| Literature DB >> 30233222 |
Laura Amanda Vallejo-Aparicio1, Germán Peces-Barba2, Alicia Gil3, Alicia Huerta Hernandez1.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: The Salford Lung Study in Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (SLS COPD) is a 12-month, open-label randomized clinical trial comparing clinical effectiveness and safety of initiating once-daily fluticasone furoate/vilanterol (FF/VI) 92/22 mcg with continuing usual care (UC) in patients with COPD followed in primary care in the UK. The objective of this analysis is to estimate the economic impact of these results when applied to Spain.Entities:
Keywords: COPD; COPD Salford Lung Study; cost–consequence analysis; fluticasone furoate/vilanterol
Year: 2018 PMID: 30233222 PMCID: PMC6132231 DOI: 10.2147/CEOR.S169154
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clinicoecon Outcomes Res ISSN: 1178-6981
Figure 1Economic model structure.
Abbreviation: FF/VI, fluticasone furoate/vilanterol.
Figure 2Spanish COPD target population estimation.
Model inputs for base-case analysis
| Variables | UC group | FF/VI 92/22 mcg group |
|---|---|---|
| Mean annual rate of moderate/severe exacerbations | 1.64 | 1.50 |
| Monthly drug costs | €57.29 | €51.52 |
| Annual drug costs | €697.03 | €626.83 |
| Assumed proportion of days covered, % | 100 | 100 |
| Assumed current uptake, % | 96 | 4 |
| Assumed new uptake, % | 90 | 10 |
| Distribution of exacerbations, % (mean, rate) | ||
| Moderate | 95 (1.56) | 94 (1.41) |
| Severe | 5 (0.08) | 6 (0.09) |
| Cost of exacerbation management | ||
| Moderate | €365.78 | €365.78 |
| Severe | €960.18 | €960.18 |
Notes:
Based on ITT population data;
UC cost calculated as an average drug cost at Price to Public plus Value Added Tax;
Price to Public plus Value Added Tax of FF/VI 92/22 mcg;
Serious adverse events of pneumonia were excluded from the analysis as its incidence was similar between treatment groups in the Salford Lung Study in COPD.5
Abbreviations: UC, usual care; FF/VI, fluticasone furoate/vilanterol; ITT, intent to treat.
Detail of retail prices used for UC arm monthly cost estimation
| Active ingredient | Brand name | Strength and pack size | Cost per pack PTP + VAT (€) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Propionate Fluticasone | Flixotide Accuhaler® | 500 mcg × 60 doses | €31.47 |
| 100 mcg × 60 doses | €14.11 | ||
| Flixotide® | 250 mcg × 120 doses | €31.47 | |
| 50 mcg × 120 doses | €14.11 | ||
| Fluticasona Cipla® | 125 mcg × 120 doses | €15.74 | |
| 250 mcg × 120 doses | €31.49 | ||
| Budesonide | Budesonida Pulmictan® | 200 mcg × 200 doses | €14.03 |
| 50 mcg × 200 doses | €14.03 | ||
| 200 mcg × 100 doses | €28.07 | ||
| Budesonida Aldo-Union® | 200 mcg × 200 doses | €27.04 | |
| 50 mcg × 200 doses | €14.03 | ||
| 200 mcg × 120 doses | €27.04 | ||
| Miflonide® | 400 mcg × 120 doses | €7.56 | |
| 200 mcg × 60 doses | €13.33 | ||
| 200 mcg ×120 doses | €20.25 | ||
| 400 mcg × 60 doses | €8.41 | ||
| Pulmicort Turbuhaler® | 200 mcg × 100 doses | €16.84 | |
| 100 mcg × 200 doses | €16.84 | ||
| 400 mcg × 100 doses | €33.69 | ||
| Budesonida Easyhaler® | 200 mcg × 200 doses | €7.56 | |
| 100 mcg × 200 doses | €11.11 | ||
| 400 mcg × 100 doses | €20.25 | ||
| Beclometasone | Becotide® | 50 mcg × 200 doses | €3.50 |
| Becloforte® | 250 mcg × 200 doses | €18.98 | |
| Furoate mometasone | Asmanex Twisthaler® | 200 mcg × 60 doses | €29.07 |
| 400 mcg × 60 doses | €51.14 | ||
| Ciclesonide | Alvesco® | 160 mcg × 60 doses | €32.78 |
| Salmeterol | Serevent® | 25 mcg × 120 doses | €35.42 |
| Serevent Accuhaler® | 50 mcg × 60 doses | €37.09 | |
| Beglan® | 25 mcg × 120 doses | €33.97 | |
| