| Literature DB >> 30532170 |
Chao Liu1, Tingting Lin1, Zhenlei Zhou1.
Abstract
To investigate the effects of etomidate, emulsified isoflurane, and their combination with dexmedetomidine on physiological parameters, electrocardiogram (ECG) results, and the quality of induction and recovery during isoflurane maintenance anaesthesia. 5 mixed-breed dogs received each of four treatments: etomidate (E group); emulsified isoflurane (EI group); both dexmedetomidine and etomidate (DE group); or both dexmedetomidine and emulsified isoflurane (DEI group). All drugs were IV injection administered for induction, followed by 1.5 MAC (minimal alveolar concentration) of isoflurane to maintain anaesthesia. Rectal temperature (RT), respiratory rate (RR), heart rate (HR), mean arterial pressure (MAP), and ECG were measured at baseline, 0, 5, 10, 20, 40, and 60 minutes after intubation. The quality of induction and recovery was evaluated for all dogs. All the anaesthetic procedures provided good conditions for induction of anaesthesia. The quality of induction and recovery in the E group was worse than other groups. The decrease of RR in the E and DE groups was stronger than that in the EI and DEI groups. The dogs in the E group had the most significant prolongation of the Q-T interval and changes in the S-T segment. Deviation and extension of the S-T segment were noted in the El group. The dogs in the DE and DEI groups had fewer changes in the ECG results than those in the E and EI groups. The addition of dexmedetomidine caused less effect on cardiopulmonary parameters and the ECG results than either etomidate or emulsified isoflurane alone. Thus, etomidate or emulsified isoflurane in combination with dexmedetomidine may be useful clinically for the induction of anaesthesia.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30532170 PMCID: PMC6285997 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0208625
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Comparison of induction and recovery scores, and the induction and recovery time in the 4 groups (E, EI, DE, and DEI) after intravenous administration and maintenance anaesthesia with isoflurane (1.5 MAC) for 60 min.
| E | EI | DE | DEI | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Induction time of anaesthesia (min) | 0.76±0.22 | 1.51±0.86 | 0.65±0.11 | 0.78±0.08 |
| Sedation score | 3.00±0.00 | 3.00±0.00 | 3.00±0.00 | 3.00±0.00 |
| Intubation score | 0.75±0.50 | 0.60±0.89 | 0.25±0.50 | 0.50±0.58 |
| Induction quality score | 1.00±0.00 | 0.60±0.54 | 0.20±0.44 | 0.20±0.44 |
| Recovery quality score | 2.20±0.84 | 1.50±0.84 | 1.40±0.89 | 1.00±0.00 |
| Time to palpebral reflex recovery (min) | 1.79±1.16 | 1.92±0.74 | 1.61±1.25 | 1.41±0.51 |
| Time to extubation (min) | 2.14±1.43 | 4.59±2.43 | 5.77±1.88 | 3.87±2.10 |
| Time to raising the head (min) | 4.31±1.80 | 4.50±1.80 | 6.64±2.05 | 4.35±2.14 |
| Time to first stand-up (min) | 7.48±2.76 | 5.29±1.64 | 7.39±1.97 | 5.25±2.10 |
The values are presented as mean ± standard deviation.
a Significantly different from E group (P<0.05).
b Significantly different from EI group (P<0.05).
c Significantly different from DEI group (P<0.05).
Comparison of the cardiopulmonary effects in the 4 groups (E, EI, DE, and DEI) by intravenous administration and maintenance anaesthesia with isoflurane (1.5 MAC) for 60 min.
