Luis Valencia1, Emma M Nomena2,3, Aji P Mathew1, Krassimir P Velikov2,3,4. 1. Division of Materials and Environmental Chemistry , Stockholm University , Frescativägen 8 , 10691 Stockholm , Sweden. 2. Unilever R&D Vlaardingen , Olivier van Nortlaan 120 , 3133 AT Vlaardingen , The Netherlands. 3. Institute of Physics , University of Amsterdam , Science Park 904 , 1098 XH Amsterdam , The Netherlands. 4. Soft Condensed Matter, Debye Institute for Nanomaterials Science , Utrecht University , Princetonplein 5 , 3584 CC Utrecht , The Netherlands.
Abstract
Low-concentration oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by cellulose nanofibrils (CNFs) extracted from primary plant cell wall materials are used to prepare thin biobased CNF-oil composite films by solvent casting. Flexible, transparent, and biodegradable composite films are obtained, with increased thermal stability (up to 300 °C) as the oil concentration increases. Examination of the microstructure demonstrates a clear dependency on the oil content, as a multilayered structure where the oil phase trapped between two layers of CNFs is appreciated at high oil concentrations. The embedded oil significantly influences the mechanical and wetting properties of the films, confirming their potential for use in packaging systems. Encapsulation of curcumin in the composite films leads to an increased antioxidant (up to 30% radical scavenging activity) and antimicrobial activity, inhibiting the growth of foodborne bacteria such as Escherichia coli. The resulting composite films show promising results in the field of active packaging for applications in the food, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic industries.
Low-concentration oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by cellulose nanofibrils (CNFs) extracted from primary plant cell wall materials are used to prepare thin biobased CNF-oil composite films by solvent casting. Flexible, transparent, and biodegradable composite films are obtained, with increased thermal stability (up to 300 °C) as the oil concentration increases. Examination of the microstructure demonstrates a clear dependency on the oil content, as a multilayered structure where the oil phase trapped between two layers of CNFs is appreciated at high oil concentrations. The embedded oil significantly influences the mechanical and wetting properties of the films, confirming their potential for use in packaging systems. Encapsulation of curcumin in the composite films leads to an increased antioxidant (up to 30% radical scavenging activity) and antimicrobial activity, inhibiting the growth of foodborne bacteria such as Escherichia coli. The resulting composite films show promising results in the field of active packaging for applications in the food, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic industries.
Entities:
Keywords:
active packaging; edible barrier; emulsion; nanocellulose; oleofilm
Nowadays, there is an urgent need of replacing
petroleum-based
polymeric materials, which represent a big environmental concern because
of their nonrenewability and poor biodegradability. Current packaging
materials not only consume our limited natural resources but also
lead to all kind of waste, from which around 8 million metric tons
of plastic wound up in the ocean every year,[1] threatening not only the surrounding environment but also human
health.[2] In this sense, the development
of renewable materials that follow the principles of sustainability
has become a necessity.During the last decades, extensive research
effort has been destined
to utilize bio-based materials from renewable resources.[3] Among them, nanocellulose (i.e., nanowhiskers,
nanofibrils) extracted from different biomass sources has emerged
as a key sustainable alternative because of its outstanding mechanical
properties, biodegradability, low cost, and renewable nature.[4−6] Several approaches for nanocellulose-based packaging materials have
been developed during the last years, nevertheless, preserving food
stability and quality, without the need of further chemical modifications
or additives that increment the environmental impact, remains still
a challenge.[4]Recently, some innovative
works have turned their attention into
Pickering emulsions as templates or intermediaries for structured
materials, where biopolymers can be used as emulsifiers because of
their multi-anchoring amphiphilic nature.[7,8] This
has recently led to the development of low-density biopolymer-based
porous materials, oleofilms, and 3D-printed scaffolds,[7,9−12] which represent an attractive alternative from an environmental
point of view as they do not require additional surface-active agents.
