Daniel W Spaite1,2, Bentley J Bobrow1,2,3, Samuel M Keim1,2,4, Bruce Barnhart1, Vatsal Chikani3, Joshua B Gaither1,2, Duane Sherrill4, Kurt R Denninghoff1,2, Terry Mullins3, P David Adelson5, Amber D Rice1,2, Chad Viscusi1,2, Chengcheng Hu1,4. 1. Arizona Emergency Medicine Research Center, College of Medicine, The University of Arizona, Phoenix. 2. Department of Emergency Medicine, College of Medicine, The University of Arizona, Tucson. 3. Arizona Department of Health Services, Bureau of EMS, Phoenix, Arizona. 4. Mel and Enid Zuckerman College of Public Health, The University of Arizona, Tucson. 5. Barrow Neurological Institute at Phoenix Children's Hospital, Department of Child Health/Neurosurgery, College of Medicine, The University of Arizona, Phoenix.
Abstract
Importance: Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a massive public health problem. While evidence-based guidelines directing the prehospital treatment of TBI have been promulgated, to our knowledge, no studies have assessed their association with survival. Objective: To evaluate the association of implementing the nationally vetted, evidence-based, prehospital treatment guidelines with outcomes in moderate, severe, and critical TBI. Design, Setting, and Participants: The Excellence in Prehospital Injury Care (EPIC) Study included more than 130 emergency medical services systems/agencies throughout Arizona. This was a statewide, multisystem, intention-to-treat study using a before/after controlled design with patients with moderate to critically severe TBI (US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Barell Matrix-Type 1 and/or Abbreviated Injury Scale Head region severity ≥3) transported to trauma centers between January 1, 2007, and June 30, 2015. Data were analyzed between October 25, 2017, and February 22, 2019. Interventions: Implementation of the prehospital TBI guidelines emphasizing avoidance/treatment of hypoxia, prevention/correction of hyperventilation, and avoidance/treatment of hypotension. Main Outcomes and Measures: Primary: survival to hospital discharge; secondary: survival to hospital admission. Results: Of the included patients, the median age was 45 years, 14 666 (67.1%) were men, 7181 (32.9%) were women; 16 408 (75.1% ) were white, 1400 (6.4%) were Native American, 743 (3.4% ) were Black, 237 (1.1%) were Asian, and 2791 (12.8%) were other race/ethnicity. Of the included patients, 21 852 met inclusion criteria for analysis (preimplementation phase [P1]: 15 228; postimplementation [P3]: 6624). The primary analysis (P3 vs P1) revealed an adjusted odds ratio (aOR) of 1.06 (95% CI, 0.93-1.21; P = .40) for survival to hospital discharge. The aOR was 1.70 (95% CI, 1.38-2.09; P < .001) for survival to hospital admission. Among the severe injury cohorts (but not moderate or critical), guideline implementation was significantly associated with survival to discharge (Regional Severity Score-Head 3-4: aOR, 2.03; 95% CI, 1.52-2.72; P < .001; Injury Severity Score 16-24: aOR, 1.61; 95% CI, 1.07-2.48; P = .02). This was also true for survival to discharge among the severe, intubated subgroups (Regional Severity Score-Head 3-4: aOR, 3.14; 95% CI, 1.65-5.98; P < .001; Injury Severity Score 16-24: aOR, 3.28; 95% CI, 1.19-11.34; P = .02). Conclusions and Relevance: Statewide implementation of the prehospital TBI guidelines was not associated with significant improvement in overall survival to hospital discharge (across the entire, combined moderate to critical injury spectrum). However, adjusted survival doubled among patients with severe TBI and tripled in the severe, intubated cohort. Furthermore, guideline implementation was significantly associated with survival to hospital admission. These findings support the widespread implementation of the prehospital TBI treatment guidelines. Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01339702.
