Alex Campbell1, Nicole Wong2, Paul Monk3, Jacob Munro3, Zaid Bahho4. 1. Orthopaedic Registrar, Auckland City Hospital, Auckland. 2. House Officer, Auckland City Hospital, Auckland. 3. Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon and Lecturer, University of Auckland, Auckland. 4. Senior Orthopaedic Registrar, Auckland City Hospital, Auckland.
Abstract
AIM: To highlight the growing cost of electric-scooter (e-scooter) related injuries necessitating surgical intervention by the Auckland City Hospital Orthopaedic Department. METHODS: Retrospective audit of operations by the Auckland City Hospital Orthopaedic Department from 15 October 2018 up to and inclusive of 22 February 2019. Inclusion criteria was that the direct cause of injury necessitating surgery was secondary to an e-scooter accident. Further demographic data was collected including injury sustained and operation details. The surgical costs were calculated, including anaesthetic time, surgical time, staffing, implants used and inpatient stay as well as clinic follow-up. RESULTS: Over the 19-week period of this study there were 21 patients requiring 23 operations as a direct result of e-scooters. The summative anaesthetic, theatre suite and staffing costs of these operations was $162,901. Implants required to fix the fractures totalled $39,898. Ninety-three inpatient nights and 61 follow-up clinic appointments were required incurring an additional expense of $141,639 and $16,119 respectively. Overall, these 23 cases cost a total of $360,557. The extrapolated loss of income was $44,368 secondary to these injuries. This represents a total economic cost of $404,925, or $19,282 per person. CONCLUSION: This study highlights that there can be serious consequences of e-scooter travel. High energy trauma not previously associated with scooter injuries is becoming increasingly prevalent as a result of readily available e-scooters. Many of the injuries identified represent significant morbidity to patients in terms of pain, lengthy rehabilitation and loss of income. Furthermore, the socioeconomic costs for DHBs continues to climb and adds to the acute surgical burden in an already busy healthcare system. The hazards of e-scooters should not be underestimated by both the general public and policy-makers.
AIM: To highlight the growing cost of electric-scooter (e-scooter) related injuries necessitating surgical intervention by the Auckland City Hospital Orthopaedic Department. METHODS: Retrospective audit of operations by the Auckland City Hospital Orthopaedic Department from 15 October 2018 up to and inclusive of 22 February 2019. Inclusion criteria was that the direct cause of injury necessitating surgery was secondary to an e-scooter accident. Further demographic data was collected including injury sustained and operation details. The surgical costs were calculated, including anaesthetic time, surgical time, staffing, implants used and inpatient stay as well as clinic follow-up. RESULTS: Over the 19-week period of this study there were 21 patients requiring 23 operations as a direct result of e-scooters. The summative anaesthetic, theatre suite and staffing costs of these operations was $162,901. Implants required to fix the fractures totalled $39,898. Ninety-three inpatient nights and 61 follow-up clinic appointments were required incurring an additional expense of $141,639 and $16,119 respectively. Overall, these 23 cases cost a total of $360,557. The extrapolated loss of income was $44,368 secondary to these injuries. This represents a total economic cost of $404,925, or $19,282 per person. CONCLUSION: This study highlights that there can be serious consequences of e-scooter travel. High energy trauma not previously associated with scooter injuries is becoming increasingly prevalent as a result of readily available e-scooters. Many of the injuries identified represent significant morbidity to patients in terms of pain, lengthy rehabilitation and loss of income. Furthermore, the socioeconomic costs for DHBs continues to climb and adds to the acute surgical burden in an already busy healthcare system. The hazards of e-scooters should not be underestimated by both the general public and policy-makers.
Authors: Eric H Tischler; Sung Huang Laurent Tsai; Adam J Wolfert; Nishant Suneja; Qais Naziri; Henry M Tischler Journal: J Clin Orthop Trauma Date: 2021-09-29
Authors: Sergio M Navarro; Victor R Vakayil; Rafat H Solaiman; Evan J Keil; Matthew W Cohen; Ellen J Spartz; Christopher J Tignanelli; James V Harmon Journal: BMC Emerg Med Date: 2022-09-01
Authors: Timon Moftakhar; Michael Wanzel; Alexander Vojcsik; Franz Kralinger; Mehdi Mousavi; Stefan Hajdu; Silke Aldrian; Julia Starlinger Journal: Arch Orthop Trauma Surg Date: 2020-08-27 Impact factor: 3.067
Authors: Deniz Uluk; Tobias Lindner; Michael Dahne; Jens Werner Bickelmayer; Kassandra Beyer; Anna Slagman; Friedrich Jahn; Christian Willy; Martin Möckel; Undine A Gerlach Journal: Emerg Med J Date: 2021-06-07 Impact factor: 2.740