Brigitte A G Lamers1, Robert Graf2, Bas F M de Waal1, Ghislaine Vantomme1, Anja R A Palmans1, E W Meijer1. 1. Institute for Complex Molecular Systems and Laboratory of Macromolecular and Organic Chemistry , Eindhoven University of Technology , P.O. Box 513, 5600 MB Eindhoven , The Netherlands. 2. Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research , Ackermannweg 10 , 55128 Mainz , Germany.
Abstract
Nanomaterials with highly ordered, one- or two-dimensional molecular morphologies have promising properties for adaptive materials. Here, we present the synthesis and structural characterization of dinitrohydrazone (hydz) functionalized oligodimethylsiloxanes (oDMSs) of discrete length, which form both 1- and 2D nanostructures by precisely controlling composition and temperature. The morphologies are highly ordered due to the discrete nature of the siloxane oligomers. Columnar, 1D structures are formed from the melt within a few seconds as a result of phase segregation in combination with π-π stacking of the hydrazones. By tuning the length of the siloxane, the synergy between these interactions is observed which results in a highly temperature sensitive material. Macroscopically, this gives a material that switches reversibly and fast between an ordered, solid and a disordered, liquid state at almost equal temperatures. Ordered, 2D lamellar structures are formed under thermodynamic control by cold crystallization of the hydrazones in the amorphous siloxane bulk via a slow process. We elucidate the 1- and 2D morphologies from the nanometer to molecular level by the combined use of solid state NMR and X-ray scattering. The exact packing of the hydrazone rods within the cylinders and lamellae surrounded the liquid-like siloxane matrix is clarified. These results demonstrate that controlling the assembly pathway in the bulk and with that, tuning the nanostructure dimensions and domain spacings, material properties are altered for applications in nanotechnology or thermoresponsive materials.
Nanomaterials with highly ordered, one- or two-dimensional molecular morphologies have promising properties for adaptive materials. Here, we present the synthesis and structural characterization of dinitrohydrazone (hydz) functionalized oligodimethylsiloxanes (oDMSs) of discrete length, which form both 1- and 2D nanostructures by precisely controlling composition and temperature. The morphologies are highly ordered due to the discrete nature of the siloxane oligomers. Columnar, 1D structures are formed from the melt within a few seconds as a result of phase segregation in combination with π-π stacking of the hydrazones. By tuning the length of the siloxane, the synergy between these interactions is observed which results in a highly temperature sensitive material. Macroscopically, this gives a material that switches reversibly and fast between an ordered, solid and a disordered, liquid state at almost equal temperatures. Ordered, 2D lamellar structures are formed under thermodynamic control by cold crystallization of the hydrazones in the amorphous siloxane bulk via a slow process. We elucidate the 1- and 2D morphologies from the nanometer to molecular level by the combined use of solid state NMR and X-ray scattering. The exact packing of the hydrazone rods within the cylinders and lamellae surrounded the liquid-like siloxane matrix is clarified. These results demonstrate that controlling the assembly pathway in the bulk and with that, tuning the nanostructure dimensions and domain spacings, material properties are altered for applications in nanotechnology or thermoresponsive materials.
Liquid crystals (LCs)
and block copolymers (BCPs) form a variety
of ordered structures that result in well-defined morphologies, which
have been successfully applied in electronics as well as in optics
or membranes.[1−5] Insights into the relation between nanostructure morphology and
macroscopic property is paramount to create functional materials for
nanotechnology. Both LCs and BCPs can access the same type of morphologies
such as lamellar, cylindrical, bicontinuous cubic, and spherical phases.[6] However, the formation of ordered domains in
BCP and LC materials proceeds via different mechanisms. For BCPs,
phase segregation drives the morphology, which can be tuned by the
BCP length (N), composition, and Flory–Huggins
interaction parameter (χ).[7,8] In contrast, the nanostructure
formation of LCs results from the directionality of the mesogens,
i.e., rods or discs, in combination with the mobility of the side
chains.[9]A recent target in nanotechnology
is to enhance long-range order
and decrease domain spacings. This has resulted in fading boundaries
between organic-LC and polymer-BCP chemistry by merging the directionality
and crystallinity of LCs with the phase segregation in BCPs.[10] Early examples are phase-segregated LCs, while
more recent examples are based on discrete length block co-oligomers.[6,11−18] Herein, the absence of molar mass dispersity (Đ = 1.00) results in phase-segregated structures even at very low
degrees of polymerizations.[17,19] Furthermore, the discrete
length of the oligomers gives the ability to really design and understand
structure formation into ordered morphologies. Inspired by telechelic
molecules forming supramolecular polymers,[20−25] we recently introduced oligodimethylsiloxane (oDMS) end-functionalized molecules. By balancing the volume fractions
of the blocks and the directional group association, different molecular
arrangements were formed based on supramolecular BCP phase segregation.[26] The introduction of crystalline interactions
next to phase segregation can further enhance the nanostructure organization.
