BACKGROUND: The identification of prognostic factors of gastric cancer (GC) has allowed to predict the evolution of patients. AIM: Assess the reliability of the lymphoparietal index in the prediction of long-term survival in GC treated with curative intent. METHOD: Prospective study of the Universidad de Chile Clinical Hospital, between May 2004 and May 2012. Included all gastric cancer surgeries with curative intent. Exclusion criteria were: gastrectomies due to benign lesions, stage 4 cancers, R1 resections, palliative procedures, complete esophagogastrectomies and emergency surgeries. RESULTS: A total of 284 patients were included; of the sample 65.4% were male,mean age of 64.5 years,75% were advanced cancers, 72.5% required a total gastrectomy, 30 lymph nodes harvest. Surgical morbidity and mortality were 17.2% and 1.7%. 5-year survival was 56.9%. The N+/T index could predict long-term survival in all de subgrups (p<0.0001), although had a reliable prediction in early GC (p=0.005), advanced GC (p<0.0001), signet ring cell GC (p<0.0001), proximal GC (p<0.0001) and distal GC (p<0.0001). The ROC curves N+/T index, LNR and T classification presented areas below the curve of 0.789, 0.786 and 0,790 respectively, without a significant statistical difference (p=0.96). CONCLUSION: The N+/T index is a reliable quotient in the prognostic evaluation of gastric adenocarcinoma patients who have been resected with curative intent.
BACKGROUND: The identification of prognostic factors of gastric cancer (GC) has allowed to predict the evolution of patients. AIM: Assess the reliability of the lymphoparietal index in the prediction of long-term survival in GC treated with curative intent. METHOD: Prospective study of the Universidad de Chile Clinical Hospital, between May 2004 and May 2012. Included all gastric cancer surgeries with curative intent. Exclusion criteria were: gastrectomies due to benign lesions, stage 4 cancers, R1 resections, palliative procedures, complete esophagogastrectomies and emergency surgeries. RESULTS: A total of 284 patients were included; of the sample 65.4% were male,mean age of 64.5 years,75% were advanced cancers, 72.5% required a total gastrectomy, 30 lymph nodes harvest. Surgical morbidity and mortality were 17.2% and 1.7%. 5-year survival was 56.9%. The N+/T index could predict long-term survival in all de subgrups (p<0.0001), although had a reliable prediction in early GC (p=0.005), advanced GC (p<0.0001), signet ring cell GC (p<0.0001), proximal GC (p<0.0001) and distal GC (p<0.0001). The ROC curves N+/T index, LNR and T classification presented areas below the curve of 0.789, 0.786 and 0,790 respectively, without a significant statistical difference (p=0.96). CONCLUSION: The N+/T index is a reliable quotient in the prognostic evaluation of gastric adenocarcinomapatients who have been resected with curative intent.
Over the last 40 years, gastric cancer (GC) has experienced significant changes with
regards to treatment and prognosis. Thus, an increase in patients with
undifferentiated cancers (particularly signet cell cancer), tumors in the superior
third of the stomach,and a greater proportion of total gastrectomies have been
observed, in addition to a significant decrease in surgical mortality and an
improvement in a 5-year global survival rate(SVg5)
,
,
,
.Identification of some prognostic factors has contributed in the therapeutic decision
making process
,
. In Chilean reality, there are few studies with multivariate analysis
,
,
. Recently a new prognostic factor was created and validated, the
lymphoparietal index (N+/T)
.The main objective of this study was to assessthe reliability of the lymphoparietal
index in the prediction of long-term survival in GC treated with curative intent.
METHOD
Prospective analysis of the oncological database of a Chilean University Hospital
(Universidad de Chile Clinical Hospital) between May 2004 and May 2012.This article
does not contain any experimental studies with human or animal subjects performed by
any of the authors.
Patients
All patients with gastric adenocarcinoma and Siewert II and III esophagogastric
junction in the adult population, surgically treated with a curative intent,
were included. Subtotal, total and extendedgastrectomies were included.Exclusion criteria included: gastrectomies due to benign lesions, stage 4 cancers
according to the 7th edition TNM classification, R1 resections,
palliative procedures, complete esophagogastrectomiesand emergency
surgeries.