| Group | Baseline | 0 | 5 | 10 | 20 | 40 | 60 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAP (mmHg) | E | 127±11 | 121±7 | 103±10 | 99±9 | 93±8 | 95±13 | 99±18 |
| EI | 119±5 | 102±9 | 97±11 | 95±11 | 92±6 | 89±6 | 91±12 | |
| DE | 130±9 | 141±17 | 130±20 | 125±21 | 113±11 | 96±11 | 89±5 | |
| DEI | 131±9 | 140±20 | 132±22 | 123±30 | 106±15 | 90±8 | 94±9 | |
| DAP (mmHg) | E | 59±24 | 67±11 | 46±5 | 45±10 | 41±5 | 44±8 | 46±14. |
| EI | 57±15 | 48±6 | 48±15 | 48±12 | 44±5 | 43±9 | 48±9 | |
| DE | 80±6 | 97.0±29 | 89±25 | 92±33 | 79±23 | 51±8 | 49±11 | |
| DEI | 72±11 | 103±21 | 94±23 | 83±31 | 60±15. | 47±7 | 49±6 | |
| MAP (mmHg) | E | 95±7.5 | 85±9 | 65±6 | 63±9 | 59±5 | 61±9 | 62±13 |
| EI | 83±10 | 66±5 | 66±16 | 69±12 | 60±5 | 58±8 | 63±10 | |
| DE | 107±5 | 114±20 | 107±24 | 106±12 | 86±17 | 64±8 | 60±9 | |
| DEI | 102±11 | 119±21 | 110±23 | 102±31 | 75±15 | 61±5 | 63±7 | |
| RT(°C) | E | 38.3±0.3 | 38.2±0.3 | 37.9±0.1 | 37.8±0.1 | 37.7±0.4 | 37.6±0.6 | 37.4±0.6 |
| EI | 39.0±0.5 | 38.6±0.4 | 38.5±0.3 | 38.4±0.3 | 38.2±0.3 | 37.8±0.4 | 37.7±0.6 | |
| DE | 38.7±0.2 | 38.6±0.2 | 38.7±0.3 | 38.6±0.3 | 38.5±0.4 | 38.2±0.4 | 37.8±0.2 | |
| DEI | 39.0±0.2 | 38.7±0.6 | 38.7±0.6 | 38.6±0.5 | 38.5±0.5 | 38.5±0.5 | 38.2±0.6 | |
| HR beats·min-1 | E | 97±18 | 123±4 | 123±9 | 123±14 | 110.4±9 | 97±12 | 102±10 |
| EI | 102±15 | 124±18 | 126±7 | 125±9 | 111±18 | 109±16 | 115±14 | |
| DE | 101±14 | 103±18 | 105±23 | 118±25 | 108±18 | 103±8 | 97±5 | |
| DEI | 115±24 | 118±22 | 114±17 | 109±14 | 106±18 | 102±19 | 96±20 | |
| RR Respiration·min-1 | E | 20±4 | 9±3 | 11±5 | 12±7 | 8±2 | 10±3 | 14±7 |
| EI | 30±2 | 10±2 | 8±2 | 10±3 | 13±3 | 15±6 | 16±7 | |
| DE | 21±5 | 6±2 | 9±4 | 9±3 | 9±3 | 12±5 | 11±2 | |
| DEI | 24±4 | 12±2 | 13±3 | 13±2 | 11±1 | 13±1 | 14±2 | |
| SpO2 | E | — | 97.8±0.8 | 97.2±1.5 | 97.4±1.1 | 97.8±0.83 | 98.8±1.0 | 99.2±0.8 |
| EI | — | 97.4±0.54 | 98.0±0.7 | 98.4±1.1 | 98.0±1.0 | 98.0±1.0 | 98.0±1.2 | |
| DE | — | 98.6±2.1 | 99.0±1.0 | 98.6±1.1 | 98.6±0.5 | 99.0±0.2 | 99.0±1.2 | |
| DEI | — | 98.6±1.3 | 98.0±0.9 | 97.6±1.8 | 98.6±0.8 | 98.6±0.8 | 98.7±0.9 |
The values are presented as mean ± standard deviation. SAP, systolic arterial pressure; DAP, diastolic arterial pressure; MAP, mean arterial pressure; RT, rectal temperature; HR, heart rate; RR, respiratory rate; SpO2, haemoglobin oxygen saturation. Time points: baseline, 0, 5, 10, 20, 40, and 60 min after maintenance anaesthesia. "—", not available;
*Significantly different from the baseline within the group (P < 0.05).
