Joel Lexchin1. 1. School of Health Policy and Management, York University; University Health Network; Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont. jlexchin@yorku.ca.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The independent French drug bulletin, La revue Prescrire (henceforth Prescrire), annually releases a list of drugs to avoid. The aim of this analysis was to review the status of the 2017 list of drugs in Canada to determine whether they had been approved for marketing, their therapeutic status and whether they have been recommended for listing on public drug plans. METHODS: This descriptive analysis reviewed a list of drugs compiled by Prescrire. The status of each drug in Canada was assessed through the Drug Product Database. Therapeutic ratings were obtained from the Patented Medicine Prices Review Board (PMPRB) and the formulary listing recommendation came from the Common Drug Review (CDR) or the pan-Canadian Oncology Drug Review (pCODR). For drugs without a formulary recommendation the Ontario Drug Benefit (ODB) Formulary was searched to see if the product was listed. RESULTS: Prescrire recommended not using 92 drugs. The PMPRB evaluated 36 of these drugs; 2 were classed as substantial improvements or breakthroughs, 3 as moderate improvements and 31 as little or no therapeutic improvement. Nine of the remaining drugs that were approved in Canada were not assessed because they were approved before 1988 (the year the PMPRB was established), 4 were approved from December 2015 onward and had not yet been reviewed by the PMPRB, and for 1 the approval date was unknown. Twenty-six of the drugs were evaluated by CDR or pCODR, of which 13 were recommended for formulary listing. Sixteen additional drugs that were not evaluated were on the ODB Formulary. INTERPRETATION: Many drugs that Prescrire recommended avoiding were available in Canada. The results also highlight the diversity of the conclusions that different expert panels have reached. Copyright 2018, Joule Inc. or its licensors.
BACKGROUND: The independent French drug bulletin, La revue Prescrire (henceforth Prescrire), annually releases a list of drugs to avoid. The aim of this analysis was to review the status of the 2017 list of drugs in Canada to determine whether they had been approved for marketing, their therapeutic status and whether they have been recommended for listing on public drug plans. METHODS: This descriptive analysis reviewed a list of drugs compiled by Prescrire. The status of each drug in Canada was assessed through the Drug Product Database. Therapeutic ratings were obtained from the Patented Medicine Prices Review Board (PMPRB) and the formulary listing recommendation came from the Common Drug Review (CDR) or the pan-Canadian Oncology Drug Review (pCODR). For drugs without a formulary recommendation the Ontario Drug Benefit (ODB) Formulary was searched to see if the product was listed. RESULTS: Prescrire recommended not using 92 drugs. The PMPRB evaluated 36 of these drugs; 2 were classed as substantial improvements or breakthroughs, 3 as moderate improvements and 31 as little or no therapeutic improvement. Nine of the remaining drugs that were approved in Canada were not assessed because they were approved before 1988 (the year the PMPRB was established), 4 were approved from December 2015 onward and had not yet been reviewed by the PMPRB, and for 1 the approval date was unknown. Twenty-six of the drugs were evaluated by CDR or pCODR, of which 13 were recommended for formulary listing. Sixteen additional drugs that were not evaluated were on the ODB Formulary. INTERPRETATION: Many drugs that Prescrire recommended avoiding were available in Canada. The results also highlight the diversity of the conclusions that different expert panels have reached. Copyright 2018, Joule Inc. or its licensors.