| Literature DB >> 30886730 |
Alain Meyer1,2, Carlo Alberto Scirè3, Rosaria Talarico4, Tobias Alexander5, Zahir Amoura6, Tadej Avcin7, Simone Barsotti8,9, Lorenzo Beretta10, Jelena Blagojevic11, Gerd Burmester5, Ilaria Cavazzana12, Patrick Cherrin6, Laura Damian13, Andrea Doria14, João Eurico Fonseca15, Federica Furini16, Ilaria Galetti17, Frederic Houssiau18, Thomas Krieg19, Larosa Maddalena14, David Launay20, Raquel Campanilho-Marques15, Thierry Martin21, Marco Matucci-Cerinic11, Pia Moinzadeh19, Carlomaurizio Montecucco22, Maria Francisca Moraes-Fontes23, Luc Mouthon24, Rossella Neri4, Sabrina Paolino25, Yves Piette26, Simona Rednic13, Farah Tamirou18, Angela Tincani12, Natasa Toplak7, Stefano Bombardieri27, Eric Hachulla20, Ulf Mueller-Ladner28, Matthias Schneider29, Vanessa Smith26, Ana Vieira30, Maurizio Cutolo25, Marta Mosca4,8, Lorenzo Cavagna22.
Abstract
Idiopathic inflammatory myopathies (IIMs) encompass a heterogeneous group of rare autoimmune diseases characterised by muscle weakness and inflammation, but in antisynthetase syndrome arthritis and interstitial lung disease are more frequent and often inaugurate the disease. Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) have been proposed for IIMs, but they are sparse and heterogeneous. This work aimed at identifying: i) current available CPGs for IIMs, ii) patients ' and clinicians' unmet needs not covered by CPGs. It has been performed in the framework of the European Reference Network on rare and complex connective tissue and musculoskeletal diseases (ReCONNET), a network of centre of expertise and patients funded by the European Union's Health Programme. Fourteen original CPGs were identified, notably recommending that: i) extra-muscular involvements should be assessed; ii) corticosteroids and methotrexate or azathioprine are first-line therapies of IIMs. ii) IVIG is a treatment of resistant-DM that may be also used in other resistant-IIMs; iii) physical therapy and sun protection (in DM patients) are part of the treatment; v) tumour screening for patients with DM include imaging of chest, abdomen, pelvis and breast (in woman) along with colonoscopy (in patients over 50 years); vi) disease activity and damages should be monitor using standardised and validated tools. Yet, only half of these CPGs were evidence-based. Crucial unmet needs were identified both by patients and clinicians. In particular, there was a lack of large multidisciplinary working group and of patients ' preferences. The following fields were not or inappropriately targeted: diagnosis; management of extra-muscular involvements other than skin; co-morbidities and severe manifestations.Entities:
Year: 2019 PMID: 30886730 PMCID: PMC6397434 DOI: 10.1136/rmdopen-2018-000784
Source DB: PubMed Journal: RMD Open ISSN: 2056-5933
Figure 1Flow chart constructed from Pubmed, Embase and national databases. CPGs, clinical practice guidelines.