In oDMS-based low MW amorphous–crystalline
BCOs and block molecules with crystalline end-groups, the long-range
order in the nanostructure morphology was improved indeed.[26−31] However, due to the constraints imposed by the crystalline domains,
the morphology is forced into a lamellar structure, irrespective of
the volume fraction of the blocks. This crystallization driven self-assembly
has been exploited for the formation of 2D nanomaterials.[32,33]The directional interactions of discrete molecules are the
driving
force for self-assembly in the bulk and determine the final nanostructure
morphology. An analogy can be made with the assembly of small molecules
in solution since the directional interactions between molecules results
in a variety of supramolecular morphologies, similar to phase-segregated
structures in the bulk. Cylindrical, fibrous structures are formed
through one-dimensional (1D) interactions, which can proceed via an
isodesmic or cooperative/nucleation–elongation mechanism.[34] Sheet-like architectures mostly assemble via
crystallization of rigid molecules, hence formed via nucleation and
growth.[35−37] As a result of the mechanism by which they are formed
and the pathway selection, the assembly of 1D or 2D nanostructures
is highly dependent on environmental effects such as temperature and
solvent.[38,39] Structures formed under kinetic control
can be different than those resulting from the thermodynamic equilibrium.[40−44]Inspired by the pathway control in solution, we report here
on
the nanostructure formation of oDMS end-functionalized
block molecules in the bulk into 1D and 2D morphologies. For this,
we synthesized a novel family of homo- and heterotelechelic oDMS-based discrete oligomers end-capped with dinitrophenylhydrazones
that can assemble either via crystallization or supramolecular interactions
(Scheme ).[45,46] The liquid-like siloxane oligomer gives the molecules mobility and
causes confinement of the hydrazones in an amorphous matrix. The compounds
all show the presence of long-range, ordered domains. Solid state
nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in combination with X-ray
scattering gives detailed information on the polymorphism and driving
forces of the hydrazone assembly in cylinders or lamellae. The morphology
is controlled by thermodynamics and kinetics, and highly sensitive
toward slight changes in temperature. This gives rise to fast thermal
solid–liquid phase transitions in a very small temperature
window, which can be utilized in thermoresponsive materials. Finally,
we show the influence of dispersity by the incorporation of a disperse oDMS linker, which has not been reported for this type oDMS-based block molecules.
Scheme 1
Molecular Structures
of hydz-Si15, hydz-Sin-hydz, and hydz-Si∼22-hydz and Di- and Triblock
Molecules
The disperse block is indicated
with a tilde (∼).
Molecular Structures
of hydz-Si15, hydz-Sin-hydz, and hydz-Si∼22-hydz and Di- and Triblock
Molecules
The disperse block is indicated
with a tilde (∼).
Results and Discussion
Synthesis
of Dinitrohydrazone-(oligo)dimethylsiloxane Di- and
Triblock Molecules
We synthesized a series of oDMS end-functionalized hydrazone triblock molecules and one diblock
molecule (Scheme ).
Discrete oDMS-dihydrides with chain lengths of exactly
8, 16, 24, or 40 repeating units (denoted as Si8, Si16, Si24, or Si40) were synthesized via
a stepwise procedure previously described by our group.[26] Olefin terminated dinitrohydrazones (hydz) were
attached to the oDMS-dihydrides via a platinum catalyzed
hydrosilylation reaction (Scheme S1). Similarly,
a disperse oDMS triblock molecule (Đ = 1.2) was obtained from commercially available oDMS-dihydride with an average of 22 siloxane repeating units (hydz-Si∼22-hydz). Moreover, a diblock molecule (hydz-Si15) was synthesized from discrete oDMS-hydridecontaining only one reactive hydride group that was obtained via a
literature procedure.[16] All compounds were
obtained in high yields (60–97%) and molecular characterization
by NMR, MS (Maldi-Tof), DSC, and GPC-SEC indicated the high purity
of all of the materials (Figures S1–S6).
Temperature Sensitivity of hydz-oDMS Di- and
Triblock Molecules
Whereas all oDMS-dihydrides
and oDMS-hydride are viscous fluids, after functionalization
with the hydrazone group the block molecules appear as waxy solids.
