering and subsequently higher level of mitochondrial depolarization.
Meanwhile, OBN significantly augmented the ROS production because
lysosome disruption directly induces potent ROS evocation.[30] Moreover, a further enhancement in ROS generation
was induced when Raji cells were treated with cOBN. This might be
the consequence of involvement of both type I and type II pathways.
Figure 5
Type II
apoptotic pathways including (A) actin cytoskeleton remodeling,
(B) intercell homotypic adhesion, (C) lysosome-mediated cell death,
and (D) ROS generation after Raji cells were treated with RTX, cRTX,
OBN, or cOBN.
Type II
apoptotic pathways including (A) actin cytoskeleton remodeling,
(B) intercell homotypic adhesion, (C) lysosome-mediated cell death,
and (D) ROS generation after Raji cells were treated with RTX, cRTX,
OBN, or cOBN.
In Vivo Validation of cOBN Activity
Having demonstrated cOBN combines
the effects of type I and type
II anti-CD20 antibodies, we sought to test its therapeutic efficacy in vivo. NOD/SCID-Rag1nullγnull (NRG) mice bearing systemically disseminated Raji B-cell lymphomas
were given three doses of saline, OBN, and cOBN weekly as indicated
in Figure A. Saline
treated mice became hind limb paralyzed rapidly with the median survival
of 19 days. OBN significantly extended the median survival to 57 days.
Significantly, cOBN further prolonged the mice survival with the median
survival of 83 days, and half of the mice were still paralysis-free
after 100 days (Figure B) without the loss of body weight (Figure C). At the end point, bone marrow (BM) cells
were isolated from femur, and dissemination of Raji cells (human CD10+CD19+)
in BM was analyzed (Figure D and Supporting Information Figure S6). Variably significant amounts of Raji cells were observed in BM
of paralyzed mice from different treatments. However, in long-term
survivors treated with cOBN, the presence of Raji cells was minimal.
Figure 6
(A) Treatment
schedule (see Experimental Procedures for
dosing), (B) paralysis-free survival, (C) body weight change,
and (D) residual Raji cells (human CD10+CD19+) in bone marrow (BM)
of NRG mice bearing disseminated Raji B-cell lymphomas after treatment
with saline, OBN, or cOBN. A 5 h interval was applied between the
consecutive injections of OBN-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2)10 for
cOBN treatment. BM cells isolated from native NRG mouse served as
the negative control, and Raji cells served as the positive control.
*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, by
Student’s t test.
(A) Treatment
schedule (see Experimental Procedures for
dosing), (B) paralysis-free survival, (C) body weight change,
and (D) residual Raji cells (human CD10+CD19+) in bone marrow (BM)
of NRG mice bearing disseminated Raji B-cell lymphomas after treatment
with saline, OBN, or cOBN. A 5 h interval was applied between the
consecutive injections of OBN-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2)10 for
cOBN treatment. BM cells isolated from native NRG mouse served as
the negative control, and Raji cells served as the positive control.
*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, by
Student’s t test.Previously, we demonstrated that multivalent cross-linking of CD20-pretargeted
Fab′ fragments from RTX by N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide
(HPMA) copolymer amplified apoptosis and circumvented numerous resistant
pathways.[8,23] While still exploiting the concept of two-step
pretargeting–postassembly, the next-generation platform developed
herein has several features, which leads to broader impacts in the
following aspects.First, it broadens the scope of application.
Previous strategies
harnessed Fab′ fragments of antibodies solely as targeting
agents, and primarily focused on augmenting the cross-linking of surface
receptors. The application is limited to antibodies that activate
a similar pathway (receptor ligation) to induce apoptosis, such as
RTX. In contrast, due to the loss of antibody conformation and abrogation
of initial effect, such approach is not applicable to a variety of
antibodies whose main mechanisms of action exclude receptor cross-linking.