Surgical technique
Defined in previous report
Definitions
Were used: 1) TNM classification was standarized using the AJCC 7th
edition
(Table 1); 2) the lymphoparietal
index (N+/T) calculates the quotientbetween the number of lymph nodes that are
positive for adenocarcinoma metastasis and the T classification of the patient,
andfor mathematical purposes, the T1a and T1b subdivisions were indistinctly
acceptedas 1 in the denominator (examples: 1/T1a = 1/1 = 1, 6/T3 = 6/3 = 2,
24/T4 = 24/4 = 6); the ratio results were divided into N+/T A (0), N+/T B
(0.1-3) and N+/T C (>3) subgroups; 3) the lymph node index (LNR) was divided
into four groups: group 0: 0% of lymph nodes compromised, group 1: from 1% to 9%
of lymph nodes compromised, group 2: from 10 to 25% of lymph nodes compromised
and group 3: more than 25% of lymph nodes compromised
; 4) surgical mortality was defined as occurring from the moment of
surgery up to postoperative day 30.
TABLE 1
TNM classification (n=284)
n
%
Classification T
T1
71
25
T2
31
10.9
T3
73
25.7
T4
109
38.3
Classification N
N0
114
40.1
N1
33
11.6
N2
39
13.7
N3a
55
19.3
N3b
43
15.1
Stage
IA
67
23%
IB
14
4.9%
IIA
27
9.5%
IIB
34
11.9%
IIIA
31
10.9%
IIIB
51
17.9%
IIIC
60
21.1%
Classification TNMacording to 7ª ed. of 2010 AJCC
Classification TNMacording to 7ª ed. of 2010 AJCC
Follow-up
The present study had 100% follow up. The database was completed in a prospective
manner: the survival update was carried out annually using the database of our
hospital and the Chilean Civil Registry
Statistical analysis
The prognostics factors evaluated were demographic, clinical, surgical,
anatomopathological and prognostic indexes. The distribution of variables was
determined by the Shapiro-Wilk test. In accordance with this
test, the continuous variables with parametric distribution (ordinal) were
expressed on average and with a standard deviation (SD), while for the
continuous variables with non parametric distribution (nominal) the median and
inter-quartile (IC25%-75%) ranges were used. The categorical
variables were described in percentages. The Fisher, x
, t student and Wilcoxon Rank-Sum tests were used based on the
characteristics and distribution of the variables. For the analytical
statistical analysis, the StataR14 program was used and p<0.05 was
considered statistically significant. Univariate and multivariate analyses were
performed calculating the odds ratio (OR) with a 95% confidence interval (CI).
The Kaplan-Meier method in the Prism7MR program was used to calculate
the survival curves. The StataR program was used to create the ROC
curves.
RESULTS
A total of 284 patients were included with a mean age of 64.5 years (+/-12.7 DS) of
which 65.4% were male. 69.7% of all patients presented co-morbidities with high
blood pressure, tobacco use and diabetes being the most common with 38.3%, 34.8% and
17.6 % respectively. 24.6% of all patients presented first-degree relatives with
gastric cancer.In reference to the surgical technique, 72.5% of patients required a total
gastrectomy, 19.7% a subtotal gastrectomy and 7.8% an extended gastrectomy. The
organs additionally resected included the pancreas (41%), distal esophagus (27%),
colon (14%), small intestine (14%) and kidney (4%). The lymphadenectomy was D1 in
14.7% and D2 in 85.2%. The mean global lymph node harvest was 30 lymph nodes
(IC25-75%: 22-41). The number of lymph nodes harvested during D1
lymphadenectomies were 28 (IC25%-75%:19-32.5), while 33 were harvested in
D2 lymphadenectomies (IC25%-75%: 24-44). Mean operating time was 208 min
(+/-63.8 DS. All samples (100%) were R0 resections.The mean hospital stay of patients was nine days (CI25-75%: 7-11).
Postoperative surgical morbidity corresponded to 17.2%, while surgical mortality
consisted of five patients (attributed to three esophagojejunostomy filtrations, one
pneumonia associated to mechanical ventilation and one duodenal stump fistula) which
represented 1.7%.The histopathological study revealed that 58.4% of tumors were of the intestinal type
while 36.6% diffuse (undifferentiated or with signet ring cells) and 4.9% were
mixed. 25% of the study corresponded to incipient cancers and 75% to advanced.
Patients with signet ring cells represented 24.2% of the total sample.
Lymphovascular invasion was identified in 50.3% of the sample, while perineural
invasion was observed in 41.5%. The mean of compromised lymph nodes per person was
2(IC25-75%: 0-9). Table1 shows the TNM classification of patients.The mean global survival was 69.9 months (interval between 1-158 months, DS +/-
47.9). The rate of patients with a SVg5 was 56.9%. The SVg5 of these was 90.1% in
incipient and 44.6% in advanced GC.Global survival according to the N+/T index in our population presented significant
differences in each group (N+/TA, N+/TB and N+/TC) with p<0.0001 (Figure 1). Survival according to N+/T index
adjusted to early/advanced GC, proximal/distal GC and signet ring cell GC, are shown
in Figures 2, 3 and 4 respectively.