Under the polarized optical microscope (POM), the formation of birefringent
structures was observed upon cooling from the melt (Figure ). All discrete block molecules
formed spherulites (Figure B–E), except the shortest analogue (hydz-Si8-hydz), which formed a needle-like texture (Figure A). Interestingly, the hydz-Si16-hydz, hydz-Si24-hydz, and hydz-Si15 block
molecules grow spherulites with sizes up to 5 mm from one nucleation
point (Figure F).
This has been reported occasionally for mixtures of polymers and small
molecules,[47,48] but for oligomers with covalently
attached small molecule end-groups, such large textures have not been
reported to date. The nucleation point for spherulite growth appeared
on millisecond time scales, which gives a first hint that a very fast
thermal phase transition occurs in these systems. The nucleation is
always observed within the hole of the hot stage as this spot is slightly
cooler than the surrounding material that is in direct contact with
the hot stage. However, the location of the nucleation point within
the hole varies upon repeatedly heating above the clearing temperature
followed by cooling to the ordered structure. When the temperature
was kept constant directly after nucleation, oscillations of the spherulite
growth were observed (Video S1). These
may result from the hot stage fluctuations causing small variations
in temperature. Alternatively, the release of energy upon formation
of the ordered structure may cause minor heating of the sample resulting
in constantly clearing and growing of the structure. Hence, these
block molecules are highly sensitive to minimal temperature changes
around their transition temperatures.
Figure 1
Polarized optical microscope images of
hydz-Si8-hydz
(A), hydz-Si16-hydz (B), hydz-Si24-hydz (C),
hydz-Si40-hydz (D), and hydz-Si15 (E). Scale
bars represent 250 μm. Giant spherulite of hydz-Si24-hydz under cross-polarizers (F), scale bar represents 5 mm. Bulk
material was melted between two glass plates and cooled at 2 K min–1.
Polarized optical microscope images of
hydz-Si8-hydz
(A), hydz-Si16-hydz (B), hydz-Si24-hydz (C),
hydz-Si40-hydz (D), and hydz-Si15 (E). Scale
bars represent 250 μm. Giant spherulite of hydz-Si24-hydz under cross-polarizers (F), scale bar represents 5 mm. Bulk
material was melted between two glass plates and cooled at 2 K min–1.We evaluated and quantified
the thermal sensitivity around the
transition temperatures by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC).
Upon heating, all block molecules showed a glass transition (Tg) at temperatures below 40 °C (Table , entry 1–5).
For the discrete di- and triblock molecules, very sharp and narrow,
endothermic peaks at temperatures between 117 and 147 °C (T1) were observed (Figure ). The corresponding enthalpic energy (ΔHfus = 1.3–3.9 kJ mol–1) of this transition is relatively low compared to the crystalline
hydrazone block (ΔHfus = 35.4 kJ
mol–1, Figure S7). Furthermore,
the position of T1 is independent of the
heating rate (Figure B). Both results point to the presence of an order–disorder
transition in the discrete systems. The related cooling traces of
the materials revealed an equally sharp exothermic transition T2 that is also independent of the cooling rate
(Figure S8). Going through this transition,
the material changed into a solid, ordered morphology. For all discrete
block molecules, T2 was nearly identical
to the order–disorder transition (T1; Figures C and S9). In particular, these temperatures differ
by only 0.4–1.3 °C, indicating that almost no supercooling
is necessary to obtain the nanostructured material from the isotropic
melt. Hence, the materials are extremely sensitive toward temperature
fluctuations, as was observed at elevated temperatures under the POM.
Table 1
Thermal Properties of hydz-oDMS Di-
and Triblock Molecules
entry
compounda
Mwb [g mol-1]
Tgc [°C]
T1d [°C]
T2d [°C]
ΔHfusd [kJ mol-1]
Tccd [°C]
Tmd [°C]
1
hydz-Si8-hydz
1302.0
40.4
138.2
136.9
1.3
101.7
107.8
2
hydz-Si16-hydz
1913.2
3.2
147.7
146.7
2.2
35.4
55.7
3
hydz-Si24-hydz
2506.4
–5.8
143.5
143.1
2.6
n.o.
n.o.
4
hydz-Si40-hydz
3692.9
–12.6
117.3
116.0
3.9
n.o.
n.o.
5
hydz-Si15
1482.7
–17.5
124.1
123.5
3.3
n.o.
n.o.
6
hydz-Si∼22-hydz
∼2360
–8.5
115.4
112.8
∼1.1
47.2
70.0
Block molecules hydz-Sin-hydz as depicted in Scheme . Disperse block
is indicated with a tilde (∼);
Calculated molecular weight.
Glass transition temperature (Tg) determined with DSC using a heating rate
of 10 K min–1.