However, the preparation of cellulose nanofibrils (CNFs)-based oleofilms
with potential application in food-active packaging that utilize the
unique properties of CNFs has never been demonstrated.Herein,
we report for the very first time, a simple and straightforward
method to obtain thin-layered translucent composite films by casting
CNF-stabilized Pickering emulsions. The resulting films are fully
edible and biodegradable. Microscopic characterization techniques
were used to elucidate the microstructure of the films at different
oil concentrations. The properties of the films for packaging solutions
were assessed in terms of mechanical stiffness, thermal properties,
moisture uptake, transparency, and wettability. Moreover, we demonstrate
that the oil phase that is stabilized in the dried films allows the
encapsulation of lipophilic bioactive compounds, such as curcumin,
opening a wide window of opportunities to tailor specific properties
such as antimicrobial and antioxidant activity for active barriers.
Experimental Part
Materials
Soybeanoil was obtained from Sigma-Aldrich
(Sigma-Aldrich—S7381) and used as received (density = 0.9191
g/mL). Herbacel AQ + type N from Herbafood Ingredients GmbH Germany
(84–90 wt % dietary fiber, 4–9 wt % water, 2–5
wt % ash) was used as the cellulose raw material originated from citrus
peels (lot number: 30902065) and used as received. It contains around
60 wt % of cellulose, 3.4 wt % of hemicellulose, and 5 wt % of proteinaceous
materials.[13] Curcumin (>94% curcuminoid
content) and 2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) were purchased from
Sigma-Aldrich and were used as received.
Preparation of Emulsions
The citrus fiber powder was
first suspended in deionized water and thoroughly mixed using a LM5-A
Silverson laboratory mixer (Silverson, USA) with a 1 mm screen hole
at 3500 rpm for 5 min and afterward passed once through a high-pressure
homogenizer (Microfluidizer M 110S (MF), Microfluidics Corp., USA)
with a z-shape geometry (diameter 87 μm) operating at a pressure
of 1200 bar. Then, soybeanoil was added and the mixture was microfluidized
at 1200 bar. All samples were stored in closed containers at 5 °C
after preparation.
Encapsulation of Curcumin in Pickering Emulsions
Prior
to mixing with CNFs, curcumin was added to soybeanoil at the concentration
of 1 mg/g and the mixture was vigorously mixed for approximately 20
min followed by centrifugation at 14 000g for
10 min to precipitate the undissolved curcumin. Concentration of curcumin
in the oil phase was estimated by UV–vis spectroscopy (see Figure S11) as 5.5 × 10–6 wt %.
Preparation of Composite Films
Given amount of emulsion
with the variable oil–CNF weight ratio was poured into plastic
Petri dishes after degassing to remove any presence of bubbles and
dried in a vacuum oven at 35 °C for 24 h.
Characterization
Confocal laser scanning microscopy
(CLSM) was performed to visualize the microstructure of the emulsions
by location of the CNFs and oil droplets. For localization of the
CNF, the fresh emulsions were stained with Direct Yellow (Solophenyl
Flavine 96 at 0.5 wt %) by adding a drop of the dyes to about 1 g
of the emulsion. A drop of the resulting mix was then placed on a
cover slip and micrographs of the emulsions were acquired using a
Leica TCS-SP5 and DMI6000 inverted microscope (Leica GmbH, Germany).
Fluorescence from the samples was excited at 488 nm for Direct Yellow,
and emission was detected at 496–555 nm. A 63× oil-immersion
objective was used to scan the images at approximately 30 μm
below the cover slip. To image the oil droplets, fresh emulsions were
stained by mixing around 1 g of the samples with a drop of 1 wt %
Nile blue–Nile red solution. Excitation wavelengths are 488
and 633 nm and detection was at 520–602 and 661–786
nm.The size distributions of the oil droplets were measured
by dynamic light scattering (Zetasizer Nano ZS, Malvern Instruments
Ltd., Worcestershire, UK), using disposable sizing cuvettes filled
with 1 mL of 0.5 wt % emulsions at 25 °C. Data were collected
after 2 min equilibration time and averaged over 10 measurements.
