The addition of a metal overlayer to a semiconductor photocatalyst is a frequently used synthetic route to passivate the surface and, via the formation of a Schottky barrier, to enhance catalytic activity of the photocatalyst material. While it is known that Schottky junctions decrease recombination by charge separation, measurements of the depletion region dynamics have remained elusive. Here, we use ultrafast pump-probe transient photoelectron spectroscopy to measure material-specific dynamics of the Zn/n-GaP(100) system. Through photoemission measurements the Schottky barrier height is determined to be 2.1 ± 0.1 eV at 10 monolayers of total Zn deposition. Transient photoemission measurements utilizing a 400 nm pump pulse show that, after excitation, holes are transferred from n-GaP(100) to the Zn overlayer within a few ps, as evidenced by shifts of the Zn 3d and Ga 3d core levels to higher binding energies. Within the timescale of the experiment (130 ps) no carrier recombination is observed in the junction. Furthermore, a long-lived surface photovoltage signal is observed at times >1 ms after photoexcitation. This work further exemplifies the potential of transient extreme ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy as a material-specific technique for the study of heterojunctions.
The addition of a n class="Chemical">metal overlayer to a semiconductor photocatalyst is a frequently used synthetic route to passivate the surface and, via the formation of a Schottky barrier, to enhance catalytic activity of the photocatalyst material. While it is known that Schottky junctions decrease recombination by charge separation, measurements of the depletion region dynamics have remained elusive. Here, we use ultrafast pump-probe transient photoelectron spectroscopy to measure material-specific dynamics of the Zn/n-GaP(100) system. Through photoemission measurements the Schottky barrier height is determined to be 2.1 ± 0.1 eV at 10 monolayers of total Zn deposition. Transient photoemission measurements utilizing a 400 nm pump pulse show that, after excitation, holes are transferred from n-GaP(100) to the Zn overlayer within a few ps, as evidenced by shifts of the Zn 3d and Ga 3d core levels to higher binding energies. Within the timescale of the experiment (130 ps) no carrier recombination is observed in the junction. Furthermore, a long-lived surface photovoltage signal is observed at times >1 ms after photoexcitation. This work further exemplifies the potential of transient extreme ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy as a material-specific technique for the study of heterojunctions.
n class="Chemical">Gallium phosphide, a semiconducting material with an indirect band n class="Chemical">gap of
2.26 eV, has received much attention for its potential applications in
optics, electronics, and photocatalysis. Of particular importance for photocatalysis is the ability
of GaP to retain its original surface structure and electronic properties while
operating in an aqueous solution. While the basic photocatalytic activity of
untreated GaP is established, the already promising efficiency and stability of GaP
can be improved through the use of coatings of metals or semiconductors. In the earliest work, Au and Ag
films were deposited onto n- and p-type GaP wafers and the electrical properties
were characterized in the presence and absence of illumination with light. The experiments showed a marked
increase in photocurrent in these samples, as well as an increased resistance to
corrosion in solution when compared to untreated GaP samples. Subsequent work
focused on nanostructured GaP with a variety of dopant atoms, metals, and
semiconductor materials on the surface, leading to further improvements in catalytic
efficiency and stability.
To understand the effect of surface treatments on the cn class="Chemical">arrier lifetime and behavior
in the depletion region of GaP junctions with other materials, the work here
explores the Zn/n-GaP system using a high harmonic generation (HHG) based extreme
ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (XUV-PES) technique. In addition to the element, oxidation state, and
surface sensitivity afforded by the photoemission method, time dependent dynamicsare obtained by incorporation of a time-delayed UV/Vis laser pulse in conjunction
with the XUV probe pulse. This technique has been previously used to observe the
dynamics of electron transport in defect rich and defect poor TiO2 films
on p-Si(100) as well as Zn layers
on p-Si(100). Now, using the same
technique, the dynamics of surface charging by hole transport from n-GaP to Znare
observed. Observation of the Ga 3d and Zn 3d core levels allows for the
characterization of dynamics in both the GaP and Zn of the heterojunction in
real-time.
