Johan Ormel1, Ronald C Kessler2, Robert Schoevers1. 1. Department of Psychiatry, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, The Netherlands. 2. Department of Health Care Policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA.
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Since the 70s, treatment of depression, especially pharmacologically, has expanded enormously. However, epidemiological studies show that 12-month population prevalence rates have not dropped. This observation raises multiple questions. How good are treatments of depression actually? Do they improve long-term outcomes? Have the treatment gaps narrowed? And how can we make mental healthcare more effective at the population level? RECENT FINDINGS: Recent publications suggest some answers. Controlled treatment trials show that effectiveness of specific treatments (pharmacological, psychological) is modest and probably overestimated owing to substantial spontaneous recovery and nonspecific therapeutic effects. Treatment gaps are still substantial and prevention has unclear long-term effects and is not structurally embedded. Future relevance of genetic information for better personalized treatment is potentially high but uncertain. Increasingly, the potential of treatment to improve long-term outcome is being questioned. SUMMARY: To reduce prevalence, it is essential to narrow the treatment gaps, provide timely interventions and high-quality treatment, eradicate waiting lists, prescribe antidepressants more cautiously and better managed, consider psychological alternatives, and provide more psychosocial treatment in primary care with physician-assistants. In addition, research is needed on long-term outcome of different treatment modalities, and least but not last the value of structurally socially embedded preventive interventions.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Since the 70s, treatment of depression, especially pharmacologically, has expanded enormously. However, epidemiological studies show that 12-month population prevalence rates have not dropped. This observation raises multiple questions. How good are treatments of depression actually? Do they improve long-term outcomes? Have the treatment gaps narrowed? And how can we make mental healthcare more effective at the population level? RECENT FINDINGS: Recent publications suggest some answers. Controlled treatment trials show that effectiveness of specific treatments (pharmacological, psychological) is modest and probably overestimated owing to substantial spontaneous recovery and nonspecific therapeutic effects. Treatment gaps are still substantial and prevention has unclear long-term effects and is not structurally embedded. Future relevance of genetic information for better personalized treatment is potentially high but uncertain. Increasingly, the potential of treatment to improve long-term outcome is being questioned. SUMMARY: To reduce prevalence, it is essential to narrow the treatment gaps, provide timely interventions and high-quality treatment, eradicate waiting lists, prescribe antidepressants more cautiously and better managed, consider psychological alternatives, and provide more psychosocial treatment in primary care with physician-assistants. In addition, research is needed on long-term outcome of different treatment modalities, and least but not last the value of structurally socially embedded preventive interventions.
Authors: Juyoen Hur; Manuel Kuhn; Shannon E Grogans; Allegra S Anderson; Samiha Islam; Hyung Cho Kim; Rachael M Tillman; Andrew S Fox; Jason F Smith; Kathryn A DeYoung; Alexander J Shackman Journal: Psychol Sci Date: 2022-06-03
Authors: Mary E McNamara; Jason Shumake; Rochelle A Stewart; Jocelyn Labrada; Alexandra Alario; John J B Allen; Rohan Palmer; David M Schnyer; John E McGeary; Christopher G Beevers Journal: Psychiatry Res Date: 2021-02-13 Impact factor: 3.222
Authors: Jessica P K Doll; Jorge F Vázquez-Castellanos; Anna-Chiara Schaub; Nina Schweinfurth; Cedric Kettelhack; Else Schneider; Gulnara Yamanbaeva; Laura Mählmann; Serge Brand; Christoph Beglinger; Stefan Borgwardt; Jeroen Raes; André Schmidt; Undine E Lang Journal: Front Psychiatry Date: 2022-02-17 Impact factor: 4.157
Authors: David Villarreal-Zegarra; Milagros Cabrera-Alva; Rodrigo M Carrillo-Larco; Antonio Bernabe-Ortiz Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2020-07-19 Impact factor: 2.692