The refractive indexes used for soybeanoil and water were 1.47 and
1.33, respectively. The particle size was characterized by intensity-averaged
mean and polydispersity index.
X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy
Analyses were collected
with an AXIS Ultra DLD electron spectrometer (Kratos Analytical Ltd.,
U.K.) using a monochromatized Al Kα radiation operating at 150
W and energy of 20 eV for individual photoelectron lines. All the
binding energies were referenced to the C 1s hydrocarbon peak at 284.6
eV. The high-resolution C 1s spectrum was fitted using a Shirley background
subtraction and a series of Gaussian peaks, USA.The uniaxial
mechanical properties of the films were measured through a tensile
test using a Zwick mechanical testing machine (model ZO10) at a crosshead
speed of 5 mm/min with a gauge length of 20 mm. The measurements were
carried at 50% humidity and 25 °C. The reported results were
the average of calculating five specimens per sample.The thermal
behavior of the composite films was assessed by thermogravimetric
analyses using a TA Instruments Discovery thermal analyzer, for measuring
the mass transformation as a function of temperature, in an interval
of 30–600 °C, at a heating rate of 5 °C/min. The
samples were exposed to nitrogen gas at a flow rate of 20 mL/min and
the nitrogen flow in the balance was 10 mL/min.The morphology
of the samples was examined by scanning electron
microscopy (SEM) conducted on a JEOL 7000 with an accelerated voltage
of 2 kV. The specimens were coated with a thin gold layer prior visualization.The transparency of the films was measured using a Lambda 650 S
UV–vis spectrometer, measuring in the range of 250–800
nm in the transmission mode.The surface hydrophobicity of the
films was determined by the sessile
drop method using a goniometer (Drop Shape Analysis System, DSA100,
Krüss GmbH, Germany). A water droplet was carefully dropped
onto the films, and the drop shape was monitored for 90 s using a
digital camera. The contact angle value was obtained by measuring
the angle between the film surface and the tangent line at the point
of contact with the water droplet.
Antioxidant Activity
The antioxidant activity of the
composite films was determined by the DPPH antioxidant assay. The
test consisted in adding 100 mg of the composite film into a 50 μM
DPPH solution in ethanol. The reaction mixtures were kept at 30 °C
in darkness and the absorbance was measured at 517 nm overtime by
using an ultraviolet–visible (UV–vis) spectrophotometer.
The reduction in radical scavenging activity (%-RSA) was calculated
following previous reports,[14] and expressed
as followswhere Ablank( is the absorbance measured for
the DPPH solution,
and Asample( is the
absorbance measured for the DPPH containing the film samples at the
same time t.
Antimicrobial Activity
The antimicrobial activity of
the films containing curcumin was assessed using the strain Escherichia coliK12. For the tests,
exponentially growing cultures of E. coli were diluted to approximately 200 cells/mL. Diluted cultures were
placed on the films inside of polystyrene cell culture wells and incubated
without stirring for 24 h at 37 °C. The films were then carefully
washed with distilled water to remove planktonic and loosely attached
cells. The visualization of the bacterial cells was performed by confocal
microscopy 24 h after inoculation using a Leica TCS-SP5 and DMI6000
inverted microscope (Leica GmbH, Germany). Viable and nonviable bacteria
were tracked using the Live/Dead BacLight Bacterial Viability Kit
(Sigma-Aldrich). For staining, the surface of each specimen was covered
with 100 μL of stain (a 2:1 mixture of calcein-AM and propidium
iodide in buffer solution), then incubated at 37 °C for 15 min
before imaging. Calcein-AM stains viable cells only (excitation: 488
nm, emission: 500–530 nm), while propidium iodide stains dead
cells (excitation: 488 nm, emission 600–630 nm). Composite
films without curcumin were used as references.
