N Tan1, J Acheson2, N Ali3. 1. Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, UK. n.tan@nhs.net. 2. National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, London, UK. 3. Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: GCA in the Indian Subcontinent (ISC) is rare. Our centre in London, UK, serves an ethnically diverse population, including a significant population of patients of ISC descent. We hypothesise that patients of ISC descent are no less likely than others to present with symptoms suggestive of GCA and therefore to undergo temporal artery biopsy (TAB). METHOD: A retrospective audit of all TABs performed at our institution over an 8 year period, to identify ethnicity (white, black, ISC, other, unknown) and biopsy result. We compared the proportion of all patients of ISC descent attending the ED to the proportion of ISC patients undergoing TAB. We compared the proportion of positive TABs among ISC patients with positive TABs among white patients. We also compared the proportion of TAB in ISC patients with all non-ISC ethnicities combined. RESULTS: The proportion of patients undergoing TAB who were of ISC descent (16.3% of 92) was comparable to the proportion of A&E attendances made up by ISC patients [p = 0.1339]. 3.8% (1/26) of positive biopsies were among patients of ISC descent. White patients were significantly more likely to have a positive biopsy than patients of ISC ethnicity (33% of 61 white patients vs. 7% of 15 ISC [p = 0.0456]), as were patients of non-ISC ethnicity (32.5% of 77 non-ISC patients vs. 7% of 15 ISC patients [p = 0.0464]). DISCUSSION: At our centre, biopsy proven GCA occurs in patients of ISC descent, but rarely. Full investigation for GCA continues to be appropriate where it is suspected, regardless of ethnicity.
BACKGROUND: GCA in the Indian Subcontinent (ISC) is rare. Our centre in London, UK, serves an ethnically diverse population, including a significant population of patients of ISC descent. We hypothesise that patients of ISC descent are no less likely than others to present with symptoms suggestive of GCA and therefore to undergo temporal artery biopsy (TAB). METHOD: A retrospective audit of all TABs performed at our institution over an 8 year period, to identify ethnicity (white, black, ISC, other, unknown) and biopsy result. We compared the proportion of all patients of ISC descent attending the ED to the proportion of ISC patients undergoing TAB. We compared the proportion of positive TABs among ISC patients with positive TABs among white patients. We also compared the proportion of TAB in ISC patients with all non-ISC ethnicities combined. RESULTS: The proportion of patients undergoing TAB who were of ISC descent (16.3% of 92) was comparable to the proportion of A&E attendances made up by ISC patients [p = 0.1339]. 3.8% (1/26) of positive biopsies were among patients of ISC descent. White patients were significantly more likely to have a positive biopsy than patients of ISC ethnicity (33% of 61 white patients vs. 7% of 15 ISC [p = 0.0456]), as were patients of non-ISC ethnicity (32.5% of 77 non-ISC patients vs. 7% of 15 ISC patients [p = 0.0464]). DISCUSSION: At our centre, biopsy proven GCA occurs in patients of ISC descent, but rarely. Full investigation for GCA continues to be appropriate where it is suspected, regardless of ethnicity.
Authors: Imtiaz A Chaudhry; Farrukh A Shamsi; Elsanusi Elzaridi; Yonca O Arat; Thomas M Bosley; Fenwick C Riley Journal: Br J Ophthalmol Date: 2007-01-17 Impact factor: 4.638