Hannah R Shanks1, Amir H Milani1, Dongdong Lu1, Brian R Saunders1, Louise Carney1, Daman J Adlam2, Judith A Hoyland2,3, Christopher Blount4,5, Mark Dickinson4,5. 1. School of Materials , University of Manchester , MSS Tower, Manchester , M13 9PL , U.K. 2. Division of Cell Matrix Biology and Regenerative Medicine, Faculty of Biology, Medicine and Health , University of Manchester , Oxford Road, Manchester , M13 9PT , U.K. 3. NIHR Manchester Biomedical Research Centre, Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust , Manchester Academic Health Science Centre , Manchester , M20 2LR , U.K. 4. Photon Science Institute , University of Manchester , Oxford Road, Manchester , M13 9PL , U.K. 5. School of Physics & Astronomy , University of Manchester , Oxford Road, Manchester , M13 9PL , U.K.
Abstract
Injectable gels that support load are desirable for restoring the mechanical properties of degenerated load-bearing tissue. As these gels become increasingly sophisticated, the need to remotely image them and monitor their swelling increases. However, imaging such gels and monitoring their swelling using noninvasive means is challenging. Here, we use a very low concentration of near-infrared (NIR) core-shell-shell (CSS) reporter nanoparticles to both image and monitor swelling changes of two load-supporting gels. The load-supporting injectable gel consisted of covalently interlinked pH-responsive microgel (MG) particles. The latter gel was not cytotoxic and is termed a doubly cross-linked microgel (DX MG). Inclusion of a complementary fluorescent dye enabled ratiometric monitoring of gel swelling changes in response to pH via nonradiative resonance energy transfer (NRET). In addition, changes in the CSS nanoparticle emission intensity provided a NIR-only method that could also be used to monitor gel swelling. The gel was able to be imaged using NIR light, after being subcutaneously injected into a tissue model. To demonstrate versatility of our approach, CSS and the dye were included within a model implantable gel (poly(acrylamide/acrylic acid)) and fluorescent detection of swelling investigated. Because the concentrations of the reporting species were too low to affect the mechanical properties, our approach to remote gel imaging and swelling monitoring has good potential for application in injectable gels and implants.
Injectable gels that support load are desirable for restoring the mechanical properties of degenerated load-bearing tissue. As these gels become increasingly sophisticated, the need to remotely image them and monitor their swelling increases. However, imaging such gels and monitoring their swelling using noninvasive means is challenging. Here, we use a very low concentration of near-infrared (NIR) core-shell-shell (CSS) reporter nanoparticles to both image and monitor swelling changes of two load-supporting gels. The load-supporting injectable gel consisted of covalently interlinked pH-responsive microgel (MG) particles. The latter gel was not cytotoxic and is termed a doubly cross-linked microgel (DX MG). Inclusion of a complementary fluorescent dye enabled ratiometric monitoring of gel swelling changes in response to pH via nonradiative resonance energy transfer (NRET). In addition, changes in the CSS nanoparticle emission intensity provided a NIR-only method that could also be used to monitor gel swelling. The gel was able to be imaged using NIR light, after being subcutaneously injected into a tissue model. To demonstrate versatility of our approach, CSS and the dye were included within a model implantable gel (poly(acrylamide/acrylic acid)) and fluorescent detection of swelling investigated. Because the concentrations of the reporting species were too low to affect the mechanical properties, our approach to remote gel imaging and swelling monitoring has good potential for application in injectable gels and implants.
Injectable gels are
highly desirable biomaterials that have been
investigated for delivery,[1−11] tissue engineering,[12−16] and load support.[17−20] In all of these examples, the ability to noninvasively locate and
monitor the gels remotely is advantageous for clinicians and researchers.