Results
and Discussion
A conceptual schematic illustration of the
preparation of CNF–oil
composite films is shown in Figure a. First, the suspension of CNFs (0.5 wt %), prepared
by mechanical defibrillation of citrus fiber, was mixed with soybeanoil, followed by microfluidization which resulted in a stable emulsion
(Figure b) with oil
droplet sizes ranging from 60 to 700 nm (assessed by dynamic light
scattering). The droplet size of these emulsions can be tuned and
depends linearly on the volume fraction of oil in the emulsion (see Figures S1 and S2). Depletion effects of the
nonadsorbed CNFs explain the stability of the emulsions against creaming.[15]
Figure 1
(a) Schematic illustration of the preparation of the CNF–oil
composite films; (b) CLSM micrograph of the prepared emulsion showing
the oil droplets; (c) SEM micrograph displaying the (c) surface topography;
and (d) cross-sectional image of the CNF–oil composite films.
(a) Schematic illustration of the preparation of the CNF–oil
composite films; (b) CLSM micrograph of the prepared emulsion showing
the oil droplets; (c) SEM micrograph displaying the (c) surface topography;
and (d) cross-sectional image of the CNF–oil composite films.
Microstructure of the Composite Films
The preparation
of the composite films was carried out by the conventional casting
method, leaving the emulsion to evaporate at room temperature in a
Petri dish, which resulted in a transparent flexible thin film with
minimal oil separation. The process is schematically illustrated in Figure .To further
understand the distribution of the oil and CNF phase, the surface
topography of the films was analyzed by SEM and the results are shown
in Figure e–h,
as well as the cross-sectional microscopy images of the films (see Figure a–d). From
the images, one can observe that the drying led to a complete coalescence
of the all the oil droplets, leading to a uniform oil layer that homogeneously
permeate the CNF network. Moreover, at low oil concentrations, a uniform
CNF–oil composite film was observed with no oil pockets. When
the concentration of oil increased, the oil was mainly observed between
layers of nanofibers, forming an apparent multilayered “sandwich-like”
structure, where a rigid layer of CNFs covered the surface (Figure a–d). This
layered structure is most prevalent at the highest oil concentrations,
where successive layers of oil and CNFs can be observed. The different
structure formation of the composite films depending on the oil content
is schematically represented in Figure .
Figure 2
SEM images of the CNF–oil composite films with
variable
oil-content: (a–d) cross-sectional view and (e–h) top
view. The amount of CNF was the same for all the samples (0.5 wt %
in the aqueous phase of the emulsions). The arrows point to the layers
of CNFs between which the oil layer is present.
Figure 3
Schematic diagram of the formation of the CNF–oil composite
films with low or high oil content.
SEM images of the CNF–oil composite films with
variable
oil-content: (a–d) cross-sectional view and (e–h) top
view. The amount of CNF was the same for all the samples (0.5 wt %
in the aqueous phase of the emulsions). The arrows point to the layers
of CNFs between which the oil layer is present.Schematic diagram of the formation of the CNF–oil composite
films with low or high oil content.The different microstructure formation of the composite films
was
corroborated by confocal microscopy using Direct Yellow as the staining
agent to visualize the CNF, and Nile red to image the oil phase, and
a mixture of them to visualize the overlay of both phases. The results,
shown in Figure ,
demonstrate that at low oil content, the oil is apparently interpenetrated
in the CNF network, forming a composite film that is relatively homogenous
throughout the sample: no voids or holes were observed. SEM micrographs
also confirmed the homogeneity and smoothness of the film surface
without apparent pores or cracks (Figure a–d), indicating that the CNFs were
uniformly dispersed on the surface of the films.
Figure 4
CLSM micrographs of the
composite films showing CNFs in red, the
oil phase in green, and an overlay, showing the homogenous distribution
of both phases in the film.
CLSM micrographs of the
composite films showing CNFs in red, the
oil phase in green, and an overlay, showing the homogenous distribution
of both phases in the film.
Physical Properties of Composite Films
The macroscopic
properties of the films were analyzed in order to understand the influence
of oil content over the potential performance of the composite films.