In this work the barrier height as a function of n class="Chemical">Zn coverage is determined by
monitoring the binding energy shift of the substrate Ga 3d as observed via XUV-PES.
Then, through the use of transient XUV-PES, material-specific changes in the surface
photovoltage of the Zn/n-GaP(100) system are observed in the overlayer (substrate)
through energy shifts in the position of the Zn 3d (Ga 3d). The electronic
properties, such as Fermi level pinning and carrier transport, which are observed
and discussed in the transient XUV-PES measurements, serve to further the
understanding of carrier dynamics within the depletion region of metal-semiconductor
heterojunction photocatalytic systems.
EXPERIMENTAL SETUP
The experimental appn class="Chemical">aratus used in these experiments has been previously described in
detail. Briefly, the appn class="Chemical">aratus
consists of a surface science chamber coupled to a laser and monochromator system
that provides narrow band XUV femtosecond pulses for photoemission electron
time-of-flight measurements. Ultrafast pulses are produced by a Spectra-Physics
Spitfire amplifier producing 2.7 W average power of 35 fs pulses centered at
800 nm and 1 kHz repetition rate. The amplifier is seeded by a Spectra
Physics Tsunami oscillator pumped by a 5 W frequency-doubled Nd:YVO4
continuous laser. The pulses from the amplifier are split into a probe beam, used to
generate the XUV radiation, and a pump beam that is frequency doubled to
400 nm for excitation of the GaP semiconductor material.
The 800 nm probe pulses n class="Chemical">are focused into a semi-infinite n class="Chemical">gas cell at an
intensity of 1014–1015 W cm−2.
The cell is filled with Argas at approximately 25 Torr pressure. Under these
conditions harmonics of the fundamental 800 nm light are produced from the
7th to 29th order, corresponding to 11 eV to 45 eV photon energy.
These photon energies are sufficient to bring about photoemission from the 3d core
levels of both Zn and Ga. The harmonics and residual 800 nm radiation impinge
upon a plane grating after the gas cell where they are separated. By changing the
angle of the grating, a single harmonic is selected to probe the sample. The
selected harmonic is reflected by a cylindrical and toroidal mirror, resulting in a
focused beam with a diameter of 0.2 mm. Any additional harmonics or the
800 nm fundamental are blocked by a slit at the entrance to the sample
chamber.
The pump arm is directed to a vn class="Chemical">ariable delay stage after being split from the probe
pulse to allow for time-resolved measurements. The 800 nm beam is passed
through a beta-barium borate (BBO) crystal to produce 400 nm radiation by
second harmonic generation. The resulting light is reflected from two 400 nm
high reflector optics, removing the residual 800 nm radiation. The remaining
light is focused by a lens and reflected onto the sample by a silver mirror located
slightly above the XUV beam immediately before the sample chamber, resulting in a
pump spot with 1 mm diameter at the sample.
The UHV end chamber is equipped with tools for preparation and characterization of
surfaces. Among these are an Ar+ ion gun, used to clean the
GaP(100) sample, a Zn oven, used to deposit the Zn film onto the GaP, and an Auger
spectrometer for characterizing surface composition and coverage. Photoelectrons are
collected and analyzed by a time-of-flight photoelectron spectrometer (TOF-PES) with
a 1 m long double-walled μ-metal inner tube and a
microchannel plate (MCP) detector at the end of the drift region. The signal is then
acquired via a 5 GHz multichannel scaler unit.The n-GaP(100) crystal used in this study is a bulk n class="Chemical">single crystal, grown by the
Czochralski method, that was purchased from MTI corporation. Before Zn deposition,
the n-GaP(100) film was cleaned using the argon gun with a filament emission current
of 20 mA and a beam voltage of 3 kV for 10 min. Rounds of
cleaning were repeated until an Auger electron spectroscopy spectrum of the bare
n-GaP film presented only phosphorus and gallium peaks. Through atomic force
microscopy imaging (supplementary
material Fig. S1) the RMS roughness value was
found to be 0.95 nm and 1.6 nm for an unsputtered and sputtered
sample, respectively. The Zn films were grown by evaporation of zinc metal from a
homebuilt evaporator. Briefly, the evaporator consists of a 4 cm long,
0.5 mm in diameter Ta filament wrapped around a piece of Zn metal. A current
of approximately 2.80 A is applied to the Ta filament, which results in
resistive heating of the filament and heating of the zinc. Due to the difference in
Ta and Zn evaporation temperatures no Ta is observed on the sample after Zn
deposition. Under these deposition conditions the Zn is found to deposit at a rate
of 1.4 min/monolayer (see supplementary
material Figs. 2 and 3). In this work no attempt
is made at determination of the growth mechanism. Photoemission spectroscopy
measurements of the junction system were recorded with the sample at a nominal
temperature of 25 °C.
