Colleen Fogarty Draper1,2, Giulia Tini3,4, Irene Vassallo5, Jean Philippe Godin6, MingMing Su7, Wei Jia7, Maurice Beaumont8, Sofia Moco1, Francois-Pierre Martin1. 1. Nestlé Research, Nestlé Institute of Health Sciences (NIHS), 1015, Lausanne, Switzerland. 2. Leiden University, 2300, Leiden, The Netherlands. 3. The Microsoft Research - University of Trento Centre for Computational and Systems Biology, 38068, Rovereto, Italy. 4. Department of Mathematics, University of Trento, 38050, Povo, Italy. 5. Precision for Medicine, 1202, Geneva, Switzerland. 6. Nestlé Research, 1000, Lausanne, Switzerland. 7. University of Hawaii Cancer Center (UHCC), HI, 96813, USA. 8. Clinical Development Unit, Nestlé Research, 1000, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Abstract
SCOPE: Flexitarian dieting is increasingly associated with health benefits. The study of postprandial metabolic response to vegan and animal diets is essential to decipher how specific diet components may mediate metabolic changes. METHODS AND RESULTS: A randomized, crossover, controlled vegan versus animal diet challenge is conducted on 21 healthy participants. Postprandial metabolic measurements are conducted at seven timepoints. Area under the curve analysis of the vegan diet response demonstrates higher glucose (EE 0.35), insulin (EE 0.38), triglycerides (EE 0.72), and nine amino acids at breakfast (EE 4.72-209.32); and six lower health-promoting fatty acids at lunch (EE -0.1035 to -0.13) (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Glycemic and lipid parameters vary irrespective of diet type, demonstrating that vegan and animal meals contain health-promoting and suboptimal nutrient combinations. The vegan breakfast produces the same pattern of elevated branched chain amino acids, insulin, and glucose as the animal diet from the fasting results, reflecting the low protein load in the animal and the higher branched-chain amino acid load of the vegan breakfast. Liberalization of the vegan menu to vegetarian and the animal menu to a Nordic-based diet can result in optimal metabolic signatures for both flexitarian diet strategies in future research.
RCT Entities:
SCOPE: Flexitarian dieting is increasingly associated with health benefits. The study of postprandial metabolic response to vegan and animal diets is essential to decipher how specific diet components may mediate metabolic changes. METHODS AND RESULTS: A randomized, crossover, controlled vegan versus animal diet challenge is conducted on 21 healthy participants. Postprandial metabolic measurements are conducted at seven timepoints. Area under the curve analysis of the vegan diet response demonstrates higher glucose (EE 0.35), insulin (EE 0.38), triglycerides (EE 0.72), and nine amino acids at breakfast (EE 4.72-209.32); and six lower health-promoting fatty acids at lunch (EE -0.1035 to -0.13) (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Glycemic and lipid parameters vary irrespective of diet type, demonstrating that vegan and animal meals contain health-promoting and suboptimal nutrient combinations. The vegan breakfast produces the same pattern of elevated branched chain amino acids, insulin, and glucose as the animal diet from the fasting results, reflecting the low protein load in the animal and the higher branched-chain amino acid load of the vegan breakfast. Liberalization of the vegan menu to vegetarian and the animal menu to a Nordic-based diet can result in optimal metabolic signatures for both flexitarian diet strategies in future research.