| Literature DB >> 30383856 |
Sohel Ahmad1,2, Ihsan Ul Haq3, Carlos Cáceres1, Ulysses Sto Tomas1, Thilakasiri Dammalage1, Keke Gembinsky1, Hannes Paulus2, Marc J B Vreysen1, Polychronis Rempoulakis4.
Abstract
The olive fruit fly, Bactrocera oleae (Rossi), is the most important insect pest for the cultivation of olives worldwide. Considerable research efforts have been invested in the past decades to develop eradication or suppression tactics for use within an area-wide integrated pest management (AW-IPM) approach that includes a sterile insect technique (SIT) component. One of the major obstacles encountered in the development of SIT for olive fruit fly was the inferior quality of the mass-reared flies, expressed among others evident primarily by sterile males having a different timing of peak mating and a lower mating propensity in comparison with their wild counterparts. In this study we assessed the mating behaviour and mating compatibility of olive fruit flies originating from four countries of the Mediterranean region (Croatia, France, Italy, Spain) in walk-in field cages and post zygotic compatibility (expressed as % egg hatch) under laboratory conditions. Furthermore, we tested the hypothesis whether a hybrid strain (Greece (domesticated)/Israel (wild)) adapted to laboratory rearing conditions showed any mating barriers with all the four "wild" populations. Finally, we examined the effect of colonization on the mating compatibility of the four newly established populations over three consecutive generations. The results showed no pre-zygotic (mating barriers) or post-zygotic isolations (measured by egg hatch%) among the olive fruit fly populations from the four countries tested. Also, there was no evidence of mating barriers between the hybrid strain and the wild populations of the Mediterranean region.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30383856 PMCID: PMC6211715 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0206739
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Average number of homotypic and heterotypic matings recorded in mating compatibility studies in walk-in field cages using wild Bactrocera oleae populations from Croatia (Cro), France (Fr), Italy (It), and Spain (Sp), and a laboratory hybrid strain from Israel/Greece (Is/Gr).
The letter A indicates origin of first B. oleae strain and B indicates origin of second B. oleae strain. For the mating pairs, the first letter indicates the male insect and second letter indicates the female insect. The average numbers of replicated mating values of each combination are presented (8 replicate/combination).
| Strains | Mating pairs | Mating pairs | Mating pairs | Mating pairs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | B | AA | AB | BA | BB |
| It | Fr | 18.1±1.7 | 15.5±0.9 | 12.7±0.6 | 16±1.2 |
| It | Cro | 15.3±2.1 | 14.6±0.9 | 14.6±1.3 | 15.3±2.4 |
| It | Sp | 16.3±1 | 12.6±1 | 13.5±1.4 | 12.3±1.3 |
| Fr | Cro | 15.1±1.4 | 14.1±1.3 | 12.3±1.7 | 15.7±1.8 |
| Fr | Sp | 14.2±1.3 | 11±0.9 | 16±1.4 | 14.7±1.6 |
| Cro | Sp | 10.7±1.1 | 8.1±0.5 | 10.1±0.9 | 7.6±1 |
| Cro | Is/Gr | 13.3±0.8 | 16.1±1.3 | 17.1±1.3 | 11.2±0.8 |
| It | Is/Gr | 13±1 | 16.8±1.6 | 17.8±1.4 | 13.3±1.8 |
| Sp | Is/Gr | 10.7±0.9 | 8.3±1.2 | 11.1±0.9 | 9.7±1.6 |
| Fr | Is/Gr | 14±1 | 16±0.8 | 15.7±1 | 16±0.8 |
The ISI, MRPI, and FRPI indices as obtained during the field cage tests among wild olive fruit fly populations from Croatia, France, Italy, Spain, and the hybrid Israel/Greece strain.
| Combination | ISI Mean (95% CL) | MRPI Mean (95% CL) | FRPI Mean (95% CL) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Italy× France | 0.09(-0.03±0.14) | 0.07(-0.02±0.17) | -0.01(-0.14±0.12) |
| Italy× Croatia | 0.01(-0.07±0.09) | 0.001(-0.11±0.11) | 0.006(-0.13±0.12) |
| Italy× Spain | 0.05(-0.02±0.13) | 0.06(-0.04±0.17) | 0.08(0.008±0.16) |
| France× Croatia | 0.07(-0.001±0.14) | 0.03(-0.14±0.22) | 0.04(-0.21±0.12) |
| France× Spain | 0.03(-0.01±0.08) | -0.09(-0.21±0.01) | 0.07(-0.08±0.23) |
| Croatia× Spain | -0.005(-0.11±0.09) | 0.033(-0.03±0.09) | 0.13(0.008±0.26) |
| Croatia× Israel/Greece | -0.14(-0.22±0.05) | 0.01(-0.03±0.07) | 0.05(-0.02±0.13) |
| Italy× Israel/Greece | -0.13(-0.19±0.08) | 0.01(-0.10±0.07) | 0.02(-0.08±0.14) |
| Spain× Israel/Greece | 0.02(-0.05±0.11) | -0.04(-0.11±0.01) | 0.12(-0.03±0.28) |
| France× Israel/Greece | -0.03(-0.09±0.03) | -0.02(-0.12±0.07) | -0.03(-0.09±0.02) |
All the replicated (n = 8) combination values were evaluated in 95% CL.
