| Literature DB >> 31288821 |
Herma Lennaerts1, Maxime Steppe2, Marten Munneke2, Marjan J Meinders3, Jenny T van der Steen4,5, Marieke Van den Brand6, Dorian van Amelsvoort7, Kris Vissers6, Bastiaan R Bloem2, Marieke Groot6.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Parkinson's disease (PD) is a chronic and neurodegenerative disease associated with a wide variety of symptoms. The risk of complications increases with progression of the disease. These complications have a tremendous impact on the quality of life of people with PD. The aim of this study was to examine health care professionals' experiences of potential barriers and facilitators in providing palliative care for people with PD in the Netherlands.Entities:
Keywords: Barriers; Facilitators; Focus groups; Palliative care; Parkinson’s disease; Qualitative approaches
Year: 2019 PMID: 31288821 PMCID: PMC6617627 DOI: 10.1186/s12904-019-0441-6
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Palliat Care ISSN: 1472-684X Impact factor: 3.234
Characteristics of participants
| Individual interview ( | Focus group discussion ( | |
|---|---|---|
| Gender | ||
| Women | 7 | 26 |
| Professional background | ||
| Neurologist | 1 | 1 |
| Elderly care physician | 1 | 2 |
| Psychologist | – | 1 |
| PD nurse practitioner | 1 | 6 |
| Community nurse | 1 | 1 |
| Physiotherapist | 1 | 10 |
| Speech therapist | 1 | 3 |
| Occupational therapist | 1 | 3 |
| Dietician | 1 | 2 |
| Othera | 2 | – |
| Age | ||
| 25–34 | 1 | 2 |
| 35–44 | 4 | 4 |
| 45–54 | 1 | 11 |
| 55–64 | 4 | 11 |
| 65+ | – | 1 |
| Highest educational level | ||
| Secondary education | – | 2 |
| Higher education | 5 | 20 |
| University | 5 | 7 |
| Setting | ||
| Academic hospital | 3 | 3 |
| Community hospital | 1 | 3 |
| Nursing home | 1 | 12 |
| Private clinic | 2 | 8 |
| Home care | 2 | 2 |
| Hospice | – | – |
| Rehabilitation centre | – | 2 |
| Primary healthcare centre | 1 | 4 |
aOther: general practitioner & psychiatrist
Researchers’ characteristics
| Code | Initials | Gender | Age | Occupation and experience |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I1 | H.L. | Female | 35 | PhD candidate, master degrees in Social Sciences. 5 years experience on multiple projects for PD, nursing care and 14 years experience in PD-patient care. |
| I2 | M.S. | Female | 29 | Master degrees in Psychology. Two years experience on multiple projects for PD and 5 years employed as coordinator at ParkinsonNet, a Dutch nationwide PD network |
| I3 | M.G. | Female | 51 | Senior researcher, assistant professor, PhD in Palliative Care, over 18 years of experience on research projects in palliative care, senior lecturer Qualitative Research, Nurse (NP) |
| I4 | M.M. | Male | 50 | Associate professor in healthcare innovation, director of strategy Movement Disorders Centre of Expertise, Managing Director ParkinsonNet, 17 years of experience on multiple multidisciplinary research and innovation projects for PD |
Perceived facilitators & barriers for palliative care for persons with PD
| Themes | Barriers | Facilitators |
|---|---|---|
| Addressing needs of persons with PD and family caregivers | A persons cognitive deficits and communication problems Tension between needs from a person and his/her family caregivers A lack of time in interaction with family caregivers | Early speaking about wishes and needs with person, family and health care professionals |
| Disease management | Lack of clear responsibilities and roles in (introducing) palliative care Limited resources; lack of time, high workloads and financials | More evidence and guidance in offering adequate disease management |
| Professionals need for training | A lack of competences and specifically for the spiritual domain | Training helps in feeling more confident Communication skills; an open and sensitive attitude |
| Connection between services | Limited communication between health care professionals | Availability of specialized palliative care services Care coordination; need for a central figure to coordinate palliative care |
Quotes taken from the interviews and focus group discussions
| Quote number | |
|---|---|
Q1 Theme: Addressing needs of persons with PD and their family caregivers | This female with PD is in a phase that we need to make choices for the future. We do not know what she wants and how she think of her end of life…. Now, she has several cognitive problems… shouldn’t these conversations have been introduced earlier in the trajectory when this women was cognitively at a better level? (individual interview, nurse practitioner) Many people with PD at advanced stage can’t communicate anymore. They can live their life but we can’t communicate on that moment about what they want and what is important for them. (focus group discussion) |
