| Literature DB >> 30276675 |
Henri M de Bakker1, Gijsbrecht H J Roelandt2,3, Vidija Soerdjbalie-Maikoe4, Rick R van Rijn2,4,5, Bernadette S de Bakker6.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Fire deaths are challenging fatalities for forensic pathologists, as the main question of whether death was due to the fire or not needs to be answered. In this retrospective study, we assessed whether post-mortem computed tomography (PMCT) has an added value prior to a forensic autopsy of burned victims.Entities:
Keywords: Burns; Forensic medicine; Forensic pathology; Radiology
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30276675 PMCID: PMC6420456 DOI: 10.1007/s00330-018-5731-5
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Eur Radiol ISSN: 0938-7994 Impact factor: 5.315
Causes of death based on the autopsy reports
| Cause of death | Specifics of cause of death | Certainty of cause of death |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-mortem fire effects (n = 31) | - CO intoxication (n = 21) | Cause of death might have been influenced by blunt force in one case and by drugs and asphyxiation in another case |
| Fatal neck pressure (strangulation) or airway obstruction (smothering) (n = 4) | - Strangulation (n = 3) | In all cases cause of death was certain |
| External blunt force trauma (n = 4) | - Beating (n = 3) | In one case asphyxiation might have contributed to the death due to swelling caused by the beating |
| Penetrating injury (n = 6) | - Stab/cut injuries (n = 3) | In all cases the cause of death was certain |
| Organ disease (n = 1) | - Heart failure (n = 1) | The cause of death was certain |
| Unknown (n = 4) | - Death due to thermal damage was likely, but could not be diagnosed for certain | Forensic autopsy could not determine cause of death |
Findings using PMCT in burned victims
| Cases a | Specifics of damage | Causes of damage | Other findings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cranial/facial burns (n = 24) | Thermal soft tissue defects without skeletal damage: (n = 4) | All caused by fire | Damaged cerebrum and cerebellum (n = 17) |
| Thermal soft tissue defects with skeletal damage: (n = 9) | Bone damage caused by: | ||
| Thermal soft tissue defects with loss of skeletal structures: (n = 11) | Impossible to determine c | ||
| Skeletal damage without thermal soft tissue defects: (n = 3) | Bone damage caused by: | ||
| Neck burns (n = 23) | Thermal soft tissue defects without skeletal damage: (n = 10) | All caused by fire | Fractured spinal column (n = 3) |
| Thermal soft tissue defects with skeletal damage: (n = 5) | Bone damage caused by: | ||
| Thermal soft tissue defects with loss of skeletal structures: (n = 8) | Impossible to determine | ||
| Skeletal damage without thermal soft tissue defects: (n = 7) | Bone damage caused by: | ||
| Soft tissue defects not caused by fire: (n = 5) | Swelling (n = 2) | ||
| Thorax burns (n = 32) | Thermal soft tissue defects without skeletal damage: (n = 8) | All caused by fire | Fluid in chest cavity (n = 19, of which 16 cases concerned blood) |
| Thermal soft tissue defects with rib fracture: (n = 5) | Bone damage caused by: | ||
| Thermal soft tissue defects with loss of rib structures: (n = 19) | Impossible to determine | ||
| Rib damage without thermal soft tissue defects: (n = 5) | Bone damage caused by: | ||
| Abdomen burns (n = 34) | Thermal damage without an opening to the abdominal cavity: (n = 15) | All caused by fire | Air inside organs (n = 19) |
| Thermal soft tissue defects with an opening to the abdominal cavity: (n = 19) | Burned organs: | ||
| Damage to internal organs not related to burns: (n = 6) | Liver (n = 1) ballistic trauma | ||
| Upper extremity burns (n = 40) | Thermal soft tissue defects without skeletal damage: (n = 17) | All caused by fire | Pugilistic attitude (n = 21) |
| Thermal soft tissue defects with skeletal damage: (n = 3) | All caused by fire | ||
| Thermal soft tissue defects with loss of skeletal structures: (n = 20) | Impossible to determine | ||
| Lower extremity burns (n=36) | Thermal soft tissue defects without skeletal damage: (n = 19) | All caused by fire | Thermal amputation (n = 15) |
| Thermal soft tissue defects with skeletal damage: (n = 2) | All caused by fire | ||
| Thermal soft tissue defects with loss of skeletal structures: (n = 15) | Impossible to determine | ||
| Skeletal damage without thermal soft tissue defects: (n = 1) | Blunt force |
