| Literature DB >> 31358421 |
Rachael M Jones1, Susan C Bleasdale2, Dayana Maita2, Lisa M Brosseau3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Personal protective equipment (PPE) is a primary strategy to protect health care personnel (HCP) from infectious diseases. When transmission-based PPE ensembles are not appropriate, HCP must recognize the transmission pathway of the disease and anticipate the exposures to select PPE. Because guidance for this process is extremely limited, we proposed a systematic, risk-based approach to the selection and evaluation of PPE ensembles to protect HCP against infectious diseases.Entities:
Keywords: Exposure; High-consequence infections; Industrial hygiene; Infection prevention; Intubation; Job hazard analysis
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31358421 PMCID: PMC7132808 DOI: 10.1016/j.ajic.2019.06.023
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Am J Infect Control ISSN: 0196-6553 Impact factor: 2.918
Questions to consider in evaluation of PPE ensembles to protect health care workers from infectious diseases
| Question | Rationale |
|---|---|
| 1. How long does it take to don the PPE ensemble? | Doffing duration affects the response time, which can affect the usability of the ensemble in an emergency scenario. |
| 2. How long does it take to doff the PPE ensemble? | In the event of gross contamination, PPE failure, or high anxiety, HCP should be able to doff the PPE and remove themselves to a safe environment for rapid evaluation of risk or disinfection. Doffing speed is not a priority in all care scenarios. |
| 3. How easy is it to don the PPE correctly? | PPE should be easy to don correctly, difficult to don incorrectly, and/or should have a clear indicator of incorrect donning so as to minimize risk of PPE failure. |
| 4. Can pieces of PPE be removed or changed without contaminating the wearer or other pieces of PPE in the ensemble? | HCP should be able to remove or change a piece of the ensemble without contaminating their body or respiratory tract, and without contaminating other pieces of PPE in the ensemble. In the context of doffing, this helps to minimize risk associated with doffing other pieces of PPE. |
| 5. Can a piece of PPE be replaced without affecting performance of the other pieces of PPE in the ensemble? | HCP should be able to replace pieces of PPE that are contaminated or fail without doffing completely and egressing to a safe environment. |
| 1. Is the piece of PPE correctly sized for the wearer? | PPE that is too large or too small may limit usability. For example, fabric may bunch at the wrist when gowns are too large, whereas gowns that are too small may not cover the wrists or may limit arm motions. |
| 2. Can the wearer move in the PPE ensemble? | PPE should be designed to allow for full range of motion. |
| 3. Does the PPE allow for necessary dexterity and tactility? | Although dexterity and tactility are most closely associated with hands, it is more broadly relevant as health care requires HCP to use all parts of their bodies. |
| 4. Does the PPE ensemble allow for unobstructed vision? | Eye, face, and/or head coverings should not distort or limit the field of view. |
| 5. Does the PPE ensemble allow for the use of corrective eyewear? | Many HCP wear corrective eyewear (eye glasses) that must fit under or adjacent to pieces of PPE. |
| 6. Can the wearer hear people and equipment while wearing the PPE ensemble? | HCP need to be able to hear the patient, other HCP, and equipment during care activities. Some pieces of PPE, such as PAPRs, make noise that can impact hearing. |
| 7. Can people understand verbal communication from the wearer of the PPE ensemble? | HCP need to be understood by the patient and other HCP. Sounds made by the HCP need to penetrate the PPE ensemble. |
| 8. Can the wearer breathe comfortably while wearing the PPE? | Resistance to breathing can cause discomfort and anxiety. |
| 9. How long can the PPE ensemble be worn without the wearer experiencing physiological or psychological stress? | HCP must be able to wear the PPE ensemble for a longer period of time than the care activity requires. Physiological and psychological stress is known to occur with PPE, |
| 10. How long do the pieces of PPE and the PPE ensemble maintain their integrity and functionality during use? | PPE should not tear, move on the body, or degrade during the planned duration of use. Frequent complaints in this regard including fogging of goggles and moistening of N95 FFRs. |
