Literature DB >> 31406896

Adolescent mothers' experiences of the transition to motherhood: An integrative review.

Erfina Erfina1,2,3, Widyawati Widyawati1,4, Lisa McKenna3, Sonia Reisenhofer3, Djauhar Ismail1,5.   

Abstract

A woman experiences heightened vulnerability and faces tremendous challenges when transitioning to motherhood. This is exacerbated for young mothers and studies have shown that adolescent mothers experience an increased burden of responsibility during the transition to motherhood. Recent research addressing the experiences of adolescent mothers has increased. However, the current literature on this topic is still fragmented. The aim of this study was to conduct an integrative review of the literature to explore adolescent mothers' experiences of transition to motherhood and identify associated factors. The literature was searched using electronic databases: Medline, Cumulative index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), ProQuest, Scopus and PubMed. Relevant articles published in English from February 2005 to 2018 were included. Eighteen articles were included in the analysis. Based on this review, factors influencing a successful to transition to motherhood for adolescents included physical problems related to birth and breastfeeding, psychological well-being, ability to care for their baby, social support, education and economic strain and the provision of healthcare. The literature indicated a relationship between social supports and the development of positive maternal identity in the transition period for adolescent motherhood. Future healthcare interventions for adolescent mothers during the transitional period should aim to provide social support and the increase ability of adolescent mothers to manage the physical and psychological challenges of young motherhood, and enhance new mothers' knowledge about caring for babies.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Adolescent; Motherhood; Role; Social support

Year:  2019        PMID: 31406896      PMCID: PMC6608651          DOI: 10.1016/j.ijnss.2019.03.013

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Int J Nurs Sci        ISSN: 2352-0132


Introduction

In recent decades, adolescent pregnancy has become an important health issue in many countries [1]. About 16 million girls aged 15–19 years and two million girls under the age of 15 years give birth every year [2]. Having babies during adolescence can have serious consequences for the health of the girl and her infant [3,4]. Adolescent bodies are not yet fully developed and too closely timed pregnancies, can result in girls who marry before the age of 18 years experiencing higher rates of life-threatening or debilitating conditions as a result of pregnancy [5]. The prevalence of other complications among adolescent mothers with severe maternal outcomes was found in one study to be 75% among mothers aged under 15 years and 47.8% among mothers aged 16–19 years. A high risk of stillbirth was found among all adolescent age groups, but the risk was significant only among adolescent mothers aged 16–17 years (AOR = 1.32; 95% CI, 1.11–1.57) [4] and there were increased rates of depressive symptoms in the postpartum period [6]. The transition to motherhood is a major development in a woman's life [7]. The transition begins during pregnancy and extends into the postpartum period. Settling-in process began as mothers began to feel competent and to develop confidence with their infants. Settling-in is usually achieved around four months following birth [7,8]. Transition to motherhood for teenage girls has been associated with many additional challenges compared with older new mothers [9]. These girls must manage multiple significant life changes at the same time, the shift to adulthood, a possible marriage, pregnancy, and motherhood [10]. A woman experiences heightened vulnerability and faces tremendous challenges when transitioning to motherhood [11]. This is exacerbated for young mothers and studies have shown that adolescent mothers experience an increased burden of responsibility during the transition to motherhood [12,13]. Adolescents often become mothers without the necessary knowledge, skills and resources to deal with early motherhood, which adds stress to their already challenged developmental level [14]. Thus, for effective adolescent motherhood transition support, an overview of the experiences of adolescent motherhood during pregnancy and childbirth and the factors associated with the transition to successful adolescent motherhood should be explored. Recent research addressing the experiences of adolescent mothers has increased around the role of parental support [15], the influence of the father's involvement [16], joys and challenges of adolescent mothers [12,17], and health care experiences of adolescent mothers [18,19]. However, the current literature on this topic is still fragmented. The present review focused on identifying factors associated with the transition to motherhood for adolescent mothers. The knowledge gained from this study has importance in enabling healthcare professionals, as well as other professionals, dealing with pregnant teenagers to understand the key aspects of becoming and being a teenage mother, thus offering the teenage mothers they encounter optimum care. Thus, the aim of this paper was to identify associated factors during transition of adolescent mothers based on mothers' experiences.