The ECG changes in the 4 groups with intravenous administration of E, EI, DE, and DEI and maintenance anaesthesia with isoflurane (1.5 MAC) for 60 min.
| Group | Base | 0 | 5 | 10 | 20 | 40 | 60 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P-wave duration (s) | E | 0.040±0.000 | 0.038±0.002 | 0.037±0.002 | 0.037±0.002 | 0.039±0.002 | 0.038±0.002 | 0.038±0.002 |
| El | 0.036±0.005 | 0.043±0.007 | 0.042±0.005 | 0.038±0.004 | 0.043±0.007 | 0.039±0.003 | 0.037±0.004 | |
| DE | 0.040±0.000 | 0.039±0.004 | 0.038±0.005 | 0.036±0.003 | 0.037±0.003 | 0.038±0.005 | 0.037±0.002 | |
| DEl | 0.038±0.004 | 0.038±0.005 | 0.035±0.005 | 0.039±0.005 | 0.040±0.003 | 0.036±0.003 | 0.038±0.002 | |
| P-wave amplitude (mV) | E | 0.19±0.07 | 0.23±0.08 | 0.22±0.08 | 0.22±0.09 | 0.18±0.06 | 0.16±0.05 | 0.17±0.05 |
| El | 0.15±0.06 | 0.18±0.07 | 0.17±0.05 | 0.18±0.04 | 0.17±0.04 | 0.17±0.03 | 0.17±0.04 | |
| DE | 0.17±0.03 | 0.21±0.05 | 0.21±0.04 | 0.20±0.04 | 0.18±0.05 | 0.17±0.05 | 0.17±0.02 | |
| DEl | 0.14±0.04 | 0.15±0.04 | 0.16±0.04 | 0.16±0.03 | 0.16±0.03 | 0.16±0.04 | 0.15±0.04 | |
| QSR-wave duration (s) | E | 0.054±0.002 | 0.043±0.006 | 0.045±0.006 | 0.046±0.007 | 0.044±0.003 | 0.045±0.004 | 0.044±0.006 |
| El | 0.050±0.000 | 0.048±0.008 | 0.048±0.008 | 0.047±0.005 | 0.048±0.007 | 0.046±0.006 | 0.046±0.007 | |
| DE | 0.055±0.004 | 0.046±0.006 | 0.045±0.005 | 0.047±0.008 | 0.049±0.008 | 0.047±0.006 | 0.048±0.007 | |
| DEl | 0.058±0.004 | 0.048±0.009 | 0.048±0.011 | 0.047±0.012 | 0.048±0.010 | 0.046±0.008 | 0.049±0.007 | |
| R-wave amplitude (mV) | E | 1.15±0.70 | 1.16±0.48 | 1.06±0.48 | 1.15±0.41 | 1.15±0.46 | 1.23±0.52 | 1.28±0.61 |
| El | 1.10±0.39 | 1.29±0.46 | 1.35±0.46 | 1.26±0.47 | 1.26±0.59 | 1.30±0.66 | 1.34±0.65 | |
| DE | 0.96±0.55 | 1.14±0.47 | 1.08±0.45 | 1.06±0.50 | 0.93±0.55 | 0.78±0.59 | 0.70±0.54 | |
| DEl | 1.28±0.56 | 1.52±0.54 | 1.48±0.50 | 1.39±0.45 | 1.22±0.45 | 1.08±0.55 | 1.00±0.51 | |
| T-wave duration (s) | E | 0.074±0.008 | 0.093±0.018 | 0.095±0.014 | 0.104±0.018 | 0.114±0.012 | 0.118±0.008 | 0.121±0.013 |
| El | 0.063±0.027 | 0.075±0.030 | 0.079±0.017 | 0.074±0.021 | 0.085±0.023 | 0.088±0.018 | 0.092±0.018 | |
| DE | 0.066±0.009 | 0.090±0.013 | 0.084±0.018 | 0.094±0.016 | 0.095±0.024 | 0.091±0.022 | 0.094±0.018 | |
| DEl | 0.071±0.012 | 0.089±0.008 | 0.094±0.019 | 0.081±0.013 | 0.077±0.020 | 0.083±0.016 | 0.082±0.017 | |