This is exemplified by our results that hyper-cross-linking of OBN
Fab′ failed to further improve results obtained with OBN (Figure C). Instead, the
current strategy switches the focus to cell-surface multimerization
of antibodies, which looks to its application in a broader range.
To this end, Fab′ fragment is replaced by whole antibody. As
for the case of cOBN, it not only simplifies the fabrication process,
but also brings the benefits of antibody multimerization at the cell
surface receptor (Figure ) while still maintaining the biological activities of the
original antibody (Figure ). This eventually leads to a significant enhancement in therapeutic
efficacy (Figure A
and 6).Second, it broadens the functions
of the antibody. The mechanisms
of type I and type II anti-CD20 antibodies are distinct and theoretically
complementary, but in reality their combination is antagonistic because
their binding epitopes overlap. Our two-step strategy spatially separates
the operations of receptor binding by OBN-MORF1 pretargeting (exerting
type II effects) and antibody multimerization by HSA-(MORF2) cross-linking (exerting type I effects), which ensures
them to work independently. As compared with a previous strategy that
largely relied on amplification of type I signals, the next generation
combines the activation pathways of type I and type II antibodies
into one system. In our previous study using HPMA copolymer (P-(MORF2) conjugate) to cross-link Fab′(RTX)-MORF1 pretargeted cells, direct stochastic optical reconstruction
microscopy (dSTORM) indicated sporadic cell-to-cell cross-linking.[32] With a more rigid structure of HSA in the current
study, the ability of HSA-(MORF2) to
accommodate OBN-MORF1 attached on the same cell might decrease. However,
the pretreatment of type II OBN antibody induces significant cell
aggregation. The consequently closer proximity between cell interfaces
is highly likely to increase the chance for unoccupied MORF2 in HSA-(MORF2) to hybridize with OBN-MORF1 bound to other
cells. Thus, intracell and intercell CD20 cross-linking might simultaneously
occur after cOBN treatment. This approach might further provide additional
treatment strategies suitable for a broader spectrum of B-cell malignancies,
including treatment-resistant tumors.Third, it broadens the
utilization of the technique. In addition
to random-coiled HPMA copolymers-MORF2 conjugates that were previously
used for CD20 cross-linking, we demonstrated a more rigid structure
of HSA-(MORF2) (x =
5, 10, 15) with multivalency hybridized with antibody-MORF1 and effectively
induced significant apoptosis (Figure B). This implies that this technique is general and
can be expanded to various nanovehicles ranging from linear polymers
to more rigid systems (e.g., proteins, nanoparticles,
micelles). Moreover, HSA is a natural transport protein with a long
circulatory half-life, natural biocompatibility, and multiple ligand
binding sites. It is already an effective carrier for drugs, peptides,
and antibodies in clinical applications, with good reproducibility,
large-scale manufacture capability, and low cost. As compared with
the original effector using HPMA copolymer, the HSA-based construct
has its own advantage in translatability into clinics.
Conclusions
In summary, we successfully multimerized and
cross-linked CD20-prebound
OBN antibody by exploiting the hybridization of a pair of complementary
oligonucleotides and tethering antibodies to HSA. Normally, type I
and type II anti-CD20 antibodies exploit complementary mechanisms
of cell death induction to treat B-cell malignancies, but their combination
is antagonistic. Our designed system provides a therapeutic approach
capable of maintaining the characteristic features of type II antibodies
and simultaneously inducing additional type I effects: OBN-MORF1 targets
CD20, leading to actin cytoskeleton remodeling, lysosome disruption,
and ROS production; HSA-(MORF2)10 cross-links CD20-bound
OBN-MORF1, resulting in calcium influx and caspase activation. With
the two types of mechanisms collaborating in one system, cOBN (OBN-MORF1
followed by HSA-(MORF2)) showed notable
survival extension of mice bearing disseminated Raji B-cell lymphomas.