Importance: Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a massive public health problem. While evidence-based guidelines directing the prehospital treatment of TBI have been promulgated, to our knowledge, no studies have assessed their association with survival. Objective: To evaluate the association of implementing the nationally vetted, evidence-based, prehospital treatment guidelines with outcomes in moderate, severe, and critical TBI. Design, Setting, and Participants: The Excellence in Prehospital Injury Care (EPIC) Study included more than 130 emergency medical services systems/agencies throughout Arizona. This was a statewide, multisystem, intention-to-treat study using a before/after controlled design with patients with moderate to critically severe TBI (US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Barell Matrix-Type 1 and/or Abbreviated Injury Scale Head region severity ≥3) transported to trauma centers between January 1, 2007, and June 30, 2015. Data were analyzed between October 25, 2017, and February 22, 2019. Interventions: Implementation of the prehospital TBI guidelines emphasizing avoidance/treatment of hypoxia, prevention/correction of hyperventilation, and avoidance/treatment of hypotension. Main Outcomes and Measures: Primary: survival to hospital discharge; secondary: survival to hospital admission. Results: Of the included patients, the median age was 45 years, 14 666 (67.1%) were men, 7181 (32.9%) were women; 16 408 (75.1% ) were white, 1400 (6.4%) were Native American, 743 (3.4% ) were Black, 237 (1.1%) were Asian, and 2791 (12.8%) were other race/ethnicity. Of the included patients, 21 852 met inclusion criteria for analysis (preimplementation phase [P1]: 15 228; postimplementation [P3]: 6624). The primary analysis (P3 vs P1) revealed an adjusted odds ratio (aOR) of 1.06 (95% CI, 0.93-1.21; P = .40) for survival to hospital discharge. The aOR was 1.70 (95% CI, 1.38-2.09; P < .001) for survival to hospital admission. Among the severe injury cohorts (but not moderate or critical), guideline implementation was significantly associated with survival to discharge (Regional Severity Score-Head 3-4: aOR, 2.03; 95% CI, 1.52-2.72; P < .001; Injury Severity Score 16-24: aOR, 1.61; 95% CI, 1.07-2.48; P = .02). This was also true for survival to discharge among the severe, intubated subgroups (Regional Severity Score-Head 3-4: aOR, 3.14; 95% CI, 1.65-5.98; P < .001; Injury Severity Score 16-24: aOR, 3.28; 95% CI, 1.19-11.34; P = .02). Conclusions and Relevance: Statewide implementation of the prehospital TBI guidelines was not associated with significant improvement in overall survival to hospital discharge (across the entire, combined moderate to critical injury spectrum). However, adjusted survival doubled among patients with severe TBI and tripled in the severe, intubated cohort. Furthermore, guideline implementation was significantly associated with survival to hospital admission. These findings support the widespread implementation of the prehospital TBI treatment guidelines. Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01339702.
Authors: Raj K Narayan; Mary Ellen Michel; Beth Ansell; Alex Baethmann; Anat Biegon; Michael B Bracken; M Ross Bullock; Sung C Choi; Guy L Clifton; Charles F Contant; William M Coplin; W Dalton Dietrich; Jamshid Ghajar; Sean M Grady; Robert G Grossman; Edward D Hall; William Heetderks; David A Hovda; Jack Jallo; Russell L Katz; Nachshon Knoller; Patrick M Kochanek; Andrew I Maas; Jeannine Majde; Donald W Marion; Anthony Marmarou; Lawrence F Marshall; Tracy K McIntosh; Emmy Miller; Noel Mohberg; J Paul Muizelaar; Lawrence H Pitts; Peter Quinn; Gad Riesenfeld; Claudia S Robertson; Kenneth I Strauss; Graham Teasdale; Nancy Temkin; Ronald Tuma; Charles Wade; Michael D Walker; Michael Weinrich; John Whyte; Jack Wilberger; A Byron Young; Lorraine Yurkewicz Journal: J Neurotrauma Date: 2002-05 Impact factor: 5.269
Authors: Daniel P Davis; Robyn Heister; Jennifer C Poste; David B Hoyt; Mel Ochs; James V Dunford Journal: Neurocrit Care Date: 2005 Impact factor: 3.210
Authors: Ellen J MacKenzie; Sharada Weir; Frederick P Rivara; Gregory J Jurkovich; Avery B Nathens; Weiwei Wang; Daniel O Scharfstein; David S Salkever Journal: J Trauma Date: 2010-07
Authors: Joshua B Gaither; Daniel W Spaite; Bentley J Bobrow; Samuel M Keim; Bruce J Barnhart; Vatsal Chikani; Duane Sherrill; Kurt R Denninghoff; Terry Mullins; P David Adelson; Amber D Rice; Chad Viscusi; Chengcheng Hu Journal: Ann Emerg Med Date: 2020-11-11 Impact factor: 5.721
Authors: Mary Beth Howard; Nichole McCollum; Emily C Alberto; Hannah Kotler; Mary E Mottla; Laura Tiusaba; Susan Keller; Ivan Marsic; Aleksandra Sarcevic; Randall S Burd; Karen J O'Connell Journal: Prehosp Disaster Med Date: 2021-05-31 Impact factor: 2.866
Authors: Danielle S Gruen; Francis X Guyette; Joshua B Brown; David O Okonkwo; Ava M Puccio; Insiyah K Campwala; Matthew T Tessmer; Brian J Daley; Richard S Miller; Brian G Harbrecht; Jeffrey A Claridge; Herb A Phelan; Matthew D Neal; Brian S Zuckerbraun; Mark H Yazer; Timothy R Billiar; Jason L Sperry Journal: JAMA Netw Open Date: 2020-10-01
Authors: Felipe Teran; Sarah M Perman; Oscar J L Mitchell; Kelly N Sawyer; Audrey L Blewer; Jon C Rittenberger; Marina Del Rios Rivera; James M Horowitz; Joseph E Tonna; Cindy H Hsu; Pavitra Kotini-Shah; Shaun K McGovern; Benjamin S Abella Journal: J Am Heart Assoc Date: 2020-05-12 Impact factor: 5.501