Order–disorder temperature
(T1) measured while heating, disorder–order
temperature (T2) measured while cooling
and enthalpy of fusion per mole block molecule measured while heating
(ΔHfus). Cold crystallization temperature
(Tcc) and melting temperature (Tm) measured while heating. Determined with DSC
using a heating and cooling rate of 2 K min–1. Enthalpic
values are per mole of block molecule; n.o.: not observed.
Figure 2
DSC traces (second heating run) of hydz-oDMSn-hydz triblock molecules (A) and hydz-Si16-hydz
with varying heating rates (B). DSC trace (second heating and cooling
run) of hydz-Si15 diblock molecule (C). Endothermic heat
flows have a positive value. A temperature ramp of 2 K min–1 was used if not otherwise specified.
Block molecules hydz-Sin-hydz as depicted in Scheme . Disperse block
is indicated with a tilde (∼);Calculated molecular weight.Glass transition temperature (Tg) determined with DSC using a heating rate
of 10 K min–1.Order–disorder temperature
(T1) measured while heating, disorder–order
temperature (T2) measured while cooling
and enthalpy of fusion per mole block molecule measured while heating
(ΔHfus). Cold crystallization temperature
(Tcc) and melting temperature (Tm) measured while heating. Determined with DSC
using a heating and cooling rate of 2 K min–1. Enthalpic
values are per mole of block molecule; n.o.: not observed.DSC traces (second heating run) of hydz-oDMSn-hydz triblock molecules (A) and hydz-Si16-hydz
with varying heating rates (B). DSC trace (second heating and cooling
run) of hydz-Si15diblock molecule (C). Endothermic heat
flows have a positive value. A temperature ramp of 2 K min–1 was used if not otherwise specified.Interestingly, for hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz two additional transitions were observed when a low heating
rate was applied (2 K min–1, Figure A). With the help of variable temperature
X-ray experiments (Figure S10), we could
assign the lower temperature to a cold crystallization transition
(Tcc) whereas the higher temperature is
a melting transition (Tm). Both transitions
are only observed when heating slowly (2 K min–1) and disappear upon heating at 5 K min–1 or faster
(Figure B). Hence,
the formation of the crystalline phase for hydz-Si8-hydz
and hydz-Si16-hydz is a slow process. The other structures
with the longer siloxane-spacers did not show any crystallization.
Nanostructure Formation into 1D Assemblies
The nanoscale
morphology of the hydrazone block molecules was examined using medium
and wide-angle X-ray scattering experiments at room temperature. Well-defined
and long-range ordered nanostructures were observed by the appearance
of sharp reflection peaks (Figure A). All block molecules with fSi ≥ 0.72 formed a hexagonally packed cylindrical phase
(Table , entry 2–5),
evidenced by regular scattering reflections at q*,
√3q*, √4q*, and √7q* in the 1D transmission scattering profile (Figure A). In accordance to the microstructure
observed by POM, the nanostructure of hydz-Si8-hydz was
different from all the other discrete hydrazone block molecules. The
scattering profile of the shortest analogue reveals a lamellar structure
by the presence of integer multiples of the principle scattering peak
(q*; Figure A). The domain spacings (d) range from 4.0
to 5.4 nm with increasing size of siloxane (Table , entry 1–5). The diblock molecule
(hydz-Si15) also forms hexagonally packed cylinders and
its domain spacing matches perfectly the range of the triblock molecules
considering the volume taken up by the siloxane fraction. Accordingly,
we confirm similar packing models for the di- and triblock molecules
in which the hydrazone block forms a cylinder with a diameter ranging
from 2.4 to 2.7 nm (see SI for calculation).
Figure 3
1D transmission scattering profiles for
hydz-oDMS tri- and diblock molecules at room temperature
(A). 2D wide-angle
X-ray scattering profile for hydz-Si16-hydz showing the
alignment of the cylinders and directional π–π stacking (B).
Table 2
Morphological Characterization of
hydz-oDMS Di- and Triblock Molecules
entry
compounda
fSib
phasec
dc [nm]
dcrystd [nm]
1
hydz-Si8-hydz
0.56
LAM
4.0
3.4
2
hydz-Si16-hydz
0.72
CYL
4.2
4.9
3
hydz-Si24-hydz
0.80
CYL
4.6
n.o.
4
hydz-Si40-hydz
0.87
CYL
5.4
n.o.
5
hydz-Si15
0.83
CYL
4.9
n.o.
6
hydz-Si∼22-hydz
∼0.78
LAM
5.6
n.o.
Block molecules
hydz-Sin-hydz as depicted in Scheme . Disperse block is indicated with a tide
(∼).