However, imaging methods usually require bespoke labeling of the gel
network, which may change the mechanical properties or introduce toxicity
concerns and require expensive imaging instrumentation. Load supporting
gels have excellent potential for intervertebral disc (IVD) repair.[17] Degeneration of the intervertebral disks, or
DIVD, is a major problem that causes pain.[21−24] DIVD affects 40% of under 30
year olds and 90% of people aged 55 and over.[24] Treatment strategies for DIVD include injecting gels that form in situ and are sufficiently swellable, to restore the mechanical
properties of degraded IVDs.[20,25,26] Here, we introduce a new and versatile approach for including reporter
NIR particles within such gels that allows remote imaging and swelling
changes to be monitored using low cost laboratory equipment, without
the need for bespoke labeling chemistry.Near-infrared (NIR)
light deeply penetrates biological tissue[27,28] and has previously been used with gels for imaging[29] and drug delivery applications.[16] While there are examples of gels which are NIR-responsive,[30,31] there are relatively few which emit NIR light.[29] Part of the reason for the relative lack of such biomaterials
is that NIR dyes usually require chemical modification to be attached
to a network. As a method to circumvent this obstacle, we recently
introduced particles that contain poly[2-methoxy-5-(2-ethylhexyloxy)-1,4-phenylenevinylene]
(MEH-PPV) and an NIR dye silicon 2,3-naphthalocyanine bis(trihexylsilyloxide)
(NIR775) in polymer dots, which were, in turn, embedded within an
acrylate particle matrix.[32] These core–shell–shell
(CSS) reporter particles (Scheme ) emitted light at 775 nm and also participated in
nonradiative energy transfer (NRET) in the presence of a complementary
dye.[32] Here, we greatly extend our previous
work by including CSS particles within an injectable gel and an implantable
gel for the first time. NIR imaging of the injectable gel as well
as remote swelling detection for both gels using NRET and NIR fluorescence
are demonstrated.
Scheme 1
Preparation and Swelling of pH-Responsive Doubly Cross-Linked
MG
Gels (DX MG) Containing NIR Core–Shell–Shell (CSS) Reporter
Particles and AF Dye
EA, MAA, DVB, GMA,
and BDDA
are ethyl acrylate, methacrylic acid, divinyl benzene, glycidyl methacrylate,
and 1,4-butanediol diacrylate, respectively. NIR775 and MEH-PPV are
a near-infrared dye and poly[2-methoxy-5-(2-ethylhexyloxy)-1,4-phenylenevinylene],
respectively. These two fluorophores were combined within polymer
dots located within the inner and outer regions of the CSS particles,
as described in ref (32).
Preparation and Swelling of pH-Responsive Doubly Cross-Linked
MG
Gels (DX MG) Containing NIR Core–Shell–Shell (CSS) Reporter
Particles and AF Dye
EA, MAA, DVB, GMA,
and BDDA
are ethyl acrylate, methacrylic acid, divinyl benzene, glycidyl methacrylate,
and 1,4-butanediol diacrylate, respectively. NIR775 and MEH-PPV are
a near-infrared dye and poly[2-methoxy-5-(2-ethylhexyloxy)-1,4-phenylenevinylene],
respectively. These two fluorophores were combined within polymer
dots located within the inner and outer regions of the CSS particles,
as described in ref (32).The injectable gel used in this study is
based on glycidyl methacrylate-functionalized
poly(ethyl acrylate-co-methacrylic acid-co-divinylbenzene) (PEA-MAA-DVB-GMA) microgels (MGs). The latter are
covalently interlinked after injection to give a hydrogel at 37 °C
(Scheme ). These gels
are termed doubly cross-linked microgels (DX MGs). We stress that
the term “doubly cross-linked” is well established[33] and is used to identify two types of cross-linking
(intra-MG and inter-MG) of such gels and should not be confused with
double network gels.[34] The MG building
blocks swell when the pH approaches the particle pKa.[35−43] DX MGs have been shown to be a promising system for restoring the
mechanical properties of degenerated IVDs.[20] The advantage of DX MGs is that almost all of the gel construction
is performed prior to injection. Here, we mixed a very small amount
of CSS particles into the DX MG precursor solution prior to gel formation.
We also included a dye that was complementary to the CSS particles
(AF430, which is abbreviated as AF) to enable NRET for ratiometric
monitoring of gel swelling changes.NRET may occur when a donor
fluorophore has an emission which overlaps
the absorbance of an acceptor fluorophore.[44,45] This can cause quenching of the donor when the distance between
the fluorophores is close to the Förster distance (Ro). The latter is the distance at which the
amount of energy transferred is equal to that lost through emission.[46]Ro is typically
less than 10 nm. NRET is strongly dependent upon the separation distance
of the fluorophores and has been used to monitor pH within biological
systems.[47] NRET has also been studied for
polymer dots containing MEH-PPV and NIR775.[48] In the present study, we investigate injectable DX MG/CSS/AF gels
(Scheme ). The presence
of the AF dye provides a distance dependent ratiometric NRET response
(via energy transfer to the CSS particles), which enables the swelling
of the gels to be reported remotely. We also show that single intensity
NIR emission can be used to monitor gel swelling changes.The
study begins by investigating the properties of DX MG/CSS gels.
