| Literature DB >> 30515559 |
Aleksandra Napieralska1, Iwona Brąclik2, Michał Radwan2, Marek Mandera3, Sławomir Blamek4.
Abstract
PURPOSE: To assess the results and tolerance of radiosurgery/hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy performed after craniospinal irradiation for recurrent tumor.Entities:
Keywords: CSI; Radiotherapy; Recurrence; Reirradiation
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30515559 PMCID: PMC6351705 DOI: 10.1007/s00381-018-4010-8
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Childs Nerv Syst ISSN: 0256-7040 Impact factor: 1.475
Primary treatment in particular patients
| Patient | Histopathology | Primary tumor location | Age | Surgery | CTH | CSI | Total dose |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 3 | Non-radical surgery | Yes | No | – |
| 2 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 4 | Radical surgery | Yes | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 54 Gy/tumor bed boost |
| 3 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 9 | Non-radical surgery | Yes | Yes | 35.1 Gy/craniospinal axis, 55.1 Gy/tumor boost |
| 4 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 10 | Non-radical surgery | Yes | Yes | 35.1 Gy/craniospinal axis, 55.1 Gy/tumor boost |
| 5 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 22 | Non-radical surgery | – | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 60 Gy/tumor boost |
| 6 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 30 | Radical surgery | – | No | – |
| 7 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 31 | Radical surgery | – | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 54 Gy/tumor bed boost |
| 8 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 46 | Non-radical surgery | – | Yes | 30.6 Gy/craniospinal axis, 53.9 Gy/tumor boost |
| 9 | AE | Frontal lobe | 19 | Radical surgery | – | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 60 Gy/tumor bed boost |
| 10 | AE | Frontal lobe | 34 | Radical surgery | – | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 60 Gy/tumor bed boost |
| 11 | PNET | Frontal lobe | 32 | Non-radical surgery | Yes | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 54 Gy/tumor boost |
| 12 | AE | Temporal lobe | 22 | Non-radical surgery | – | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 60 Gy/tumor boost |
| 13 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 33 | Radical surgery | Yes | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 54 Gy/tumor bed boost |
| 14 | MB | Posterior cranial fossa | 20 | Radical surgery | – | Yes | 36 Gy/craniospinal axis, 54 Gy/tumor bed boost |
AE anaplastic ependymoma, CSI craniospinal irradiation, CTH chemotherapy, MB medulloblastoma, PNET primitive neuroectodermal tumor, RTH radiotherapy
Treatment of the recurrence in particular patients
| Patient | Time to recurrence (months) | Location of recurrence | ECOG at recurrence | Surg. | CTH | RT* | TD RT (Gy) | SRS/SRT TD (Gy) | Treatment effect | Follow-up (months) | Last control status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 10.1 | Temporal lobe, out-of-field of initial RT boost | 1 | – | Yes (3 types) | Yes | 36 Gy on craniospinal axis + 54 Gy tumor boost | 10.0 | CR | 13.3 | Dead |
| 2 | 6.2 | Frontal lobe, out-of-field of initial RT boost | 1 | – | Yes (1 type) | – | 15.0 | SD | 15.2 | Dead | |
| 3 | 31.4 | Frontal lobe, out-of-field of initial RT boost | 1 | – | Yes (4 types) | – | 15.0 | N/A | 3.8 | Dead | |
| 4 | 17.3 | Frontal lobe, out-of-field of initial RT boost | 1 | – | Yes (3 types) | – | 8.0 | N/A | 13.0 | Dead | |
| 5 | 28.5 | Posterior cranial fossa, in-field of initial RT boost | 0 | – | – | – | 14.0 | CR | 77.1 | Dead | |
| 6 | 10.5 | Posterior cranial fossa, in-field of initial RT boost | 1 | Yes | – | Yes | 36 Gy on craniospinal axis + 54 Gy tumor boost | 10.0 | SD | 26.5 | Dead |
| 7 | 3.4 | Posterior cranial fossa, in-field of initial RT boost | 0 | – | – | – | 12.0 | CR | 41.4 | Alive | |
| 8 | 16.0 | Frontal lobe, out-of-field of initial RT boost | 1 | – | – | – | 15.0 | SD | 7.7 | Dead | |