As antibodies, oligonucleotides, and HSA are all clinically used and
commercially available, we expect our simple but rational two-step
pretargeting–postassembly strategy for multimerizing antibodies
at the cell surface may be easily expanded to arm other antibodies
targeting different receptors with additional functionalities and
strengthen their therapeutic efficacy.
Experimental
Section
Synthesis of Antibody-MORF1 Conjugate
First, the end
amino group of 3′-amine-derivatized 25-mer phosphorodiamidate
morpholino oligomer MORF1 (5′-GAGTAAGCCAAGGAGAATCAATATA-linker-amine-3′,
MW = 8630.5 Da, customized and purchased from Gene Tools, Philomath,
OR) was converted to maleimide group by the reaction with 50 excess
of succinimidyl-(N-maleimidopropionamido)-diethylene
glycol]ester (SM-(PEG)2, Thermo Fisher Scientific). Briefly,
3′-amine-derivatized MORF1 (1.8 mg, 200 nmol) was dissolved
in 100 μL of 10 mM phosphate buffered saline (PBS, pH 7.4),
and SM-(PEG)2 (4.25 mg, 10 μmol) was dissolved in
50 μL of dimethyl sulfoxide. Then the two solutions were mixed
and the reaction was stirred for 2 h at room temperature to produce
maleimide modified MORF1. Afterward, unreacted SM-(PEG)2 was removed by ultracentrafiltration (Ultracel 3000 Da MWCO, Millipore)
with 10 mM PBS (pH 6.5) washing four times. Maleimide content was
measured using modified Ellman’s assay, and >90% conversion
was achieved.To conjugate MORF1 to monoclonal antibody rituximab
(RTX) or obinutuzumab (OBN), RTX (Genentech) or OBN (Genentech) with
the concentration of 4 mg/mL was reduced by 20 mM tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine
(TCEP, Sigma-Aldrich) in 100 mM citric buffer (pH 5.5) at 37 °C
for 2 h to selectively expose the thiol group in the hinge region.[33] Afterward, the reduced antibodies were purified
by ultracentrafiltration (Ultracel 30 000 Da MWCO, Millipore)
with 10 mM PBS (pH 6.5) four times. Ellman’s assay was used
to quantify the amount of exposed thiol groups on antibodies, and
approximately ∼6 thiol groups were found on a single thiolated
RTX and thiolated OBN. The conjugation of maleimide modified MORF1(300
μM) to thiolated RTX/OBN (200 μM) was performed in 0.5
mL of 10 mM PBS (pH 6.5) at room temperature for 2.5 h with the feeding
molar ratio [MORF1]:[RTX/OBN] of 1.5:1. The fabricated RTX-MORF1 and
OBN-MORF1 was further purified by ultracentrafiltration (Ultracel
30 000 Da MWCO, Millipore) with 10 mM PBS (pH 7.4) washing
four times.To prepare fluorescent-labeled RTX-MORF1-Cy5 and
OBN-MORF1-Cy5,
the lysine side-chains of RTX and OBN (4.5 mg, 30 nmol) were reacted
with cyanine 5 monosuccinimidyl ester (Cy5-NHS, Lumiprobe, 40 μg,
60 nmol) in 1 mL PBS (pH 7.4) for 2 h at room temperature with the
feeding molar ratio [antibody]:[Cy5-NHS] of 1:2. The obtained RTX-Cy5
and OBN-Cy5 was further purified using a PD 10 column to remove the
unreacted dye, then reduced by TCEP to expose thiol groups and conjugated
with maleimide modified MORF1 as described above.
Synthesis of
HSA-(MORF2) Conjugate
HSA-(MORF2) conjugate was synthesized
by maleimide functionalization of human serum albumin (HSA) surface
followed by thiol–ene reaction with thiol modified MORF2.[10] Briefly, HSA (3.35 mg, 50 nmol) was dissolved
in 450 μL of 10 mM PBS (pH 7.4), and SM-(PEG)2 (2.5
mg, 5.5 μmol) was dissolved in 50 μL of dimethyl sulfoxide.