Latency to mating pair of the couples [mean ± SE] in the walk-in field cage for heterotypic and homotypic crosses of five different populations of Bactrocera oleae.
| Populations | Mating combination | Latency |
|---|---|---|
| Croatia × Spain | Croatia × Croatia | 460.9±6.3 |
| Croatia × Spain | 442±6.2 | |
| Spain × Croatia | 451.0±8.8 | |
| Spain × Spain | 447.2±7.3 | |
| Italy × Croatia | Italy × Italy | 419.8±4.2 |
| Italy× Croatia | 411.4±3.7 | |
| Croatia × Italy | 418.4±4.3 | |
| Croatia × Croatia | 415.8±4.2 | |
| Italy × Spain | Italy × Italy | 413.4±5.4 |
| Italy × Spain | 416.7±6.7 | |
| Spain × Italy | 415.9±6.0 | |
| Spain × Spain | 418.1±5.9 | |
| France × Spain | France × France | 420.0±4.4 |
| France × Spain | 420.0±5.3 | |
| Spain × France | 422.1±4.5 | |
| Spain × Spain | 421.3±4.4 | |
| France × Croatia | France × France | 395.6±5.1 |
| France × Croatia | 405.9±5.3 | |
| Croatia × France | 404.3±5.2 | |
| Croatia × Croatia | 412.1±4.9 | |
| Italy × France | Italy × Italy | 402.3±4.9 |
| Italy × France | 394.7±5.0 | |
| France × Italy | 397.3±5.4 | |
| France × France | 387.0±5.5 | |
| Israel/Greece × Croatia | Croatia × Croatia | 295.2±6.7 |
| Croatia × Israel/Greece | 293.9±5.3 | |
| Israel/Greece × Croatia | 302.5±4.6 | |
| Israel/Greece × Israel/Greece | 305.6±6.8 | |
| Israel/Greece × Spain | Spain × Spain | 417.3±8.1 |
| Spain × Israel/Greece | 415.1±7.4 | |
| Israel/Greece × Spain | 416.2±10.0 | |
| Israel/Greece × Israel/Greece | 407.0±8.0 | |
| Israel/Greece × Italy | Italy × Italy | 310.4±7.3 |
| Italy × Israel/Greece | 304.9±5.7 | |
| Israel/Greece × Italy | 309.3±6.3 | |
| Israel/Greece × Israel/Greece | 307.4±7.6 | |
| Israel/Greece × France | France × France | 277.1±3.5 |
| France × Israel/Greece | 271.1±3.1 | |
| Israel/Greece × France | 273.9±3.2 | |
| Israel/Greece × Israel/Greece | 269.5±3.6 |
Fertility (% egg hatch) (mean±SE), for all possible mating combinations among four wild Bactrocera oleae populations originating from different geographical regions.
| Populations | Mating combination | Egg hatch (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Italy × France | Italy × Italy | 89.1±3.1 |
| Italy × France | 96.6±1.0 | |
| France × Italy | 91.5±1.1 | |
| France x France | 95.4±0.6 | |
| Italy × Spain | Italy × Italy | 87.2±2.1 |
| Italy × Spain | 85.1±3.5 | |
| Spain × Italy | 89.8±2.4 | |
| Spain × Spain | 81.3±4.8 | |
| France × Spain | France × France | 68.7±7.7 |
| France× Spain | 76.3±7.3 | |
| Spain × France | 72.9±5.2 | |
| Spain × Spain | 82.0±5.5 | |
| Italy × Croatia | Italy × Italy | 82.4±4.5 |
| Italy × Croatia | 76.1±6.7 | |
| Croatia × Italy | 86.1±3.3 | |
| Croatia × Croatia | 83.2±2.7 | |
| Spain × Croatia | Spain × Spain | 87.8±1.9 |
| Spain × Croatia | 73.9±3.7 | |
| Croatia × Spain | 82.7±1.1 | |
| Croatia × Croatia | 56.2±3.1 | |
| France × Croatia | France × France | 92.5±1.9 |
| France × Croatia | 74.8±5.8 | |
| Croatia × France | 89.7±3.8 | |
| Croatia × Croatia | 90.1±1.6 |