| Literature DB >> 30338297 |
Abstract
The author explores new directions of understanding the pathways of peer influence on adolescent suicidal behavior by leveraging quasi-experimental variation in exposure to peer suicidal behaviors and tracing the flows of influence throughout school environments and networks. The author uses variation in peers' family members' suicide attempts to deploy an across-grade level, within-school analysis to estimate causal effects. Key findings include a gender-specific pathway, whereby girls are affected by their female grademates' experiences with family member suicidality but are unaffected by their male grademates. These specific pathways allow novel approaches to be used that leverage the gender specificity of the influences within an instrumental variable analysis. The findings suggest large (gender-specific) peer effects on suicidal behaviors in adolescence.Entities:
Keywords: gender; peer effects; peer influence; suicidal behaviors
Year: 2017 PMID: 30338297 PMCID: PMC6190909 DOI: 10.1177/2378023117729952
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Socius ISSN: 2378-0231
Selected Descriptive Statistics, Add Health, Wave 1 (n ≈ 19,700).
| Variable | Minimum | Maximum | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Suicidal thoughts, W1 | 0.13 | 0.34 | 0 | 1 |
| Grade-level suicidal thoughts, W1 | 0.13 | 0.07 | 0 | 1 |
| Grade-level family suicide attempt | 0.04 | 0.04 | 0 | 1 |
| Same-sex grade-level family suicide attempts | 0.04 | 0.05 | 0 | 1 |
| Opposite-sex grade-level family suicide attempts, W1 | 0.05 | 0.05 | 0 | 1 |
| Black | 0.22 | 0.42 | 0 | 1 |
| Hispanic | 0.17 | 0.37 | 0 | 1 |
| Other race | 0.08 | 0.27 | 0 | 1 |
| Age (years), W1 | 16.13 | 1.72 | 12 | 21 |
| Male | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0 | 1 |
| Maternal education, W1 | 13.18 | 2.25 | 0 | 17 |
| Family income (×$10,000), W1 | 4.55 | 3.96 | 0 | 99 |
| Parents married, W1 | 0.70 | 0.42 | 0 | 1 |
| Family suicide attempt indicator | 0.04 | 0.21 | 0 | 1 |
| Friend suicide attempt indicator | 0.17 | 0.38 | 0 | 1 |
| Missing family information indicator | 0.34 | 0.47 | 0 | 1 |
| Grade 8 at W1 | 0.13 | 0.34 | 0 | 1 |
| Grade 9 | 0.18 | 0.38 | 0 | 1 |
| Grade 10 | 0.20 | 0.40 | 0 | 1 |
| Grade 11 | 0.19 | 0.39 | 0 | 1 |
| Grade 12 | 0.17 | 0.37 | 0 | 1 |
Note: W1 = wave 1.
Balancing Tests Are Consistent with Quasi-random Variation in Grademate Exposure.
| Fixed Effects? | Grade-level Family Suicide Attempt
| |
|---|---|---|
| None | School | |
| Black | .002 | −.000 |
| Hispanic | .000 | −.000 |
| Other race | −.000 | −.000 |
| Age, W1 | .001 | .000 |
| Male | −.000 | −.000 |
| Maternal education, W1 | −.001** | −.000 |
| Family income, W1 | −.000*** | −.000 |
| Married parents, W1 | −.003*** | −.001 |
| Parent is happy, W1 | −.001 | −.001 |
| Family member attempted suicide, W1 | .003 | −.002 |
| Friend attempted suicide, W1 | .001 | .000 |
| Missing family information indicator | .000 | .000 |
| School-level family suicide attempt | .486 | |
| Constant | .041*** | .016 |
| Observations | 19,752 | 19,752 |
| .027 | .277 | |
Note: Grade fixed effects controlled but omitted from the table. Standard errors are clustered at the school level. W1 = wave 1.