aMultiple affected body regions can be present in one case
bBlunt force was seen as the cause of damage when no soft tissue defects matching thermal or penetrating injury was found
cDue to the extent of fire damage caused to the area it is impossible to determine if other forces were applied
dA fracture was designated as old when a callus was present
Fig. 1Typical post-mortem CT findings in the head exposed to fire. a, b Axial images. In both cases, a dural tear and herniated brain tissue can be seen (single arrow). The case in (b) shows also an intracranial heat haematoma (double arrow). c Picture of an opened skull with heat haematoma (arrows) during autopsy. d, e Axial images. In both cases, heat fractures can be seen in the outer table (arrows) on locations where all soft tissue are burned away, resulting in separation of inner and outer table (split diploë sign). The case in (e) shows also a bilateral intracranial heat haematoma; *air-fluid level. f Enlarged section of (e). The arrows indicate the split diploë sign
Fig. 2Radiology of the explanted hyoid-larynx complex from a body exposed to fire. a X-ray shows fractures of the hyoid bone body and the greater horn on the right side (arrows). b Same case as in (a). Axial CT image of the body and greater horns of the hyoid bone. The fracture of the hyoid body is indicated by the white arrow. Histology showed haematomas at the fracture sites, which indicate that the person was alive when trauma to the neck was sustained
Fig. 3Examples of dense border sign on CT and at autopsy. a Axial image of a burned thorax. A ‘dense border sign’ can be seen at the surface of the lung that was exposed to fire (arrows). This is due to shrinkage and loss of fluid of the exposed tissue [3]. Note how the lungs are relatively intact in contrast to the absent burned surrounding structures. b Pathological specimen of the lung from the case presented in (a), showing a partly burned surface (arrows) that was in direct contact with the fire. c Axial image of a burned abdomen. A subtle dense border sign can be seen at part of the liver surface that was exposed to fire (arrows). See (d) for the pathological specimen of this case. d Pathological specimen of the liver from the case presented in (c), showing a partly burned surface (arrow) that was in direct contact with the fire, and a relatively normal part of the liver that was covered and protected from the fire by the body wall
Fig. 4Drug packages in a burned body. a Axial image of a body almost completely destructed by fire. Note the relative sparing of the drug packages (arrows). b Reconstructed sagittal image of the same case as in (a). Drug packages are indicated by arrows. c Image taken during autopsy of the carbonised body of the victim presented in (a) and (b). Note the light-coloured foreign body as small detail in the blackened tissue at autopsy. d Overview of the relatively unharmed drug packages that were recovered from the carbonised body presented in (a–c) during autopsy
Fig. 5Typical proximal displacement of the patella in the left knee exposed to fire. a Anteroposterior 3D reconstruction of a CT of the lower extremities of a body exposed to fire, presenting patellar displacement. b Enlarged part of the 3D-CT scan in (a). Note the proximal displacement of the patella of the left knee (arrow). The patellar ligament is burned through or ruptured by the force of the shrinking rectus femoris muscle. c The proximally displaced and blackened left patella (black arrow) could be identified at autopsy. Its normal location is indicated by the dashed arrow. Typical flexing of the joints in legs and feet that were exposed to fire can be appreciated. Note also the coverage of the right patella by soft tissues, which prevents the patella from proximal displacement
Fig. 6Example of mottled lucencies in a burned body. a Axial image of the pubic bone, scanned in prone position as it was found at the crime scene. The left side of the pubic bone, not covered by soft tissues, contains mottled lucencies inside of the bone (arrow), whereas the right pubic bone appears normal [3]. b The same case as in (a) at autopsy. Ventral view of the pelvic region. Forearms and hands are also visible. The partially intact abdominal skin of the victim suggests a prone position during the fire. Note the heavily burned left groin (arrow) compared to the right groin that is still more or less covered by soft tissues