Zhe Hui Hoo1, Nicole R Bramley2, Rachael Curley2, Frank P Edenborough3, Stephen J Walters4, Michael J Campbell4, Martin J Wildman2. 1. School of Health and Related Research (ScHARR), University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK; Sheffield Adult CF Centre, Northern General Hospital, Sheffield, UK. Electronic address: z.hoo@sheffield.ac.uk. 2. Sheffield Adult CF Centre, Northern General Hospital, Sheffield, UK; School of Health and Related Research (ScHARR), University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK. 3. Sheffield Adult CF Centre, Northern General Hospital, Sheffield, UK. 4. School of Health and Related Research (ScHARR), University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: In CF, people with higher FEV1 are less aggressively treated with intravenous (IV) antibiotics, with resultant negative impact on their health outcomes. This could be entirely clinician-driven, but patient choice may also influence IV use. In this prospective observational study, we explored IV recommendations by clinicians and IV acceptance by adults with CF to understand how clinical presentations consistent with exacerbations resulted in IV use. METHODS: Clinical presentations consistent with exacerbations, IV recommendation by clinicians and IV acceptance by patients were prospectively identified for every adult with CF in Sheffield throughout 2016, excluding those who had lung transplantation (n = 7) or on ivacaftor (n = 13). Relevant demographic data, e.g. %FEV1, were extracted from medical records. Multi-level mixed-effects logistic regression models were used to compare IV recommendations vs non-recommendations for all clinical encounters, and IV acceptance vs non-acceptance for all IV recommendations. RESULTS: Among 186 adults (median age 27 years, median FEV1 78.5%), there were 434 exacerbation events and 318 IV use episodes following 1010 clinical encounters. Only 254 (58.5%) of exacerbations were IV treated. A diagnosis of exacerbation, higher number of symptoms and lower %FEV1 were independent predictors for IV recommendation by clinicians. Higher number of symptoms and lower %FEV1 were also independent predictors for IV acceptance by adults with CF. CONCLUSIONS: Lower IV use among adults with higher %FEV1 was influenced by both clinicians' and patients' decisions. Using IV antibiotics as an exacerbation surrogate could under-estimate exacerbation rates and conceal differential treatment decisions according to varying clinical characteristics.
INTRODUCTION: In CF, people with higher FEV1 are less aggressively treated with intravenous (IV) antibiotics, with resultant negative impact on their health outcomes. This could be entirely clinician-driven, but patient choice may also influence IV use. In this prospective observational study, we explored IV recommendations by clinicians and IV acceptance by adults with CF to understand how clinical presentations consistent with exacerbations resulted in IV use. METHODS: Clinical presentations consistent with exacerbations, IV recommendation by clinicians and IV acceptance by patients were prospectively identified for every adult with CF in Sheffield throughout 2016, excluding those who had lung transplantation (n = 7) or on ivacaftor (n = 13). Relevant demographic data, e.g. %FEV1, were extracted from medical records. Multi-level mixed-effects logistic regression models were used to compare IV recommendations vs non-recommendations for all clinical encounters, and IV acceptance vs non-acceptance for all IV recommendations. RESULTS: Among 186 adults (median age 27 years, median FEV1 78.5%), there were 434 exacerbation events and 318 IV use episodes following 1010 clinical encounters. Only 254 (58.5%) of exacerbations were IV treated. A diagnosis of exacerbation, higher number of symptoms and lower %FEV1 were independent predictors for IV recommendation by clinicians. Higher number of symptoms and lower %FEV1 were also independent predictors for IV acceptance by adults with CF. CONCLUSIONS: Lower IV use among adults with higher %FEV1 was influenced by both clinicians' and patients' decisions. Using IV antibiotics as an exacerbation surrogate could under-estimate exacerbation rates and conceal differential treatment decisions according to varying clinical characteristics.
Authors: Martin J Wildman; Alicia O'Cathain; Chin Maguire; Madelynne A Arden; Marlene Hutchings; Judy Bradley; Stephen J Walters; Pauline Whelan; John Ainsworth; Iain Buchan; Laura Mandefield; Laura Sutton; Paul Tappenden; Rachel A Elliott; Zhe Hui Hoo; Sarah J Drabble; Daniel Beever Journal: Thorax Date: 2021-09-23 Impact factor: 9.102