| 11. Does the PPE ensemble prevent by-pass by the wearer? | It should be difficult or impossible for HCP to reach under or around the PPE, such as to shift the respirator to scratch her/his face. |
| 12. Is the PPE disposable? | PPE that is not disposable requires a plan for cleaning and disinfection. Disposable PPE requires a plan for waste management, and a robust supply. |
| 1. Is the PPE sterile? | Some contexts require the use of sterile pieces of PPE. |
| 2. Does the PPE ensemble have junctions between pieces of PPE through which pathogens may penetrate? | There may be gaps between pieces of PPE that may need to be closed through the use of tape or adjustments. Consider, is there an alternative piece of PPE that would eliminate that junction? Critical junctions may occur at the wrist, forehead, or neck, for example. |
| 3. Does the PPE ensemble block the anticipated disease transmission pathway? | Revisit the hazard analysis to ensure that the PPE ensemble covers the necessary body parts–the exposure surfaces, otherwise effectiveness will be reduced. |
| 4. Does the PPE offer the necessary level of protection? | Some pieces of PPE allow penetration of some fraction of pathogens by design, others may fail, resulting in exposure. High hazard infectious diseases should lead to the selection of PPE with low penetration and low likelihood of failure. |
HCP, health care personnel; PAPRs, powered air-purifying respirators; PPE, personal protective equipment.
JHA for the work activity of intubation
| Hazards | Anticipated HCP exposure surface | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Task | Description | Patient's body | Environment | Patient's bodily fluids | |
| 1. Preparation | HCP obtains and opens the intubation kit | None | HCP may go back and forth between patient area and kit storage area | None | Hands |
| 2. Pre-Oxygenation | HCP uses an ambu-bag to ventilate the patient | HCP may need to position the patient's head; HCP's hands touch the patient's head | HCP handles the ambu-bag | Ventilation may generate respiratory aerosols | Hands and respiratory tract |
| 3. Pretreatment | HCP administers sedative through IV access | HCP may touch patient near IV access point | None | None | None |
| 4. Paralysis induction | HCP administers paralytic drug through IV access | HCP may touch patient near IV access point | None | None | None |
| 5. Protection | HCP inserts tooth protector into patient's mouth | HCP’ hands touch patient's face and mouth | HCP may touch respiratory secretions in patient's mouth | Hands | |
| 6. Positioning | HCP adjusts the position of the patient's head | HCP’ hands touch patient's head | None | None | None |
| 7. Placement and proof | HCP inserts the endotracheal tube and checks its placement in the respiratory tract | HCP may hold patient's head in place with torso and arms; HCP may lean close to the patient's face | None | Insertion may induce cough and vomiting, generating aerosols | Torso, arms, and respiratory tract |
| 8. Post-Intubation management | HCP secures the intubation tube by taping it to the patient's face, and connects tube to the ventilator machine | HCP may touch patient's face | HCP touches ventilator machine and tubing | Respiratory secretions may be on the tube or patient's face | Hands |
HCP, health care personnel; JHA, job hazard analysis.
Assume that intravenous access has already been established, otherwise use of a syringe has potential for blood exposure.
Infectious disease hazard analysis for methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV) in health care settings
| Hazard information | MRSA | SARS-CoV |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Present on skin and at site of colonization or infection, including nares | Respiratory secretions, blood, and stool |
| Source strength | Shed from skin and site of colonization, high bacterial concentrations in fluids at site of infection | High viral concentrations in fluids; aerosols emitted in cough and through aerosol-generating medical procedures involving the respiratory tract |
| Infectivity | Generally considered to have low infectivity | Moderate infectivity |
| Transmission route(s) | Contact transmission | Contact and droplet; opportunistic airborne |
| Exposure surface | Colonization or infection occurs in the nares, skin, or breaks in the skin | Infection initiated in the respiratory tract |
| Disease severity | Severe for people with risk factors, such as invasive devices and compromised immune systems | Severe acute respiratory infection |