The sample is typically positioned 5 mm away from the entrance of the TOF-PES
with the sample-surface-normal pn class="Chemical">arallel to the spectrometer axis. This results in a
laser beam incidence angle of 45° with respect to the surface normal. The
sample position can be reproduced with an accuracy of 0.02 mm and
0.5°. The base pressure of the chamber is typically
2 × 10−10 Torr and rises to
7 × 10−10 Torr when the sample
chamber is opened to the beamline, due to residual Argas from the HHG cell. The
calibration of the energy scale of the TOF-PES is checked by acquiring photoelectron
spectra at 3 adjacent harmonics, which are known to be spaced by 3.1 eV.
Thus, the features in each PES are expected to also be spaced by 3.1 eV,
giving an internal calibration standard. The angular acceptance of electrons in the
TOF is 4° to either side of the surface normal, giving a total acceptance of
8°. Typical static photoemission spectra consist of an average of the
collected photoemission spectra of 500 000 laser pulses. To efficiently
acquire time-resolved data, each spectrum acquired in a transient measurement is
composed of 180 000 laser pulses. In a transient PES experiment, time points
between −5 to 5 ps are collected with 1 ps steps, while points outside this
region are collected with approximately 20 ps steps. Cross correlation measurements
of the pump and probe pulses by the laser assisted photoelectric effect (LAPE) gave
an instrument response function of 80 fs for this experiment.
The photoemisn class="Chemical">sion spectrum of cleann-n class="Chemical">GaP, recorded using the 27th harmonic of the
nominal 800 nm fundamental from the Ti:Sapphire laser (41.9 eV photon
energy), is shown in Fig. 1(a). To avoid any
effects due to the generation of excited carriers by ambient light, all light
sources in the chamber were turned off and all chamber viewports were covered during
acquisition. All binding energies discussed herein are referenced to the center of a
Fermi-Dirac distribution,
which is fit to a spectrum of the tantalum clips holding the sample in place. For
the Fermi-Dirac fit, the distribution is convoluted with a Gaussian function to
account for instrumental broadening. The width of this Gaussian is only dependent on
the instrument, and it was determined to be 0.5 eV by previous work in our
group for this instrument.
FIG. 1.
(a) Photoemission spectrum and band structure of n-GaP(100). (b)
Photoemission spectrum and band structure of 10 ML Zn/n-GaP(100). (c)
Enlarged view of the valence regions of n-GaP and 10 ML Zn/n-GaP. Dashed
lines show the linear fit of n-GaP as well as the Fermi-Dirac fit for 10 ML
Zn/n-GaP(100). (d) Measured barrier height as a function of Zn coverage.
(a) Photoemisn class="Chemical">sion spectrum and band structure of n-GaP(100). (b)
Photoemission spectrum and band structure of 10 ML Zn/n-GaP(100). (c)
Enlarged view of the valence regions of n-GaP and 10 ML Zn/n-GaP. Dashed
lines show the linear fit of n-GaP as well as the Fermi-Dirac fit for 10 ML
Zn/n-GaP(100). (d) Measured barrier height as a function of Zn coverage.