| 9 | 34.2 | Frontal lobe, in-field of initial RT boost | 0 | Yes | – | – | 15.0 | PD | 40.5 | Alive | |
| 10 | 27.9 | Parietal lobe, close to the field of initial RT boost | 1 | Yes | – | Yes | 30.0 in 2 Gy fractions | 15.0 | SD | 30.0 | Dead |
| 11 | 4.9 | Cribriform plate, close to the field of initial RT boost | 2 | – | Yes (2 types) | Yes | 20.0 in 2 Gy fractions | 6.0 | SD | 17.4 | Dead |
| 12 | 10.0 | Temporal lobe, in-field of initial RT boost | 0 | Yes | – | – | 15.0 | PD | 11.4 | Dead | |
| 13 | 8.9 | Posterior cranial fossa, in-field of initial RT boost | 0 | Yes | Yes (1 type) | – | 15.0/3 fx | PD | 2.9 | Dead | |
| 14 | 77.7 | Posterior cranial fossa, in-field of initial RT boost | 0 | – | – | – | 30.0/6 fx | CR | 6.7 | Alive |
CR complete regression, CTH chemotherapy, ECOG performance status, fx fraction, N/A data not available, SD stable disease, SRS radiosurgery, PD progression of the disease, RT conventional radiotherapy, Surg. surgery, TD total dose
*RT—four patients received conventionally fractionated radiotherapy as part of the treatment of recurrence (two of them, who were not irradiated previously, CSI) before SRS/SRT
Fig. 1Overall survival and progression-free survival
Fig. 2Survival curves according to patients’ performance status at the time of diagnosis of the disease
Fig. 3Survival curves according to patients’ performance status at the time of diagnosis of the recurrence
Publications on reirradiation after craniospinal irradiation [10–23, 25]
| Study | Number of patients | Doses applied in salvage treatment | 5-year overall survival | Toxicity of salvage treatment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rao AD et al. [ | 67 | 18.6–70.1 Gy (median 53.1), median fd 1.8 Gy | Median OS MB, 8.4 months; ependymoma, 20.5 months; whole group 5-year OS, 35% | 1 case of radionecrosis |
| Wetmore et al. [ | 38 | Mean TD of 38 Gy (range 18–54 Gy) | 5-year OS, 55% ± 14%; 10-year OS, 33% ± 16% (from the date of recurrence) | Increased incidence of necrosis |
| Bakst et al. [ | 13 | TD 30 Gy, fd 1.5 Gy | 5-year OS 65% (from the date of recurrence), 12 patients received CTH; median OS 37 months | 1 case of asymptomatic, in-field necrosis |
| Saran et al. [ | 14 | TD 30–40 Gy in 6–8 fractions | 5-year OS, 20%; median OS, 29 months | No toxicity. |
| Abe et al. [ | 12 | Median peripheral TD 20 Gy (normalization on isodose 50%) | 2-year OS, 33% ± 14%; 3-year OS, 25% ± 13% (all patients received CTH after SRT, 5 + PBSCT); median OS, 19 months | 1 case of brainstem edema, 1 patient died due to toxicity of CTH |
| Massimino et al. [ | 17 | 7 patients TD 20.2 Gy, fd 1.3 Gy, 3 patients TD 50 Gy | 10/17 received RT, all HD CTH ± PBSCT; for whole group: 5-year OS 20%, median OS 41 months | Not reported for RT |
| Bauman et al. [ | 14 | Not specified for MB | Median OS 11.5 months | No radiation necrosis |
| Chojnacka et al. [ | 6 | TD 40 Gy, fd 2 Gy | Median OS 17.5 months, 1 death during FU (83% alive) | No grade 3–5 toxicity |
| Milker-Zabel et al. [ | 20 | Mean TD 24 Gy (SRT) or 15 Gy (SRS) | 6-year OS, 35%; median OS, 73 months | No late toxicity |
| Patrice et al. [ | 14 | Median min. TD 12 Gy | 2-year OS 45%, 13 patients received CTH; median OS 10 months | No radiation necrosis |
| Padovani et al. [ | 5 | TD 28 Gy, fd 1.8 Gy | All: concomitant temozolomide, 80% alive after mean FU of 25 months | No neurologic toxicity |
| Bugulione et al. [ | 1 | TD 52.8 Gy, fd 1.2 Gy/twice a day | Alive after 18 months | No radiation necrosis |
| Keshavarzi et al. [ | 1 | TD 14 Gy in 1 fraction | Alive after 12 months | No toxicity |
| Privitera et al. [ | 1 | TD 24 Gy | CTH + bevacizumab died with disease after 35 months | No radiation necrosis |
| Cieślak et al. [ | 1 | TD 45 Gy, fd 1.8 Gy | Alive after 15 months | No toxicity |
CTH chemotherapy, fd fraction dose, FU follow-up, HD high dose, min. minimum, OS overall survival, PBSCT peripheral blood stem cell transplantation, RT radiotherapy, SRS stereotactic radiosurgery, SRT stereotactic radiotherapy, TD total dose