Volume fraction
of the siloxane
block, calculated using bulk densities for PDMS (0.95 g mL–1)[16] and the crystal structure of 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazone
(1.558 g mL–1).[45]
Morphology of nanostructure determined
with SAXS at room temperature. LAM = lamellar phase. CYL = hexagonally
packed cylinders. Domain spacing (d) calculated using d = 2π/q*.
Domain spacing of crystalline, lamellar
phase determined with SAXS at room temperature. Structure obtained
upon annealing at 102 and 36 °C for hydz-Si8-hydz
and hydz-Si16-hydz, respectively; n.o.: not observed.
Block molecules
hydz-Sin-hydz as depicted in Scheme . Disperse block is indicated with a tide
(∼).Volume fraction
of the siloxane
block, calculated using bulk densities for PDMS (0.95 g mL–1)[16] and the crystal structure of 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazone
(1.558 g mL–1).[45]Morphology of nanostructure determined
with SAXS at room temperature. LAM = lamellar phase. CYL = hexagonally
packed cylinders. Domain spacing (d) calculated using d = 2π/q*.Domain spacing of crystalline, lamellar
phase determined with SAXS at room temperature. Structure obtained
upon annealing at 102 and 36 °C for hydz-Si8-hydz
and hydz-Si16-hydz, respectively; n.o.: not observed.1D transmission scattering profiles for
hydz-oDMS tri- and diblock molecules at room temperature
(A). 2D wide-angle
X-ray scattering profile for hydz-Si16-hydz showing the
alignment of the cylinders and directional π–π stacking (B).A single reflection peak was observed
in the wide angle region
(5 < q < 25 nm–1) for all
tri- and diblock molecules (Figure A). This represents a domain spacing of 0.3 nm which
we assign to the interdisc distances, i.e., π–π
stacking of the aromatic rods. These interactions are highly directional
when flow or shear alignment was applied to the sample, as shown in
the 2D X-ray scattering data for hydz-Si16-hydz (Figure B). Herein, the presence
of highly aligned cylinders was observed and the direction of the
interdisc interactions are found perpendicular to the cylinder orientation.
The alignment of the hydrazones was further confirmed by measuring
the absorbance of light linear and perpendicular to the column axis
of shear aligned films. We found a dichroic ratio varying from 2.2
to 5.9 indicating that the absorption of light parallel to the columnar
axis is lower than that perpendicular to the axis (Figure S11). Molecular orientation phenomena of the hydrazones
in the cylindrical morphology were further studied by FT-IR. The presence
of a ν(NH) peak at 3275 nm–1 indicates intramolecular
hydrogen bonding as this peak did not disappear upon heating the sample
to an isotropic state (Figure S12). A similar
discotic hexagonal packing for semidiscoid dinitrophenylhydrazone
molecules was reported by Paulus and co-workers.[46] We share their conclusion and assign the formation of columnar
structures to the antiparallel dimerization of the hydrazones occurring
via dipole–dipole interactions.
Nanostructure Formation
into 2D Assemblies under Thermodynamic
Control
We measured variable temperature X-ray scattering
in order to elucidate the additional transitions (Tcc and Tm) for hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz observed by DSC upon heating
at 2 K min–1. The morphology change of these block
molecules was followed upon heating with the same rate. We observe
a transition to a lamellar, crystalline structure for both block molecules
when heated to Tcc (Figure S10). Heating above this temperature results in melting
of the crystalline structure since melting is directly followed after
crystallization, also observed by DSC (Figure A). However, we were able to trap the crystalline
structure for hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz
at room temperature by cooling directly after the Tcc was reached (101.7 and 35.4 °C, respectively).
The resulting brittle solid consisted of a lamellar nanostructure
for both block molecules, indicated by a principle scattering peak
(q*) followed by its integer multiples in the 1D
transmission scattering profile (Figure ). Measuring in the wide-angle regime (5
< q < 25 nm–1) reveals crystallization
of the hydrazone by the presence of multiple scattering peaks. The
domain spacing of the lamellar, crystalline structure (dcryst) is 3.4 and 4.9 nm for hydz-Si8-hydz
and hydz-Si16-hydz, respectively (Table , entry 1–2). As a result of the crystallization,
the lamellar domain spacing (dcryst) decreased
by 0.6 nm compared to the amorphous lamellar domain spacing (d = 4.0 nm) for hydz-Si8-hydz. Accordingly, the
crystallized hydrazone rods are less shifted toward each other due
to intermolecular hydrogen bonding (Figure S13).[45]
Figure 4
1-D transmission scattering profiles of
crystallized hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz,
measured at room temperature.