The n-GaP photoemisn class="Chemical">sion spectrum shows two distinct features [Fig. 1(a)]. The first, a broad and multi-peaked
feature appears between −0.7 eV and −13.5 eV binding
energy. The observed features are in good agreement with the previously calculated
density of states for intrinsic GaP. The onset of this band, at
0.7 ± 0.1 eV below the Fermi level of the sample,
indicates that the conduction band minimum is located
1.5 ± 0.1 eV above the Fermi level. This value is
obtained by fitting to the zero-background rise of the valence band edge, with the
error bars representing a single standard deviation. The onset of the valence band
was found by a linear fit of the valence band edge. The value of the valence band
offset is where the linear fit intercepts the x-axis [see Fig. 1(c)]. The second feature of interest, located at
−20.7 ± 0.1 eV binding energy, corresponds to the
Ga 3d core level. For this feature, the Ga 3d core level was fit with a Voigt line
shape, with the error bars denoting one standard deviation. This peak location is in
agreement with previous measurements of n-type GaP and other semiconductors
incorporating Ga.
The spectrum of 10 ML n class="Chemical">Zn deposited onto n-GaP is show in Fig. 1(b). Deposition of Zn induces several changes in the observed
photoemission spectrum, with the foremost being the new, intense Zn 3d photoemission
feature occurring at −10.6 ± 0.1 eV binding
energy, as found by Voigt fitting. This feature is assigned to the 3d core level of
the deposited Zn overlayer, as discussed in previous work from our group and
others. While the Zn 3d
core orbital of bulk Zn is composed of two spin-orbit split components of
−10.2 and −10.3 eV, the resolution in our experiment is
insufficient to observe this splitting. Finally, it is clear upon comparison of the
clean n-GaP spectrum and the 10 ML Zn/n-GaP spectrum that the binding energy of the
Ga 3d peak shifts from −20.6 ± 0.1 eV to
−20.1 ± 0.1 eV. While the coverage of Zn greatly
diminishes the Ga 3d signal due to the short mean free path of the Ga 3d electrons
the peak is still visible. In a study of Zn deposition onto the GaP substrate (see
supplementary
material) it was observed that after forming a
monolayer the Zn atoms form particles. Thus, the coverage is not uniform over the
entire surface, allowing Ga 3d electrons to escape despite their short mean free
path.
The shift of the n class="Chemical">Ga 3d core level is related to the change in band bending upon
deposition of Zn and can be used to assess the Schottky barrier height, as outlined
in several previous studies. Briefly, the energy difference between the
valence band maximum of GaP and the Ga 3d core level is a constant value that is
intrinsic to the semiconductor [denoted as Ec-v in Figs. 1(a) and 1(b)]. The Ga 3d binding energy, referenced to the Fermi level of the
system, is known to shift with the bending of the valence and conduction bands.
Since the Ga 3d shifts with the valence band, the changing position of the Ga 3d
relative to the Fermi level, in conjunction with the known Ec-v value,
gives the energetic separation of the valence band and the Fermi level. By
subtracting this value from the band gap of GaP (2.26 eV), the separation of the Fermi level
and conduction band can be found, thus giving the Schottky barrier height. The band
diagrams for n-GaP(100) and 10 ML Zn/n-GaP(100) are shown in Figs. 1(a) and 1(b).
In Fig. 1(d) the measured Schottky barrier
height as a function of n class="Chemical">Zn coverage is displayed. For these measurements
photoelectron spectra were recorded sequentially at differing Zn coverages, followed
by fitting as described above. At 0 ML of Zn, the barrier height of
1.5 ± 0.1 eV corresponds to the native n-GaP surface
barrier to electron flow. As the coverage is increased, there is a clear shift of
the barrier height to lower values, followed by a rise of the value with increasing
Zn coverage. Such behavior has been previously observed for photoemission
measurements of other metal-GaP contacts using synchrotron radiation, and it is
explained by non-equilibrium effects that arise from the measurement
techniques.
