| Literature DB >> 30509254 |
Abhinav Acharya1, Shahrukh Khan2, Ha Hoang3, Silvana Bettiol4, Lynette Goldberg5, Leonard Crocombe1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Over the past two decades, there has been a decrease in dental diseases in Australia; however, the number of preventable dental hospital admissions has not diminished. This review reports on the factors associated with preventable dental hospital admissions in Australia.Entities:
Keywords: Australia; Dental; Hospitalisation; Oral health; Public health
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30509254 PMCID: PMC6278106 DOI: 10.1186/s12913-018-3733-2
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Health Serv Res ISSN: 1472-6963 Impact factor: 2.655
Search Terms
| Mesh Terms for oral conditions | Free text terms | Mesh terms for Hospitalization |
|---|---|---|
| Periodontal disease | Dental condition | Hospitalization |
| Periodontitis | Oral Condition | Institutionalization |
| Chronic Periodontitis | Adult Periodontitis | Preventable hospitalization |
| Temporomandibular Joint Disorders | Dental abscess | Emergency service |
| Dental caries | Oral abscess | Emergency Medicine |
| Jaw fracture | TMJ Diseases | Emergency Medical Services |
| Mandibular fracture | TMJ Disorders | Patient admission |
| Maxillary fracture | Temporomandibular Disorder | Patient readmission |
| Maxillofacial injuries | Oral cancer | Emergencies |
| Facial injuries | Oral squamous cell carcinoma | First Aid |
| Mouth Diseases | Tooth decay | Crisis Intervention |
| Halitosis | Dental decay | ER |
| Pulpitis | Tooth pain | Hosp |
| Tooth Avulsion | Dental pain | ED |
| Facial Nerve Diseases | Tooth fracture | Emergency Department |
| Trigeminal Nerve Diseases | Dental fracture | Length of stay |
| Facial Neuralgia | Maxillofacial injury | Emergency |
| Lingual Nerve Injuries | Oral diseases | |
| Mouth Neoplasms | Oral Manifestations | |
| Oral Fistula | Oral health | |
| Oral Ulcer | Endodontic Inflammation | |
| Oral Submucous Fibrosis | Pulpitides | |
| Ranula | Endodontic infection | |
| Salivary gland Diseases | Tooth Avulsions | |
| Xerostomia | Facial Nerve Injury | |
| Stomatitis | Facial Nerve Trauma | |
| Tongue diseases | Facial Neuropathy, Traumatic | |
| Oral Tuberculosis | Cranial Nerve VII Injuries | |
| Glossitis | Facial Nerve Avulsion | |
| Hairy Tongue | Tooth Luxation | |
| Tongue Neoplasms | Avulsed Tooth | |
| Sialadenitis | Tooth Luxation | |
| Aphthous Ulcers | Tooth Dislocation | |
| Herpetic Stomatitis | Dental implant failure | |
| Denture Stomatitis | ||
| Peri-implantitis | ||
| Root caries | ||
| Dental Fluorosis |
Quality appraisal of studies using Mixed Method Appraisal Tool
| Author and year | Are there clear quantitative research questions (objectives)? | Do the collected data address the research question (objective)? | Are participants recruited in a way that minimises selection bias? | Are measurements appropriate regarding the exposure/intervention and outcomes? | In the groups being compared, are the participants comparable, or do researchers take into account the difference between the groups? | Are there complete outcome data (80% or above), or an acceptable follow-up rate for cohort studies (depending on the duration of follow up)? | Overall quality score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tennant et.al., 2000 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | 1 |
| Smith et.al, 2006 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | 1 |
| Kruger et.al, 2006 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | 1 |
| Slack-Smith et.al, 2008 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | 1 |
| Slack-Smith et.al, 2011 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | 1 |
| Slack-Smith et.al, 2012 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | 1 |
| Verma et.al, 2014 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | 1 |
| Alsharif et.al,2014 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | 1 |
| Kruger et.al, 2015 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | 1 |
| Kruger et.al, 2016 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | 1 |
| Kruger et.al, 2016 [ | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | 1 |
Characteristics of studies and the summary of results