Then the two solutions were mixed and the reaction was stirred for
2 h at room temperature to convert the surface amino groups of HSA
to maleimide groups. Afterward, unreacted SM-(PEG)2 was
removed by ultracentrafiltration (Ultracel 30 000 Da MWCO,
Millipore) with 10 mM PBS (pH 6.5) washing four times to yield maleimide
modified HSA. And according to modified Ellman’s assay, the
amount of maleimide molecules per HSA was ∼33.To prepare
MORF2 with a thiol end group, 3′-disulfide amide-derivatized
25-mer phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer MORF2 (5′-TATATTGATTCTCCTTGGCTTACTC-linker-disulfide-3′,
MW = 8585 Da, customized and purchased from Gene Tools, Philomath,
OR) was reduced with TCEP. Briefly, 3′-disulfide amide-derivatized
MORF2 (2.51 mg, 300 nmol) was dissolved in 250 μL of 10 mM PBS
(pH 7.4) containing 10 mM TCEP. Then the reaction was incubated at
37 °C for 30 min. Afterward the resultant fragment 4-thiolbutanamide
and excessive TCEP were removed by ultrafiltration (3000 Da MWCO)
and washed four times with 10 mM PBS (pH 6.5). The freshly prepared
thiolated MORF2 (250 nmol) was added into maleimide modified HSA solution
in 500 μL of 10 mM PBS (pH 6.5) and the reaction was performed
at room temperature for 3 h. For synthesis of HSA-(MORF2) with different valences, the feeding molar ratios
of [HSA-mal] to [MORF2-SH] were 1:2, 1:10, 1:20, and 1:30. At the
end, unreacted MORF2 was removed by ultrafiltration (30 000
Da MWCO) with four times PBS (pH 7.4). To prepare fluorescent-labeled
HSA-(MORF2)-Cy3, the surface amine groups
of HSA (3.35 mg, 50 nmol) were reacted with cyanine 3 monosuccinimidyl
ester (Cy3-NHS, Lumiprobe, 70 μg, 100 nmol) in 1 mL PBS (pH
7.4) for 2 h at room temperature with the feeding molar ratio of 1:2.
The obtained HSA-Cy3 was further purified using a PD 10 column to
remove the unreacted dye, then followed above procedures.
Characterizations
An ÄKTA FPLC system equipped
with Sephacryl S-100 HR16/60 column (GE Healthcare) eluted with PBS
(pH 7.2) was used to monitor the reactions. The MORF content was determined
by UV–visible spectrophotometry at 260 nm in 0.1 N HCl (252120
M–1 cm–1) and HSA content was
quantified by bicinchoninic acid protein assay. The amount of Cy3
and Cy5 was measured by the absorbance at 547 and 650 nm on the UV–vis
spectrophotometer (Agilent Cary Bio 400), respectively, and calculated
based on the standard curve.
Investigation of Hybridization between OBN-MORF1
and HSA-(MORF2)
Analysis of
the hydrodynamic effective
diameters of OBN-MORF1 conjugate, HSA-(MORF2)10 conjugate
and their mixture at 1:1 MORF1-MORF2 ratio (in PBS pH 7.4, room temperature,
10 min) was performed using a Zetasizer Nano ZS90 (Malvern Instruments,
UK). Analysis of the hypochromic effect upon MORF1-MORF2 hybridization
was performed using NanoDrop (ND-1000 spectrophotometer, TECAN). OBN-MORF1
and HSA-(MORF2)10 solutions (PBS, pH 7.4 or 0.1 N HCl)
were mixed in different ratios with a constant total MORF (MORF1+MORF2)
concentration of 2.5 μM at room temperature. Ten min post mixture,
the optical density at 260 nm was recorded. All measurements were
performed in triplicate.
