| Literature DB >> 31548904 |
Justin Carrard1, Tej Pandya2, Laurène Niederhauser3, Denis Infanger1, Arno Schmidt-Trucksaess1, Susi Kriemler4.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: The global lack of sports and exercise medicine (SEM) teaching at medical schools contrasts with evidence that physical activity (PA) plays a major role in preventing and treating non-communicable diseases (NCDs). The aims of this study were to (a) examine whether Swiss medical students are expected to acquire SEM-related skills and knowledge, (b) systematically reviewed SEM teaching in the Swiss undergraduate medical curricula, (c) assess if Swiss medical students are aware of SEM and (d) whether they would like SEM to be included in their curricula.Entities:
Keywords: Switzerland; medical students; online survey; sports and exercise medicine; teaching; undergraduate
Year: 2019 PMID: 31548904 PMCID: PMC6733322 DOI: 10.1136/bmjsem-2019-000575
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med ISSN: 2055-7647
Figure 1Systematic review process of SEM teaching in the Swiss undergraduate medical curricula (ISSEMG, International Syllabus in Sport and Exercise Medicine Group).
SEM-related learning objectives in profiles
| ID | Learnings objectives | Related key SEM domains |
|
| ||
| GO 1.13 | Advise and counsel patients on their health and lifestyle in an empathetic non-judgmental manner. Perform a motivational interview | Physical activity and human health |
| GO 1.23 | Understand the population perspective as a core aspect of public health, and the application of basic principles of social medicine; advocate for the health and healthy environment of the local community and society as a whole | Physical activity and human health |
| GO 2.7 | Develop effective, shared strategies with their patients to increase their adherence to therapeutic options and improve their adoption of healthy habits and lifestyles | Physical activity and human health |
| GO 2.8 | Assist patients in the adoption of health promoting habits and provide effective counselling in the use of personal data obtained through screening procedures, imaging, serologic or genetic findings (precision/prediction medicine) | Physical activity and human health |
| GO 2.9 | Improve patient’s and family’s health literacy by assisting them to identify, access and make use of information and communication technologies to support their healthcare and the adoption of healthy lifestyles | Physical activity and human health |
| GO 4.1 | Understand the principles of population medicine and its strategies, and use the main tools that are used in epidemiology and public health. These include the gathering and use of health determinants and indicators, descriptive and explanatory statistics, risk and protective factors and the concepts of prevention and health promotion at individual, community and environmental levels | Physical activity and human health |
| GO 4.2 | Define and illustrate health promotion and health-enhancing strategies at various levels such as the monitoring and promotion of a safe environment and the promotion of effective public health policies and interventions. In doing so, they take into account financial, material and staffing resources, at both community and public health levels. | Physical activity and human health |
| GO 5.2 | Incorporate health surveillance activities into interactions with individual patients (discussing lifestyles, counselling). Such activities include screening, immunisation and disease prevention, risk and harm reduction measures and health promotion. | Physical activity and human health |
|
| ||
| EPA 1.8 | Review the patient’s health behaviour and lifestyle as part of a routine check-up, as far as possible, and assess the patient’s opinions, representations and expectations | Physical activity and human health |
| EPA 1b | Perform an age-specific assessment of a child’s/adolescent’s development and lifestyle | Physical activity and human health |
| EPA 2b | Assessment of nutritional status | Nutrition |
| EPA 2o | Inspection and palpation of skeleton and joints | Injuries related to sport and exercise |
| EPA 2 p | Functional testing of joint mobility: shoulders, elbows, wrists, fingers, hips, knees and ankles | Injuries related to sport and exercise |
| EPA 2q | Inspection, palpation, percussion and mobility of the spine | Injuries related to sport and exercise |
| EPA 7.1 | Establish a management plan that integrates information gathered from the history, the physical examination, laboratory tests and imaging as well as the patient’s preference; incorporate the prescription of medications, physiotherapy and physical rehabilitation, dietetic and lifestyles advice, psychological support, social and environmental measures into the management plan | Physical activity and human health |
|
| ||
| SSP 4 | Fatigue, tiredness | Medical issues related to exercise |
| SSP 14 | Unexpected or sudden death | Medical issues related to exercise |
| SSP 15 | Weight gain, obesity | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 82 | Back pain | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 83 | Deformities of skeleton and joints | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 85 | Pain, burning, cramp, numbness in the extremities | Medical issues related to exercise |
| SSP 108 | Contusion, soft tissue bruising | Injuries related to sport and exercise |
| SSP 109 | Dislocation of joint | Injuries related to sport and exercise |
| SSP 112 | Head and brain injuries and trauma | Injuries related to sport and exercise |
| SSP 113 | Injuries of the extremities | Injuries related to sport and exercise |
| SSP 131 | Abnormal blood pressure | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 158 | Abnormal glycaemia and markers of glycaemia homeostasis | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 197 | Functional impairment (cognition, sensory and motor) | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 198 | Malnutrition and sarcopenia | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 221 | Consultation before engaging in sports activities | Medical issues related to exercise |
| SSP 223 | Promotion of healthy lifestyle | Physical activity and human health |
| SSP 227 | Shared assessment of risks and protective factors for frequent life-compromising diseases such as cardiovascular, metabolic and oncologic diseases | Physical activity and human health |
SEM, Sports and exercise medicine.
