Literature DB >> 30597106

Phylotocol: Promoting Transparency and Overcoming Bias in Phylogenetics.

Melissa B DeBiasse1,2, Joseph F Ryan1,2.   

Abstract

The integrity of science requires that the process be based on sound experimental design and objective methodology. Strategies that increase reproducibility and transparency in science protect this integrity by reducing conscious and unconscious biases. Given the large number of analysis options and the constant development of new methodologies in phylogenetics, this field is one that would particularly benefit from more transparent research design. Herein, we introduce phylotocol (fi lō 'ta kôl), an a priori protocol-driven approach in which all analyses are planned and documented at the start of a project. The phylotocol template is simple and the implementation options are flexible to reduce administrative burdens and allow researchers to adapt it to their needs without restricting scientific creativity. While the primary goal of phylotocol is to increase transparency and accountability, it has a number of auxiliary benefits including improving study design and reproducibility, enhancing collaboration and education, and increasing the likelihood of project completion. Our goal with this Point of View article is to encourage a dialog about transparency in phylogenetics and the best strategies to bring transparent research practices to our field.
© The Author(s) 2018. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Society of Systematic Biologists.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Accountability; confirmation bias; open science; phylogenetics; phylotocol; protocol; transparency

Mesh:

Year:  2019        PMID: 30597106      PMCID: PMC6568013          DOI: 10.1093/sysbio/syy090

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Syst Biol        ISSN: 1063-5157            Impact factor:   15.683


  17 in total

Review 1.  The case for motivated reasoning.

Authors:  Z Kunda
Journal:  Psychol Bull       Date:  1990-11       Impact factor: 17.737

2.  Trust but verify: trial registration and determining fidelity to the protocol.

Authors:  Deborah A Zarin; Tony Tse
Journal:  Ann Intern Med       Date:  2013-07-02       Impact factor: 25.391

3.  Inferring ancient divergences requires genes with strong phylogenetic signals.

Authors:  Leonidas Salichos; Antonis Rokas
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2013-05-08       Impact factor: 49.962

4.  Transparency in Ecology and Evolution: Real Problems, Real Solutions.

Authors:  Timothy H Parker; Wolfgang Forstmeier; Julia Koricheva; Fiona Fidler; Jarrod D Hadfield; Yung En Chee; Clint D Kelly; Jessica Gurevitch; Shinichi Nakagawa
Journal:  Trends Ecol Evol       Date:  2016-07-25       Impact factor: 17.712

5.  SCIENTIFIC STANDARDS. Promoting an open research culture.

Authors:  B A Nosek; G Alter; G C Banks; D Borsboom; S D Bowman; S J Breckler; S Buck; C D Chambers; G Chin; G Christensen; M Contestabile; A Dafoe; E Eich; J Freese; R Glennerster; D Goroff; D P Green; B Hesse; M Humphreys; J Ishiyama; D Karlan; A Kraut; A Lupia; P Mabry; T A Madon; N Malhotra; E Mayo-Wilson; M McNutt; E Miguel; E Levy Paluck; U Simonsohn; C Soderberg; B A Spellman; J Turitto; G VandenBos; S Vazire; E J Wagenmakers; R Wilson; T Yarkoni
Journal:  Science       Date:  2015-06-26       Impact factor: 47.728

6.  Update on Trial Registration 11 Years after the ICMJE Policy Was Established.

Authors:  Deborah A Zarin; Tony Tse; Rebecca J Williams; Thiyagu Rajakannan
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  2017-01-26       Impact factor: 91.245

7.  The automation of science.

Authors:  Ross D King; Jem Rowland; Stephen G Oliver; Michael Young; Wayne Aubrey; Emma Byrne; Maria Liakata; Magdalena Markham; Pinar Pir; Larisa N Soldatova; Andrew Sparkes; Kenneth E Whelan; Amanda Clare
Journal:  Science       Date:  2009-04-03       Impact factor: 47.728

8.  The Impact of Protocol Amendments on Clinical Trial Performance and Cost.

Authors:  Kenneth A Getz; Stella Stergiopoulos; Mary Short; Leon Surgeon; Randy Krauss; Sybrand Pretorius; Julian Desmond; Derek Dunn
Journal:  Ther Innov Regul Sci       Date:  2016-07       Impact factor: 1.778

9.  The preregistration revolution.

Authors:  Brian A Nosek; Charles R Ebersole; Alexander C DeHaven; David T Mellor
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2018-03-13       Impact factor: 12.779

10.  Striving for transparent and credible research: practical guidelines for behavioral ecologists.

Authors:  Malika Ihle; Isabel S Winney; Anna Krystalli; Michael Croucher
Journal:  Behav Ecol       Date:  2017-03-14       Impact factor: 2.671

View more
  5 in total

1.  Six-State Amino Acid Recoding is not an Effective Strategy to Offset Compositional Heterogeneity and Saturation in Phylogenetic Analyses.

Authors:  Alexandra M Hernandez; Joseph F Ryan
Journal:  Syst Biol       Date:  2021-10-13       Impact factor: 15.683

2.  Sponges Lack ParaHox Genes.

Authors:  Claudia C Pastrana; Melissa B DeBiasse; Joseph F Ryan
Journal:  Genome Biol Evol       Date:  2019-04-01       Impact factor: 3.416

3.  Insect morphometry is reproducible under average investigation standards.

Authors:  Sándor Csősz; Bernhard Seifert; István Mikó; Brendon E Boudinot; Marek L Borowiec; Brian L Fisher; Matthew Prebus; Jayanthi Puniamoorthy; Jean-Claude Rakotonirina; Nicole Rasoamanana; Roland Schultz; Carolyn Trietsch; Jonah M Ulmer; Zoltán Elek
Journal:  Ecol Evol       Date:  2020-12-08       Impact factor: 2.912

4.  A Chromosome-level Genome Assembly of the Highly Heterozygous Sea Urchin Echinometra sp. EZ Reveals Adaptation in the Regulatory Regions of Stress Response Genes.

Authors:  Remi N Ketchum; Phillip L Davidson; Edward G Smith; Gregory A Wray; John A Burt; Joseph F Ryan; Adam M Reitzel
Journal:  Genome Biol Evol       Date:  2022-10-07       Impact factor: 4.065

5.  Inferring Tunicate Relationships and the Evolution of the Tunicate Hox Cluster with the Genome of Corella inflata.

Authors:  Melissa B DeBiasse; William N Colgan; Lincoln Harris; Bradley Davidson; Joseph F Ryan
Journal:  Genome Biol Evol       Date:  2020-06-01       Impact factor: 3.416

  5 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.