The transparency of the films was assessed by UV–vis spectroscopy
(Figure a), and the
results show that the transparency gradually decreased upon incorporation
of the oil. In order to understand this phenomenon, we calculated
the mass attenuation coefficient, derived from the Beer–Lambert
law aswhere I and I0 are the original and transmitted intensities, respectively
(I/I0 is the transmission),
μ is the mass attenuation coefficient of the sample (cm2/g) while x is the mass thickness, obtained
by multiplying the sample thickness with the density of the composite
material, calculated by adding up the densities of the individuals
weighted by respective volume fractions.
Figure 5
Physical properties of
the CNF–oil composite films: (a)
photograph showing the transparency of the films (87 wt % oil); (b)
optical transmission of films at the visible-wavelength range and
mass attenuation coefficient of composite films at λ = 700 nm;
(c) optical transmission of films in the UV-spectral range; (d) experimental
and fitted dynamic contact angle of composite films: the solid lines
were obtained by fitting eq to the experimental data (spheres); (f–e) uniaxial
tensile properties of films with different oil contents; and (g–i)
thermal properties of films.
Physical properties of
the CNF–oil composite films: (a)
photograph showing the transparency of the films (87 wt % oil); (b)
optical transmission of films at the visible-wavelength range and
mass attenuation coefficient of composite films at λ = 700 nm;
(c) optical transmission of films in the UV-spectral range; (d) experimental
and fitted dynamic contact angle of composite films: the solid lines
were obtained by fitting eq to the experimental data (spheres); (f–e) uniaxial
tensile properties of films with different oil contents; and (g–i)
thermal properties of films.Figure b
displays
the mass attenuation coefficient of the composite films as a function
of oil content. As it can be observed, a sharp nonlinear increase
in the attenuation coefficient takes place upon incorporation of 16
wt % of oil into the composite films, explained by the change in composition
of the films, where oil has a higher refractive index than air and
water, which might be present in the hygroscopic pure CNF film. Upon
further increase in oil content, the attenuation coefficient increased
linearly, suggesting the dependence only in the film mass thickness
and thus filler (i.e., oil) concentration in the composite films.The composite films also exhibited an increased absorptivity at
wavelengths below 300 nm (see Figure c): the transmittance reaches almost zero at the highest
oil concentrations, which could be attributed to the UVB and UVC-blocking
potential of soybeanoil.[16] This property
could have great implications in food-packaging applications, as UV
light is known to induce auto-oxidation of fats, as well as causing
discoloration of fresh meat, degradation of vitamins, and development
of off-flavors.[17]The surface hydrophobicity
was assessed from the wettability measurement
of the composite film samples, and the contact angle values as a function
of time are reported in Figures d and S5. The films displayed
a higher contact angle than the neat CNF film, proving the presence
of the oil over the surface of the film, and the improved water resistance
of the films, which is an essential parameter for materials destined
to packaging applications. In addition, we investigated the influence
of oil content over the contact-angle evolution as a function of time
by means of a semiquantitative exponential decay expressed as[18,19]where θi is the initial air–water-film
contact angle, right after deposition on the film surface, while k and n are the kinetic constant and the
exponential parameter, respectively. The parameters for the kinetic
constant and the exponential parameter determined for the composite
films with different oil contents are shown in Table .