Figure 2Sample, population and response rate according to gender, University, academic level and study year. (A) response rate according to gender, (B) response rate according to university, (C) response rate according to academic level and (D) sample distribution according to study year. In panels (A–C), grey columns represent the number of students in the Swiss medical students’ population. In panels (A–D), black columns represent the number of students in the sample. Data on the top of each column are expressed in %. Given that the exact number of medical students in each study year was not available for all universities, it was not possible to calculate a response rate according to the year of study. The University of Fribourg offers only a bachelor of medicine, while the University of Neuchâtel offers only the first year of study. BS=University of Basel, BE=University of Bern, FR=University of Fribourg, GE=University of Geneva, LS=University of Lausanne, NE=University of Neuchâtel, ZH=University of Zurich and n=nth year of study.
Questions 4–8 targeting SEM knowledge and preferences of the students. Several answers were allowed for questions 5 and 6, while only one answer was allowed for questions 4, 7 and 8
| Answer choices | Respondents numbers | % |
|
| ||
| 1-not at all | 48 | 2.7 |
| 2- | 244 | 13.8 |
| 3- | 752 | 42.6 |
| 4- | 596 | 33.8 |
| 5-absolutely | 124 | 7.0 |
| Mean value: 3.29 | ||
|
| ||
| Medical care of athletes (amateur and elite) | 1628 | 92.3 |
| Prevention of certain chronic diseases | 1186 | 67.2 |
| Management of sports-related health issues (illness and injury) | 1612 | 91.4 |
| Treatment of certain chronic diseases | 887 | 50.3 |
| Improvement of fitness and quality of life of both healthy and ill subjects | 1397 | 79.2 |
|
| ||
| Yes, as a part of the mandatory curriculum | 948 | 53.7 |
| Yes, as an optional course | 953 | 54.0 |
| No, I would not | 86 | 4.9 |
|
| ||
| 1 hour a week for a whole semester | 946 | 57.3 |
| 2 hours a week for a whole semester | 581 | 35.2 |
| 4 hours a week for a whole semester | 123 | 7.5 |
|
| ||
| 1-not motivated at all | 27 | 1.5 |
| 2- | 83 | 4.7 |
| 3- | 307 | 17.4 |
| 4- | 709 | 40.3 |
| 5-very motivated | 634 | 36.0 |
| Mean value: 4.05 | ||
SEM, Sports and exercise medicine.
Mandatory SEM teachings in the Swiss undergraduate medical curricula
| University | Mandatory SEM course | Topic | Lecturer | Year of study | Duration | Related key SEM domains |
| Basel | No | |||||
| Bern | Yes | Sport and nutrition | SEM doctor | Second | 1×45 min | Nutrition |
| Fribourg | Yes | Applied exercise physiology | SEM doctor | Second | 4×45 min | Physical activity and human health |
| Geneva | No | |||||
| Lausanne | Yes | Overuse injuries | SEM doctor | Fourth | 2×45 min | Injuries related to exercise |
| Neuchâtel | No | |||||
| ETH Zurich | Yes | Sport and heart | SEM doctor | Second | 1×45 min | Medical issues related to exercise |
| University of Zurich | No |
SEM, Sports and exercise medicine.
Optional SEM teachings in the Swiss undergraduate medical curricula
| University | Optional SEM course | Topics | Lecturers | Opened to | Capacity | Frequency | Duration |
| Basel | No | ||||||
| Bern | Yes |
Exercise medicine Sport and altitude Concussion in sport Sports traumatology Exercise physiology Exercise testing and training recommendation Sports cardiology Exercise and diabetes Exercise and children Exercise and women Imagery in SEM Exercise dyspnoea Doping and anti-doping Athlete care Prehospital emergency in SEM |
SEM doctors (cardiologists, orthopaedic surgeon, general physician, anaesthesiologist) Cardiologists Neurologist Paediatrician Radiologist Endocrinologist Gynaecologist | Sixth year students | Up to 20 students | Once a year | 8×1 hour 30 min |
| Fribourg | No | ||||||
| Geneva | Yes |
Exercise biochemistry Exercise and ageing Sports cardiology Endurance testing and training Sports traumatology Injury prevention and sports physiotherapy Core stability Strength testing and training |
SEM doctor (physiatrist, cardiologist) Physiologist Sports physiotherapists Sports scientist | Second to third year students | Up to 12 students | Once a year | 10×3 hours |
| Lausanne | Yes |
Exercise Medicine Exercise and diabetes Molecular adaptation to exercise Training principle Hypoxia training Exercise testing Pre-participation screening Sports medicine on the field Return to sport Exercise and children Exercise and women RED-S syndrome Exercise in extreme conditions Sports psychology Doping and anti-doping Taping Gait analysis |
SEM doctors (physiatrists, orthopaedic surgeons) Sports scientists Sports physiotherapists Endocrinologist Internist Doping specialist Sports psychologist | Third to fourth year students | Up to 20 students | Once a year | 12×3 hours |
| Neuchâtel | No | ||||||
| ETH Zürich | No | ||||||
| Zurich | Yes |
Exercise physiology The job of a sports doctor Pre-participation screening Sports cardiology and pulmonology Altitude and scuba diving Exercise is Medicine Exercise and children Exercise and women Infection and sport Concussion in sport MSK examination Sports traumatology Imagery in SEM Doping and anti-doping Sport nutrition Sports psychology Prehospital emergency in SEM |
SEM doctors (cardiologist, orthopaedic surgeon, paediatrician) Traumatologist Radiologist Sports psychologist Epidemiologist | Second to fourth year students | Up to 20 students | Twice a year | 7×4 hours |
MSK, musculoskeletal; RED-S, Relative energy deficiency in sport; SEM, Sports and exercise medicine.