| Literature DB >> 30344498 |
Abstract
Background: Some believe that Psychiatry relies solely on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). Some are not aware of the effort initiated by the Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) to propel the field to a new era of Medicine. Others are not acquainted with studies of Descriptive Psychopathology that can dissect symptoms and signs of mental illness and convert them into reliable clinical data for diagnosis and treatment purpose. This document is to bring keenness of the advances in research, translational or clinical, made in Psychiatry, and to encourage students, psychiatric residents, as well as psychiatric practitioners to integrate DSM/ICD, RDoC, and Descriptive Psychopathology into teaching and practice.Entities:
Keywords: DSM; ICD; RDoC; comparison; psychopathology; strengths and weaknesses; teaching and practice
Year: 2018 PMID: 30344498 PMCID: PMC6183547 DOI: 10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00484
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Psychiatry ISSN: 1664-0640 Impact factor: 4.157
Figure 1Flow diagram of the number of studies included and excluded. Adapted from Prisma: Moher et al. (1).
Summary of the main findings/suggestion or perspectives of studies/documents/perspectives selected as well as comments to clarify the idea that drives the necessity of integrating DSM/ICD, Descriptive Psychopathology and RDoC in practice and teaching of psychiatry.
| Berridge et al. ( | Role of dopamine in reward | Dopamine systems necessary for ‘wanting' | Anhedonia as a symptom might not only be |
| incentives, but not for ‘liking' | explained by the dopamine. | ||
| Berrios et al.( | The history of mental symptoms | Mental symptoms; complex reflexions of | Clinian should be able to distinguish symptoms |
| dysfunctional brain sites | that are noises or the one describing biological signals | ||
| Gordon ( | RDoC: Outcomes to Causes and Back | To establish statistical approach—Bayesian causal modeling | DSM knows the outcomes(observations) not the |
| causes (underlying disease processes) | |||
| Hengartner et al. ( | Outline the major limitations | DSM/ICD does not define distinct natural entities | Genetic research and the neurosciences failed to aid |
| of categorical psychiatric diagnoses | DSM/ICD diagnoses are not exclusive or exhaustive | psychiatric diagnoses or prognoses due to imposed limitations of | |
| DSM and ICD | |||
| Insel 2013 | Transforming Diagnosis | DSM diagnoses are based on clusters of clinical symptoms | RDoC gears toward precision medicine to |
| DSM diagnosis lack validity | diagnose and treat mental disorder | ||
| Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) will incorporate genetics, | |||
| imaging, cognitive science for a new classification | |||
| Kendell et al. ( | Examine the evidence of Zone of rarity | No appropriate statistical techniques, | Author concluded there is little evidence that |
| of mental disorders. Validity and | or clinical research strategies to determine whether there is | current psychiatric diagnoses are valid. However, does not | |
| utility of psychiatric diagnoses | Zone of rarity for mental disorder | exclude their usefulness | |
| Kirk et al. ( | Reliability of DSM | No credible evidence that DSM increases | The critic targeted DSM-III |
| reliability | |||
| Siegle et al. ( | Time course of emotional | Depressed individuals show atypically sustained | Suggests that depression is a disorder |
| information processing in | processing on emotional information processing tasks | characterized by sustained processing, | |
| depressed and nondepressed | (sustained pupil dilation) | a psychophysiological basis | |
| Taylor et al. ( | Beyond the DSM and ICD | Reduction of teaching the mental status examination | For Taylor, DSM/ICD approach patient care as a treatment mode |
| and descriptive psychopathology | with rapid diagnosis and pharmacotherapy | ||
| A skeletal view of psychopathology | |||
| Treadway et al. ( | Anhedonia in depression | Anhedonia in depression: | Anhedonia needs characterization, both |
| Decisional anhedonia | positively-valence affective stimuli | clinical presentation and biological basis | |
| biological studies: | |||
| Motivation and decision-making | |||
| Tyrer et al. ( | Comparison of DSM and ICD | DSM promotes research | ICD is more comprehensive than DSM |
| ICD better descriptions and definitions of disease | DSM is more accurate than ICD | ||
| Walter et al. ( | Biological psychiatry, third wave | Mental disorders are brain disorders | Biological psychiatry has to approach theories of the mental |
| constitution and insights of philosophy of mind (arts and science) | |||
| Woody et al. ( | Integrating RDoC into depression | Depression shares 2 RDoC domains | An integration of depression risk into cognitive, genetic, and neural models |
| research | Negative; Loss construct. Positive: Reward constructs. |
The thought behind the integration is multifaceted: from the origin of psychiatry as philosophy (Walter et al.), categorical diagnosis checklist (Taylor et al., Hengartner et al., Kirk et al.) to the integration of genetics, biology, immunology, physiology and experimental psychology (Woody et al.).
