E K Leask1, B L Ehlmann1,2, M M Dundar3, S L Murchie4, F P Seelos4. 1. Division of Geological and Planetary Sciences, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California, USA. 2. Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California, USA. 3. Computer and Information Sciences Department, Indiana University-Purdue University at Indianapolis, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA. 4. Johns Hopkins University/Applied Physics Laboratory, Laurel, Maryland, USA.
Abstract
A previously unidentified artifact has been found in Compact Reconnaissance Imaging Spectrometer for Mars targeted I/F data. It exists in a small fraction (<0.05%) of pixels within 90% of images investigated and occurs in regions of high spectral/spatial variance. This artifact mimics real mineral absorptions in width and depth and occurs most often at 1.9 and 2.1 μm, thus interfering in the search for some mineral phases, including alunite, kieserite, serpentine, and perchlorate. A filtering step in the data processing pipeline, between radiance and I/F versions of the data, convolves narrow artifacts ("spikes") with real atmospheric absorptions in these wavelength regions to create spurious absorption-like features. The majority of previous orbital detections of alunite, kieserite, and serpentine we investigated can be confirmed using radiance and raw data, but few to none of the perchlorate detections reported in published literature remain robust over the 1.0- to 2.65-μm wavelength range. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Many minerals can be identified with remote sensing data by their characteristic absorptions in visible-shortwave infrared data. This type of data has allowed geological interpretation of much of Mars' surface, using satellite-based observation. We have discovered an issue with the Compact Reconnaissance Imaging Spectrometer for Mars instrument's data processing pipeline. In ~ <0.05% of pixels in almost all images, noise in the data is smoothed in such a way that it mimics real mineral absorptions, falsely making it look as though certain minerals are present on Mars' surface. The vast majority of previously identified minerals are still confirmed after accounting for the artifact, but some to all perchlorate detections and a few serpentine detections were not confirmed, suggesting that the artifact created false detections. This means concentrated regions of perchlorate may not occur on Mars and so may not be available to generate possibly habitable salty liquid water at very cold temperatures.
A previously unidentified artifact has been found in Compact Reconnaissance Imaging Spectrometer for Mars targeted I/F data. It exists in a small fraction (<0.05%) of pixels within 90% of images investigated and occurs in regions of high spectral/spatial variance. This artifact mimics real mineral absorptions in width and depth and occurs most often at 1.9 and 2.1 μm, thus interfering in the search for some mineral phases, including alunite, kieserite, serpentine, and perchlorate. A filtering step in the data processing pipeline, between radiance and I/F versions of the data, convolves narrow artifacts ("spikes") with real atmospheric absorptions in these wavelength regions to create spurious absorption-like features. The majority of previous orbital detections of alunite, kieserite, and serpentine we investigated can be confirmed using radiance and raw data, but few to none of the perchlorate detections reported in published literature remain robust over the 1.0- to 2.65-μm wavelength range. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Many minerals can be identified with remote sensing data by their characteristic absorptions in visible-shortwave infrared data. This type of data has allowed geological interpretation of much of Mars' surface, using satellite-based observation. We have discovered an issue with the Compact Reconnaissance Imaging Spectrometer for Mars instrument's data processing pipeline. In ~ <0.05% of pixels in almost all images, noise in the data is smoothed in such a way that it mimics real mineral absorptions, falsely making it look as though certain minerals are present on Mars' surface. The vast majority of previously identified minerals are still confirmed after accounting for the artifact, but some to all perchlorate detections and a few serpentine detections were not confirmed, suggesting that the artifact created false detections. This means concentrated regions of perchlorate may not occur on Mars and so may not be available to generate possibly habitable salty liquid water at very cold temperatures.
Authors: John D Rummel; David W Beaty; Melissa A Jones; Corien Bakermans; Nadine G Barlow; Penelope J Boston; Vincent F Chevrier; Benton C Clark; Jean-Pierre P de Vera; Raina V Gough; John E Hallsworth; James W Head; Victoria J Hipkin; Thomas L Kieft; Alfred S McEwen; Michael T Mellon; Jill A Mikucki; Wayne L Nicholson; Christopher R Omelon; Ronald Peterson; Eric E Roden; Barbara Sherwood Lollar; Kenneth L Tanaka; Donna Viola; James J Wray Journal: Astrobiology Date: 2014-11 Impact factor: 4.335
Authors: F Poulet; J-P Bibring; J F Mustard; A Gendrin; N Mangold; Y Langevin; R E Arvidson; B Gondet; C Gomez; M Berthé; S Erard; O Forni; N Manaud; G Poulleau; A Soufflot; M Combes; P Drossart; T Encrenaz; T Fouchet; R Melchiorri; G Bellucci; F Altieri; V Formisano; S Fonti; F Capaccioni; P Cerroni; A Coradini; O Korablev; V Kottsov; N Ignatiev; D Titov; L Zasova; P Pinet; B Schmitt; C Sotin; E Hauber; H Hoffmann; R Jaumann; U Keller; F Forget Journal: Nature Date: 2005-12-01 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Bethany L Ehlmann; John F Mustard; Scott L Murchie; Francois Poulet; Janice L Bishop; Adrian J Brown; Wendy M Calvin; Roger N Clark; David J Des Marais; Ralph E Milliken; Leah H Roach; Ted L Roush; Gregg A Swayze; James J Wray Journal: Science Date: 2008-12-19 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: M H Hecht; S P Kounaves; R C Quinn; S J West; S M M Young; D W Ming; D C Catling; B C Clark; W V Boynton; J Hoffman; L P Deflores; K Gospodinova; J Kapit; P H Smith Journal: Science Date: 2009-07-03 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Janice L Bishop; Eldar Z Noe Dobrea; Nancy K McKeown; Mario Parente; Bethany L Ehlmann; Joseph R Michalski; Ralph E Milliken; Francois Poulet; Gregg A Swayze; John F Mustard; Scott L Murchie; Jean-Pierre Bibring Journal: Science Date: 2008-08-08 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: John F Mustard; S L Murchie; S M Pelkey; B L Ehlmann; R E Milliken; J A Grant; J-P Bibring; F Poulet; J Bishop; E Noe Dobrea; L Roach; F Seelos; R E Arvidson; S Wiseman; R Green; C Hash; D Humm; E Malaret; J A McGovern; K Seelos; T Clancy; R Clark; D D Marais; N Izenberg; A Knudson; Y Langevin; T Martin; P McGuire; R Morris; M Robinson; T Roush; M Smith; G Swayze; H Taylor; T Titus; M Wolff Journal: Nature Date: 2008-07-16 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Colin M Dundas; Patricio Becerra; Shane Byrne; Matthew Chojnacki; Ingrid J Daubar; Serina Diniega; Candice J Hansen; Kenneth E Herkenhoff; Margaret E Landis; Alfred S McEwen; Ganna Portyankina; Adomas Valantinas Journal: J Geophys Res Planets Date: 2021-07-29 Impact factor: 4.434