| Literature DB >> 31170975 |
Stefan Nickels1, Alexander K Schuster2, Heike Elflein2, Christian Wolfram2, Andreas Schulz3, Thomas Münzel4, Manfred E Beutel5, Irene Schmidtmann6, Robert P Finger7, Norbert Pfeiffer2.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Most definitions of visual impairment focus on the status of the better-seeing eye only, but this approach might underestimate the influence of the worse-seeing eye on the vision-related quality of life (VRQoL).Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31170975 PMCID: PMC6554962 DOI: 10.1186/s12955-019-1158-1
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Health Qual Life Outcomes ISSN: 1477-7525 Impact factor: 3.186
Cross-table illustrating the categorization of subjects according to visual impairment of both eyes in the population-based Gutenberg Health Study (2007–2012)
| Worse-seeing eye: | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No VI | Mild VI | Moderate/severe | ||
| Better-seeing eye: | No VI | “b0/w0”, | “b0/w1”, | “b0/w2”, |
| Mild VI | / | “b1/w1”, | “b1/w2”, | |
| Moderate/severe VI | / | / | “b2/w2”, | |
BE Better-seeing eye, WE Worse-seeing eye, VI Vision impairment; no VI: < 0.32 logMAR, mild VI: 0.32–0.5 logMAR; moderate/severe VI: > 0.5 logMAR
Characteristics of the study sample of the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS) with visual acuity of both eyes and NEI VFQ-25 data available
| All | |
|---|---|
| N | 11,941 |
| Age [y] | 54.7 (11.1) |
| Women | 49.9% (5958) |
| Socioeconomic status | 13.1 (4.4) |
| Eye characteristics: | |
| Mean spherical equivalent [dpt] | −0.12 (−1.25/0.81) |
| Visual acuity (better eye) [logMAR] | 0 (0/0.10) |
| Visual acuity (worse eye) [logMAR] | 0 (0/0.22) |
| Contact lenses or glasses | 89.2% (10646) |
| Distance glasses | 68.0% (8116) |
| History of eye surgery | 7.3% (876) |
| Glaucoma | 2.3% (270) |
| Age-related macular degeneration | 0.4% (51) |
| Amblyopia | 9.9% (1186) |
| Vision-related quality of life: | |
| Visual functioning scale (NEI VFQ-25) | 89.6 (81.3/95.1) |
| Socioemotional scale (NEI VFQ-25) | 100.0 (94.5/100.0) |
Continuous variables were described by mean values and standard deviation, and a skewed distribution was described by the median and interquartile range. Discrete variables were described by relative and absolute frequencies.
NEI VFQ-25 visual functioning scale scores and socioemotional scale scores by categories of vision impairment of the better-seeing eye only in the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS), 2007–2012
| Visual impairment of the better-seeing eye | visual functioning scale score (VFS) | socioemotional scale score (SES) |
|---|---|---|
| No VI ( | 89.6 (81.3/95.1) | 100 (94.6/100) |
| Mild VI ( | 70.2 (57.6/78.0) | 88.4 (67.9/97.1) |
| Moderate/severe VI ( | 63.2 (46.6/78.7) | 76.3 (68.0/93.9) |
Scores displayed as medians (interquartile range); VI Vision impairment; no VI: < 0.32 logMAR, mild VI: 0.32–0.5 logMAR; moderate/severe VI: > 0.5 logMAR
NEI VFQ-25 visual functioning scale scores by categories of vision impairment considering both the better-seeing eye and worse-seeing eye of the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS), 2007–2012
| Worse-seeing eye | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No VI ( | Mild VI ( | Moderate/severe VI ( | ||
| Better-seeing eye | No VI | 89.6 (81.4/95.1), | 84.0 (74.9/89.6), | 80.5 (68.0/89.5), |
| Mild VI | / | 70.2 (62.5/80.2), | 66.8 (45.7/76.0), | |
| Moderate/severe VI | / | / | 63.2 (46.6/78.7), | |
Scores displayed as medians (interquartile range), VI Vision impairment; no VI: < 0.32 logMAR, mild VI: 0.32–0.5 logMAR; moderate/severe VI: > 0.5 logMAR
NEI VFQ-25 socioemotional scale scores by categories of vision impairment (by the better-seeing eye and worse-seeing eye) of the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS), 2007–2012
| Worse-seeing eye | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No VI ( | Mild VI ( | Moderate/severe VI ( | ||