We then investigate injectable load-bearing DX MG/CSS/AF gels and
their NRET behavior. The latter is shown to sensitively track the
reversible pH-triggered swelling changes of the gel. The gels are
also shown to have an NIR emission intensity that varies with gel
swelling. The cytotoxicity of the gel is also assessed. The versatility
of using NIR reporting with ratiometric detection is demonstrated
by including CSS and AF within a poly(acrylamide/acrylic acid) gel,
which is a model implantable gel. The study concludes with a demonstration
of NIR imaging of the injectable DX MG/CSS/AF gel, when subcutaneously
injected into chicken flesh. Because we demonstrate that CSS particles
are a versatile and highly sensitive reporter for remote NIR imaging
and monitoring of gel swelling, they should have good potential for
future biomaterial applications.
Experimental
Details
Materials
Ammonium persulfate 98% (APS), ethyl acrylate
(EA, ≥95%), divinylbenzene (DVB, 85%), glycidyl methacrylate
(GMA, ≥97.0%), acrylic acid (AA, 99%), acrylamide (AAm, ≥99%), N,N′-methylenebis(acrylamide) (mBAAm,
99%), and N,N,N′,N′-tetramethylethylenediamine (TEMED)
(99%) were all purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. Alexa Fluor 430 NHS succinimidyl
ester (AF) and tetrahydrofuran (THF) were purchased from ThermoFisher
Scientific UK Ltd. MAA was purchased from VWR Ltd. The CSS particles
were synthesized using the seed–feed emulsion polymerization
method described earlier.[32] The CSS reporter
particles contained MEH-PPV and NIR775 within a PEA-MAA-(1,4-butanediol
diacrylate) polymer matrix (see Scheme ). The PEA-MAA-DVB-GMA MG particles used to construct
the DX MG gels were synthesized by emulsion polymerization and then
GMA-functionalized following the method previously reported.[49] All water used was ultrahigh purity and was
distilled and deionized.
Injectable DX MG/CSS/AF Gel Synthesis
The PEA-MAA-DVB-GMA
MGs were covalently interlinked to form a DX MG gel containing a small
proportion of CSS particles in the presence of AF dye. Accordingly,
MG dispersion (1.47 mL, 13.7 wt %) and aqueous CSS dispersion (132
μL, 2.36 × 10–3 wt % dispersion) and
AF solution (132 μL, 4.7 μM) were mixed. APS solution
(50 μL, 78 mM) was then added to the mixture, and this solution
was added to the larger chamber of a 10:1 Medmix double-barrel syringe.
A solution of NaOH (150 μL, 4.0 M) and TEMED (50 μL, 4.0
wt %) was then mixed together, with a volume ratio of 48:2, respectively,
and added to the smaller chamber of the double syringe. Injection
resulted in mixing of the two solutions by coextrusion, and this produced
a shear-thinning physical gel due to pH-triggered MG swelling caused
by the pH increase. The physical gel was then placed in an incubator
at 37 °C overnight for covalent interlinking. To prepare the
DX MG/CSS gels, the AF solution was replaced with the same volume
of water. To prepare DX MG gels, both the AF solution and CSS dispersion
were replaced with water. The pH of the as-made gels was ∼6.5.
Implantable Poly(acrylamide/acrylic acid) Gel Synthesis
A cross-linked poly(acrylamide/acrylic acid) gel (denoted as PAAm-AA-mBAAm)
was used as a model implantable gel and prepared via free-radical
copolymerization in water following the method described by Nesrinne
et al.[50] AA (3.0 g, 0.042 mol) and AAm
(2.0 g, 0.028 mol) were dissolved in water (7.50 g). This solution
was purged with nitrogen gas for 20 min before APS (160 μL of
a 0.50 g/mL solution in water), mBAAm (0.25 g, 0.0016 mol, in 16.0
mL water), and TEMED accelerator (480 μL, 0.0032 mol) were added.
The monomer solution was then transferred to vials and allowed to
react at room temperature for a minimum of 2 h.
Physical Measurements
A Malvern Zetasizer NanoZS instrument
was used to measure the z-average diameter (d). TEM data were obtained
using a Tecnai 12 Biotwin, with a Gatan 1k CCD camera. Samples were
prepared using ultrathin lacey carbon and copper TEM grids (Agar Scientific),
and dispersion samples were dried at room temperature. Confocal laser
scanning microscopy (CLSM) images were obtained using a broadband
confocal Leica TCSSP5. UV–visible spectroscopy measurements
were obtained using a Hitachi U-1800 spectrophotometer. A FLS980 spectrometer
from Edinburgh Instruments was used to obtain photoluminescence (PL)
data. The excitation wavelength was set at 470 nm. Digital photographs
of the gels were obtained using either white light or irradiation
at 470 nm and a 495 nm lens filter.Swelling studies for the
gels used buffer solutions and a gravimetric method. The gels were
suspended in buffer for 2 days to equilibrate. The volume swelling
ratio (Q) of the gels was calculated using the following
equationwhere Q( is the ratio of the swollen mass
to the dry mass. The parameters
ρS and ρP are the densities of the
solvent and polymer, respectively. The latter was taken as 1.2 g/cm3.NIR imaging was achieved with an incident 470 nm laser.
