| Literature DB >> 31077256 |
Lindsay Richards1, Berhanu Erko2, Keerati Ponpetch3,4, Sadie J Ryan5,4, Song Liang6,7.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Reports of natural infections of Schistosoma mansoni in a number of species of nonhuman primates (NHPs) in Africa, coupled with the substantial overlap of NHP habitats and human schistosomiasis endemic areas, has led to concerns about the role of NHPs in the transmission of human schistosomiasis. We conducted a systematic review of the literature to describe the current scope of knowledge for Africa, for the NHP species implicated, their geographical distribution, infection rates with S. mansoni, and to discuss the implications for public health and conservation. MAIN TEXT: A systematic search of the literature was performed using PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar, the World Health Organization (WHO) library database, World Cat, and ScienceDirect without any language restriction. Studies examining S. mansoni infection of any African NHP species were included. Study types, primate species, their geographical distribution, and parasite diagnostic techniques reported in the studies were qualitatively summarized. Data for species with sample sizes ≥10 were included in the meta-analysis. We assessed the reported infection rate, and used a random-effects model to estimate the summary infection rates and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). We assessed heterogeneity among studies using the I2 statistics. Twenty-nine publications, from 1960 to 2018, were identified and included in the review. The studies examined a total of 2962 primates belonging to 22 species in 11 genera across ten countries (Cameroon, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Gabon, Kenya, Nigeria, Senegal, Tanzania, Uganda, and Zimbabwe), and S. mansoni infections were found in nine species of five genera in all countries. When we excluded studies with sample sizes < 10, data from 24 studies on 11 species of primates in three genera in ten countries remained in the meta-analysis. The overall pooled estimate of infection rate was 10% (95% CI: 6-16%) with high heterogeneity (I2 = 94.77%) across countries and species/genera. Among the three genera, Pan had the highest infection rate of 15% (95% CI: 0-55%), followed by Papio at 11% (95% CI: 6-18%), and Cercopithecus at 5% (95% CI: 0-14%). The association between NHP and human infections was positive, but not significant, due to low study sample matches and high variation.Entities:
Keywords: Africa; Infection; Nonhuman primate; Schistosoma mansoni; Systematic review; Transmission
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31077256 PMCID: PMC6509776 DOI: 10.1186/s40249-019-0543-7
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Infect Dis Poverty ISSN: 2049-9957 Impact factor: 4.520
Fig. 1Flowchart showing inclusion and exclusion of studies on Schistosoma mansoni infections of nonhuman primates in Africa and search results
Key characteristics of included studies on Schistosoma mansoni infections in nonhuman primates in Africa
| Year | Site | Host species | Study type | Diagnostic technique | % (infected/ examined) | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1960 | Kenya: Athi & Kibwezi Rivers |
| Wild | Necropsy | 23.88 (32/134) | Miller [ |
| 1960 | Kenya:Machakos District and Lake Albert |
| Wild | Necropsy | 54.69 (35/64) | Nelson [ |
| 1961 | Kenya |
| Wild | Necropsy | 28.00 (42/150) | Strong et al. [ |
| 1969 | Tanzania: Lake Manyara National Park |
| Wild | Necropsy | 80.00 (4/5) | Fenwick [ |
