John D Haltigan1, Glenn I Roisman2, Ashley M Groh3, Ashley S Holland4, Cathryn Booth-LaForce5, Fred A Rogosch6, Dante Cicchetti2,6. 1. Department of Psychiatry, University of Toronto, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, ON, Canada. 2. Institute of Child Development, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA. 3. Department of Psychology, University of Missouri-Columbia, Columbia, MO, USA. 4. Department of Psychology, Edgewood College, Madison, WI, USA. 5. School of Nursing, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA. 6. Mt. Hope Family Center, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Longitudinal investigations of relatively large typical-risk (e.g., Booth-LaForce & Roisman, 2014) and higher-risk samples (e.g., Raby et al., 2017; Roisman et al., 2017) have produced evidence consistent with the claim that attachment states of mind in adolescence and young adulthood, as measured by the Adult Attachment Interview (AAI), are associated with the quality of caregiving experienced during childhood. None of these studies, however, has examined whether such associations are consistent across sex and/or race, as would be expected in light of the sensitivity hypothesis of attachment theory. METHODS: We examine whether sex or race moderates previously reported links between caregiving and AAI states of mind in two longitudinal studies (pooled N = 1,058) in which caregiving was measured either within (i.e., observed [in]sensitive care) or outside (i.e., childhood maltreatment) of the normative range of caregiving experiences. RESULTS: Hierarchical moderated regression analyses in both longitudinal cohorts provided evidence that maternal insensitivity and experiences of maltreatment were prospectively associated with dismissing and preoccupied states of mind in adolescence, as hypothesized. Moreover, these associations were generally comparable in magnitude for African American and White/non-Hispanic participants and were not conditional on participants' biological sex. CONCLUSIONS: Both maternal insensitivity and the experience of maltreatment increased risk for insecure attachment states of mind in adolescence. Moreover, our analyses provided little evidence that either participant race or participant sex assigned at birth moderated these nontrivial associations between measures of the quality of experienced caregiving and insecure attachment states of mind in adolescence. These findings provide support for the sensitivity hypothesis of attachment theory and inform the cultural universality hypothesis of attachment processes.
BACKGROUND: Longitudinal investigations of relatively large typical-risk (e.g., Booth-LaForce & Roisman, 2014) and higher-risk samples (e.g., Raby et al., 2017; Roisman et al., 2017) have produced evidence consistent with the claim that attachment states of mind in adolescence and young adulthood, as measured by the Adult Attachment Interview (AAI), are associated with the quality of caregiving experienced during childhood. None of these studies, however, has examined whether such associations are consistent across sex and/or race, as would be expected in light of the sensitivity hypothesis of attachment theory. METHODS: We examine whether sex or race moderates previously reported links between caregiving and AAI states of mind in two longitudinal studies (pooled N = 1,058) in which caregiving was measured either within (i.e., observed [in]sensitive care) or outside (i.e., childhood maltreatment) of the normative range of caregiving experiences. RESULTS: Hierarchical moderated regression analyses in both longitudinal cohorts provided evidence that maternal insensitivity and experiences of maltreatment were prospectively associated with dismissing and preoccupied states of mind in adolescence, as hypothesized. Moreover, these associations were generally comparable in magnitude for African American and White/non-Hispanic participants and were not conditional on participants' biological sex. CONCLUSIONS: Both maternal insensitivity and the experience of maltreatment increased risk for insecure attachment states of mind in adolescence. Moreover, our analyses provided little evidence that either participant race or participant sex assigned at birth moderated these nontrivial associations between measures of the quality of experienced caregiving and insecure attachment states of mind in adolescence. These findings provide support for the sensitivity hypothesis of attachment theory and inform the cultural universality hypothesis of attachment processes.
Authors: Caroline L Bokhorst; Marian J Bakermans-Kranenburg; R M Pasco Fearon; Marinus H van IJzendoorn; Peter Fonagy; Carlo Schuengel Journal: Child Dev Date: 2003 Nov-Dec
Authors: Glenn I Roisman; Fred A Rogosch; Dante Cicchetti; Ashley M Groh; John D Haltigan; Katherine C Haydon; Ashley S Holland; Ryan D Steele Journal: Dev Psychopathol Date: 2017-05
Authors: Jay Belsky; Deborah Lowe Vandell; Margaret Burchinal; K Alison Clarke-Stewart; Kathleen McCartney; Margaret Tresch Owen Journal: Child Dev Date: 2007 Mar-Apr
Authors: Diana J English; Mukund P Upadhyaya; Alan J Litrownik; Jane M Marshall; Desmond K Runyan; J Christopher Graham; Howard Dubowitz Journal: Child Abuse Negl Date: 2005-05
Authors: Michelle E Alto; Jennifer M Warmingham; Elizabeth D Handley; Fred Rogosch; Dante Cicchetti; Sheree L Toth Journal: Attach Hum Dev Date: 2020-03-04