Regression Analysis Linking Grademates’ Exposure to Family Suicide Attempts and Own Suicidal Thoughts: Baseline Ordinary Least Squares and School-level Fixed-Effects Analysis.
| Variable | Suicidal Thoughts at W1
| ||
|---|---|---|---|
| No Fixed Effects | School Fixed Effects | School Fixed Effects | |
| Grade-level family suicide attempts, W1 | .120** | .093 | |
| Same-sex grade-level family suicide attempts, W1 | .180*** | ||
| Opposite-sex grade-level family suicide attempts, W1 | −.017 | ||
| Family member attempted suicide, W1 | .144*** | .143*** | .145*** |
| Friend attempted suicide, W1 | .164*** | .162*** | .161*** |
| Black | −.029*** | −.030*** | −.032*** |
| Hispanic | −.011 | −.013 | −.014 |
| Other race | .018** | .005 | .006 |
| Age, W1 | .006* | .008** | .007** |
| Male | −.045*** | −.046*** | −.041*** |
| Maternal education, W1 | −.000 | −.001 | −.001 |
| Family income, W1 | −.000 | −.000 | −.000 |
| Married parents, W1 | −.017*** | −.016*** | −.016*** |
| Parent is happy, W1 | −.032** | −.034** | −.032** |
| Constant | .060 | .042 | .048 |
| Observations | 19,725 | 19,725 | 19,413 |
| .061 | .068 | .069 | |
| 4.458 | 1.837 | 11.20 | |
Note: Additional controls: grade-level fixed effects, constant, indicator for missing family-level variables. Standard errors clustered at the school level. W1 = wave 1.
Regression Analysis Linking Grademates’ Exposure to Family Suicide Attempts and Own Suicidal Thoughts: Baseline Ordinary Least Squares and School-level Fixed-effects Analysis by Gender.
| Variable | Suicidal Thoughts W1
| |
|---|---|---|
| School Fixed Effects | School Fixed Effects | |
| Sample | Male | Female |
| Same-sex grade-level family suicide attempts, W1 | .083 | .230*** |
| Opposite-sex grade level family suicide attempts, W1 | .040 | −.050 |
| Family member attempted suicide, W1 | .163*** | .134*** |
| Friend attempted suicide, W1 | .143*** | .168*** |
| Black | −.040*** | −.026** |
| Hispanic | −.018* | −.009 |
| Other race | .010 | .000 |
| Age, W1 | .010** | .005 |
| Maternal education, W1 | −.002 | −.001 |
| Family income, W1 | −.000 | −.000 |
| Married parents, W1 | −.005 | −.028*** |
| Parent is happy, W1 | −.016 | −.045** |
| Constant | −.055 | .085 |
| Observations | 9,547 | 9,866 |
| .064 | .077 | |
| 1.258 | 7.629 | |
Note: Additional controls: Grade level fixed effects, indicator for missing family level variables. Standard errors clustered at the school level.
Instrumental Variable Analysis.
| Outcome
| Suicidal Thoughts
| ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sample
| Full
| Full
| Full
| Full
| Full
|
| Specification | Basic | IV | First stage | IV/FE | First stage |
| Grade-level suicidal thoughts, W1 | .096** | .361*** | .352* | ||
| Black | −.027*** | −.024*** | −.015*** | −.030*** | −.001 |
| Hispanic | −.010 | −.009 | −.006 | −.012 | −.003* |
| Other race | .017** | .015* | .007 | .006 | −.002 |
| Age, W1 | .006* | .006* | −.001 | .007** | .002* |
| Male | −.045*** | −.045*** | .001 | −.046*** | .000 |
| Maternal education, W1 | −.000 | −.001 | .000 | −.001 | −.000 |
| Family income, W1 | −.000 | −.000 | .000 | −.000 | .000 |
| Married parents, W1 | −.018*** | −.017*** | −.003* | −.016*** | −.001 |
| Parent is happy, W1 | −.031** | −.031** | −.001 | −.033** | −.002 |
| Family member attempted suicide, W1 | .144*** | .142*** | .003 | .142*** | .003 |
| Friend attempted suicide, W1 | .163*** | .161*** | .007*** | .162*** | .002 |
| Missing family information indicator | −.002 | −.001 | −.003* | −.001 | −.001 |
| Grade-level family suicide attempts, W1 | .331*** | .264*** | |||
| Constant | .054 | .026 | .096*** | .064*** | |
| Observations | 19,726 | 19,724 | 19,724 | 19,724 | 19,724 |
| .062 | .059 | .113 | .052 | .086 | |
| 24.65 | 10.45 | ||||
Note: Grade fixed effects controlled but omitted from the table. Standard errors are clustered at the school level. FE = fixed effects; IV = instrumental variable; W1 = wave 1.