Visualization of Biorecognition on Raji B
Cell Surface
B-lymphoma cell lines including CD20 highly
expressing Raji, Raji-GFP,
and CD20 negative DG-75 cells were cultured in RPMI-1640 medium (Gibco)
supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS) and 1% penicillin-streptomycin.
Cells were suspended and cultured in T75 cell culture flasks and incubated
at 37 °C in a humidified 5% CO2 atmosphere.To visualize the hybridization between of OBN-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2)via MORF1-MORF2 biorecognition
on Raji cell surface, Raji cells (2 × 105) were first
incubated with OBN-MORF1-Cy5 (0.5 μM) for 1 h at 37 °C.
Then, cells were washed with cold PBS twice to remove unbound OBN-MORF1-Cy5.
Afterward, cells were further incubated with HSA-(MORF2)10-Cy3 (0.5 μM MORF2) for 1 h at 37 °C. After washed twice
with cold PBS, the cell nuclei were stained with 5 μg/mL Hoechst
33392 (Thermo Scientific) for 5 min. At the end, cells were washed
with cold PBS three times, and suspended in PBS in 4 well chambers
prior to confocal visualization.To demonstrate the biorecognition
of OBN-MORF1/RTX-MORF1 and HSA-(MORF2) on cell surface was CD20 receptor specific,
a 1:1 cell coculture of CD20 positive Raji-GFP cells expressing green
fluorescence protein and CD20 negative DG-75 cells were consecutively
treated with OBN-MORF1-Cy5/RTX-MORF1-Cy5 and HSA-(MORF2)10-Cy3. The biorecognition on these different two cell lines were distinguished
by GFP expression and analyzed by flow cytometry.
Apoptosis Induction
Measurements
Raji cells (2 ×
105) were treated with RTX (RTX, 0.5 μM, 1 h →
cell culture medium, 24 h), cRTX (RTX-MORF1-Cy5, 0.5 μM, 1 h
→ HSA-(MORF2)10, 0.5 μM MORF2, 24 h), OBN
(OBN, 0.5 μM, 1 h → cell culture medium, 24 h), cOBN
(OBN-MORF1-Cy5, 0.5 μM, 1 h → HSA-(MORF2)10, 0.5 μM MORF2, 24 h), RTX and OBN combination (0.5 μM
RTX + 0.5 μM OBN, 1 h → cell culture medium, 24 h), or
treated as indicated. Afterward, cells were washed with PBS and stained
with Annexin V-FITC and propidium iodide (PI) in dark for 15 min,
following the RAPID protocol provided by the manufacturer (Oncogene
Research Products, Boston, MA).
Maximum CD20 Binding Assay
Raji cells (2 × 105) were incubated with a series
of increasing concentrations
(0.1, 1, 10, 100, 1000 nM Fab′) of OBN, RTX, Fab′(OBN)-MORF1
and Fab′(RTX)-MORF1 for 1 h at 4 °C. Then cells were washed
and stained with Alexa Fluor 488-labeled secondary antibody (1:200,
1% BSA) for 30 min at 4 °C, prior to flow cytometry analysis.
Evaluation of CD20 Translocation within Lipid Rafts
Raji
cells (2 × 105) were treated with Cy5 labeled
RTX (0.5 μM, 2 h, 37 °C), cRTX (RTX-MORF1-Cy5, 0.5 μM,
2 h, 4 °C → HSA-(MORF2)10, 0.5 μM MORF2,
2 h, 37 °C), OBN (0.5 μM, 2 h, 37 °C), cOBN (OBN-MORF1-Cy5,
0.5 μM, 2 h, 4 °C → HSA-(MORF2)10, 0.5
μM MORF2, 2 h, 37 °C). Then cells were washed with cold
PBS to remove unbound antibodies. Afterward cells were fixed with
4% paraformaldehyde and stained with Alexa Fluor-555 conjugated cholera
toxin B subunit (CTB, 10 μg/mL, Thermo Scientific) at 4 °C
for 30 min. Then cells were washed and transferred to 4-well chamber
for confocal microscopy imaging.
