| Literature DB >> 30621779 |
Abdul Rafeh Naqash1, Danielle M File2, Carolyn M Ziemer3, Young E Whang4, Paula Landman5, Paul B Googe6, Frances A Collichio4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: With the advent of immune-checkpoint inhibitors and targeted treatments (TT), there have been unprecedented response rates and survival in advanced melanoma, but the optimal sequencing of these two treatments modalities is unknown. Combining or sequencing these agents could potentially result in unique toxicities. Cutaneous adverse events (CAE) after sequential exposure to these agents represents one toxicity that needs further description.Entities:
Keywords: B-RAF inhibitors; Cutaneous adverse events; DRESS syndrome; Immune checkpoint blockade; Metastatic melanoma; Vemurafenib/cobimetinib
Year: 2019 PMID: 30621779 PMCID: PMC6323838 DOI: 10.1186/s40425-018-0475-y
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Immunother Cancer ISSN: 2051-1426 Impact factor: 13.751
Therapy and Rash Characteristics
| Patient | Demographics at Time of Rash Onset | Therapy Sequence [(Days to Rash Onset (RO)] | Clinical Course | Lab Abnormalities | CTCAE Rash Grade (G), Characterization Location Initial Diagnosis | Histopathology | Confounding Variables | Current Survival Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 54 year old Caucasian female | I/N ×1 - > N (Day − 315 to − 148) V/C (Day −12 to RO) | Hospitalized High grade fever Hypotension Oral mucositis | Hyponatremia Hypokalemia Elevated lactate (2.5XULN) Lymphocytopenia Elevated sIL-2R (20 X ULN) CRP 163 | G-4, Diffuse morbilliform eruption of trunk and extremities DRESS vs SJS vs drug reaction | Papillary dermal edema, slight basal layer vacuolization, superficial dermal perivascular lymphocytic infiltration and eosinophils | Started allopurinol 14 days prior to rash onset | Deceased |
| 2 | 60 year old Caucasian female | N (Day − 408 to −228) D/T (Day −214 to RO) | ICU High grade fever Hypotension AMS Lip swelling Difficulty swallowing | Transaminitis | G-4, Diffuse morbilliform eruption of trunk and extremities Drug reaction vs sepsis vs DRESS | Subepidermal vesicle formation with eosinophils; positive direct immunofluorescence with linear IgG and IgA at the basement membrane zone suggestive of bullous pemphigoid or linear IgA bullous dermatosis | On course of amoxicillin-clavulanic acid at rash onset | Alive |
| 3 | 54 year old Caucasian male | D/T (Day − 331 to − 143) N (Day − 122 to − 24) V/C (Day − 16 to RO) | Hospitalized High grade fever | Hyponatremia Elevated creatinine Lymphocytopenia | G-4, Diffuse targetoid lesions involving trunk, extremities and face SJS vs drug eruption (including DRESS) vs viral exanthem | Papillary dermal edema, slight basal layer vacuolization, superficial dermal perivascular lymphocytic infiltration and eosinophils | Symptoms of upper respiratory tract infection present immediately prior to rash onset | Deceased |
| 4 | 58 year old Caucasian female | N (Day − 344 to −43) V/C (Day −13 to RO) | Outpatient management | None | G-4 Diffuse morbilliform eruption of trunk and extremities Drug reaction | No biopsy performed | Started with full doses of V/C when had been instructed to start at a reduced dose of each | Deceased |
| 5 | 59 year old Caucasian female | V/C (Day −75 to −11) P (Day −6 to RO) | ICU High grade fever Hypotension Tachycardia | Elevated creatinine Transaminitis Hyperbilirubinemia CRP 200 | G-4 Diffuse morbilliform eruption of trunk and extremities Sepsis vs DRESS vs pembrolizumab induced reaction | Papillary dermal edema, slight basal layer vacuolization, superficial dermal perivascular lymphocytic infiltration and eosinophils; few plasma cells, neutrophils, and a rare focus of parakeratosis | Concern for sepsis from cellulitis (re-fevered after antibiotics narrowed) | Deceased |
| 6 | 58 year old Caucasian female | P (Day −56) V/C (Day −21 to RO) | Outpatient management | Transaminitis Lymphocytopenia CRP 159 | G-2 Discrete scattered erythematous edematous plaques on extremities Drug reaction vs Sweets Syndrome vs early SJS | Papillary dermal edema, slight basal layer vacuolization, superficial dermal perivascular lymphocytic infiltration and eosinophils | No apparent confounding variables | Alive |