Instrumental Variable Analysis: Use of Same-sex Grademate Instrument.
| Variable | Suicidal Thoughts
| |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full
| Full
| Full
| Full
| Full
| Full
| |
| IV/School FE | First Stage | IV/School × Grade FE | First Stage | IV/School × Sex FE | First Stage | |
| Same-sex grade-level suicidal thoughts, W1 | .493*** | .690*** | .518*** | |||
| Black | −.031*** | .000 | −.031*** | .001 | −.031*** | .000 |
| Hispanic | −.013 | −.000 | −.013 | .002 | −.014 | .000 |
| Other race | .005 | −.000 | .005 | .001 | .005 | −.001 |
| Age, W1 | .008** | .000 | .008** | −.002** | .008** | .000 |
| Male | −.015** | −.056*** | −.003 | −.055*** | ||
| Maternal education, W1 | −.001 | −.000 | −.001 | −.000 | −.001 | −.000 |
| Family income, W1 | −.001 | .000 | −.001 | .000 | −.001 | .000 |
| Married parents, W1 | −.017*** | .000 | −.017*** | .002 | −.017*** | −.000 |
| Parent is happy, W1 | −.032** | −.001 | −.033** | −.000 | −.033** | −.001 |
| Family member attempted suicide, W1 | .139*** | .007** | .140*** | .011*** | .139*** | .008** |
| Friend attempted suicide, W1 | .158*** | .007*** | .159*** | .002 | .159*** | .004** |
| Missing family information indicator | −.002 | .001 | −.002 | .002 | −.003 | .000 |
| Same-sex grade-level family suicide attempts, W1 | .283*** | .321*** | .286*** | |||
| Constant | .105*** | .168*** | .075*** | |||
| Observations | 19,655 | 19,655 | 19,655 | 19,655 | 19,655 | 19,655 |
| .045 | .177 | .010 | .215 | .029 | .068 | |
| 29.61 | 26.27 | 25.86 | ||||
| Number of schools, W1 | 144 | 144 | ||||
Note: Grade fixed effects controlled but omitted from the table. Standard errors are clustered at the school level. FE = fixed effects; IV = instrumental variable; W1 = wave 1.
Regression Analysis Linking Grademates’ Exposure to Family Suicide Attempts and Own Suicidal Thoughts: Nonlinear Analysis.
| Outcome
| Suicidal Thoughts
| ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Sample
| Full
| Male
| Female
|
| Fixed Effects? | School | School | School |
| Second quartile grade-level family suicide attempts (>0 and <0.04) | .008 | .014 | .002 |
| Third quartile grade-level family suicide attempts (>0.04 and <0.0625) | .005 | .010 | .002 |
| Fourth quartile grade-level family suicide attempts (>0.0625) | .012 | .007 | .020 |
| Black | −.030*** | −.039*** | −.025* |
| Hispanic | −.013 | −.020* | −.007 |
| Other race | .005 | .008 | .000 |
| Age, W1 | .008** | .011*** | .006 |
| Male | −.046*** | ||
| Maternal education, W1 | −.001 | −.002 | −.001 |
| Family income, W1 | −.000 | −.000 | −.000 |
| Married parents, W1 | −.016*** | −.005 | −.028*** |
| Parent is happy, W1 | −.034** | −.021 | −.045** |
| Family member attempted suicide, W1 | .143*** | .161*** | .131*** |
| Friend attempted suicide, W1 | .162*** | .145*** | .169*** |
| Missing family information indicator | −.002 | .000 | −.005 |
| Observations | 19,725 | 9,772 | 9,953 |
| .069 | .064 | .077 | |
| .745 | .614 | .883 | |
Note: Additional controls: grade-level fixed effects, constant. Standard errors clustered at the school level. W1 = wave 1.