1-D transmission scattering profiles of
crystallized hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz,
measured at room temperature.We have shown that the nanostructure of hydz-Si8-hydz
and hydz-Si16-hydz can be tuned toward 1D or 2D assemblies
by precisely controlling the temperature. The block molecules that
contain a larger content of siloxane are stable 1D structures at room
temperature up to the order–disorder temperature. Most likely,
the siloxanecontent is too high to form crystalline structures and
therefore the theoretical cold crystallization temperature would be
far below room temperature. Hence, the long siloxanes give too much
mobility to the molecular system in order to allow crystallization
of the hydrazones, also explaining the extremely sharp disorder–order
and order–disorder transitions.
Molecular Picture of the
1D and 2D Assemblies Revealed by Solid
State NMR spectroscopy
Additional information on the molecular
packing of the hydrazone rods was acquired using solid state NMR spectroscopy.
The temperature-dependent 1H and 1H double-quantum
(DQ)-filtered MAS NMR spectra indicate that the siloxane is highly
mobile at all temperatures (Figure S14 and S15). Thus, the amorphous siloxane can be seen as a bulk solvent for
the hydrazone assembly, separating fibers of π-stacked hydrazone
rods or layers of crystalline hydrazones. For the 1D assembly formed
by hydz-Si24-hydz, the 1H and 1H
DQ-filtered MAS NMR spectra also indicate that the α-protons
next to the ether experience the highest dynamic restrictions compared
to the rest of the alkane spacer and siloxane oligomer (Figure S14). This means that this group finds
itself at the interface of the hydrazone and siloxane phase. The packing
of the π-stacked hydrazones in the cylinders was analyzed by
the 13C CP-MAS NMR spectra (Figure A). Herein, motionally broadened signals
for the hydrazone units were observed, indicating substantial molecular
fluctuations on the 10 kHz to MHz time scale. The five sharp signals
in the spectrum (δ > 60 ppm) can be assigned to the quaternary
aromatic sites in the hydrazone moiety. The chemical shifts of these
signals are significantly less sensitive to local density fluctuations
and molecular motions. Therefore, they show only a reduced motional
broadening. Furthermore, the CP-MAS method, based on heteronuclear
dipolar couplings, reveals that the hydrazone moieties do not move
isotropically in the columnar phase. Combining these findings with
the observed π–π stacking reflection in the X-ray
diffraction pattern leads to the structural model depicted in Figure B. Herein, the hydrazone
units in the columns are stabilized by phase segregation and stack
with a typical π–π stacking distance of 0.3 nm.
The hydrazone pairs are randomly orientated, however, the central
point of the column is the nitro-substituted phenyl ring that experiences
the most restrictions in motion.
Figure 5
13C CP MAS NMR of cylinder
forming hydz-Si24-hydz at 40 °C (A). Schematic representation
of the proposed
packing model of the cylinder-forming hydz-oDMS tri-
and diblock molecules (B).
13C CP MAS NMR of cylinder
forming hydz-Si24-hydz at 40 °C (A). Schematic representation
of the proposed
packing model of the cylinder-forming hydz-oDMS tri-
and diblock molecules (B).Moreover, the molecular packing of hydz-Si8-hydz and
hydz-Si16-hydz in the 2D, crystalline morphology was obtained
next to the packing into the 1D structure observed above Tm (60 and 110 °C, respectively). Insights into the
crystalline packing of the hydrazones was obtained by the 13C CP MAS NMR spectra. Herein, all peaks are sharp and the signal-to-noise
ratio obtained under comparable experimental conditions as for the
cylinder forming structures is significantly improved (Figure A). This indicates that in
the 2D morphology, the hydrazone units are fully immobilized in a
crystalline environment within the amorphous, mobile siloxane matrix
(Figure B). The sudden
onset for line narrowing of the hydz-Si16-hydz and hydz-Si8-hydz at the temperature just above Tm (60 and 110 °C, respectively) in the 1H MAS
NMR confirms the crystalline state of the hydrazone units below these
temperatures (Figure S15). Hence, the molecular
mobility is increased rapidly above Tm while for the noncrystalline, 1D structure of hydz-Si24-hydz, the line narrowing was much more gradual in the same temperature
range (Figure S14). The molecular packing
of the hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz into
the 1D structure observed above Tm is
similar to the hydz-Si24-hydz described above.
Figure 6
13C CP MAS NMR spectra of crystallized hydz-Si8-hydz and
hydz-Si16-hydz, measured at 40 °C (A).
Schematic representation of the proposed packing model of the crystalline
lamellae-forming hydz-oDMS triblock molecules hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz (B).
13C CP MAS NMR spectra of crystallized hydz-Si8-hydz and
hydz-Si16-hydz, measured at 40 °C (A).