| Author, year, state | Number of hospitalised episodes/age | Classification for diagnosis of disease | Study design | Covariates | Summary of results | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reason for hospitalisation | Demographic factors | |||||
| Tennant et.al., 2000 [ | ICD 9 [mentioned as ICD (5200–5299)] | Cross sectional Retrospective | Aboriginality, Residency (rural and metropolitan), Age, Gender | Dental caries was the primary reason for hospitalisation in preschool and primary school children. | Out of total hospitalised cases, | |
| Smith et.al, 2006 [ | ICD- 10 AM | Cross sectional Retrospective | Age, Indigenous status, Residency (rural and metropolitan), IRSD, ARIA | The prevalence of hospital admissions due to oral conditions were: | Female (52.2%) were more hospitalised than male. | |
| Kruger et.al, 2006 [ | ICD- 10 AM | Cross sectional Retrospective | Age, Aboriginality, Residency, Gender, | The reasons for hospitalisation were | Out of total oral condition related hospital admission cases, 50.2% were male and 3.5% were aboriginal descent. | |
| Slack-Smith et.al, 2008 [ | ICD – 9 | Cross sectional Retrospective | Age, Sex, Birth weight, year of birth, SEIFA, Health insurance, Health region, Rurality, Maternal age group, Mother’s Indigenous status, Intellectual disability, Birth defect | The reasons for hospitalisation were | Children (0-5 years) accounted 3% of total dental hospital admission. | |
| Slack-Smith | ICD-9, | Cross sectional Retrospective | Indigenous status, Age, ARIA, Length of stay | Main causes of dental admission were: | 3.2% of indigenous children had dental related hospital admission as compared to 2.7% non-indigenous children. | |
| Slack-Smith | ICD-9 | Cross sectional | Age, Intellectual disability, Length of stay, Child year of birth, Sex, Mother’s Indigenous status, SEIFA, Health insurance, Mothers age group, Rurality, Health region, Birth defect. | Reasons for dental related hospital admissions; | Male gender (OR 1.14), low birth weight (OR 1.17), birth defects (OR 1.74), intellectual disability (OR 2.10), children of indigenous mother (OR 4.45), having public health insurance (OR 1.29), and rurality/remoteness (OR 2.29) had significantly higher odds of dental related hospital admissions. | |
| Verma | N/A | Cross Sectional | Age, Gender, timing of presentation | Causes for attending ED due to dental related cause: | Male (60.2%) had more dental presentation to ED than female (39.8%). | |
| Alsharif | ICD 10 AM | Cross sectional | Hospital area and type, Age, gender, Indigenous status, SEIFA, ARIA, Insurance status, Length of stay | Major categories of dental related hospital admissions: | 5% of total dental related hospital admission for this age group were indigenous children. | |
| Kruger | ICD-10 AM | Cross Sectional Retrospective | Age, gender, ethnicity, SEIFA, Indigenous status, ARIA, AR-DRG, Income, Housing, Education, Employment, Family structure, Disability, Transport. | The rate of hospitalisation due to preventable dental cause has been increasing significantly over the years. | 3.2 per 1000 people were admitted to hospital due to oral condition. | |
| Kruger & Tennant 2016 [ | N = 11,608 | ICD-10 AM | Cross sectional Retrospective | Age, gender, ethnicity, SEIFA, Indigenous status, ARIA, AR-DRG, Income, Housing, Education, Employment, Family structure, Disability, Transport. | Causes of dental related hospital admission: | Most patients for dental related hospital admissions were from least disadvantaged (27.9%, OR 60.04) and accessible areas (16.4%, OR 10.58). |
| Kruger | ICD-10 AM | Cross sectional Retrospective | Age, gender, ethnicity, SEIFA, Indigenous status, ARIA, AR-DRG, Income, Housing, Education, Employment, Family structure, Disability, Transport. | Causes of dental related hospital admissions: | 48% were male and 2.8% were aboriginal descent. | |
ICPC International Classification of Primary Care, AR-DRD Australian Refined Diagnosis Related Groups, ICD International Classification of Diseases
IRSD Index of relative socio economic disadvantage, ARIA Accessibility/Remoteness Index of Australia, DRG Diagnostic Related Group, SEIFA Socio-Economic Indexes for Areas, WA Western Australia
Fig. 1PRISMA flow diagram of literature search and paper selection process
Fig. 2Schematic diagram of preventable dental hospital admission: risk factors and preventive strategies