The sample
investigated consisted of chicken breast (lean chicken breast purchased
from Tesco Ltd., U.K.). A camera fitted with a filter which blocked
light below 720 nm was used to take images of the samples, with an
exposure time of 30 s. A DX MG/CSS/AF pregel (1.0 mL, 13.7 wt %) was
prepared as described above and injected approximately 2.0 mm below
the surface of the chicken breast at room temperature using a 21-gauge
needle. The physical gel cured in situ to form DX MG/CSS/AF gel at
room temperature.
Cytotoxicity Experiments and Assays
Human nucleus pulposus
(NP) cells were cultured in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s
medium supplemented with antibiotic/antimycotic (Sigma-Aldrich, U.K.),
Glutamax, and 10% fetal bovine serum (Thermo Fisher Scientific, U.K.)
within a humidified 5% CO2 incubator at 37 °C. Cells
were harvested by trypsinisation and seeded at a density of 5 ×
104 cells onto 13 mm sterile glass coverslips in 24-well
culture plates. After overnight incubation, the media was replenished
and toroid shaped gels, sterilized in 70% ethanol and washed with
phosphate buffered saline (PBS), were introduced to the NP cell cultures.
Control samples received a corresponding volume of PBS. The cells
were then cultured for 72 h and live/dead assays (Thermo Fisher Scientific,
U.K.) performed at each time point in duplicate according to the manufacturer’s
instructions. Images were obtained with an Olympus BX51 fluorescence
microscope.NP cells were cultured, harvested, and seeded at
a density of 5 × 104 cells per well onto 13 mm nontissue
culture treated well plates containing disc shaped gels and controls
(n = 3) as described above. At the appropriate time
point, PrestoBlue cell viability reagent was added (Thermo Fisher
Scientific, U.K.) and incubated for 4 h. Absorbance values were then
determined at 570 nm using a FLUOstar OMEGA plate reader.
Results
and Discussion
Injectable NIR DX MG Gels
We prepared
NIR DX MG/CSS
gels by blending a small amount of CSS with PEA-MAA-DVB-GMA MG gel
building blocks prior to free-radical coupling of the pendant MG vinyl
groups (see Scheme ). The NIR reporter CSS particles comprised only ∼0.001 wt
% of the total polymer in the gel. The CSS particles were prepared
using emulsion polymerization[32] and contained
MEH-PPV and NIR775. The number-average diameter of these particles
determined using TEM (Figure A) was 84 nm.[32] The particles had
PL emission maxima at 590 and 775 nm (Figure S1A), which are due to MEH-PPV and NIR775, respectively. As discussed
in detail previously,[32] MEH-PPV/NIR775
polymer dots were located at the core and outer shell of the CSS particles.
The CSS particle inner shell was PEA-MAA-BDDA. The PEA-EA-DVB-GMA
MG building blocks used to construct the DX MG were prepared using
emulsion polymerization of MAA, EA, and DVB followed by reaction with
vinyl functionalization with GMA.[49] The
number-average diameter of the MGs determined from TEM (Figure B) was 68 nm. The MGs contained
60.3% EA, 34.3 mol % MAA, 0.8 mol % DVB, and 4.6 mol % GMA from potentiometric
titration data (Figure S2A). They had an
apparent pKa of 6.7 and swelled strongly
when the pH exceeded 6.0 (Figure S2B).
The concentrated MG dispersion formed an injectable shear-thinning
physical gel when the pH approached the pKa and was subsequently cured at 37 °C. The free-standing gels
(Figure C) were orange-brown
when illuminated at 470 nm (Figure D). A digital photograph showing the ability of the
DX MG gels to be injected is shown in Figure A.
Figure 1
TEM images of (A) CSS particles and (B) PEA-EA-DVB-GMA
MG building
blocks. Scale bar: 200 nm. Photographs of DX MG/CSS gels under (C)
white light and (D) 470 nm light. Scale bars: 1.0 cm. (E) CLSM z-stack image of the DXMG/CSS gel (excitation wavelength,
λex = 476 nm). Scale bar: 2.0 μm. (F) UV–visible
and PL emission spectra for DX MG/CSS gel.