Scope and key recommendations of available CPGs for IIMs
| Scope | First author, date of publication (ref) | Key recommendations of the CPG |
| General management | Sunderkotter, 2016 | All patients with IIMs should undergo a pulmonary function test and—in case of pathological findings—further pulmonology workup. Tumour screening in DM with anti-TIF1-γ include 18-fluoro-deoxyglucose-positron emission tomography/CT or CT of the thorax and abdomen in combination with a gynaecological/urological examination is recommended (no strategy is provided in other case by the CPG). Treatment of IIMs includes: CS (intravenous if severe, oral if not). AZA (for adult) and MTX (for children) when: (1) severe IIMs, (2) impossibility to reduce CS dosage below the ‘Cushing threshold’ after 3 months. IVIG is recommended in patients unresponsive to CS+AZA. Non-pharmacological measures: regular physical therapy, sun protection (for patients with DM). |
| Enders, 2017 | All children with suspected IIMs should be referred to a specialised centre. High-risk patients (as defined in the CPG) need immediate/urgent referral. Assessment of organ involvement (muscle, skin, lung, heart), calcinosis and antibodies (see CPG for details) is recommended for all children with IIMs. Disease activity, damages and health status should be monitored in a standardised way. Juvenile IIMs treatment includes: Sun protection, exercise programme. First line: high-dose CS and MTX. If failure (considered within the first 12 weeks): topical TACRO/ CS (if localised skin disease), CsA or MMF (if intolerance to MTX), IVIG as adjunct or RTX as adjunct or CYC or antitumour necrosis factor therapies (if resistance). | |
| Treatment (overall) | Drake, 1996 | Non-pharmacological treatments of IIMs include physical therapy, photoprotection and adequate nutrition. Pharmacological treatments of IIMs include CS (topical and systemic); antimalarial and CS-sparing agents (no limitative list provided in the CPG). Calcinosis treatments include medical (diphosphonates, aluminium hydroxide, probenecid, colchicine and low-dose warfarin) and surgical management. |
| Hengstman, 2009 | First line of IIMs is prednisone (1 mg/kg) and AZA or MTX. Second line, in case of severe pulmonary involvement, is CsA or TACRO or CYC. Second line, in case of no severe pulmonary involvement, is IVIG. Third line is RTX or TACRO or MMF or CsA or CYC. | |
| Treatment (IVIG) | Bril, 1999 | IVIG is favourably recommended for the treatment of DM and recommended as a last resort for the other IIMs. |
| Feasby, 2007 | IVIG is recommended as an adjunctive treatment for DM who did not adequately respond to other immunosuppressant medications (such as CS, MTX or AZA). IVIG may be considered as an adjunctive treatment option for PM who failed to respond to first-line therapies. IVIG is not recommended for IBM. | |
| Donofrio, 2009 | IVIG therapy is recommended as add-on treatment in refractory IIMs. IVIG is not recommended for IBM. | |
| Patwa, 2012 | IVIG may be considered for the treatment of non-responsive adult DM. Evidence is insufficient to support or refute the use of IVIG in treating IBM and PM. | |
| Enk, 2016 | Severe forms of DM, PM and IBM are considered by the authors as indication of IVIG, as first-line treatment (in fulminant course, severe myolysis or paralysis) or second-line treatment (in other cases), with continuation of immunosuppressive therapy. | |
| Pregnancy | Doria, 2004 | Patients with IIMs should be correctly informed on the risk of becoming pregnant. Pregnancies should be planned when IIMs is in remission Patients with IIMs should be regularly monitored during gestation and postpartum by a multidisciplinary team. In the case of disease relapse, treatment has to be started as soon as possible. IIMs treatment in pregnant patients is: CS (1 mg/kg/day until thenormalisation of serum creatine kinase levels). If insufficient response: CsA, AZA, plasma exchange or IVIG. |
| Disease measurement (tools) | Alexanderson, 2007 | Disease activity and disability should be measured at disease onset, at 3, 6 and 12 months, and then at least once a year. Only valid and reliable clinical outcome measures should be used (such clinical outcome measures were not available at the time of the publication of the CPG). |
| Tumour screening | Titulaer, 2011 | Patients with DM should have CT-thorax/abdomen, ultrasound of the pelvic region and mammography in women, ultrasound of testes in men under 50 years and colonoscopy in men and women over 50. If primary screening is negative, repeat screening after 3–6 months and screen every 6 months up till 4 years. |
| Extramuscular involvement (skin) | Fujimoto, 2016 | For calcinosis in IIMs: low-dose warfarin, aluminium hydroxide gel, diltiazem hydrochloride, probenecid or bisphosphonate are recommended as an option. Surgical treatment is also recommended as an option. For panniculitis in IIMs: CS is recommended. If no response, immunosuppressants such as CsA, MTX and AZA are recommended as an option. |
| Extramuscular involvement (lung) | Morrisset, 2016 | In acute or severe IIMs–ILD: high-dose steroids+CYC or RTX or CsA or TACRO is recommended. In chronic or mild to moderate IIMs–ILD: steroids+MMF or AZA is recommended. In case of failure: it is recommended to switch agent or consider combination of agents, or consider IVIG or consider transplantation referral. |
AZA, azathioprine; CPGs, clinical practice guidelines; CS, corticosteriod; CYC, cyclophosphamide; CsA, ciclosporin A; DM, dermatomyositis; IBM, inclusion body myositis; IIM: idiopathic inflammatory myopathy; ILD: interstitial lung disease; IVIG, intravenous immunoglobulin; MMF, mycophenolate mofetil; MTX, methotrexate; PM, polymyositis; RTX, rituximab; TACRO, tacrolimus.
