Gerasimos Baltsavias1, Anton Valavanis2, Luca Regli3. 1. Department of Neuroradiology, Clinical Neuroscience Center, University Hospital Zurich, Steinradstrasse 23, 8704, Zurich, Switzerland. gebalts@gmail.com. 2. Department of Neuroradiology, Clinical Neuroscience Center, University Hospital Zurich, Steinradstrasse 23, 8704, Zurich, Switzerland. 3. Department of Neurosurgery, Clinical Neuroscience Center, University Hospital Zurich, Frauenklinikstrasse 10, 8091, Zurich, Switzerland.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The types of cranial dural arteriovenous fistulae (cDAVFs) that constitute good surgical candidates are unclear despite the use of classifications. We aimed to compare the DES classification with other classification schemes in identifying "ideal lesions for surgery." The DES scheme is based on two features: the level of the shunt (BVS, bridging vein shunt; DSS, dural sinus shunt; ISS, isolated sinus shunt; EVS, emissary vein shunt) and the type of leptomeningeal venous reflux (LVR) (direct, exclusive, strained). METHODS: In this observational cohort study, the angiographies of 20 consecutive patients treated over 1 year were analyzed retrospectively. We defined cDAVFs as ideal for surgery, if cure may be achieved by disconnecting the arterialized draining vein through a single craniotomy. To evaluate the performance of each classification scheme in identifying the "ideal lesion for surgery," we carried out a sensitivity analysis of the Borden, Cognard, and DES schemes. RESULTS: Eight lesions were Borden type 3 and 1 type 2, and 11 type 1. According to Cognard, 2 lesions were type IV, 2 type III, 1 type IIa+b, 11 type I, and 4 lesions could not be clearly classified. According to the DES scheme, 8 lesions were DSS, 4 BVS, 3 ISS, and 5 EVS. All 4 lesions classified as BVS in the DES were ideal lesions for surgery (sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV 100%). Not all high-grade lesions according to Borden were good surgical candidates. CONCLUSION: The DES scheme, as opposed to other classifications, facilitates the therapeutic decision-making especially for selecting candidates for surgery.
BACKGROUND: The types of cranial dural arteriovenous fistulae (cDAVFs) that constitute good surgical candidates are unclear despite the use of classifications. We aimed to compare the DES classification with other classification schemes in identifying "ideal lesions for surgery." The DES scheme is based on two features: the level of the shunt (BVS, bridging vein shunt; DSS, dural sinus shunt; ISS, isolated sinus shunt; EVS, emissary vein shunt) and the type of leptomeningeal venous reflux (LVR) (direct, exclusive, strained). METHODS: In this observational cohort study, the angiographies of 20 consecutive patients treated over 1 year were analyzed retrospectively. We defined cDAVFs as ideal for surgery, if cure may be achieved by disconnecting the arterialized draining vein through a single craniotomy. To evaluate the performance of each classification scheme in identifying the "ideal lesion for surgery," we carried out a sensitivity analysis of the Borden, Cognard, and DES schemes. RESULTS: Eight lesions were Borden type 3 and 1 type 2, and 11 type 1. According to Cognard, 2 lesions were type IV, 2 type III, 1 type IIa+b, 11 type I, and 4 lesions could not be clearly classified. According to the DES scheme, 8 lesions were DSS, 4 BVS, 3 ISS, and 5 EVS. All 4 lesions classified as BVS in the DES were ideal lesions for surgery (sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV 100%). Not all high-grade lesions according to Borden were good surgical candidates. CONCLUSION: The DES scheme, as opposed to other classifications, facilitates the therapeutic decision-making especially for selecting candidates for surgery.
Authors: C Cognard; Y P Gobin; L Pierot; A L Bailly; E Houdart; A Casasco; J Chiras; J J Merland Journal: Radiology Date: 1995-03 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: Mohammed A Azab; Emma R Dioso; Matthew C Findlay; Jayson Nelson; Cameron A Rawanduzy; Philip Johansen; Brandon Lucke-Wold Journal: J Rare Dis Orphan Drugs Date: 2022-06-07