Figure 3
Digital photographs showing
injection of the pregel used to prepare
the DX MG/CSS/AF gel obtained under (A) white light and also (B) 470
nm light. The arrows highlight the point of injection. Scale bars:
5 mm. (C) UV–visible and PL spectra for DXMG/CSS/AF gels. The
pH of the gel was 5.0. Live/dead images of human NP cells (D) with
and (E) without DXNG/CSS/AF gel after 48 h. Green represents live
cells, and red represents dead cells. Scale bars: 100 μm. (F)
Uniaxial compression stress–strain data for DX MG/CSS/AF gel.
TEM images of (A) CSS particles and (B) PEA-EA-DVB-GMA
MG building
blocks. Scale bar: 200 nm. Photographs of DX MG/CSS gels under (C)
white light and (D) 470 nm light. Scale bars: 1.0 cm. (E) CLSM z-stack image of the DXMG/CSS gel (excitation wavelength,
λex = 476 nm). Scale bar: 2.0 μm. (F) UV–visible
and PL emission spectra for DX MG/CSS gel.A representative CLSM image for the DXMG/CSS gel (Figure E) shows that the
CSS particles
were well distributed throughout the gel. This is an important advantage
of the CSS particles. Our previous study showed that the CSS particles
have superior dispersion stability (especially at physiological ionic
strength and pH) compared to the parent MEH-PPV/NIR775 polymer dots.[32] The UV–visible absorbance and PL spectra
of DXMG/CSS gel (Figure F) showed features due to MEH-PPV and NIR775. Indeed, the maxima
in both the UV–visible absorption and PL spectra for the gel
are at the same wavelengths as those in the respective spectra of
the CSS particles (Figure S1A). For example,
the PL emission spectrum (Figure F) shows the MEH-PPV and NIR775 peaks at 590 and 775
nm. The former peak for MEH-PPV was strongly red-shifted compared
to the absorbance maximum (496 nm), which is a common observation
for conjugated polymers which tend to have large Stokes shifts.The DX MG/CSS gel was strongly pH-responsive due to its MAA-rich
MG building blocks. Figure A shows that, while the gel volume swelling ratio (Q) had a value of 8.1 at pH 4.0, Q increased
to 60 at pH 8.0. Importantly, the Q values of the
CSS-free DX MG were indistinguishable from those for the DX MG/CSS
gels. These results confirm that the CSS particles did not affect
the gel network swelling. The reversibility of gel swelling was investigated
using pH switching (see Figure B). The DX MG/CSS gel reversibly swelled between pH 4.0 and
8.0. Figure C shows
that increasing the pH of the gel decreased the PL intensity. The
strong decrease of the NIR peak PL intensity (I775) with pH is shown in Figure D. This behavior is because gel swelling decreases
the number of CSS particles per unit volume. This interpretation is
confirmed by the fact that I775 was pH-invariant
for the parent CSS particles in dispersion (Figure S1B).
Figure 2
(A) Swelling ratio (Q) for DX MG/CSS
gels with
varying pH. Samples were immersed in buffers for 48 h to equilibrate
prior to measurement. The inset shows images of DXMG gels. Scale bar:
6.0 mm. (B) Reversibility of DX MG/CSS gel swelling with pH switching.
(C) Emission spectra for DXMG/CSS with varying pH. (D) Ratio of PL
intensities measured at 547 and 775 nm (I547/I775) as well as I775 for DXMG/CSS at different pH values.
(A) Swelling ratio (Q) for DX MG/CSS
gels with
varying pH. Samples were immersed in buffers for 48 h to equilibrate
prior to measurement. The inset shows images of DXMG gels. Scale bar:
6.0 mm. (B) Reversibility of DX MG/CSS gel swelling with pH switching.
(C) Emission spectra for DXMG/CSS with varying pH. (D) Ratio of PL
intensities measured at 547 and 775 nm (I547/I775) as well as I775 for DXMG/CSS at different pH values.In the studies described below, we use the ratio of the PL
intensities
at 547 and 775 nm (I547/I775) to probe the swelling of DX MG/CSS gels containing
AF. Here, we note that the I547/I775 ratio for DX MG/CSS does not change with
pH (see Figure D).
The same result was observed for the parent CSS dispersion (see Figure S1B). Such ratiometric invariance occurred
because MEH-PPV and NIR775 were codeposited within hydrophobic domains
of CSS that are unaffected by changes in pH or gel swelling. These
results nicely exemplify the difference between single intensity PL
and ratiometric measurements. The latter are less sensitive to background
changes.[51] In the following section, we
use both single intensity and ratiometric PL data to study DX MG/CSS/AF
gel swelling.