Evaluation of Calcium Influx
Raji cells (4 × 105), loaded with intracellular
calcium indicator Fluo-3AM (5
μM, Thermo Scientific) for 30 min at 37 °C, were suspended
in 400 μL cell culture medium (containing 2.5 mM Ca2+), and excited at 488 nm and the emission at 530 nm was measured
on flow cytometry. A baseline was obtained for 100 s before the addition
of RTX-MORF1 (1 μM) or OBN-MORF1(1 μM). Then the fluorescent
intensity was recorded for another 300 s. Afterward, HSA-(MORF2)10 (5 μM MORF2) was added into the cell suspension and
fluorescence intensity was further recorded for 200 s during the HSA-based
conjugate stimulation. The bump in flow cytometry signal indicates
the addition of the corresponding conjugates to cell solution. Calcium
influx is defined as the rise in calcium concentration after the bump,
as compared with the baseline before the bump.
Evaluation
of CD20 Cross-Linking and Caspase Activation
Raji cells were
pretreated with β-cyclodextrin (2 wt %, 20
min) to deplete lipid rafts or pan caspase inhibitor Z-VAD-FMK (50
μM, 1 h), followed by the treatment with RTX, cRTX, OBN, or
cOBN as described above. Apoptosis induction after different treatments
was measured by dual staining of Annexin V-FITC and PI, and compared
with the corresponding controls that were not pretreated.
Evaluation
of Actin Cytoskeleton Remodeling
Raji cells
(2 × 105) were treated with cRTX (RTX-MORF1-Cy5, 0.5
μM, 1 h → HSA-(MORF2)10, 0.5 μM MORF2,
24 h), cOBN (OBN-MORF1-Cy5, 0.5 μM, 1 h → HSA-(MORF2)10, 0.5 μM MORF2, 24 h), or nontreated. Then cells were
fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde at room temperature for 10 min, and
stained with Alexa Fluor 488 phalloidin (1:200 dilution, Thermo Scientific)
to label F-actin at 4 °C for 1 h. Afterward, cells were washed
and imaged by confocal microscopy.
Evaluation of Intercell
Homotypic Adhesion
Raji cells
(2 × 105) were treated with RTX, cRTX, OBN, cOBN as
described, or not treated. Then the morphologies of cells were captured
by microscopy. In another experiment, approximately half of Raji cells
were incubated with Vybrant DiI cell-labeling solution (Thermo Scientific)
at 37 °C for 20 min to generate Raji-Dil, and further mixed with
the other half of Raji-GFP cells. The cell mixtures were treated as
above, and flow cytometry was used to evaluate the aggregation behavior
of the cells.
Evaluation of Lysosome Collapse
Type II anti-CD20 antibody-induced
cell death is executed by lysosomes which disperse their contents
into the cytoplasm and surrounding environment. Thus, lysosomal collapse
is a characteristic feature of OBN-induced cell death. To correlate
the changes in the lysosomal compartment with cell death, Raji cells
(2 × 105) were treated with RTX, cRTX, OBN, cOBN as
described, or not treated, followed by labeling with Lysotracker (200
nM, 20 min, 37 °C, Thermo Scientific), prior to flow cytometry
analysis.
Evaluation of ROS Production
Raji
cells (2 × 105) were treated with RTX, cRTX, OBN,
cOBN as described, or
not treated. Then cells were treated with 2 mM of 2′,7′-dichlorodihydrofluorescein
diacetate (H2DCFDA, Thermo Scientific) for 30 min at 37
°C. Afterward, cells were washed, resuspended in PBS and allowed
for recovery for 20 min at 37 °C. Trypan blue (0.004% w/v) was
subsequently added to quench the extracellular fluorescence for 5
min. Then cells were washed and flow cytometry was applied to detect
the intracellular ROS.