Method

Literature search methods

An integrative approach is used to summarize previous research and to illustrate what is known about a particular phenomenon or health problem comprehensively and [20], in this case, the review focused on factors associated with a positive transition to adolescent motherhood. The literature was searched using electronic databases: Medline, Cumulative index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), ProQuest, Scopus and PubMed. Keywords were: 'motherhood* OR adolescent mother* OR adolescent motherhood* OR teenage mother* OR teenage motherhood* OR becoming a mother* OR motherhood transition* OR maternal identity*. Inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) written in English language between 2005 and 2018, (2) reported on mothers aged younger than 21 years old, (3) specific to transition to adolescent motherhood, and (4) original research. The search included adolescent motherhood during the transition period, which was defined as the period of pregnancy up to six months postpartum. Exclusion criteria were: (1) Unpublished research due to lack of formal peer-review, (2) reviews of literature or (3) articles reporting on assessment tool development.

Search outcomes

The search yielded 1288 titles related to adolescent motherhood (see details in Fig. 1). After duplicates were removed, 1175 manuscripts remained. Thirty-five papers remained after review of titles and abstracts, and these underwent full text review. Assessment of full texts excluded a further 17 papers leaving 18 papers for inclusion in this review.
Fig. 1

The Flow chart describing details of literature search and selection strategy.

The Flow chart describing details of literature search and selection strategy.

Data abstraction and quality assessment

The first author initially identified and reviewed citation on title and abstract. A second author independently reviewed and evaluated the papers selected for inclusion. We extracted the data related to author/s, year of publication, country, aim of the study, design and methods, sample and setting, key findings and evaluated the quality of the study (Table 1). Research studies which met the inclusion criteria were assessed for quality using the standard quality assessment criteria of Joanna Briggs Institute dependent on study design [21]. Quantitative studies were evaluated for the quality of: sample recruitment procedure, representativeness and sufficient sample size, inclusion criteria, connection between theoretical framework and hypothesis, instruments validity and reliability, ability to compare groups, suitable statistical data analysis, and generalizability of results. On the other hand, qualitative research studies were evaluated on: methodological congruency with the indicated philosophical view, study question, data collection procedures, data analysis methods, results interpretation, ethical consideration of study process and the basis of existing conclusion.
Table 1

Details of studies in this review.

Authors (Year)CountryAim of the studyDesign and methodsSample and settingsKey findingsQuality score
Mohammadi N et al. (2016) [9]IranTo explore the experience of pregnancy in Iranian teenage womenAn interpretive phenomenological studyIn-depth interviews11 adolescent mothers aged 15–17 yearsPrimary Health Care Centre

Fast development

Dual self-perception

positive self- perception on becoming pregnant,

negative self- perception such as feeling doubt to manage responsibilities as mothers

High
Ngum Chi Watts M et al. (2015) [10]AustraliaTo solicit lived experiences of African Australian young refugee women who had experienced early motherhood in AustraliaQualitative studyIn-depth interview16 African Australian teenagers who had refugee backgroundsCommunity setting

Mixed feelings and experiences, positive feelings: sense of maturity and responsibility,

Complete their school education,

Social economy strain,

Feeling stress and regret,

Family support, support from friends and wide community

High

Mangeli M et al. (2017) [12]IranTo explore the challenges encountered by Iranian adolescent mothers during the transition to motherhoodQualitative studyIn-depth interviews16 adolescent within ages of 14–18 at the time of childbirthCommunity setting

Increasing burden of responsibility

Experiencing physical problems,

Receiving insufficient support,

Inefficiency in maternal role,

Emotional and mental distress;

Role conflict

High
Sheeran N et al. (2016) [13]AustraliaTo explicate the experience of being a mother for adolescent women who experienced a preterm or term birth in Australia.Interpretative phenomenological studyIndividual guided interview14 primiparous women aged 15–19 yearsFour hospitals (both regional and metropolitan) southeast Queensland

Birth status did not meaningfully differentiate on being a mother

Transforming to be good mother

High
Copeland R et al. (2017) [15]Costa RicaTo gain a better understanding of the lived experiences of mothers, as well as the kinds of support they received during and after the pregnancyQualitative studySemi-structured interviewsCase study22 women who had become pregnant in adolescence (before the age of 18 years)Primipara and multiparaCommunity setting

Family support was the most important factor in mitigating adolescent experiences of stress

Feeling positive towards baby

Negative feeling about their choices related to the pregnancy

High
Malette J et al. (2015) [16]USATo explain the relationships between prenatal and post birth father involvement, inter-parental relationship quality, and maternal identity.Cross-sectional studyQuestionnaire of prenatal father involvementInter-parental relationship QualityMaternal identity125 mothers aged from 14 to 19 yearsSchool based program for adolescent parent from 32 schools in Ohio.