Synthesis of the physicians’ unmet needs
| Unmet need related with | Unmet needs | Description |
| Stakeholders | Patients’ preference | None of the CPGs are based on patients preference. |
| Multidisciplinary working group | None of the CPGs involved >2 different specialities. | |
| CPGs scope and targets | Diagnosis | None of the CPGs provide a integrated strategy for diagnosis. |
| Extramuscular involvement | Only one eminence-based CPG cover diagnosis and management of ILD. | |
| Management by subgroups of IIMs | None of the CPG is personalised by subgroup of inflammatory myopathies below than DM versus other IIMs. | |
| Activity and damage assessment | Only one eminence-based CPG specifically addresses disease activity and damages assessment. | |
| Life or organ-function threatening complications | None of the CPG cover management of life or organ-function threatening complications. | |
| Comorbidities | None of the CPG cover comorbidities prevention, diagnosis and treatment. | |
| Transition management | None of the CPG targets transition management. |
CPGs, clinical practice guidelines; DM, dermatomyositis; IIM: idiopathic inflammatory myopathy; ILD: interstitial lung disease.
CPGs general characteristics
| Author | Date | Target | Main authors specialty | Other specialty involved | Based on | Scope |
| Drake | 1996 | IIMs as a whole | Dermatology | None | Evidence | Treatment (overall) |
| Bril | 1999 | IIMs as a whole | Neurology | None | Eminence | Treatment (IVIG) |
| Doria | 2004 | Adult IIMs | Rheumatology | Neurology | Eminence | Pregnancy |
| Feasby | 2007 | IIMs as a whole | Neurology | None | Evidence | Treatment (IVIG) |
| Alexanderson | 2007 | IIMs as a whole | Rheumatology | Physical therapy | Eminence | Disease measurement (tools) |
| Donofrio | 2009 | Adult IIMs | Neurology | None | Evidence | Treatment (IVIG) |
| Hengstman | 2009 | IIMs as a whole | Neurology | None | Eminence | Treatment (overall) |
| Titulaer | 2011 | IIMs as a whole | Neurology | None | Evidence | Tumour screening |
| Patwa | 2012 | Adult IIMs | Neurology | None | Evidence | Treatment (IVIG) |
| Sunderkotter | 2016 | IIMs as a whole | Neurology | Dermatologist | Eminence | General management |
| Enk | 2016 | IIMs as a whole | Dermatology | None | Eminence | Treatment (IVIG) |
| Fujimoto | 2016 | IIMs as a whole | Dermatology | None | Evidence | Treatment (skin disease) |
| Morrisset | 2016 | Adult IIMs | Pneumology | None | Eminence | Lung disease |
| Enders | 2017 | Juvenile IIMs | Rheumatology | None | Evidence | General management |
Evidence was graded according to Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation Working Group 2007 (http://www.gradeworkinggroup.org/)
CPG: clinical practice guideline;IIM: idiopathic inflammatory myopathy; IVIG: intravenous immunoglobulin;