Injectable and Implantable NIR Gels with
Built-In NRET for Monitoring
Swelling
Motivated by the NRET reporting properties of CSS
particles in dispersion,[32] we hypothesized
that the addition of a secondary dye with emission complementary to
that of the CSS absorbance could result in swelling-dependent NRET
within DXMG/CSS gels. If NRET were operative, then pH-triggered swelling
could in theory alter the separation distance between the CSS and
the dye, resulting in sensitive changes in energy transfer that enable
ratiometric PL monitoring of swelling. In this case, both AF and CSS
particles were added to the MG pregel dispersion to prepare DX MG/CSS/AF
gels (see Scheme ).
Photographs of the gels obtained under white light and 470 nm illumination
are shown in Figure A and B, respectively. The inclusion of AF
caused the emission color for the gels to become green (compare to Figure D).Digital photographs showing
injection of the pregel used to prepare
the DX MG/CSS/AF gel obtained under (A) white light and also (B) 470
nm light. The arrows highlight the point of injection. Scale bars:
5 mm. (C) UV–visible and PL spectra for DXMG/CSS/AF gels. The
pH of the gel was 5.0. Live/dead images of human NP cells (D) with
and (E) without DXNG/CSS/AF gel after 48 h. Green represents live
cells, and red represents dead cells. Scale bars: 100 μm. (F)
Uniaxial compression stress–strain data for DX MG/CSS/AF gel.A criterion for NRET is that the
PL maxima of the donor should
overlap the absorbance of the acceptor.[46] Comparison of the PL and UV–visible absorbance spectra for
CSS (acceptor) and AF (donor) shows that this indeed was the case
(see Figure S3). The presence of AF and
CSS can be seen from the UV–visible spectrum of the DX MG/CSS/AF
gel as a shoulder at ∼430 nm (AF) and peak at 775 nm (CSS),
respectively (see Figure C). The PL spectra for DX MG/CSS/AF show two superimposed
peaks due to MEH-PPV and AF. The maximum at 547 nm is due to AF. We
investigated the effect of CSS concentration on the intensity of this
peak (i.e., I547) using the Stern–Volmer
equation (see Figure S4). The data indicate
quenching of the AF signal due to the CSS particles via NRET occurred
within the gel. On the basis of Ro for
related fluorophores,[52,53] the present data imply that AF
and the polymer dots in CSS had an average separation in the 5–10
nm range.Parts D and E of Figure show the results of live/dead assays, carried
out using human
nucleus pulposus (NP) cells, in the presence and absence, respectively,
of DXMG/CSS/AF. These images show that cells cultured for up to 72
h did indeed survive in the presence of the gels and remained viable
(see also Figure S5). This conclusion is
also supported by the Presto Blue assay (Figure S6), which shows that, although there was a small decrease
in cell viability after 72 h, approximately 80% of the cells were
still viable, when compared to the control. We measured the mechanical
properties of the DX MG/CSS/AF gels using uniaxial compression (see Figure F), because related
gels have been used to support load in degenerated IVDs.[20] The gel had a modulus of 61.4 ± 0.5 kPa
and was able to withstand approximately 83.0 ± 1.5% compression
before failing with a stress-at-break of 554 ± 5 kPa. These values
are in the region where use to augment or repair a degenerated IVD
could be considered.[54]We next investigated
the effect of pH on the PL response for the
DX MG/CSS/AF gels. The gels swelled strongly when the pH increased
(see Figure A). The
data in Figure B show
that the emission from the MEH-PPV (∼590 nm) was dominant in
the spectrum at pH 4.0. As the pH increased, the AF peak (547 nm)
became more pronounced relative to the MEH-PPV peak, although both
PL intensities decreased because of gel swelling. The relative change
of these PL intensities implies that NRET was weakest at pH 8.0. This
is due to an increase in distance between the AFdonor and MEH-PPV
acceptor. The latter was located in the polymer dots within the CSS
particles[32] (see Scheme ). The 547 and 775 nm peak intensities for
DX MG/CSS and DX MG/CSS/AF are shown in Table S1. It is noted that DX MG/CSS/AF has greater PL intensities
at both wavelengths, across all three pH values compared to DX MG/CSS
even though the CSS concentrations were the same in both cases. We
followed the energy transfer using the I547/I775 ratio. Energy transfer decreased
with increasing I547/I775. Interestingly, the latter increased linearly with
pH (see Figure C).
Also, a power-law relationship was apparent between I547/I775 and Q (see Figure D).
These data confirm that quenching due to NRET becomes less efficient
as Q increases. The I547/I775 ratio faithfully tracked the reversible
gel swelling/deswelling cycles (see Figure E), which is potentially important for applications.
The individual spectra of the gels cycled between pH 8 and 4 are shown
in Figure S7.