Table 1
Kinetic Constant
(k) and the Exponential Parameter (n) of the Contact
Angle as a Function of Time for the CNF/Oil Composite Films with Different
Oil Contents
Oil content (wt %)
θi (deg)
k (s–1)
n
R2
0
64.50 ± 1.04
0.18 ± 0.017
0.36 ± 0.02
0.995
16
90.04 ± 0.37
0.006 ± 0.003
0.71 ± 0.07
0.995
50
79.20 ± 1.03
0.03 ± 0.009
0.47 ± 0.07
0.982
66
75.08 ± 1.28
0.02 ± 0.013
0.54 ± 0.14
0.969
87
79.88 ± 0.87
0.03 ± 0.011
0.38 ± 0.07
0.979
As shown
in Table , the incorporation
of oil induced a significant increase in the
initial water contact angle (θi) of the films. The
hydrophobicity increased from 64°, corresponding to the neat
CNF film, to 90° for the sample containing 16 wt % oil. This
increase in surface hydrophobicity could be attributed to the loss
of free functional hydroxyl groups because of the presence of oil
on the surface.[20] Moreover, the kinetic
constant of the contact-angle evolution (k values
in Table ) was significantly
lower for the composite film containing 16 wt % oil (k = 6 × 10–3 s–1), compared
to pure CNF (k = 18 × 10–2 s–1), indicating a much slower adsorption/spreading
process of the water droplet on the surface of the composite films.On the other hand, a striking difference in surface hydrophobicity
and the kinetic constant was observed between low and high oil concentrations
(see Table ): the
films with a lower oil content are more hydrophobic than the ones
with higher oil content. We assume this is due to the difference in
the film microstructure (Figure ). At low concentrations, the CNF and oil phases seem
interwoven together making a composite film on the surface of which
both oil and cellulose is present, while at high concentrations of
oil, the layered structure is formed: successive layers of oil and
CNFs. In this case, the wetting properties of the film are dominated
by CNF. The exponential parameter n was also derived
from the fitting approach (see eq and Table ), which, as it has been previously suggested,[18] indicates whether the contact-angle evolution
arises from absorption or spreading of the water droplet on the surface
of the films, assuming values between 0 (pure adsorption) and 1 (pure
spreading).[19]The mechanical properties
of the films, measured from uniaxial
tensile testing (Figure e), clearly exhibited a linear dependence on the oil content: as
the oil content increased, the material became more ductile, implying
that the oil acted as a plasticizer, and as the oil content increased,
the film could adsorb higher amount of energy before rupture. This
is an important property for an adequate design of packaging-destined
films, which must have a certain degree of resistance and flexibility.
While the tensile strength decreased with increasing oil concentration,
the elongation at break increased dramatically especially at higher
oil concentrations (see Figure f), leading to a very flexible film. This could be attributed
to the presence of oil inclusions in the films, weakening the film
cohesion and resistance. Higher oil concentrations limit the aggregation
of CNFs, as observed in Figure a–d by the layered structure; this facilitates polymer
chain displacement and allows the films to bend and stretch further
without breaking.[21,22] On the other hand, the toughness
of the films, defined as the amount of energy that a material can
absorb prior rupture (see Figure S9), displays
a detrimental trend as a function of oil content, decreasing linearly
from 3.1 MJ/m3 for the pure CNF film, to 1.5 MJ/m3 for the composite film with 87 wt % oil content.The thermal
degradation behavior of the composite films was assessed
by thermogravimetric analysis, and results are shown in Figure h. The presence of oil clearly
enhanced the thermal stability of the films, as it increased gradually
as a function of oil content, which is simply explained by the higher
thermal stability of oil compared to cellulose, which positively influences
the thermal behavior of the composite films. Moreover, from the thermogravimetric
analysis, we can also estimate the moisture uptake of the composite
films, which is an essential parameter in food-active packaging applications,
as adsorbed water promoted bacterial growth. For the calculation,
the attention was centered in the percentage of weight loss at 100
°C (see Figure i), before any structural degradation of cellulose happens, and therefore
assuming only mass loss because of water evaporation. The moisture
uptake decreased significantly by increasing the amount of oil in
the films: for the neat CNF film, a weight of 12% was observed at
100 °C, compared to 2% for the composite film containing 87 wt
% oil.The redispersibility and degradability of the composite
films was
tested by resubmerging them in water (see Figure ), and interestingly, after only 2 min of
submitting the films in a sonication bath, they were completely redispersed
into a stable emulsion (see Figure S9).