Specifically, electron hole pairs are generated by interactions with photoelectrons
leaving the material or by direct excitation of the substrate by the XUV radiation,
which then segregate based upon the electric field present in the depletion region
of the semiconductor. In this case, this means that holes are shuttled to the
semiconductor surface, where they induce a long-lived photovoltage due to their slow
recombination. The result is an initial shift of the Fermi level to higher binding
energies at low surface coverages of Zn, giving a lower apparent barrier. This
effect is also manifested as a shift of the Fermi level to a lower than expected
value when compared to the reference (Ta sample holder) Fermi level. Such
nonequilibrium effects are removed as the metal thickness on the semiconductor is
increased, typically becoming negligible around 2 nm metal thickness. It should be noted that while
this effect is similar to the phenomenon of surface charging in photoemission in
non-metallic samples this effect arises purely from excitations of electron hole
pairs during photoemission. In the case of these experiments, the measured barrier
height at 10 ML (∼2.8 nm) of Zn coverage is used. This barrier height
is found to be 2.1 ± 0.1 eV, indicating that Zn
deposition induces a further 0.5 eV band bending in the n-GaP substrate,
which is consistent with the formation of a Schottky barrier in this system.
The noise observed in these measurements is attributed to the relatively small signal
of both the n class="Chemical">Ga 3d core level upon Zn deposition as well as the small signal of the
Fermi level. The fits to these small features lead to increased errors in the fits
used, thus giving the large error bars. Furthermore, while the position of the
sample can be well reproduced, errors in the measured quantities may result from
slight differences in the position or angle of the sample relative to the
spectrometer.
TRANSIENT XUV-PES
To assess the behavior of n class="Chemical">Zn/n-GaP junction under 400 nm illumination,
transient XUV-PES spectra are recorded for a series of pump-probe time delays. A
negative time delay indicates that the probe beam precedes the 400 nm pump
beam, while a positive time delay corresponds to excitation with the 400 nm
pump beam before the XUV probe beam induces photoemission. The spectra of 10 ML
Zn/n-GaP with XUV only, at −18 ps and +130 ps time delays are shown in
Fig. 2 for a 400 nm excitation density
of 2.5 mJ cm−2
(4.4 × 1020 carriers
cm−3).
While the carrier density was calculated assuming no attenuation by the
400 nm beam by the metal overlayer, studies have shown that as few as
10 nm layers of transition metals can attenuate the incoming radiation by
50%. This
effect is dependent upon the metal geometry on the surface as well as the metal
identity. However, even in
the 50% attenuation case the number of carriers excited by the 400 nm
radiation is still much larger than the doping concentration
(1018 cm−3) of the substrate.
FIG. 2.
XUV only spectrum (red) compared to −18 ps (blue) and +132 ps
(black) time delays for 10 ML Zn/n-GaP. The inset is an enlarged view of the
Fermi level region of each trace.
XUV only spectrum (red) compn class="Chemical">ared to −18 ps (blue) and +132 ps
(black) time delays for 10 ML n class="Chemical">Zn/n-GaP. The inset is an enlarged view of the
Fermi level region of each trace.
For all the following discusn class="Chemical">sion the features n class="Chemical">are fit as described in Sec. III. The difference between the −10 ps
time delay and XUV only spectra are found to show a slight shift, indicating that
the effect of the probe is minimal at negative (probe before pump) time delays. The
origin of this shift is discussed in further detail below. However, at +130
ps there is a clear shift of the spectrum to higher binding energies. In the spectra
there are three features of interest: the Zn 3d core level, Ga 3d core level, and
the Fermi level, which consists of electrons from the Zn overlayer. For all three of
these components a shift to higher binding energy is observed. The binding energy
shift of these features as a function of the pump-probe time delay is shown in Fig.
3. A figure with additional negative
timepoints is included in the supplementary
material.
FIG. 3.
(a) Transient traces for the binding energy shift of the Zn 3d core level
(red) and Fermi level (black). (b) Transient traces for the binding energy
of the Zn 3d (red) and Ga 3d (blue) core levels.