Figure 4
(A) Digital photographs
of the DX MG/CSS/AF gels under white light
(left) and 470 nm light (right). (B) pH-triggered PL changes for DXMG/CSS/AF
gel. The PL intensity decreases with increasing pH. (C) Q values as well as the ratio of the PL intensities of the AF peak
(547 nm) to the NIR (775 nm) peak over a range of pH values. (D) Double
logarithmic plot of the variation of I547/I775 with Q. (E) Reversibility
of Q and the ratiometric PL intensity to pH switching.
(A) Digital photographs
of the DX MG/CSS/AF gels under white light
(left) and 470 nm light (right). (B) pH-triggered PL changes for DXMG/CSS/AF
gel. The PL intensity decreases with increasing pH. (C) Q values as well as the ratio of the PL intensities of the AF peak
(547 nm) to the NIR (775 nm) peak over a range of pH values. (D) Double
logarithmic plot of the variation of I547/I775 with Q. (E) Reversibility
of Q and the ratiometric PL intensity to pH switching.The ability to use NIR emission
to monitor swelling is highly desirable
because of its relatively high penetration depth through human tissue.[55] We therefore investigated whether NIR intensity
alone could be used to follow the changes in swelling caused by pH
variation for these gels. The variation of the PL intensity at 775
nm is plotted in Figure A as a function of pH, and it can be seen that the intensity of the
NIR peak decreases with increasing pH. A similar behavior was apparent
for the DX MG/CSS gel above (Figure D). In addition, I775 showed
a negative power-law dependence with Q (see Figure B) with an exponent
of approximately −1.1. One would expect an inverse relationship
between PL intensity and Q if the PL intensity change
was solely due to changes in concentration, as suggested by a reviewer.
However, the additional effect of decreased NRET has further decreased
the exponent to −1.1. In both cases, the cause for this behavior
is the decrease of the local CSS concentration caused by swelling,
as discussed above. The high correlation of I775 with Q indicates good potential for monitoring
swelling injectable gel swelling changes remotely using NIR light.
Furthermore, the NIR intensity variation with pH shows excellent reversibility
(Figure C.). Hence,
DX MG/CSS/AF, which employed both the CSS and AF
fluorophores, provides ratiometric and single intensity
NIR monitoring of gel swelling.
Figure 5
(A) Variation of NIR peak PL intensity
measured for DX MG/CSS/AF
gel with pH. (B) Variation of NIR peak PL intensity for the gel with Q. (C) Reversibility of gel NIR PL intensity with pH. The
respective Q values are shown in Figure E. The spectra are shown in Figure S7.
(A) Variation of NIR peak PL intensity
measured for DX MG/CSS/AF
gel with pH. (B) Variation of NIR peak PL intensity for the gel with Q. (C) Reversibility of gel NIR PL intensity with pH. The
respective Q values are shown in Figure E. The spectra are shown in Figure S7.The fact that the PL changes with changes in Q were reversible shows that that AF was not released from the gel
(Figure E and Figure S7) and suggests that AF was covalently
bonded to the gel. The data show that AF did not diffuse away and
provide encouragement that AF would may remain in the gel if it were
used in vivo. NHS-esters react with nucleophiles, and amines are often
used.[56] While DX MG/CSS does not contain
amines, every GMA group incorporated provided a hydroxyl group (see Scheme ). Indeed, a coupling
reaction of NHS-esters with hydroxyl groups at pH less than 7 is known.[57] Because the DX MG gels were prepared at pH 6.5,
such a coupling reaction between AF and the DX MG matrix is plausible
and may account for the reversible PL vs Q changes
observed.In order to demonstrate versatility of our approach,
a different,
potentially implantable, hydrogel was investigated. PAAm-AA-mBAAm
gels are easily prepared and have been used for biological applications
such as breast implants and drug delivery.[58,59] Compression data were obtained for PAAm-AA-mBAAm/CSS/AF (Figure S8A). The modulus was 13.8 ± 1.5
kPa, and the strain-at-break was 76.6 ± 3.4% strain. The swelling
of the gel was pH dependent and strongly affected the PL spectra (Figure S8B). As the pH increased from pH 2.0
to pH 8.0, Q increased from 7.2 to 51.2 (Figure S8C) and the PL intensity across the whole
wavelength range decreased. The value for I547/I775 increased linearly with pH (Figure S8C). Furthermore, I547/I775 followed a power-law relationship
with Q (Figure S8D). The
NIR PL peak intensity could also be used to follow the variation of
pH and Q, as shown in Figure S8E and F, respectively. Hence, including CSS and AF within
an implantable gel demonstrated generality of our approach for monitoring
gel swelling remotely using both ratiometric and
single intensity NIR PL measurements. The fact that these gels are
also load-bearing suggests that they have potential future applications
in vivo, such as augmentation of degenerated IVDs.