Investigation of In Vivo Therapeutic
Efficacy
All animal experiments were performed according
to the protocol approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use
Committee (IACUC) of the University of Utah.8-week-old male
NOD/SCID-Rag1nullγnull (NRG) mice were
intravenously injected with 4 × 106 Raji cells in
200 μL PBS via the tail vein on Day 0. Raji
cells were allowed to develop and disseminate systemically in mice
for 10 days. On Day 10, 17, and 24, 100 μL saline, OBN (0.5
nmol), or cOBN (OBN-MORF1, 0.5 nmol → HSA-(MORF2)10, 1.5 nmol MORF2, with 5 h interval) were given intravenously to
the randomly divided mice groups (n = 5–6).
The survival rate of mice was recorded over time. The onset of hind-limb
paralysis or over 20% body weight loss was the end point.After
mice were sacrificed, fresh femurs from both hind limbs were
purged with 5 mL PBS to obtain bone marrow cells. The cell suspension
was passed through a 70 μm nylon strainer, washed with PBS,
and incubated with ACK lysing buffer (room temperature, 5 min, Thermo
Scientific) to remove red blood cells. After being washed twice with
cold PBS, allophycocyanin (APC)-labeled mouse antihuman CD19 antibody
(10 μL) and PE-labeled mouse antihuman CD10 antibody (10 μL)
(BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA) were added to 100 μL single-cell
suspension to stain the Raji cells in bone marrow.[23] Cells were incubated for 20 min at 4 °C in the dark,
and washed with PBS prior to flow cytometry analysis. Raji cells served
as positive control.
Authors: Jonathan D Graves; Jennifer J Kordich; Tzu-Hsuan Huang; Julia Piasecki; Tammy L Bush; Timothy Sullivan; Ian N Foltz; Wesley Chang; Heather Douangpanya; Thu Dang; Jason W O'Neill; Rommel Mallari; Xiaoning Zhao; Daniel G Branstetter; John M Rossi; Alexander M Long; Xin Huang; Pamela M Holland Journal: Cancer Cell Date: 2014-07-17 Impact factor: 31.743
Authors: Paula J Kaplan-Lefko; Jonathan D Graves; Stephen J Zoog; Yang Pan; Jason Wall; Daniel G Branstetter; Jodi Moriguchi; Angela Coxon; Justin N Huard; Ren Xu; Matthew L Peach; Gloria Juan; Stephen Kaufman; Qing Chen; Allison Bianchi; Jennifer J Kordich; Mark Ma; Ian N Foltz; Brian C Gliniak Journal: Cancer Biol Ther Date: 2010-04-20 Impact factor: 4.742
Authors: Sylvia Herter; Frank Herting; Olaf Mundigl; Inja Waldhauer; Tina Weinzierl; Tanja Fauti; Gunter Muth; Doris Ziegler-Landesberger; Erwin Van Puijenbroek; Sabine Lang; Minh Ngoc Duong; Lina Reslan; Christian A Gerdes; Thomas Friess; Ute Baer; Helmut Burtscher; Michael Weidner; Charles Dumontet; Pablo Umana; Gerhard Niederfellner; Marina Bacac; Christian Klein Journal: Mol Cancer Ther Date: 2013-07-19 Impact factor: 6.261
Authors: Lian Li; Yachao Li; Chieh-Hsiang Yang; D Christopher Radford; Jiawei Wang; Margit Janát-Amsbury; Jindřich Kopeček; Jiyuan Yang Journal: Adv Funct Mater Date: 2020-02-03 Impact factor: 18.808
Authors: M Tommy Gambles; Jiahui Li; D Christopher Radford; Douglas Sborov; Paul Shami; Jiyuan Yang; Jindřich Kopeček Journal: J Control Release Date: 2022-09-05 Impact factor: 11.467