Michael Coffey1, Ben Hannigan2, Alan Meudell3, Mari Jones4, Julian Hunt5, Deb Fitzsimmons4. 1. Department of Public Health, Policy and Social Sciences, Swansea University, Wales, UK. m.j.coffey@swansea.ac.uk. 2. Cardiff University, Wales, UK. 3. Caerphilly Mind, Wales, UK. 4. Swansea Centre for Health Economics, Swansea University, Wales, UK. 5. Department of Public Health, Policy and Social Sciences, Swansea University, Wales, UK.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Mental health care is a complex system that includes social care organisations providing support for people with continuing needs. The relationship over time between decisional conflict, social support, quality of life and recovery outcomes across two time periods for people experiencing mental health problems in receipt of social care was investigated. METHODS: This is a mixed methods study comprised of a quantitative survey at two time points using measures of decisional conflict, social support, recovery and quality of life in a random sample (n = 122) using social care services in Wales, UK. In addition, 16 qualitative case studies were developed from data collected from individuals, a supportive other and a care worker (n = 41) to investigate trajectories of care. Survey responses were statistically analysed using SPSS and case study data were thematically analysed. RESULTS: Participants reported increasing decisional conflict and decreasing social support, recovery and quality of life over the two time points. Linear regression indicated that higher recovery scores predict better quality of life ratings and as ratings for social support decline this is associated with lower quality of life. Correlational analysis indicated that lower decisional conflict is associated with higher quality of life. Thematic analysis indicated that 'connectedness and recovery' is a product of 'navigating the system of care' and the experience of 'choice and involvement' achieved by individuals seeking help. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that quality of life for people experiencing mental health difficulties is positively associated with social support and recovery and negatively associated with decisional delay.
PURPOSE: Mental health care is a complex system that includes social care organisations providing support for people with continuing needs. The relationship over time between decisional conflict, social support, quality of life and recovery outcomes across two time periods for people experiencing mental health problems in receipt of social care was investigated. METHODS: This is a mixed methods study comprised of a quantitative survey at two time points using measures of decisional conflict, social support, recovery and quality of life in a random sample (n = 122) using social care services in Wales, UK. In addition, 16 qualitative case studies were developed from data collected from individuals, a supportive other and a care worker (n = 41) to investigate trajectories of care. Survey responses were statistically analysed using SPSS and case study data were thematically analysed. RESULTS:Participants reported increasing decisional conflict and decreasing social support, recovery and quality of life over the two time points. Linear regression indicated that higher recovery scores predict better quality of life ratings and as ratings for social support decline this is associated with lower quality of life. Correlational analysis indicated that lower decisional conflict is associated with higher quality of life. Thematic analysis indicated that 'connectedness and recovery' is a product of 'navigating the system of care' and the experience of 'choice and involvement' achieved by individuals seeking help. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that quality of life for people experiencing mental health difficulties is positively associated with social support and recovery and negatively associated with decisional delay.
Entities:
Keywords:
Mental health care; Mixed methods; Quality of life; Recovery; Shared decision-making
Authors: Alice Newton; James Downs; Helen Brooks; Angela Devereux-Fitzgerald; Laura Richmond; Neil Caton; Karina Lovell; Penny Bee; Mary Gemma Cherry; Bridget Young; Ivaylo Vassilev; Clare Rotheram; Anne Rogers Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2022-09-09 Impact factor: 2.908
Authors: Natalie J Maples; Dawn I Velligan; Eric C Jones; Erin M Espinosa; Robert O Morgan; Melissa A Valerio-Shewmaker Journal: Community Ment Health J Date: 2021-06-27