Tal Frenkel Rutenberg1, Aseel Assaly2, Maria Vitenberg2, Shai Shemesh2, Alon Burg2, Barak Haviv3, Steven Velkes2. 1. Department of Orthopedics, Rabin Medical Center, Beilinson Hospital, Petah, Tikva, Israel. Electronic address: tal_frenkel@hotmail.com. 2. Department of Orthopedics, Rabin Medical Center, Beilinson Hospital, Petah, Tikva, Israel. 3. Department of Orthopedics, Hasharon Medical Center, Beilinson Hospital, Petah, Tikva, Israel.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: With the aging of the population the rate of fragility hip fractures increases. While medical recommendations are for hasten surgical treatment, for some older patients burdened with severe comorbidities, this might be risky. AIMS: To compare the outcomes of patients treated non-surgically to those of the most fragile patients treated surgically. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A retrospective cohort study, of individuals aged ≥65 years who presented with fragility hip fractures between 01.01.2011-30.06.2016, to a primary trauma center. Patients treated surgically were stratified according to their age-adjusted Charlsons' comorbidity index (ACCI) score. Patients in the upper third of ACCI score, representing the more fragile population, were compared to patients treated non-surgically. RESULTS: 847 patients presented with fragility fractures. 94 (11%) were treated non-surgically and 753 (89%) underwent surgery. Medical reasons were the leading cause for non-surgical treatment (61.7%). Surgically-treated patients were stratified according to their ACCI and 114 patients with ACCI > 9 were chosen for comparison. While both groups were comparable in terms of age, the non-surgical treatment group had more female patients (p. = 0.026) and a smaller proportion of independent walkers (p < 0.001). The ACCI was higher for the surgical treatment group (p < 0.001). In-hospital mortality was similar (14.9% and 18.1% for the operative and non-surgical groups respectively, P. = 0.575). However, one-year mortality was significantly higher for the non-surgical group (48.2% vs. 67.0%, P. = 0.005). The rates of in-hospital complications and 1-year readmissions were similar. CONCLUSIONS: Operative treatment for fragility hip fracture reduces long-term mortality rates even in the more fragile patients, compared to non-surgical treatment.
INTRODUCTION: With the aging of the population the rate of fragility hip fractures increases. While medical recommendations are for hasten surgical treatment, for some older patients burdened with severe comorbidities, this might be risky. AIMS: To compare the outcomes of patients treated non-surgically to those of the most fragilepatients treated surgically. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A retrospective cohort study, of individuals aged ≥65 years who presented with fragility hip fractures between 01.01.2011-30.06.2016, to a primary trauma center. Patients treated surgically were stratified according to their age-adjusted Charlsons' comorbidity index (ACCI) score. Patients in the upper third of ACCI score, representing the more fragile population, were compared to patients treated non-surgically. RESULTS: 847 patients presented with fragility fractures. 94 (11%) were treated non-surgically and 753 (89%) underwent surgery. Medical reasons were the leading cause for non-surgical treatment (61.7%). Surgically-treated patients were stratified according to their ACCI and 114 patients with ACCI > 9 were chosen for comparison. While both groups were comparable in terms of age, the non-surgical treatment group had more female patients (p. = 0.026) and a smaller proportion of independent walkers (p < 0.001). The ACCI was higher for the surgical treatment group (p < 0.001). In-hospital mortality was similar (14.9% and 18.1% for the operative and non-surgical groups respectively, P. = 0.575). However, one-year mortality was significantly higher for the non-surgical group (48.2% vs. 67.0%, P. = 0.005). The rates of in-hospital complications and 1-year readmissions were similar. CONCLUSIONS: Operative treatment for fragility hip fracture reduces long-term mortality rates even in the more fragilepatients, compared to non-surgical treatment.