| 1970 | Eritrea: Asmara |
| Wild | FECT | 33.33 (6/18) | Cheever [ |
| 1970 | Tanzania: Lake Victoria |
| Wild | FECT | 23.40 (11/47) | Cheever [ |
| 1972 | Tanzania |
| Wild | Necropsy | 16.67 (2/12) | Taylor et al. [ |
| 1974 | Zimbabwe |
| Wild | Necropsy | 1.96 (1/51) | Goldsmid [ |
| 1979 | Ethiopia: Omo National Park |
| Wild | Necropsy | CA: 66.67 (2/3) | Fuller et al. [ |
| 1982 | Kenya: Rift Valley, Lake Naivasha |
| Wild | Kato-Katz | 20.00 (8/40) | Else et al. [ |
| 1989 | Senegal: Mt. Assirik |
| Wild | FECT | 23.01 (9/39) | McGrew et al. [ |
| 1992 | Kenya: Kibwezi, Kivungoni Lake |
| Wild | FECT | 24.43 (32/131) | Muchemi [ |
| 1997 | Tanzania: Gombe National Park |
| Wild | FECT | 18.93 (39/206) | Muller-Graf et al. [ |
| 1998 | Kenya: Nairobi |
| Wild | Kato-Katz | 4.35 (4/92) | Munene et al. [ |
| 1998 | Kenya: Nairobi |
| Wild | FECT | PC: 3.60 (4/111) | Muriuki et al. [ |
| 1999 | Tanzania: Gombe National Park |
| Wild | ZSF | 2.86 (1/35) | Murray et al. [ |
| 2001 | Ethiopia: Bishan Gari; Ethiopia: Burka Dita |
| Wild | Kato-Katz | BG: 26.15 (34/130) | Erko et al. [ |
| 2003 | Kenya: Mpala Wildlife Research Centre |
| Wild | FECT | 2.38 (1/42) | Hahn et al. [ |
| 2004 | Ethiopia: Bishan Gari; Ethiopia: Burka Dita |
| Wild | FECT | BG: 33.33 (8/24) | Legesse et al. [ |
| 2006 | Nigeria: Calabar, Afi Mountain Primate Conservation Area |
| Wild | FECT | 4.35 (1/23) | Weyher et al. [ |
| 2011 | Senegal: Fongoli |
| Wild | SNF & FECT | 23.53 (4/17) | Howells et al. [ |
| 2011 | Nigeria: Calabar, Afi Mountain Primate Conservation Area |
| Semi-captive | MMT & MBT | 35.71 (10/28) | Mbaya & Udendeye [ |
| 2011 | Cameroon: Yaounde |
| Captive | FECT | 33.33 (1/3) | Pourrut et al. [ |
| 2011 | Uganda: Lake Victoria, Ngamba Island |
| Wild | ELISA, CCA, Kato-Katz, qPCR | 89.74 (35/39) | Standley et al. [ |
| 2012 | Tanzania: Gombe National Park |
| Wild/ habituated | FECT | 11.90 (15/126) | Bakuza [ |
| 2013 | Nigeria: Yankari National Park |
| Wild | FECT | 4.30 (2/46) | Mafuyai et al. [ |
| 2016 | Gabon: Loango National Park |
| Wild | MSF, MIF | GG: 62.50 (5/8) | Cervena et al. [ |
| 2017 | Kenya: Tsavo West National Park |
| Semi- captive | FECT | 2.13 (1/47) | Chimoyi [ |
| 2018 | Ethiopia: Oromia Regional State |
| Wild | Kato-Katz | CA: 21.60 (8/37) | Kebede et al. [ |
Necropsy: Autopsy; FECT Formal-Ether Concentration Technique, Kato-Katz Kato-Katz thick smear, ZSF Zinc Sulfate Flotation, SNF Sodium Nitrate Flotation, ELISA Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay, CCA Circulating Cathodic Antigen Test, qPCR Real-time Polymerase Chain Reaction, MSF Modified Sheather’s Flotation, MIF Merthiolate-Iodine-Formalin Fecal Technique, MMT Modified McMaster Technique, MBT Modified Baerman’s TechniqueIf studies did not include a specific site, only the country is provided in this table
Fig. 2Distribution of included studies and reported Schistosoma mansoni infections of nonhuman primates in Africa
Fig. 3Forest plot and pooled estimates of nonhuman primate Schistosoma mansoni infections by country (ES: Effect size)
Fig. 4Forest plot and pooled estimates of nonhuman primate Schistosoma mansoni infections by genus (ES: Effect size)
Fig. 5Association between nonhuman primate and human infections by Schistosoma mansoni
Fig. 6Distribution of endemic areas of Schistosoma mansoni and S. haematobium, and major genera of nonhuman primates found to be naturally infected by S. mansoni in Africa (Data sources: nonhuman primate – https://www.iucnredlist.org; schistosomiasis – http://www.thiswormyworld.org)