Schematic representation of the proposed packing model of the crystalline
lamellae-forming hydz-oDMS triblock molecules hydz-Si8-hydz and hydz-Si16-hydz (B).
Macroscopic Thermal Switching of hydz-oDMS
Di- and Triblock Molecules
The fast response toward temperature
changes of the columnar structured materials shows that these materials
have a great potential for a sensitive thermal switch. Thus, we evaluated
the thermal switching between the liquid and the ordered, solid state
macroscopically by rheology experiments over a temperature range of
100 to 160 °C (Figure ). All discrete block molecules showed a sharp drop of the
viscosity by almost 2 orders of magnitude within 8 s (0.25 °C)
upon heating the material (Figure S16).
This drop appears at the order–disorder transition (T1) and corresponds to the solid/liquid transition.
Upon cooling the sample, the material solidifies within the same time
span and temperature. This result confirms and quantifies the narrow
thermal transitions and the sensitivity toward thermal oscillations
observed by DSC and POM, respectively. Such instantaneous drop in
viscosity at the order–disorder transition is not reported
to date for comparable low MW telechelic oligomers or previously reported
block molecules.[32]
Figure 7
Complex viscosity change
of hydz-Si16-hydz measured
upon heating (red) and cooling (blue) by rheology experiments. A constant
strain of 0.01%, angular frequency of 10 rad s–1 and a heating and cooling rate of 2 K min–1 were
used. The viscosity values for the liquid region (T > 148 °C) have a high standard deviation as a result of
melting
of the block molecules.
Complex viscosity change
of hydz-Si16-hydz measured
upon heating (red) and cooling (blue) by rheology experiments. A constant
strain of 0.01%, angular frequency of 10 rad s–1 and a heating and cooling rate of 2 K min–1 were
used. The viscosity values for the liquid region (T > 148 °C) have a high standard deviation as a result of
melting
of the block molecules.
Effect of Dispersity on
Nanostructure Morphology and Thermal
Properties
In previous studies, we and others have shown
the effect of dispersity on morphologies formed by discrete length
A-B BCOs.[17,29,49,50] However, the consequences of dispersity in the oDMS block in A-oDMS-A type triblock molecules
has not been reported to date. The disperse hydz-Si∼22-hydz block molecule (Đ = 1.2) with an average
volume fraction siloxane of ∼0.78 shows significant differences
compared to its discrete counterpart hydz-Si24-hydz. First,
the difference is visible under the POM by the appearance of an ill-defined
structure (Figure A). X-ray scattering measurements further highlight the disparity
between the morphologies of discrete and the disperse compounds. For
disperse hydz-Si∼22-hydz, we can assign a lamellar
phase by the presence of integer multiples of the principle scattering
peak (q*; Figure B). The structure is somewhat distorted, as inferred
by broadened reflection peaks and a shoulder on the low q-side of the principal scattering peak. Furthermore, some relatively
weak scattering peaks are present in the higher q-region (q > 5), indicating (partial) crystallization
and the existence of π–π stacking by the hydrazones
in the lamellar matrix. As the discrete analogues form highly ordered
cylinders (vide supra), the presence of dispersity
results in significant changes in the morphology and dimensions of
the nanostructures.
Figure 8
Polarized optical microscope image (A) and 1D transmission
X-ray
scattering profile for disperse hydz-Si∼22-hydz
(B). The bulk material was melted between two glass plates and cooled
down with 2 K min–1 for the microscope image. Scale
bar represents 250 μm.
Polarized optical microscope image (A) and 1D transmission
X-ray
scattering profile for disperse hydz-Si∼22-hydz
(B). The bulk material was melted between two glass plates and cooled
down with 2 K min–1 for the microscope image. Scale
bar represents 250 μm.The introduction of dispersity in the hydrazone block molecule
also results into the disappearance of the narrow transitions in DSC
and with that, the fast thermal switching (Figure A). Upon heating, a cold crystallization
transition temperature (Tcc) is observed
followed by melting (Tm) similar to the
thermal transition in hydz-Si16-hydz. The melting is followed
by two broad, endothermic transitions at 93.2 and 115.4 °C. Variable
temperature X-ray measurements show the nature of the transitions
by changes in the morphology and domain spacing (Figure B). The first transition is
a partial morphological change to another lamellar morphology with
a larger domain spacing (dlam,2 = 10.5
nm), which is most likely due to the cold crystallization. Then, passing
through the order–order temperature gives a morphology change
from two lamellar phases to one hexagonally packed cylindrical phase
with a domain spacing (dcyl) of 4.8 nm.