Such behavior could be attributed to the presence of oil acting as
the plasticizer, getting in between the nanofibers and therefore allowing
ease of redispersion. This redispersibility furthermore corroborates
the edibility of the films, as they should disintegrate into oil droplets
and CNFs once ingested (the triglycerideoil will be digested under
action of lipases, and even in the presence of nanocellulose can delay
the rate of hydrolysis,[23,24] while the cellulose
part will remain intact and stay dispersed as insoluble dietary fiber[25]), besides also proving their high degree of
environmental friendliness, as the rapid degradation could allow the
easy recovery of the building blocks without any waste generation,
for their reusability in further applications.
Figure 6
Schematic illustration
demonstrating the biodegradability of the
composite films in water in which the emulsion structure is reformed
upon 2 min of sonication.
Schematic illustration
demonstrating the biodegradability of the
composite films in water in which the emulsion structure is reformed
upon 2 min of sonication.
Curcumin Encapsulation in the Composite Films
Encapsulation
of bioactive compounds using emulsions is a common formulation approach
used in food, cosmetic, and pharmaceutical industries for incorporating
high-concentrations of a substance, which can introduce specific properties
or to be released over a certain time span. By using Pickering emulsions
containing oil-soluble functional ingredients, we can further tune
the properties of the composite films. In this work, we selected curcumin
(diferuoyl methane), which is a major component of Curcuma longa, also known as turmeric, as a model
system to be incorporated in the films. Curcumin is a phenolic nutraceutical
compound which has been reported to possess therapeutic properties
and to be an efficient antioxidant and reactive radical scavenger,
owing to H-atom donation from the phenolic groups.[26] Curcumin have also shown to possess in vitro antimicrobial
potential against a wide range of microorganisms including fungi,[27] as well as several Gram-positive and Gram-negative
bacteria.[28] There are several proposed
mechanisms for the antimicrobial activity of curcumin, being presumably
the insertion into liposome bilayers (because of its lipophilicity
and amphipathicity), enhancing the permeability of the cell membrane
and eventually the rupture of intracellular components,[29,30] the most accepted one. The encapsulation of curcumin in the composite
films was carried out by dissolving curcumin in the soybeanoil prior
to the preparation of the emulsions, followed by casting to obtain
curcumin-containing films. The homogenous distribution of curcumin
throughout the films could be visualized from the complete yellow
tonality that the films acquired upon encapsulation (see Figure S14).Antioxidant activity of curcumin-containing
composite films. The susceptibility of food to oxidation is a major
concern for the food industry, as the lipid oxidation has negative
effects such as taste, appearance, texture, and shelf life, leading
to the formation of off-flavors (rancidity) and toxic compounds. For
this reason, introducing antioxidant properties is of paramount importance
when developing active food packaging.The antioxidant properties
of the curcumin-containing composite
films was assessed using the method based on the scavenging of the
DPPH radical molecule, and results are shown in Figure a–c, where the antioxidant activity
was calculated by following the decrease in the absorbance band at
517 nm (see Figure c,d), which is the maximum absorbance band of DPPH ethanolic solution.
The results in %-RSA as a function of time are shown in Figure d. All RSA kinetics exhibited
a gradual decrease at first, followed by a slowing down of the %-RSA,
to finally reach a plateau after 48 h. Moreover, clearly the %-RSA
increased as a function of oil (which contains curcumin). The neat
CNF film did not show any significant antioxidant activity, as expected.
Figure 7
%-RSA
of curcumin-loaded films evaluated by the DPPH method. (a–c)
UV–vis spectra (baseline corrected) of DPPH + films: (a) reference,
(b) film with 50 wt % oil content, and (c) film with 86 wt % oil content.
(d) Reduction in scavenging activity as a function of oil content
in films loaded with curcumin.
%-RSA
of curcumin-loaded films evaluated by the DPPH method. (a–c)
UV–vis spectra (baseline corrected) of DPPH + films: (a) reference,
(b) film with 50 wt % oil content, and (c) film with 86 wt % oil content.
(d) Reduction in scavenging activity as a function of oil content
in films loaded with curcumin.