Father's involvement associated with adolescent mothers' maternal identity

Average
Sheeran N et al. (2015) [17]AustraliaTo understanding of the daily experience of being a young mother for Australian young women who had preterm infantsQualitative interpretive phenomenologicalIndividual guided interview14 primiparous women aged 15–19 yearsFour hospitals (both regional and metropolitan) southeast Queensland

Joy and delight: Love their infant

Infant need and behaviors

Emotional rollercoaster and lack of embodied interaction with preterm birth because of “absence of baby”

Economy strain

Social support

High
Harrison ME et al. (2017) [18]CanadaTo share pregnant and parenting youths' experiences with health care to inform recommendations for promoting youth- friendly medical encountersQualitative descriptive studyFocus group discussion26 mothers aged 19 years or younger3 sites Pregnant and parenting youth in community

Negative and positive health care encounters

High
Hunter L et al. (2015) [19]UKTo explore how the inpatient experiences of a group of young women who gave birth as teenagers influenced their feeding decisions and experiences, and ascertain their ideals for breastfeeding supportQualitative studyFocus group discussion15 women aged 16–20 yearsCommunity setting in Oxfordshire

Feeling tired after birth,

Need relation support

Discomfort

High
Gyesaw N et al. (2013) [24]GhanaTo explores the experiences of adolescent mothers during pregnancy, childbirth, and care of their newbornsQualitative studyIn-depth interviewsFocus group discussions54 teenage mothers aged 14–19 yearsPrimiparaFacility and community level

Reasons for becoming pregnant,

Caring for baby

Physical problem (Pain after birth)

High
Salusky I et al. (2013) [25]Dominican RepublicTo understand the experience of becoming a mother at an early age in a group of marginal young womenQualitative studySemi-structured interviews21 young mothers who became pregnant before aged 18 years.Two areas located in community: Urban and isolated

Motivational forces resulting in early motherhood (partner and educational barriers)

Feelings surrounding pregnancy and childbirth (mixed emotions)

Motherhood was a mark of pride

Challenges of economic and educational attainment

Unconditional love for baby

High
Wilson-Mitchell et al. (2014) [26]JamaicaTo explore the experiences and impact of pregnancy on pregnant adolescents' psychological healthMixed methodIndividual interview, focus group interviews30 pregnant adolescent 16 years and olderPrimiparaTwo hospital held a “Teen-centred” clinic and a standard antenatal clinic.

Social support from family, partner and friend

Community support system

Psychological distress

Positive and negative perceptions of health services

High
Klingberg-Allvin et al. (2008) [27]VietnamTo explores married Vietnamese adolescents' perceptions and experiences related to transition into motherhood and their encounter with health care serviceQualitative studyIn-depth interviews22 women younger than 20 who were either pregnant or had newly deliveredThe Commune Health Centre (CHC)

Ambivalence in the transition to motherhood

Support from husband and extended family

Lacking power with regard to decisions in relation to pregnancy, delivery, and contraceptive usage

High
DeVito J. (2010) [28]USATo explore and better understand first-time adolescent mothers' meanings and experiences of parenting during the 4-to-6 week postpartum periodQualitative studyIndividual interview with open-ended126 adolescent mothersFour postpartum clinical sites

Struggle with between their development and being new mother, isolation and despair to maternal role, growing up

Average
Roberts S et al. (2011) [29]AustraliaTo explore the lived experiences and social context prior to becoming pregnant, of women who became mothers during adolescence in rural VictoriaQualitative interpretive phenomenologicalIn-depth semi-structured interviewsFour mothers aged between 16 and 20 yearsRural North East Victoria

