| Literature DB >> 30899566 |
Corrina Moucheraud1, Cosima Lenz1, Michaella Latkovic2, Veronika J Wirtz2.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: The rising burden of diabetes in low- and middle-income countries may cause financial strain on individuals and health systems. This paper presents a systematic review of direct medical costs for diabetes (types 1 and 2) in low- and middle-income countries.Entities:
Keywords: diabetes; health economics
Year: 2019 PMID: 30899566 PMCID: PMC6407562 DOI: 10.1136/bmjgh-2018-001258
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Glob Health ISSN: 2059-7908
Figure 1Flow of abstract and article selection. Note: Articles could be excluded from review for more than one reason.
Figure 2Year of publication for included publications. There were also two articles from 2017 (published subsequent to the search) which were added following author instructions but did not result from the search and so are not presented here.
Figure 3Geographic source of data for included publications. ECA, Europe/Central Asia region; LAC, Latin America/Caribbean region; MENA, Middle East/North Africa region; SSA, sub-Saharan Africa region.
Cost components from studies based on data reported by patients
| Country/study | Diabetes type | Outpatient (per visit) | Cost components, average per person (2016 US$) | ||||
| Outpatient visits | Laboratory (per year) | Medicines (per year) | Inpatient (per year) | ||||
| LICs (n=2) | Nepal | 1 and 2 | 4.39 | * | 31.70 | 77.70 | * |
| Mali | Unclear | * | * | * | 55.97 | 281.05 | |
| LMICs (n=6) | Kyrgyzstan | 1 and 2 | * | * | * | 141.65 | 53.43 |
| India | Unclear | 7.41 | 14.82 | 24.31 | * | 242.91 | |
| India | 2 | 6.65 | * | 23.08 | 15.20 | 20.57 | |
| India | Unclear | * | 14.93 | 16.65 | 74.78 | 18.09 | |
| India | 1 | * | * | 17.00 | 223.00 | * | |
| Solomon Islands | 2 | 2.67 | * | * | 75.76 | 218.73 | |
| UMICs (n=5) | Iran | 2 | * | 56.94 | 85.02 | 224.42 | 550.86 |
| China | 2 | * | * | * | * | 549.13 | |
| China | Unclear | * | * | * | 257.93 | 414.37 | |
| China | 2 | * | * | * | 245.78 | 655.45 | |
| Romania | Unclear | * | 5.44 | * | 459.18 | 8.10 | |
*Authors did not provide data on this cost component.
LIC, low-income country; LMIC, lower middle-income country.
Cost components from studies based on data from provider/system perspective
| Country/study | Diabetes type | Outpatient (per visit) | Cost components, average per person (2016 US$) | ||||
| Outpatient visits | Laboratory (per year) | Medicines (per year) | Inpatient (per year) | ||||
| LMICs (n=1) | Bangladesh | 2 | * | 24.00 | 27.00 | 194.00 | |
| UMICs (n=10) | Iran | 2 | * | * | 4.72 | * | * |
| Thailand | 1 and 2 | 3.99 | 18.09 | 14.74 | 26.41 | 24.95 | |
| China | 1 and 2 | * | * | * | * | 990.79 | |
| China | * | * | * | * | 1790.22 | ||
| Mexico | 2 | 10.75 | 84.81 | * | 73.07 | * | |
| Mexico | 2 | 42.32 | 173.29 | 24.13 | * | * | |
| Brazil | 2 | 4.75 | 8.66 | 16.16 | 91.30 | * | |
| Brazil | 1 | * | * | 56.93 | 415.47 | 29.44 | |
| Turkey | 2 | * | * | * | 668.41 | * | |
| Argentina | 1 and 2 | 21.74 | 152.43 | 40.06 | 679.60 | ||
*Authors did not provide data on this cost component.
LMIC, lower middle-income country; UMIC, upper middle-income country.
Cost components from studies based on data from both patient and provider/system perspectives (mixed)
| Country/study | Diabetes type | Outpatient (per visit) | Cost components, average per person (2016 US$) | ||||
| Outpatient visits | Laboratory (per year) | Medicines (per year) | Inpatient (per year) | ||||
| LMICs (n=2) | India | 2 | * | 84.40 | 61.57 | 159.86 | 300.54 |
| Nigeria | 1 and 2 | 5.97 | 26.88 | 132.87 | 522.85 | * | |
| UMICs (n=5) | Thailand | 1 and 2 | 3.99 | 28.26 | 20.20 | 42.85 | 109.42 |
| China | 2 | 46.43 | * | * | * | 627.09 | |
| Brazil | 2 | * | * | * | 864.86 | * | |
| Brazil | 2 | 20.73 | 46.23 | 78.15 | 464.48 | * | |
| Argentina | 2 | * | 63.10 | 194.96 | 703.58 | 1081.02 | |
*Authors did not provide data on this cost component.
