Maria Céu Machado1, Rodrigo Sousa2, Rosário Stone3, Maria Inês Barreto4, Filipa Garcês5, Carla Cruz6, Susana Gomes6, Mariana Rodrigues7, Ana Isabel Guerreiro8. 1. Departamento de Pediatria. Faculdade de Medicina de Lisboa. Lisboa. Portugal. 2. Serviço de Pediatria. Hospital Beatriz Ângelo. Loures. Portugal. 3. Departamento de Pediatria. Faculdade de Medicina de Lisboa. Lisboa. Serviço de Pediatria Médica. Hospital Santa Maria. Lisboa. Portugal. 4. Departamento de Pediatria. Hospital Pediátrico de Coimbra. Coimbra. Portugal. 5. Serviço de Pediatria. Hospital de Faro. Faro. Portugal. 6. Serviço de Pediatria. Hospital do Espírito Santo. Évora. Portugal. 7. Serviço de Pediatria Médica. Hospital de S João. Porto. Portugal. 8. Consultora Independente para os Direitos da Criança. Portugal.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: According to the Convention on the Rights of Children and the national standards of the Portuguese Directorate-General for Health, adolescents have the right to make decisions about their own health. The aim of this study was to identify the dynamics of the implementation of assent and informed consent in hospital settings. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Cross-sectional and multicentre study based on surveys, which included adolescents from 14 to 18 years and their parents. Heads of departments of Pediatrics and attending physicians were also interviewed. RESULTS: 194 responses from adolescents and parents were collected, and 46 interviews were conducted with physicians and heads of department. Adolescents and parents consider participation in decision making important, but parents value their own participation significantly higher (91.7% vs 47.8%, p < 0.001 in the 14 - 15 year group, 91.8% vs 53, (89.6% vs 69.6%, p = 0.016 in the 14 - 15 year group, 91.8% vs 69.4%, p = 0.005 in the 16 - 17 years group). Information leaflets are difficult to understand by teenagers. The eight heads of department felt that doctors have awareness towards communication with teenagers but have little time available. Of the 38 attending physicians, 36 said they had learned from their older colleagues and confirmed gaps in postgraduate training. DISCUSSION: This pioneering study in Portugal enabled the identification of areas that can be optimized, through health education programs for parents and adolescents, written information that is adequate to the different age groups, training in undergraduate education for medical students and also education in health institutions for professionals. CONCLUSION: Adolescents and parents, are unaware of legal and ethical standards for consent and assent. The implementation of the adolescents' right to informed assent / informed consent was not observed. Our proposal is to implement local programs for adolescents and parents.
INTRODUCTION: According to the Convention on the Rights of Children and the national standards of the Portuguese Directorate-General for Health, adolescents have the right to make decisions about their own health. The aim of this study was to identify the dynamics of the implementation of assent and informed consent in hospital settings. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Cross-sectional and multicentre study based on surveys, which included adolescents from 14 to 18 years and their parents. Heads of departments of Pediatrics and attending physicians were also interviewed. RESULTS: 194 responses from adolescents and parents were collected, and 46 interviews were conducted with physicians and heads of department. Adolescents and parents consider participation in decision making important, but parents value their own participation significantly higher (91.7% vs 47.8%, p < 0.001 in the 14 - 15 year group, 91.8% vs 53, (89.6% vs 69.6%, p = 0.016 in the 14 - 15 year group, 91.8% vs 69.4%, p = 0.005 in the 16 - 17 years group). Information leaflets are difficult to understand by teenagers. The eight heads of department felt that doctors have awareness towards communication with teenagers but have little time available. Of the 38 attending physicians, 36 said they had learned from their older colleagues and confirmed gaps in postgraduate training. DISCUSSION: This pioneering study in Portugal enabled the identification of areas that can be optimized, through health education programs for parents and adolescents, written information that is adequate to the different age groups, training in undergraduate education for medical students and also education in health institutions for professionals. CONCLUSION: Adolescents and parents, are unaware of legal and ethical standards for consent and assent. The implementation of the adolescents' right to informed assent / informed consent was not observed. Our proposal is to implement local programs for adolescents and parents.
Entities:
Keywords:
Adolescent; Decision Making; Health Personnel; Informed Consent; Parents; Portugal
Authors: Jeffrey Goldhagen; Andrew Clarke; Peter Dixon; Ana Isabel Guerreiro; Gerison Lansdown; Ziba Vaghri Journal: BMJ Paediatr Open Date: 2020-01-12