(a) Transient traces for the binding energy shift of the Zn 3d core level
(red) and Fermi level (black). (b) Transient traces for the binding energy
of the Zn 3d (red) and Ga 3d (blue) core levels.In Fig. 3(a) the transient behavior of the n class="Chemical">Zn 3d
core level (red) and Fermi level (black) are shown. The Zn 3d and Ga 3d core levels
were fit with a Voigt lineshape, while the Fermi level position was found by fitting
with a Fermi-Dirac distribution. While the intensity of the Ga 3d peak is diminished
under the conditions of the transient experiment the peak is still able to be
observed and fit by a Voigt line shape. Examination of the data shows that the time
scale of excitation is quite similar for both features. In addition to the similar
time-scales, the absolute magnitudes of the Zn 3d and Fermi level shifts for both
features are similar, with a shift of approximately 0.6 eV towards higher
binding energy compared to the static XUV only spectrum. In Fig. 3(b) the transient behavior of the Ga 3d (blue)
is shown in comparison to the Zn 3d (red). The Ga 3d core level shifts with a
similar magnitude and time to that of the Zn 3d core level and the Fermi level. This
indicates the dominant dynamic processes within the Zn overlayer and depletion
region within GaP are similar. In work performed by Kamada and coworkers on a
Cs/p-GaAs junction under continuous illumination, a similar trend was observed, with
both Cs and Ga core levels shifting by a similar magnitude and sign compared to the
unilluminated case.
To understand the processes responn class="Chemical">sible for the observed shifts, the behavior of the
n class="Chemical">Zn 3d and Ga 3d core levels will be considered first. It is clear from the
similarity of their dynamics that the process that modulates the Zn 3d binding
energy is also most likely responsible for the Ga 3d shift. The space charge region
of the material is negatively charged due to the n-type doping of the substrate.
Thus, holes are drawn towards the surface while electrons are shuttled into the bulk
of the sample. The net result is a lowering of the electron quasi-fermi level in the
Zn film and depletion region of n-GaP, which also reduces the band bending in n-GaP.
While electron accumulation occurs in the bulk of n-GaP, the probe depth of XUV-PES
is only a few nanometers, meaning that the results are mainly sensitive to the
depletion region of n-GaP. Thus, the dynamics observed are assigned to the trapping
of holes in the Zn layer, which also screens the electric field in the n-GaP
depletion region, decreasing the band bending. A schematic picture of this process
is shown in Fig. 4.
FIG. 4.
Band diagram of 10 ML Zn/n-GaP in the absence (solid lines) and presence
(dotted lines) of the 400 nm pump beam. Photoexcited electrons are
given as filled circles, while photogenerated holes are represented by empty
circles. Hole transport to the surface results in an apparent increase in
electron binding energy. Electron energy denotes the energy of electrons in
the junction.
Band diagram of 10 ML n class="Chemical">Zn/n-n class="Chemical">GaP in the absence (solid lines) and presence
(dotted lines) of the 400 nm pump beam. Photoexcited electrons are
given as filled circles, while photogenerated holes are represented by empty
circles. Hole transport to the surface results in an apparent increase in
electron binding energy. Electron energy denotes the energy of electrons in
the junction.
In the case of cn class="Chemical">arrier transport from the semiconductor to the surface layer it is
expected that the n class="Chemical">Zn 3d and Zn Fermi level should show similar dynamics, as observed
in a transient XUV-PES experiment from this laboratory on a 3.5 ML Zn/p-Si(100)
junction. It was observed in
that work that for excitation densities in which band bending in p-Si(100) was the
limiting factor, the Zn 3d and Fermi level shifted by a similar magnitude, while for
higher excitation densities the Zn 3d showed a larger shift than the Fermi level. In
both cases, the two features showed a similar time dependence. With this knowledge,
along with the 0.6 eV shift in binding energy, which is well below the
calculated band bending of 1.2 eV in the Zn/n-GaP junction, the dynamics
observed here support the assignment of the dynamics as being induced by the
transport of holes to the Zn layer after excitation, followed by a reduction in band
bending throughout the junction. It is clear from the collected data that the SPVsignal shows no change through the end of the delay ranged scanned, and thus no
attempt is made to assign a timescale for recombination. While a transient rise is
observed around time zero there is a 0.2 eV background shift when compared to
an unpumped photoelectron spectrum. Due to this background, which is discussed
below, the timescale for this initial rise is not assigned.