Feeling isolated,

Feeling dissatisfied

Life change: Transition into adulthood

understanding in sexual relationship

Average
Wahn E et al.(2005) [30]SwedenTo describe the perspectives, experiences, and reasoning about becoming and being a teenage mother by Swedish teenage girls.Qualitative studyIndividual interview20 pregnant and parenting girl aged 15–19 yearsUrban, rural and suburban district

Becoming teenage mother (Social economy problem, family pattern)

Positive transition (feel maturity)

Supportive relationship (relevant support from families, friends and society)

High
Ngai FW et al. (2015) [35]Hong KongTo explore Chinese women's perceptions of maternal role competence and factors contributing to maternal role competence during early motherhood.Exploratory descriptive studySemi-structured interviews26 mothers at six weeks postpartum aged 18 years or aboveHome visit

Lack knowledge and experiences of infant care

Social support

Contradictory information

Commitment to caring for physical and emotional well-being of child

High
DeVito J. (2007) [36]USATo investigate factors that may contribute to self-perceptions of parenting in adolescent mothers during the 4- to 6-week post-partum periodDescriptive correlational designThe Norbeck social support Questionnaire (NSSQ)The what being the parent of a baby is like-revised instrument126 adolescent mothers under 20 years of age, 4–6 weeks postpartumFour sites in New Jersey

Social support from her mother and the baby's father.

Education attainment in the future

High
Details of studies in this review. Fast development Dual self-perception positive self- perception on becoming pregnant, negative self- perception such as feeling doubt to manage responsibilities as mothers Mixed feelings and experiences, positive feelings: sense of maturity and responsibility, Complete their school education, Social economy strain, Feeling stress and regret, Family support, support from friends and wide community High Increasing burden of responsibility Experiencing physical problems, Receiving insufficient support, Inefficiency in maternal role, Emotional and mental distress; Role conflict Birth status did not meaningfully differentiate on being a mother Transforming to be good mother Family support was the most important factor in mitigating adolescent experiences of stress Feeling positive towards baby Negative feeling about their choices related to the pregnancy Father's involvement associated with adolescent mothers' maternal identity Joy and delight: Love their infant Infant need and behaviors Emotional rollercoaster and lack of embodied interaction with preterm birth because of “absence of baby” Economy strain Social support Negative and positive health care encounters Feeling tired after birth, Need relation support Discomfort Reasons for becoming pregnant, Caring for baby Physical problem (Pain after birth) Motivational forces resulting in early motherhood (partner and educational barriers) Feelings surrounding pregnancy and childbirth (mixed emotions) Motherhood was a mark of pride Challenges of economic and educational attainment Unconditional love for baby Social support from family, partner and friend Community support system Psychological distress Positive and negative perceptions of health services Ambivalence in the transition to motherhood Support from husband and extended family Lacking power with regard to decisions in relation to pregnancy, delivery, and contraceptive usage Struggle with between their development and being new mother, isolation and despair to maternal role, growing up Feeling isolated, Feeling dissatisfied Life change: Transition into adulthood understanding in sexual relationship Becoming teenage mother (Social economy problem, family pattern) Positive transition (feel maturity) Supportive relationship (relevant support from families, friends and society) Lack knowledge and experiences of infant care Social support Contradictory information Commitment to caring for physical and emotional well-being of child Social support from her mother and the baby's father. Education attainment in the future

Results

A total studies reviewed of 18 studies included 15 qualitative studies, two quantitative studies, and one mixed methods study were included in the review. All articles addressed adolescent motherhood transition. Studies were conducted in a range of countries around the world: four studies were from Australia, three studies were conducted in United States of America, two studies were conducted in Iran, and there was one study each from Canada, United Kingdom, Sweden, Ghana, Hong Kong, Vietnam, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, and Jamaica. All populations studied were adolescent mothers (aged 14–20 years) during pregnancy and childbirth period with sample sizes from 4 to 126. The study setting varied from clinical to community sites with studies taking place in urban, suburban and rural areas. Key factors reported in these studies reported by teenage mothers transitioning to motherhood related to physical problems associated with pregnancy, birth and breastfeeding, as well as psychological impacts with “mixed feelings”, caring for the baby, heightened need for social support, education and economic strain and health care. A summary of these factors is presented in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2

Factors that influence the motherhood transition of adolescent women.

Factors that influence the motherhood transition of adolescent women.