| Better-seeing eye | No VI | 100 (95.1/100), | 97.1 (91.2/100), | 94.1 (85.8/100), |
| Mild VI | / | 90.1 (72.4/97.1), | 73.7 (67.5/95.2), | |
| Moderate/severe VI | / | / | 76.3 (68.0/93.9), | |
Scores displayed as medians (interquartile range); VI Vision impairment; no VI: < 0.32 logMAR, mild VI: 0.32–0.5 logMAR; moderate/severe VI: > 0.5 logMAR)
Fig. 1Distribution of NEI VFQ-25 visual functioning scale scores by categories of vision impairment (by the better-seeing eye and worse-seeing eye) of the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS), 2007–2012. b: better-seeing eye; w: worse-seeing eye; 0: no visual impairment (< 0.32 logMAR), 1: mild vision impairment (0.32–0.5 logMAR); 2: moderate/severe vision impairment (> 0.5 logMAR); gray boxes: interquartile range (IQR); black line: median; black square: mean; whiskers: lowest data point still within 1.5 (IQR) of the lower quartile, and the highest data point still within 1.5 IQR of the upper quartile; dots: outliers
Linear regression estimates of the influence of both the better-seeing and worse-seeing eyes on the NEI VFQ-25 visual functioning scale score in the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS), 2007–2012
| Category of visual impairment considering better-seeing and worse-seeing eye | Model 1a | Model 1b |
|---|---|---|
| ( | ( | |
| Estimate (CI) | Estimate (CI) | |
| BE no VI, WE mild VI | −5.2a | −5.0a |
| (−6.1; −4.2) | (−6.0; −4.1) | |
| BE no VI, WE moderate/ severe VI | −9.03a | −9.01a |
| (−10.0; −8.0) | (−10.0; −8.0) | |
| BE mild VI & WE mild VI | −14.3a | − 14.5a |
| (−17.6; − 11.0) | (− 17.8; − 11.1) | |
| BE mild VI & WE moderate/ severe VI | −24.3a | −24.1a |
| (−27.7; − 21.0) | (− 27.4; -20.8) | |
| BE moderate/ severe VI, WE moderate/ severe VI | − 25.3a | − 24.4a |
| (−29.1; − 21.5) | (− 28.3; −20.5) |
BE Better-seeing eye, WE Worse-seeing eye, VI Vision impairment; no VI: < 0.32 logMAR, mild VI: 0.32–0.5 logMAR; moderate/severe VI: > 0.5 logMAR); all models adjusted for age and sex using both eyes with no VI as a reference; model 1b additionally adjusted for socioeconomic status; CI: 95% confidence interval; a: p < 0.0001, R2: adjusted R2
Linear regression estimates of the influence of both the better-seeing and worse-seeing eyes on the NEI VFQ-25 socioemotional scale score in the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS), 2007–2012
| Category of visual impairment considering better-seeing and worse-seeing eye | Model 1a | Model 1b |
|---|---|---|
| ( | ( | |
| Estimate (CI) | Estimate (CI) | |
| BE no VI, WE mild VI | −2.0a | − 1.9a |
| (−2.6; −1.3) | (−2.6; − 1.2) | |
| BE no VI, WE mild VI | −5.7a | − 5.7a |
| (−6.4; − 5.0) | (− 6.4; − 5.0) | |
| BE mild VI & WE mild VI | − 10.4a | −9.6a |
| (−12.8; − 8.1) | (− 12.0; −7.2) | |
| BE mild VI & WE moderate/ severe VI | − 16.0a | −15.9a |
| (−18.4; −13.6) | (− 18.3; − 13.5) | |
| BE moderate/ severe VI, WE moderate/ severe VI | −20.9a | −19.8a |
| (−23.6; − 18.2) | (−22.6; − 17.1) |
BE Better-seeing eye, WE Worse-seeing eye, VI Vision impairment; no VI: < 0.32 logMAR, mild VI: 0.32–0.5 logMAR; moderate/severe VI: > 0.5 logMAR; all models adjusted for age and sex using both eyes with no VI as reference; model 1b additionally adjusted for socioeconomic status; CI: 95% confidence interval; a: p < 0.0001, R2: adjusted R2
Fig. 2Distribution of NEI VFQ-25 socioemotional scale scores by categories of vision impairment (by better-seeing eye and worse-seeing eye) of the German population-based Gutenberg Health Study (GHS), 2007–2012. b: better-seeing eye; w: worse-seeing eye; 0: no vision impairment (< 0.32 logMAR), 1: mild vision impairment (0.32–0.5 logMAR); 2: moderate/severe vision impairment (> 0.5 logMAR); gray boxes: interquartile range (IQR); black line: median; black square: mean; whiskers: lowest data point still within 1.5 (IQR) of the lower quartile, and the highest data point still within 1.5 IQR of the upper quartile; dots: outliers