It is important to note that the pump-induced n class="Chemical">SPV discussed above is
fundamentally the same as the previous discussed probe-induced n class="Chemical">SPV
which influences the observed Schottky barrier heights (Sec. III). However, probe-induced SPV is only observed in the case in
which the substrate is strongly excited by the probe radiation. Here, the thickness
of the Zn overlayer was chosen to minimize probe-induced SPV in our experiments as
discussed in Sec. III.
Finally, as noted above, there is a clen class="Chemical">ar offset of the photoemisn class="Chemical">sion spectrum at
negative time delays relative to the XUV only spectrum of approximately
0.25 eV for all features. There are two possible explanations for this
behavior: pump space-charge effects and long-lived states excited by the
400 nm pump beam. Pump space charge effects can arise from the interaction of
photoelectrons induced by multiphoton absorption of the 400 nm pump beam and
the XUV probe induced photoelectrons. In these experiments, the total number of
photoelectrons induced by the 400 nm pump beam is kept below 0.05 electrons
per pulse through the time of flight to avoid these effects. For reference, the
number of photoelectrons induced by the XUV beam, which is the lowest stable number
of counts that can be obtained using this HHG source, is on the order of 0.2
electrons per pulse. Although the number of observed electrons originating from the
pump beam is 0.05 per pulse, the lowest energy electrons may not be observed at the
detector due to stray electric fields, which can influence their flight.
While pump-induced space charge effects can have a strong influence on the observed
trann class="Chemical">sient spectrum, at negative times it is expected that the photoemission spectrum
would shift to lower binding energies in the presence of space
charge. The observed shift
in this experiment at negative times is to higher binding energy, thus pump-induced
space charge effects are not consistent with the observed data. Furthermore, it is
expected that pump-induced space charge effects will lead to a rising increase in
the surface photovoltage shift before time zero over a period of 100 ps. In these
experiments the surface photovoltage before time zero is essentially constant over
this time frame, again indicating that pump-induced space charge effects are not
influencing the phenomena observed here.
The second posn class="Chemical">sibility, a long-lived surface photovoltage resulting from the
400 nm pump beam, is the more likely cause of this persistent shift, as
explained next. In our experiment, we observe that the SPV persists between probe
pulses, which are spaced 1 ms apart at a 1 kHz repetition rate,
implying a multiple millisecond decay of the SPV in the Zn/n-GaP system. While
previous studies of GaAs semiconductors and p-Si(100) junctions suggest that surface
photovoltage decays in these systems on the picosecond timescale, it is valuable to
consider the difference in band gaps between the different materials to get a
clearer picture of the dynamics occurring. For example, in the case of Zn on
p-Si(100), the band gap of silicon is 1.12 eV, and the Schottky barrier
height was found to be 0.725 eV. However, n-GaP has a band gap of
2.26 eV, and the Zn/n-GaP barrier height is 2.1 eV. It is known that
recombination in Schottky junction systems is governed by a modified thermionic
emission law known as the Schottky formalism where A is the
Richardson constant, β is 1/k,
φ is the Schottky barrier height, and SPV is the
measured surface photovoltage.
For similar Richardson constants and temperatures, it is clear that the main factor
determining the recombination rate is the barrier height. Since a wide band gap
semiconductor will likely have a higher barrier, it is then inferred that the recombination rate should
be significantly decreased for systems in which the semiconductor has a wide band
gap. For the wide band gap semiconductors ZnO and TiO2, surface
photovoltages have been observed to persist for milliseconds to seconds, depending
on surface conditions. It should also be noted that as the SPV
decays, the difference between Schottky barrier height and SPV becomes larger,
resulting in a lowering of the recombination rate over the barrier, limiting the
decay rate. This is suggested as the origin of the long-lived SPV observed in these
experiments.