Physical problems

Transition to becoming a mother is an important event in the life of a woman [22]. Most teenagers were not ready to become mothers and thus experienced multiple challenges [23]. Three studies reported that adolescent mothers experienced physical problems during childbirth [12,19,24]. Teenagers stated that the pain associated with labor in the postpartum period become an obstacle to caring for the baby [24]. Many young mothers felt incapacitated because of tiredness and pain after giving birth [19]. You mothers felt that this prevented them developing a deeper attachment with their newborn [19]. Hunter et al. reported that teenage mothers felt tired and helpless after giving birth and thus needed additional assistance from health workers after giving birth [19].

Psychological aspects - “mixed feelings”

The majority of studies have shown the effect of psychological aspects during transition of adolescent mothers. Young mothers articulated complex emotions during pregnancy and giving birth and expressed mixed feelings, including joy and worry, about their new responsibility [9,10,12,15,17,[25], [26], [27]]. Negative feelings to becoming mothers were expressed as feelings of loss and regret related to their past lives and perceived future opportunities. The young women regretted the loss of their adolescence, and loss of continuing education [15]. This feeling expressed by primiparous adolescent mothers. Two studies found that adolescent mothers felt isolated and alone [28,29]. Feeling isolated was a significant experience of participants' lives early in pregnancy. They felt different to their peers and were outcasts at school [29]. The same feeling was also reported by adolescent mothers after giving birth [29]. Many adolescent said their peers did not understand their conditions and the demands of meeting the needs of their babies, and thus felt a lack of support and loss of friendships with their peers [28]. Two studies reported psychological distress in adolescent primiparous mothers [12,26]. The mothers felt distress because of their perceived unpreparedness for pregnancy [29] and seven out of the 30 (23%) teenage mothers reportedly experienced depression, and 6,6% suicidal ideation or entertained thoughts of killing themselves [26]. These feelings occurred with mothers who had an unwanted pregnancy and difficulty in accepting the responsibilities of motherhood [12]. While several studies described young mothers negative feelings related to transition to motherhood, they also found most adolescent mothers revealed positive feelings associated with their transition [9,10,13,17, [30], [31], [32], [33]]. The majority of qualitative studies noted that adolescent mothers felt the transition as a life change into adulthood [29], they felt motherhood transition as a sense of maturity, and had positive self-perceptions when transforming to be good mothers [9,13,27,31]. In this context, adolescent mothers were generally happy to have their babies and felt their lives had changed for the better since becoming mothers [10]. Becoming a mother provided all the teenage mothers with the opportunity to develop. They described becoming more mature, less egocentric as they learned and grew to becoming good mothers [13,28,31]. To highlight the complexity, of new mothers feelings, one study found that despite the challenges, adolescent mothers predominantly felt unconditional love and positive feelings about their babies [25].

Caring for the baby

Many teenage mothers described that caring for their infants was the most challenging responsibility they had ever faced [34]. Three of the qualitative studies were concerned with mothers' care for their babies. The impeding factors maternal role competence included a lack of personal knowledge and experiences of infant care [12] and contradicting information from various sources [35]. However, Ngai et al. explored factors affecting maternal role competence, finding factors facilitating maternal role competence included positive experiences of infant care, well-being of the infant, success in breastfeeding and availability of social support. However, Similarly, Furthermore, one core essential characteristic of the competent mother is commitment towards caring for the emotional and physical wellbeing of the child [35].

Social support

One important aspect for adolescent mothers is social support. The most important sources of social support were found to be from their parents, especially the new mother's mother. Social support from their partner was the second most important type of support [10,16,23,24,29,33]. One cross-sectional study showed that father involvement pre and post birth was positively associated with adolescent mothers' maternal identity [16]. In line with another descriptive correlational study, social support from her mother and the baby's father were factors that may contribute to the development of positive self-perception of adolescent parenting [36] and they often needed assistance from their families to care for their babies [24]. Besides support from family, two qualitative studies reported support from friends and society was particularly needed by adolescent mothers [10,30]. Wahn et al. found that received support was experienced in varied ways, both positive and negative. Support from families, friends and society was seen to contribute to successful motherhood, but the support from the professional network was not always adapted to the adolescents' sometimes uncommunicated needs [30]. A study with African Australian adolescent mothers confirmed the need for some social support during the postpartum period to be available to assist them to meet challenges of early motherhood from family, friends, and the baby's father. However, none of the participants had received support for the baby from their community because of negative community perceptions of teen mothers that increased young women's risk of isolation [10].