LMIC, lower middle-income country; UMIC, upper middle-income country.
Figure 4Per-patient annual costs of diabetes care components (among articles reporting on these components). Note: Articles are organised first within data collection-type groups; and within each of these, in ascending order of per-capita gross domestic product.
Figure 5Per-visit outpatient visit costs of diabetes (among articles reporting on this). Note: Articles are organised first within data collection-type groups; and within each of these, in ascending order of per-capita gross domestic product. Outpatient visit costs include provider and consultation fees, as applicable.
Medication costs, per patient per year
| Country/study | Setting | Diabetes type | Cost per medication, per patient, per year (2016 US$) | |||||||
| Insulin* | NPH insulin | Analogue insulin | Oral medications† | Glibenclamide | Metformin | CVD medications‡ | Antidiabetic§ | |||
|
| ||||||||||
|
| ||||||||||
| Solomon Islands | SC | 2 | 18.83 | 27.20 | 12.55 | |||||
|
| ||||||||||
|
| ||||||||||
| Malawi | Supply | 1 | 450.00 | |||||||
| Central African Republic | Supply | 1 | 335.16 | |||||||
| Somalia | Supply | 1 | 180.00 | |||||||
| Burkina Faso | Supply | 1 | 180.00 | |||||||
| Nepal | Supply | 1 | 135.00 | |||||||
| Benin | Supply | 1 | 144.00 | |||||||
|
| ||||||||||
| Cambodia | Supply | 2 | 117.72 | 25.60 | 3.09 | 25.76 | ||||
| Mauritania | Supply | 1 | 140.22 | |||||||
| Cambodia | Supply | 1 | 180.00 | |||||||
| Pakistan | Supply | 1 | 4.98 | |||||||
| Mongolia | Supply | 1 | 0.00¶ | |||||||
| Cote d’Ivoire | Supply | 1 | 91.80 | |||||||
| India | Supply | 1 | 103.50 | |||||||
| India | SC | 2 | 439.83 | |||||||
|
| ||||||||||
| Iran | SC-Public | 2 | 79.28 | 95.71 | ||||||
| Private | 2 | 81.41 | 57.83 | |||||||
| Iran | SC | 2 | 63.24 | 236.04 | ||||||
| Jordan | SC | DM | 91.82** | |||||||
| Jordan | SC | 2 | 393.78 | 952.69 | ||||||
| Serbia | Unclear | 2 | 56.43 | 35.13 | ||||||
| Ecuador | Supply | 1 | 109.80 | |||||||
| Bulgaria | SC | 1 | 481.89 | |||||||
| St Lucia | Supply | 1 | 0.00¶ | |||||||
| China | SC | DM | 494.44 | 466.38 | ||||||
| Brazil | SC | 1 | 384.59 | 30.88 | ||||||
| Brazil | SC | 2 | 49.93 | 7.68 | 12.80 | 21.77 | 70.42 | |||
|
| ||||||||||
|
| ||||||||||
| Vietnam | Missing | 1 and 2 | 90.87 | 378.44 | ||||||
| Philippines | Missing | 1 and 2 | 242.19 | 165.17 | ||||||
|
| ||||||||||
| China | SC | 2 | 270.31 | |||||||
| China | SC | 2 | 257.72 | |||||||
| Mexico | PC | 2 | 5.16 | 12.02 | ||||||
| Brazil | SC | 2 | 278.47 | 124.38 | ||||||
| Argentina | Public | 2 | 518.69 | 1555.24‡‡ | 250.50 | |||||
Some studies also included other medicines: antibiotics35; pain relief/anti-inflammatory drugs35; gliflozin class drugs68; sulfonylureas68 69; metformin combinations (with glibenclamide,46 with DPP4i).70 An additional study included medication costs per complication without breaking this out by specific medication.45
*Indicated as (non-specific) insulin in study text.
†Indicated as group of oral antidiabetic medications (non-specified per drug) in study text (excluding medicines for comorbidities such as CVD); any specifications included as footnotes here.
‡Includes lipid-lowering medicines, antiplatelet, antihypertensive drugs. All antidiabetic medications summed together (ie, the cost of insulin plus oral antidiabetic medications).
§Insulin provided free of charge to surveyed health facilities in this country.
¶Insulin vials.
**Insulin cartridges.
††Levemir.
‡‡Insulin lispro.
CVD, cardiovascular disease; DM, diabetes mellitus; NPH, neutral protamine Hagedorn; PC, primary care; SP, specialised care.