H Khalayleh1, G Lin2, H Kadar Sfarad2, M Mostafa2, N Abu Abed2, A Imam2, A P Zbar2, E Mavor2. 1. Department of General Surgery, Kaplan Medical Center (Affiliated to the School of Medicine, Hebrew University and Hadassah, Jerusalem), 76100, Rehovot, Israel. kraceve30@hotmail.com. 2. Department of General Surgery, Kaplan Medical Center (Affiliated to the School of Medicine, Hebrew University and Hadassah, Jerusalem), 76100, Rehovot, Israel.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: There is debate concerning the need for specialist neurosurgical transfer of patients presenting to Level II trauma centers with a minimal head injury (Glasgow Coma Scale ≥13) and a small non-progressive intracranial bleeding (ICB). METHODS: A retrospective chart analysis was performed assessing the outcomes of adult patients presenting with a minor traumatic ICB on initial CT scan (minimal subarachnoid hemorrhage; small-width subdural hematoma without shift; punctate cerebral contusion). Patients with extradural hematomas and those patients on antiplatelet or anticoagulant therapy were excluded from the protocol. RESULTS: Overall 291 cases were assessed (mean age 69.9 years) with 75% of cases presenting after a fall. There was deterioration of neurological status in 11 patients (3.8%) with 8 hospital transfers and 5 with an abnormal neurological examination (NE). Two patients with an abnormal INR and a worsening head CT were transferred without neurosurgical intervention. Of the 8 transferred cases there were 2 deaths (both >90 years of age with multiple comorbidities) with one craniotomy performed for a subdural hematoma (with full recovery). Three patients meeting transfer criteria were not transferred with one death (patient >90 years of age with severe dementia). The remaining 2 patients were discharged with normal neurological outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with a minimal traumatic brain injury and a non-progressive minor ICB may be safely managed in a Level II trauma center by an acute care consultant with neurosurgical consultation but without the need for neurosurgical transfer. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Retrospective analysis: Level IV.
BACKGROUND: There is debate concerning the need for specialist neurosurgical transfer of patients presenting to Level II trauma centers with a minimal head injury (Glasgow Coma Scale ≥13) and a small non-progressive intracranial bleeding (ICB). METHODS: A retrospective chart analysis was performed assessing the outcomes of adult patients presenting with a minor traumatic ICB on initial CT scan (minimal subarachnoid hemorrhage; small-width subdural hematoma without shift; punctate cerebral contusion). Patients with extradural hematomas and those patients on antiplatelet or anticoagulant therapy were excluded from the protocol. RESULTS: Overall 291 cases were assessed (mean age 69.9 years) with 75% of cases presenting after a fall. There was deterioration of neurological status in 11 patients (3.8%) with 8 hospital transfers and 5 with an abnormal neurological examination (NE). Two patients with an abnormal INR and a worsening head CT were transferred without neurosurgical intervention. Of the 8 transferred cases there were 2 deaths (both >90 years of age with multiple comorbidities) with one craniotomy performed for a subdural hematoma (with full recovery). Three patients meeting transfer criteria were not transferred with one death (patient >90 years of age with severe dementia). The remaining 2 patients were discharged with normal neurological outcomes. CONCLUSIONS:Patients with a minimal traumatic brain injury and a non-progressive minor ICB may be safely managed in a Level II trauma center by an acute care consultant with neurosurgical consultation but without the need for neurosurgical transfer. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Retrospective analysis: Level IV.
Authors: Toan Huynh; David G Jacobs; Stephanie Dix; Ronald F Sing; William S Miles; Michael H Thomason Journal: Am Surg Date: 2006-12 Impact factor: 0.688
Authors: Ziad C Sifri; Adena T Homnick; Artem Vaynman; Robert Lavery; Wesley Liao; Alicia Mohr; Carl J Hauser; Allen Manniker; David Livingston Journal: J Trauma Date: 2006-10
Authors: Anne C Mosenthal; David H Livingston; Robert F Lavery; Margaret M Knudson; Seong Lee; Diane Morabito; Geoffrey T Manley; Avery Nathens; Gregory Jurkovich; David B Hoyt; Raul Coimbra Journal: J Trauma Date: 2004-05
Authors: Brandon P Foreman; R Ruth Caesar; Jennifer Parks; Christopher Madden; Larry M Gentilello; Shahid Shafi; Mary C Carlile; Caryn R Harper; Ramon R Diaz-Arrastia Journal: J Trauma Date: 2007-04