Education and economic strain

Five studies described other challenges contributing to adolescent motherhood as economic strain and educational attainment [10,17,25,26,30]. Practical difficulties with housing, transport and financial strain significantly impacted on experiences of some young mothers [17,25,26]. Some adolescent mothers felt regret having a baby while still at school, when they unable to finish their education, this then led to difficulty finding work compounding financial stressors. Meeting the needs of the baby, continuing their education and making friends were very difficult for teen mothers [10]. One study revealed that having a newborn was seen my young mothers as their motivation to complete school, as they claimed they would continue their education in the future in order to provide the best future possible for their babies [36]. Despite this, Mitchel et al. found that most of the teenage mothers discontinued their education and policies had not yet been implemented to support new mothers in school. Indeed, in Africa the discovery of pregnancy sometimes led to expulsion from school [12,26].

Health care providers

Four studies explored whether healthcare providers in clinical settings supported the transition process of adolescent mothers [18,19,27,30]. One study found that young women often felt disempowered and vulnerable immediately after birth [19]. When health professionals took control in providing care to the infant rather than supporting the new mother to do this herself, there was a compounded feeling of helplessness experienced by young mothers [19]. Another study described variable experiences of adolescent mothers' healthcare. Negative experiences seemed more memorable and hurtful, demonstrating mothers' general sense of mistrust [18] and lacking power with regard to decisions in relation to pregnancy, delivery, and contraceptive usage [27]. However, positive attitudes and supportive open communication from midwives and social workers helped participants to feel more confident in becoming young mothers [30].

Discussion

This study reviewed existing literature on the transition experiences to adolescent motherhood to identified factors associated. We identified factors contributing to the transition to adolescent motherhood (both positive and negative) that included physical challenges associated with birth, pregnancy, breastfeeding and psychological aspects related to transiting to motherhood with “mixed feelings”, concerns around caring for the baby, the need social support, and supportive rather than controlling healthcare. The transition to becoming a mother requires extensive psychological, social, and physical adaptation. A woman experiences heightened vulnerability and faces tremendous challenges as she makes this transition [11]. Mothers faced several health problems related to pregnancy, childbirth, postpartum and breastfeeding [12,19,24]. Pain related to the birth process and feeling tired and experiencing pain after giving birth prevented new mothers from caring for their newborns [19]. The adolescent mothers simultaneously faced multiple developmental challenges related to transition into adulthood, marriage, pregnancy and mothering responsibilities [9,12]. Meleis et al. states that good physical and psychological well-being of mothers would positively influence the process of maternal transition [8]. Our review suggests that teenage mothers experienced some negative feelings associated with being a mother, mostly related to mourning for a life as it was with friends and school. However, feelings of love with their infants expressed by teenage mothers in studies in this review highlighted their enjoyment with the process of becoming mothers. When new mothers felt happiness as a mother they were more likely to demonstrate commitment to caring for their babies. However, this review did not compare primiarous and multipara mothers' related psychologic aspects. The results of studies that explored maternal role during transition revealed caring for the baby was the most challenging mothering responsibility. The process of transition evaluated maternal competence in caring for their babies and comfort in going through the transition to becoming mothers and are important components and challenges in primary health care [37]. Adolescent mothers experienced lack of knowledge about infant care and contradictory information from various sources were obstacles to caring for their babies. However, essential characteristics of the competent mother included a commitment to care for the emotional and physical wellbeing of the infant, and availability of social support would facilitate competence in caring for the baby [35]. Social support is a well-meaning action that is given to someone with whom there is a personal relationship, and produces positive responses from the recipient [38]. Brown et al. described social support received by adolescent mothers in the first six months postpartum, suggesting that social support in the form of emotional, informational, tangible support and problem-solving support showed a positive impact during the early postpartum period [39]. Many studies indicated that social support positively influenced transition of adolescent mothers [10,15,26,30,36]. Young mothers believed social support increased their confidence in caring for their children [32]. Adolescent mothers not only needed to social support from their family, but also peers, the wider community and health services [10,26]. Previous research have shown that adolescent mothers were faced with extreme economic and social marginalization [25,30]. Some participants from studies within this review identified extreme financial hardship [25]. The meaning and experience of mothering was also framed by the level of stability in their daily life, particularly in terms of housing, income, and appropriate support [17]. Compounding their poverty, another issue related to adolescent motherhood in these studies was educational attainment [10,36]. Some young mothers had regrets in relation to having babies while still at school, and verbalized a desire to return to school. In some contexts this was not supported by school policy, and the discovery of pregnancy was met with expulsion from school [10,26]. This review found different policies across countries related to education for adolescent mothers. Role transition theory explains that the transition process requires supplementation of roles through therapeutic nursing [8]. Three studies explored whether health care providers in clinical setting contributed to transition process of adolescent mothers [17,25,27,30]. All the studies reported on experiences of adolescent mothers about their health care during pregnancy, childbirth and postpartum. The adolescent mothers experienced positive as well as negative health care encounters, the negative was reportedly more memorable and hurtful [18,19]. Health workers, and especially nurses, play an important role in each stage of achieving the mother's role. The trend towards shorter hospital stays during the postpartum period limits health care encounters for adolescent mothers. However, there is no standard for health care encounters for adolescent mothers related to maternal and babies' health. Therefore, during their short stay at the hospital, nurses and midwives must help new mothers and their partners to transition and to care for their babies before returning home [33]. It is important to recognize specific adolescent needs [27] offering encouragement and a provide a realistic appraisal of the challenges ahead [19]. This review found factors contributing to the transition to becoming a mother requiring extensive psychological, social, and physical adaptation. However, no studies evaluated cultural and policy related health care contributing to adaptation of adolescent mothers to improve their maternal roles. This is an area that could be explored further.