Q2 Theme: Addressing needs of persons with PD and their family caregivers | People will stay focused on something like hope. Maybe there are still opportunities that will help them. They try, have new hopes, but also are often disappointed. (focus group interview, occupational therapist) Speaking about prognosis should be done earlier. You see that if a person goes to a nursing home (...) they often expect that the condition will stabilize. But PD will continue and you need to discuss scenarios before things get worse. (focus group discussion, elderly care physician) |
Q3 Theme: Addressing needs of persons with PD and their family caregivers | What I find really difficult is when a family caregiver is too overburdened and puts a patient in a wheelchair for the whole day. As a caregiver said: “At least he doesn’t stand in the way then and cannot fall. The more immobile my husband is the better, that’s easier for me. But it is very emotionally taxing. (focus group discussion, occupational therapist) When a patient became ill, his partner pushed for a hospital admission. I don’t think that it was what he wanted, or what maybe was best for him. But this partner, she wanted to do something… (focus group discussion, physiotherapist) |
Q4 Theme: Disease management | When you get diagnosed with PD, you will in fact fight against the disease. You form an alliance for many years with your specialist too fight for a better quality of life or to remain stable. It is very hard for a specialist to say, Saying that a patient is in his last month of his life, I think you get different interventions, focusing more on comfort than on treatment. I think we (professionals) feel and think about it, but don’t explicitly say it. (focus group discussion) |
Q5 Theme: Disease management | You can have all kind of side effects through increasing the medication doses. For example, clozapine therapy carries a high risk of dizziness and balance problems. Balancing between pros and cons is very difficult. (focus group discussion, elderly care physician) Parkinson medication is troublesome. It’s hard to judge whether medication is effective or not. Should we give more medication or should we give less medication instead to reduce side effects? Or should we quit trying to improve balance in medication completely?” (focus group discussion, elderly care physician) |
Q6 Theme: Professionals need for training | I would never mention the word palliative to a patient. No, that’s not my thing. (individual interview, occupational therapist) You have to get used to speak about difficult issues. However, you need to persuade yourself to do this and it will eventually get easier. (individual interview, nurse practitioner) |
Q7 Theme: Professionals need for training | I think doctors won’t speak in depth about spirituality with their patients. Medical treatment is, of course, our core business and this ( |
Q8 Theme: Professionals need for training | Well, I won’t speak about dying if I see a patient for only a short time. But when I build a relationship with a patient, it is different. Even when a patient is physically stable, I probe whether they had ever thought of when the situation gets worse. (individual interview, physiotherapist) A personal relation and connection with a patient is important; sometimes it is a nurse, a physiotherapist, or a cleaner who has known a person for a couple of years. (individual interview, occupational therapist) |
Q9 Theme: Connection between services | I am also a member of a palliative care team in our region. The number of referrals for persons with PD is depressingly low. I think that should be different… I know there are many cases and why do they not consult us? (individual interview, elderly care physician) |
Q10 Theme: Connection between services | What I often hear, is that there is a need for better coordination by for example a case manager. Especially when a patient comes from a situation of transfers between hospital, rehabilitation centre and home. There are changes in medication regimen, feeding or therapy from a physiotherapist. People do not always know what is agreed upon (focus group discussion) |