| T-wave amplitude(mV) | E | 0.27±0.06 | 0.50±0.19 | 0.51±0.18 | 0.59±0.23 | 0.75±0.22 | 0.76±0.21 | 0.75±0.19 |
| EI | 0.23±0.03 | 0.38±0.09 | 0.33±0.08 | 0.33±0.11 | 0.37±0.11 | 0.41±0.12 | 0.39±0.14 | |
| DE | 0.22±0.05 | 0.43±0.13 | 0.39±0.13 | 0.41±0.18 | 0.42±0.16 | 0.40±0.15 | 0.40±0.13 | |
| DEI | 0.35±0.20 | 0.50±0.21 | 0.44±0.19 | 0.42±0.17 | 0.43±0.15 | 0.42±0.15 | 0.41±0.15 | |
| P-R interval (s) | E | 0.099±0.005 | 0.086±0.018 | 0.079±0.011 | 0.080±0.010 | 0.082±0.010 | 0.085±0.012 | 0.092±0.011 |
| EI | 0.090±0.007 | 0.084±0.008 | 0.086±0.010 | 0.082±0.007 | 0.089±0.009 | 0.086±0.009 | 0.083±0.010 | |
| DE | 0.098±0.009 | 0.101±0.016 | 0.092±0.014 | 0.099±0.015 | 0.098±0.012 | 0.097±0.012 | 0.094±0.006 | |
| DEI | 0.092±0.008 | 0.090±0.011 | 0.089±0.008 | 0.090±0.010 | 0.092±0.010 | 0.091±0.010 | 0.094±0.010 | |
| Q-T interval (s) | E | 0.216±0.019 | 0.223±0.011 | 0.225±0.010 | 0.228±0.009 | 0.241±0.007 | 0.253±0.014 | 0.255±0.017 |
| EI | 0.200±0.000 | 0.231±0.038 | 0.229±0.041 | 0.223±0.047 | 0.233±0.041 | 0.219±0.024 | 0.225±0.020 | |
| DE | 0.212±0.018 | 0.219±0.015 | 0.214±0.008 | 0.213±0.013 | 0.222±0.008 | 0.233±0.010 | 0.237±0.011 | |
| DEI | 0.205±0.011 | 0.210±0.020 | 0.214±0.019 | 0.218±0.017 | 0.222±0.012 | 0.228±0.019 | 0.227±0.016 | |
| S-T segment (s) | E | 0.090±0.012 | 0.087±0.009 | 0.085±0.010 | 0.079±0.011 | 0.083±0.012 | 0.083±0.006 | 0.091±0.010 |
| EI | 0.075±0.025 | 0.087±0.017 | 0.085±0.017 | 0.090±0.008 | 0.079±0.011 | 0.087±0.009 | 0.089±0.014 | |
| DE | 0.082±0.015 | 0.074±0.016 | 0.080±0.012 | 0.071±0.014 | 0.078±0.029 | 0.085±0.018 | 0.094±0.024 | |
| DEI | 0.080±0.024 | 0.074±0.027 | 0.073±0.027 | 0.090±0.020 | 0.098±0.024 | 0.095±0.027 | 0.094±0.023 |
The values are presented as mean ± standard deviation. Time points: baseline, 0, 5, 10, 20, 40, and 60 minutes after maintenance anaesthesia.
* Significantly different from the baseline within the group (P < 0.05).
Fig 1A: The normal ECG of dogs. B: After 5 minutes of isoflurane anaesthesia, the E group showed prolongation of the Q-T interval, S-T segment depression, and sinus tachycardia (150 beats∙ min-1). C: After 5 minutes of isoflurane anaesthesia, the EI group had S-T segment changes. D: After 5 minutes of isoflurane anaesthesia, the DE group had prolongation of the P-R interval and first-degree A-V block. E: After 5 minutes of isoflurane anaesthesia, the DEI group had sinus arrhythmia and the R-wave amplitude increased.