Histocompatibility and liver transplant outcome. Does HLA exert a dualistic effect?

An analysis of more than 500 liver transplants has demonstrated that HLA compatibility is associated with diminished allograft survival. Liver transplants with zero mismatches for class I and/or class II HLA antigens have shown significantly lower actuarial survival rates than transplants with one or more mismatches for these loci. In a group of 119 failed liver allografts from patients undergoing retransplantation, a higher incidence of failure due to rejection correlated with a lower degree of HLA compatibility especially for HLA-DR. In contrast, the incidence of liver transplant failures due to primary nonfunction was relatively higher with HLA-DR compatible transplants. Considering the role of HLA as a restriction element in cellular interactions during the immune response, these findings suggest that HLA compatibility may have a dualistic effect on liver transplant outcome. On one hand, HLA compatibility reduced transplant rejection--and on the other hand, it may enhance other immunological mechanisms leading to allograft dysfunction, particularly in patients at risk of developing recurrent autoimmune diseases or infection.