FIGURE 1
Survival according to N+/T index
FIGURE 2
Survival according to N+/T index adjusted by early and advanced
GC
FIGURE 3
Survival according to N+/T index adjusted by proximal and distal GC:
proximal GC included those in the fundus and body which received total
gastrectomy and distal GC where the ones located in the antrum which
received subtotal gastrectomy
FIGURE 4
Survival according to N+/T index adjusted by signet ring cell
condition of GC
The ROC curve of the N+/T index and the comparative curves between the T and lymph
node ratio predictive variables are represented in Figure 4. The area below the N+/T curve is 0.789 and the difference
observed between the three variables in comparison did not reach a significant
statistic, with p=0.96.
DISCUSSION
The main results of this study suggest the following: 1) The oncological results
comply with the quality models currently used for modern management of gastric
cancer; 2) the N+/T index can be a very useful tool for predicting survival for more
than five years in patients who underwent surgery for gastric adenocarcinoma with
curative intent.The presentation and treatment of GC have changed over the past 40years. The
frequency of distal tumors decreased from 64% to 25%, the intestinal type
proportion: diffuse went from 3-4:1 to almost 1:1; the resectability rate has
increased from 48% to 85% (p<0.001); 75% of all cases are total gastrectomies and
surgical mortality has decreased from 25% to 0.8% (p<0.0001)
,
.The epidemiological changes have different explanations
,
, while the best postoperative results are mainly due to two factors:
“primary factor and secondary factor”. The first has to do with the role of the
surgeon and the surgical team specialized in this pathology while the secondary
factor is represented by the advances in medicine and support units such as
intensive care, medical nutrition, physical therapies, interventional radiology,
among others
.The patients studied in this article reflect part of these changes. This is the
reason why practically 40% of cases are due to diffuse lesions, 2/3 of the
population required a total gastrectomy. The postoperative morbidity was 25.9% and
surgical mortality was 1.7%. These quality standards were within the parameters
presented n the latest Pan American gastric cancer consensus in 2016.The SVg5 of the patients in this study was 56.9%, with this number being comparable
to others published in the literature
,
.With regards to the prognostic factors of long-term survival, guidelines have been
developed with the objective of providing assistance for deciding which therapeutic
strategies should be pursued. In this manner, TNM
classification has allowed to guide the management of these patients.The prognostic effectiveness of the TNM classification and its studies are well known
and have been analyzed by different international
,
,
and domestic study groups5,11,20.Regarding the N+/T index, it is reasonable to think that the lymph node metastatic
potential of a tumor, depending on its level of invasion, could reliably predict
patient prognosis. Thus, the ratio between compromised lymph nodes and T
classification was devised, which was able to demonstrate significant
differentiation between the global survival curves of the different subgroups (Figure 1) and different scenarios (Figures 2, 3
and 4). The only two curves that did not reach
statistical significance were the comparison between N+/T subgroups B vs. C, in 1)
the positive signet ring cell GC and 2) distal GC that received subtotal
gastrectomy. One possible explanation for this finding is the small number of
patients in each arm, another explanation for this phenomenon in the positive signet
ring cell GC, is the peritoneal tropism which contributes in the worst prognosis,
although the evidence in this point is contradictory
,
,
. This could possibly explain why the survival did not differ between the
N+/T subgroups B and C.Furthermore, the analysis of ROC curves (Figure
5) demonstrates how the N+/T index has an area below the curve of 0.789,
without a significant statistical difference of T and LNR factors (p=0.96) which are
known to be well establish prognostic factors.
FIGURE 5
ROC curve of N+/T, T and LNR: areas under the curve are 0.78, 0.78
and 0.79 respectively
The strengths of this investigation are the following: 1) The study of a numerous
population that represents the international and domestic reality; 2) said
population has been managed following international treatment standards for gastric
cancer with a curative intent by a reduced number of expert surgeons; 3) the
provision of a new survival prediction index.The weaknesses of this investigation are as follows: 1) It covers a period of time in
which there was a change in TNM classification (6th and 7th
edition) which impacted the classification and quite possibly the management of
these patients; 2) it doesn`t include the adjuvant therapy used in the analysis,
this limitation is due to the absence of chemotherapy scheme registration in more
than 20% of patients, the information bias of this under registration, cannot make
conclusion reliable in adjuvant therapy. This happens because some health
provisional system of patients in our hospital, can mandate an externalization of
the service to another institution.
CONCLUSION
The N+/T index is a reliable quotient in the prognostic evaluation of gastric
adenocarcinoma patients who have been resected with curative intent.