This is followed by the transition to a disordered liquid (T1). Most likely, the appearance of multiple
morphological transitions is a result of various siloxane block lengths
which becomes more important for low MW materials. Next to low MW
BCOs, these results confirm the importance of a discrete design of
block molecules to obtain the desired material properties and morphological
precision.
Figure 9
DSC trace (second heating and cooling run) (A) and variable temperature
1-D transmission X-ray scattering profiles (B) of the disperse hydz-Si∼22-hydz. Endothermic heat flows have a positive value.
A temperature ramp of 2 K min–1 was used.
DSC trace (second heating and cooling run) (A) and variable temperature
1-D transmission X-ray scattering profiles (B) of the disperse hydz-Si∼22-hydz. Endothermic heat flows have a positive value.
A temperature ramp of 2 K min–1 was used.
Conclusions
We have presented the
assembly of hydrazone-oDMS
di- and triblock molecules with varying length of discrete siloxane
oligomers. The hydz-oDMS-hydz triblock molecules
organize in both a 1D and 2D nanostructure surrounded by the amorphous,
liquid-like siloxane block, resembling solution self-assembly. The
diblock molecule has similar thermal properties and nanostructure
organization. The crystalline, 2D morphology is formed under thermodynamic
control if the siloxane linker of the triblock molecules contains
8 or 16 repeating units. Immobilization of the hydrazone rod was observed,
while the siloxane remained highly mobile. The 1D structure is formed
rapidly over macroscopic length scales and irrespective of heating
and cooling rates for all block molecules. The driving force for the
1D structure formation is phase segregation combined with π–π
stacking by dipole–dipole interactions. The structure is formed
within a few seconds which we attribute to nucleation and elongation
only occurring in one direction. The fast thermal response upon heating
and cooling can be utilized in thermoresponsive materials. These materials
can switch reversibly between the ordered, solid and amorphous, liquid
state in a very efficient manner; almost no supercooling is necessary.
The fastest thermal responses with the narrowest temperature range
upon cooling and heating were found for the block molecules that have
the complementary driving forces for 1D structure formation. Hence,
the block molecules having volume fractions of siloxane matching a
phase segregated hexagonally packed cylindrical phase combined with
the hydrazone preferred assembly into π-stacked rods are the
best thermal switchable material. Competing interactions which are
observed for the longest and shortest triblock molecules, result in
broader thermal transitions and decreased sensitivity toward temperature.
Finally, we showed that there is a lack of morphologic control in
the disperse triblock molecule in which a distorted, lamellar morphology
was found at room temperature.The presence of discrete siloxane
linker between two assembling
molecules is crucial to gain control over the nanostructure formation
and obtain novel material properties. Tuning the exact length of the
siloxane linker gives rise to various pathways of assembly favoring
1D or 2D nanostructures, which can be controlled by temperature. The
sharp transition with a drop in viscosity opens new avenues to design
materials with unparalleled ease of processing. Additionally, the
discrete molecular design enabled us to find the synergy between two
driving forces for structure formation and with that obtain the fastest
and most sensitive thermoresponsive materials. Therefore, it is important
to use discrete oligomers in the future to be able to design novel
and highly responsive materials.
Authors: Koen Nickmans; Jeffrey N Murphy; Bas de Waal; Philippe Leclère; Jan Doise; Roel Gronheid; Dick J Broer; Albertus P H J Schenning Journal: Adv Mater Date: 2016-09-30 Impact factor: 30.849
Authors: José Augusto Berrocal; R Helen Zha; Bas F M de Waal; Jody A M Lugger; Martin Lutz; E W Meijer Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2017-04-07 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Mathijs F J Mabesoone; Albert J Markvoort; Motonori Banno; Tomoko Yamaguchi; Floris Helmich; Yuki Naito; Eiji Yashima; Anja R A Palmans; E W Meijer Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2018-06-18 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Brigitte A G Lamers; Bas van Genabeek; J Hennissen; Bas F M de Waal; Anja R A Palmans; E W Meijer Journal: Macromolecules Date: 2019-01-29 Impact factor: 5.985
Authors: Brigitte A G Lamers; Martin H C van Son; Freek V de Graaf; Bart W L van den Bersselaar; Bas F M de Waal; Kazuki Komatsu; Hiroshi Sato; Takuzo Aida; José Augusto Berrocal; Anja R A Palmans; Ghislaine Vantomme; Stefan C J Meskers; E W Meijer Journal: Mater Horiz Date: 2022-01-04 Impact factor: 13.266
Authors: Nada S Al-Kadhi; Fowzia S Alamro; Saheed A Popoola; Sobhi M Gomha; Noha S Bedowr; Shahd S Al-Juhani; Hoda A Ahmed Journal: Molecules Date: 2022-07-19 Impact factor: 4.927