Limitation and implication for future study

This integrative review has some theoretical and methodological limitations. Firstly, most reviewed studies used qualitative methods; hence it is difficult to determine if each factor had significant correlation to effective transition of adolescent mothers. Two studies using quantitative cross-sectional methods and one study using mixed methods showed social support and involvement of the baby's father was associated with maternal identity of adolescent mothers during the transition period. Furthermore, only studies conducted in English language were included so relevant studies published in other languages were not included. Future studies should aim to build on previous work to clarify relationships between the factors outlined in this review and motherhood transition outcomes. Moreover, further studies are needed to determine the effectiveness of nursing and midwifery interventions in the transition period of young mothers.

Conclusion

Our review has presented current knowledge of adolescents' experiences to the motherhood transition and identified influencing factors. Factors found to contribute included physical problems, psychological aspects, caring for the baby, social support, and healthcare provision. Social support was also associated with the development of maternal identity in the transition period of adolescent mothers. This integrative review contributes to nursing and midwifery science in relation to further understanding the transition of adolescent mothers. Future interventions for adolescent mothers during the transitional period should aim to provide social support and increase the ability of adolescent mothers to deal with the challenges they experience when becoming young mothers.

Conflicts of interest

No conflict of interest has been declared by the authors.
  24 in total

Review 1.  Parenthood experiences during the child's first year: literature review.

Authors:  Kerstin Nyström; Kerstin Ohrling
Journal:  J Adv Nurs       Date:  2004-05       Impact factor: 3.187

Review 2.  Becoming a mother versus maternal role attainment.

Authors:  Ramona T Mercer
Journal:  J Nurs Scholarsh       Date:  2004       Impact factor: 3.176

3.  The integrative review: updated methodology.

Authors:  Robin Whittemore; Kathleen Knafl
Journal:  J Adv Nurs       Date:  2005-12       Impact factor: 3.187

4.  Becoming and being a teenage mother: how teenage girls in South Western Sweden view their situation.

Authors:  Elisabeth Hertfelt Wahn; Eva Nissen; Beth Maina Ahlberg
Journal:  Health Care Women Int       Date:  2005-08

5.  Nursing support of the process of becoming a mother.

Authors:  Ramona T Mercer
Journal:  J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs       Date:  2006 Sep-Oct

Review 6.  Clinical assessment of mothering during infancy.