NIR Imaging
of an Injected DX MG/CSS/AF Gel
Finally,
we investigated the ability to use DX MG/CSS/AF as an injectable gel
for NIR imaging. Figure A shows that the precursor dispersion emitted NIR light when irradiated
at 470 nm. This was due to a combination of NIR emission and Tyndall
scattering. Parts B and C of Figure show white light and NIR imaging of the gel when injected
into a chicken breast, at a depth of ∼2.0 mm. The wavelength
of 470 nm resulted in maximum fluorescence of the gel and caused minimal
NIR autofluorescence of the chicken breast. The use of 470 nm wavelength
also enabled internal energy transfer to the NIR775 emission. It can
be seen from Figure C that the injected gel had a higher NIR fluorescence intensity when
compared to the plain chicken breast. A control (DX MG gel) that did
not contain fluorophores was also placed on the surface of the chicken
flesh. The latter sample resulted in no fluorescence. DX MG/CSS/AF
gel was also injected onto the surface of the chicken for comparison,
and this could easily be seen via the NIR camera. These data demonstrate
that injectable DX MG/CSS/AF gel has good potential for NIR imaging.
A potential limitation of NIR imaging using an excitation wavelength
of 470 nm is that it only has an epidermis penetration depth of approximately
0.3 mm.[60]
Figure 6
Digital photographs showing (A) a mixed
MG/CSS/AF dispersion before
curing. NIR imaging of the chicken breast was undertaken with subcutaneous
DXMG injection, at a depth of 2 mm, when irradiated with a 470 nm
laser. The blue arrow represents the incident irradiation beam. The
white outline represents the sides of the vial. After subcutaneous
injection of gel, the NIR fluorescence intensity increased. The system
is shown with a sample of the DX MG/CSS/AF gel and a control gel which
did not contain fluorophores (DX MG) on top of the flesh. Part B shows
the system in white light. Part C shows NIR light emitted by the DX
MG/CSS/AF gel (≥720 nm), when it has been excited with 470
nm light. The chicken breast is outlined. Scale bars: 5.0 mm.
Digital photographs showing (A) a mixed
MG/CSS/AF dispersion before
curing. NIR imaging of the chicken breast was undertaken with subcutaneous
DXMG injection, at a depth of 2 mm, when irradiated with a 470 nm
laser. The blue arrow represents the incident irradiation beam. The
white outline represents the sides of the vial. After subcutaneous
injection of gel, the NIR fluorescence intensity increased. The system
is shown with a sample of the DX MG/CSS/AF gel and a control gel which
did not contain fluorophores (DX MG) on top of the flesh. Part B shows
the system in white light. Part C shows NIR light emitted by the DX
MG/CSS/AF gel (≥720 nm), when it has been excited with 470
nm light. The chicken breast is outlined. Scale bars: 5.0 mm.
Conclusions
In
this study, new CSS nanoparticles were used to image gels and
monitor changes in swelling using NIR light. The use of added AF dye
enabled ratiometric detection to be used. In our approach, the CSS
and AF dye were simply blended with the gel precursors. Inclusion
of the low concentrations of CSS particles did not alter the swelling
properties of the DX MG gels. The injectable pH-responsive gels studied
here reversibly swelled when the pH was changed between 4.0 and 8.0.
The AF-containing gels were able to sensitively report the swelling
changes due to NRET. The CSS particles also enabled the gels to be
studied using exclusively NIR emission, which has added potential
for future biomaterial applications. We also demonstrated the versatility
of this new approach to NIR labeling via CSS particle entrapment by
using it for a model implantable PAAm-AA-mBAAm gel. The data reported
in this work bring the possibility of injectable NIR gels that have
potential for both imaging and remote monitoring of swelling and load
support for DIVDs a step closer.
Authors: Brenton Pennicooke; Ibrahim Hussain; Connor Berlin; Stephen R Sloan; Brandon Borde; Yu Moriguchi; Gernot Lang; Rodrigo Navarro-Ramirez; Jonathan Cheetham; Lawrence J Bonassar; Roger Härtl Journal: Spine (Phila Pa 1976) Date: 2018-02-15 Impact factor: 3.468
Authors: Amir H Milani; Anthony J Freemont; Judith A Hoyland; Daman J Adlam; Brian R Saunders Journal: Biomacromolecules Date: 2012-08-30 Impact factor: 6.988
Authors: Michael D Leavell; Petr Novak; Christopher R Behrens; Joseph S Schoeniger; Gary H Kruppa Journal: J Am Soc Mass Spectrom Date: 2004-11 Impact factor: 3.109