Note that regarding Gordon 2017 and Insel 2013 they are online access perspectives not published articles or book references.
Probabilistic relationships between diseases and symptoms.
The chapter on mood disorder from Sadock's is not precisely like the write up on pneumonia from Harrison's.
| Definition | Pneumonia is an infection of the pulmonary parenchyma | A large group of psychiatric disorders in which pathological moods and related vegetative and psychomotor disturbances dominate the clinical picture | |
| Pathophysiology | Pneumonia results from the proliferation of microbial pathogens at the alveolar level and the host's response to those pathogens | Disturbances in all four spheres: mood, psychomotor activity, cognitive, and vegetative | |
| Pathology | Initial phase is edema | Immunological Disturbance: Structural and Functional Brain dysfunction: Alterations of Sleep Neurophysiology: Thyroid Axis Activity: Genes: | decreased lymphocyte proliferation hyperintensities in subcortical regions premature loss of deep (slow wave) sleep blunted TSH* response to TRH* challenge solute carrier family 6 member 3, dopamine receptor D4 |
| Etiology | Bacteria, fungi, viruses, and protozoa | Acute stress responses involve activation of central and peripheral components of two interactive psychoneuroendocrine systems Physical, verbal, and sexual abuse and parental neglect Substance abuse | |
| Epidemiology | More than 5 million CAPS* cases occur annually in the United States | Lifetime prevalence estimates average 11.1 (range 8.0 to 18.4) in low and 14.6 (range 6.6 to 21.0) in high-income countries | |
| Clinical manifestations | Febrile with tachycardia and Cough | Markedly diminished interest or pleasure in all(anhedonia) | |
| Physical examination: | Tactile fremitus | Psychomotor Disturbances Fold often associated with depression: Veraguth's fold | |
| DSM-V criteria: | 1-Depressed mood most of the day 2.Markedly diminished interest or pleasure in all 3-Significant weight loss 4-Insomnia or hypersomnia 5.Psychomotor agitation or retardation | ||
| Diagnosis Clinical Diagnosis: Infectious Noninfectious | |||
| Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) Thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) Blood and urine toxicology screen Complete blood cell (CBC) count Blood alcohol level | |||
| Etiologic Diagnosis | Gram's Stain and Culture of Sputum | ||
| Treatment | Antibiotic managment | Serotonin reuptake inhibitor, electroconvulsive therapy | |
| Complications: | Respiratory failure | Suicide. Impairment of social functioning. Cardiovascular, metabolic syndrome | |
Adapted from Kaplan and Sadock (.
Thyroid Releasing Hormone.
Figure 2This diagram illustrates the concept of the integration. 1-The idea is to start the patient assessment by dissecting and analyzing his or her symptomatology. 2-An attempt will be made to fit the patient symptoms and signs into a diagnosis. 3-The third step is to attempt to understand the patient symptoms, probable DSM diagnosis (regardless a diagnosis) by using scientific data (markers, imaging, molecules, expected behavior, scores on standardized scales. 4-The process is dynamic between RDoC and DSM/ICD/ Descriptive Psychopathology. Adapted from Prisma: Moher et al. (1).