All days are calculated from rash occurrence (RO) being day 0, I Ipilimumab, N Nivolumab, P Pembrolizumab, V Vemurafenib, C Cobimetinib, D Dabrafenib, T Trametinib, sIL-2R Soluble interleukin-2 receptor, ULN Upper limit of normal, High grade fever= > 102, AMS Altered mental status, CRP C-reactive protein (reference range < 10.0 mg/L), SJS Stevens Johnson syndrome, DRESS Drug Reaction with Eosinophilia and Systemic Symptoms, CTCAE Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events (CTCAE 4.03)
Fig. 1Therapy timelines for patients in relation to rash onset showing sequencing of ICB and TT
Fig. 2Diffuse morbilliform eruption involving trunk (a, b) and extremities (c)
Fig. 3Skin biopsy of rash with histology. a Skin biopsy shows slight basal layer vacuolization, dermal edema and a superficial dermal perivascular lymphocyte and eosinophil infiltrate. No necrosis is present. (H&E, 200X). b Eosinophils (arrows) are present with lymphocytes around the superficial dermal capillaries fibrinoid necrosis of capillary walls, a sign of vasculitis, is not present. (H&E, 400X)
Rash Treatment and Outcome
| Patient | Supportive Measures | Treatment | Total Steroid Duration | Duration of Rash | Targeted Therapy Re-initiation | Additional Therapies | Disease Status after Rash |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | IVFs | Dexamethasone 10 mg q6h inpatient then prednisone 1 mg/kg followed by extended taper outpatient | 42 days prescribed (however remained on steroids for entire duration of targeted therapy) | 39 days | Yes, D/T 44 days after rash onset On prednisone 10 mg daily | Temozolomide | Mixed response at 1 month, significantly worsened disease at 2 months |
| 2 | IVFs | Prednisone 150 mg daily inpatient followed by extended taper outpatient | 53 days | 37 days | Yes, D/T 39 days after rash onset On prednisone 10 mg daily | Ipilimumab Pembrolizumab CD40 agonist/ Pembrolizumab | Mixed response at 1 month, stable disease at 1 year, worsened disease at 18 months |
| 3 | IVFs | Methylprednisolone 50 mg daily inpatient followed by prednisone 60 mg daily with extended taper outpatient | 17 days after first rash onset For duration of targeted therapy after rash recurrence | 16 days | Yes, V/C (dose reduced) 24 days after rash onset Off prednisone Immediate fever and rash, held additional 13 days then restarted while on prednisone 30 mg daily | None | Mixed response at 1 month, improved disease at 4 months, worsened systemic disease at 8 months, worsened intracranial disease at 9 months |
| 4 | None | Prednisone 20 mg daily for 3 days, 10 mg daily for 3 days | 6 days | 12 days | Yes, V/C 13 days after rash onset Off prednisone Recurrence of rash after 1st dose, discontinued again Restarted 59 days after rash onset Immediate grade 4 allergic reaction to vemurafenib Tolerated D/T 166 days after initial rash onset when started with concurrent steroids | Temozolomide D/T Ipilimumab | Improved disease at 1 month, mixed response at 3 months (before temozolomide), worsened disease at 5 months (on temozolomide) improved response at 9 months (after initiation of D/T), worsened disease at 13 months |
| 5 | IVFs, Vasopressors | Methylprednisolone 70 mg BID inpatient followed by prednisone 60 mg daily with extended taper outpatient | 54 days at time of readmission for rash recurrence when tapered to prednisone 5 mg daily, prolonged taper again thereafter | 15 days | No | Temozolomide | Disease progression at 2 months (before temozolomide), worsened disease at 5 months |
| 6 | None | Prednisone 10 mg daily followed by extended taper | Ongoing (> 50 days) | 6 days | Yes, V/C 7 days after rash onset On prednisone 10 mg daily | None | No disease progression |
IVFs Intravenous fluids, V Vemurafenib, C Cobimetinib, D Dabrafenib, T Trametinib
Practical Advice for Clinical Management
| - Consult dermatology and biopsy right away, photographs recommended to help document rash. | |
| - Consider obtaining CRP as surrogate for IL-6 as patients may present with SIRS. | |
| - Consider re-initiation of therapy after rash (at lower dose, with steroid overlap), particularly if no signs of SJS, biopsy appears benign relative to clinical rash, and patient was having a good response to the therapy or does not have alternate therapy options. | |
| - Consider avoidance of other stimulating medications or known activating medications such as amoxicillin, amoxicillin-clavulanic acid, allopurinol |