It should be noted that previous studies have indicated that the interaction between
an electron leaving the surface and the electric field generated by n class="Chemical">SPV may have an
effect on the observed transient spectra. Specifically, the observed dynamics may show a SPV
present at negative time delays, as observed in the data here. However, this effect
will also cause a slow rise of the photovoltage shift at negative time delays, which
does not occur in the data. Thus, it is unlikely that a time-evolving electric field
effect in the sample is the origin of the observed shift. The characterized
transients relative to this shift are the only processes reported here.
CONCLUSIONS
In this work the photoexcitation dynamin class="Chemical">cs of a 10 ML n class="Chemical">Zn/n-GaP(100) system were
measured using a HHG based transient XUV-PES technique. XUV-PES spectra reveal that
deposition of Zn results in an additional 0.5 eV of band bending from the
clean n-GaP surface, giving a Schottky barrier height of 2.1 eV and showed a
1.5 eV surface barrier height in clean n-GaP. Transient photoemission
measurements, using 400 nm pump pulses, show that the Zn and Ga 3d core
levels and Zn Fermi level shift by approximately 0.6 eV to higher binding
energy and display similar dynamics. Such results are indicative of hole transport
from n-GaP into the Zn overlayer, resulting in a reduction in band bending at the
interface and a shift of the electron quasi-Fermi level to lower energy. These
findings contrast with the results obtained for studies of p-type Si with Zn in our
group, in which electron transport to the Zn layer was the dominant process. The observed dynamics also indicate
that there is a long-lived population of holes in the Zn overlayer, persisting for
over 1 ms after the initial excitation. This population is attributed to the
slowing of the thermionic emission process as the Schottky barrier is recovered
after excitation. Here, element-specific photoelectron signals are derived not only
from the deposited surface material, but also from the underlying semiconductor
elements in the junction. Therefore, this work shows the powerful possibilities for
element and material-specific XUV-PES measurements at junctions, providing for
future measurement of a wide number of heterojunction systems with photoelectron
spectroscopy on femtosecond and picosecond timescales.
Finally, the results of this study show both the promise and problems with
time-resolved photoemisn class="Chemical">sion at short timescales. While it is clen class="Chemical">ar that the
electronic structure of the sample can be probed in great detail using XUV
photoemission, and that short timescale dynamicsare well captured, the long
timescales associated with electron-hole recombination in this junction (and likely
in other wide-bandgap semiconductor-metal junctions) are not adequately measured.
This issue is due to the repetition rate of the laser, which in this experiment is
1 kHz, although it can be much higher in other tabletop laser-based
experiments, and due to the physical limitations of delay stages. While femtosecond
experiments have had success with narrow bandgap semiconductor systems, it is clear
that approaches with longer timescales, such as synchrotron-based experiments, may
be beneficial for systems with much longer lifetimes. Experiments with nanosecond
laser systems with repetition rates of 10–20 Hz may also prove useful
when coupled to an XUV source such as a helium lamp.
See supplementn class="Chemical">ary material contains AFM images
of the sputtered and unsputtered surface and Auger Electron Spectroscopy data
for the n class="Chemical">GaP/Zn depositions. An extended transient showing negative time points
is also included.
Authors: Shu Hu; Matthew R Shaner; Joseph A Beardslee; Michael Lichterman; Bruce S Brunschwig; Nathan S Lewis Journal: Science Date: 2014-05-30 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Anthony Standing; Simone Assali; Lu Gao; Marcel A Verheijen; Dick van Dam; Yingchao Cui; Peter H L Notten; Jos E M Haverkort; Erik P A M Bakkers Journal: Nat Commun Date: 2015-07-17 Impact factor: 14.919