Authors:  Eileen R Fowles; June Andrews Horowitz
Journal:  J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs       Date:  2006 Sep-Oct

7.  Self-perceptions of parenting among adolescent mothers.

Authors:  Josephine Devito
Journal:  J Perinat Educ       Date:  2007

8.  Psychosocial factors and maternal wellbeing: an exploratory path analysis.

Authors:  Fei-Wan Ngai; Sally Wai-Chi Chan
Journal:  Int J Nurs Stud       Date:  2010-12-08       Impact factor: 5.837

9.  One foot wet and one foot dry: transition into motherhood among married adolescent women in rural Vietnam.

Authors:  Marie Klingberg-Allvin; Nguyen Binh; Annika Johansson; Vanja Berggren
Journal:  J Transcult Nurs       Date:  2008-07-31       Impact factor: 1.959

Review 10.  Postpartum depression in adolescent mothers: an integrative review of the literature.

Authors:  Vanessa Reid; Mikki Meadows-Oliver
Journal:  J Pediatr Health Care       Date:  2007 Sep-Oct       Impact factor: 1.812

View more
  14 in total

1.  Young First-Time Mothers' Parenting of Infants: The Role of Depression and Social Support.

Authors:  Helen Y Lee; Renee C Edwards; Sydney L Hans
Journal:  Matern Child Health J       Date:  2020-05

2.  Adolescent mothers' lived experiences whilst providing continuous kangaroo mother care: A qualitative study.

Authors:  Anneline E Robertson; Talitha Crowley
Journal:  Health SA       Date:  2020-12-08

3.  The development of adolescent agency and implications for reproductive choice among girls in Zambia.

Authors:  Katharine J McCarthy; Katarzyna Wyka; Diana Romero; Karen Austrian; Heidi E Jones
Journal:  SSM Popul Health       Date:  2021-12-24

4.  Knowledge and use of lactational amenorrhoea as a family planning method among adolescent mothers in Uganda: a secondary analysis of Demographic and Health Surveys between 2006 and 2016.

Authors:  Catherine Birabwa; Pamela Bakkabulindi; Solomon T Wafula; Peter Waiswa; Lenka Benova
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2022-02-22       Impact factor: 2.692

5.  Maternal self-efficacy and emotional well-being in Chilean adolescent mothers: the relationship with their children's social-emotional development.

Authors:  Laura Léniz-Maturana; Rosa Vilaseca; David Leiva
Journal:  PeerJ       Date:  2022-04-12       Impact factor: 3.061

6.  Psychopathological and Psychosocial Risk Profile, Styles of Interaction and Mentalization of Adolescent and Young Mother-Infant Dyads.

Authors:  Elena Ierardi; Alessandro Albizzati; Margherita Moioli; Cristina Riva Crugnola
Journal:  Int J Environ Res Public Health       Date:  2022-04-14       Impact factor: 4.614

7.  An exploration of the breastfeeding behaviors of women after cesarean section: A qualitative study.

Authors:  Juan Wen; Guiling Yu; Yan Kong; Furong Liu; Holly Wei
Journal:  Int J Nurs Sci       Date:  2020-07-20

8.  "I have to provide for another life emotionally, physically and financially": understanding pregnancy, motherhood and the future aspirations of adolescent mothers in KwaZulu-Natal South, Africa.

Authors:  Desiree Govender; Saloshni Naidoo; Myra Taylor
Journal:  BMC Pregnancy Childbirth       Date:  2020-10-14       Impact factor: 3.007

9.  A Social Media Group Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Intervention to Prevent Depression in Perinatal Youth: Stakeholder Interviews and Intervention Design.

Authors:  Anupa Gewali; Alana Lopez; Kristin Dachelet; Elise Healy; Marimirca Jean-Baptiste; Holly Harridan; Yolanda Evans; Jennifer A Unger; Amritha Bhat; Darius Tandon; Keshet Ronen
Journal:  JMIR Ment Health       Date:  2021-09-15

10.  The Presence of Meaning in Parenthood, Perceived Social Support, and Happiness of Mothers Living in Hong Kong: A Comparative Study on Younger and Older Mothers.

Authors:  Siu-Ming To; Lei Yang; Ming-Wai Yan
Journal:  Int J Environ Res Public Health       Date:  2022-02-26       Impact factor: 3.390

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.