Antimicrobial Activity of Curcumin-Containing Composite Films
Curcumin is known for its antibacterial and antifungal properties,[31] which makes it an ideal candidate for pathogen
growth inhibition in active packaging. Its poor solubility in water
is an obstacle to its use in packaging systems as an antimicrobial
agent, hence the need of encapsulation to increase its delivery. The
antimicrobial properties of curcumin depend on several factors such
as the delivery mechanism, blue-light exposure, or type of bacteria.[32,33]While curcumin is less effective against Gram-negative bacteria
such as E. coli, it can nonetheless
inhibit the growth of other bacteria strains depending on the mode
of delivery.[34] The effect of curcumin on
the antimicrobial properties of the films was assessed against E. coli, a common foodborne pathogen, and the results
indicate that while live bacteria can still be found, bacteria growth
and viability was largely inhibited compared to the samples without
curcumin (Figure ).
Surprisingly, almost total bacterial impairment was observed after
24 h of incubation using low oil concentration (16 wt %), while more
live bacteria subsided as the oil concentration increased. This is
consistent with the increased hydrophobicity of the surface of the
films, as at low oil concentrations, the microstructure of the film
contains more oil at the surface (see Figure ), hence more curcumin and a stronger bactericidal
effect. At high concentrations, the oil is located mainly between
the layers of CNF, so their surface is more vulnerable to bacteria.
Nevertheless, bacteria viability decreased at all oil concentrations
compared to the samples without oil, indicating a possible use of
the films for food-packaging applications.
Figure 8
CSLM overlay images of
showing the viability of E. coli 24
h after inoculation. Live cells are in
green and dead ones in red. Composite film without curcumin (a) was
used as the reference sample. Composite films with curcumin (5.5 ×
10–6 wt % in the oil) with different oil concentrations:
16 (b), 25 (c), 50 (d), 66 (e), and 83 and 87 wt % (f). Scale bar:
250 μm.
CSLM overlay images of
showing the viability of E. coli 24
h after inoculation. Live cells are in
green and dead ones in red. Composite film without curcumin (a) was
used as the reference sample. Composite films with curcumin (5.5 ×
10–6 wt % in the oil) with different oil concentrations:
16 (b), 25 (c), 50 (d), 66 (e), and 83 and 87 wt % (f). Scale bar:
250 μm.
Conclusions
We
have demonstrated the fabrication of bio-based composite films
by solvent-casting an oil-in-water emulsion stabilized by CNFs derived
from plant cell wall materials. The microstructure of such films is
dependent on the oil concentration: an interpenetrated network of
CNF and oil is obtained at low fibril concentrations, while a layered
structure of successive CNF and oil is obtained at high fibril concentrations.
The optical, mechanical, and thermal properties of the films are also
controlled by the oil concentration: higher oil concentrations have
increased ductility and thermal stability, albeit they are less translucent.
Moreover, we have shown that it is possible to encapsulate bioactive
compounds in the oil phase for added functionality. Encapsulation
of curcumin gives the films a higher antioxidant activity and antimicrobial
properties. These features open the way to new active materials with
tailored properties for use as packaging materials, drug delivery,
or strategies where oxidative degradation and microbial growth need
to be inhibited.
Authors: Suthawan Muangmeesri; Ning Li; Dimitrios Georgouvelas; Pierre Ouagne; Vincent Placet; Aji P Mathew; Joseph S M Samec Journal: ACS Sustain Chem Eng Date: 2021-12-15 Impact factor: 8.198
Authors: Viviane Lutz-Bueno; Ana Diaz; Tingting Wu; Gustav Nyström; Thomas Geiger; Carlo Antonini Journal: Biomacromolecules Date: 2022-02-23 Impact factor: 6.988
Authors: Joy Onwumere; Jȩdrzej Pia Tek; Tetyana Budnyak; Jianhong Chen; Serhiy Budnyk; Zoheb Karim; Thomas Thersleff; Piotr Kuśtrowski; Aji P Mathew; Adam Slabon Journal: ACS Appl Mater Interfaces Date: 2020-09-08 Impact factor: 9.229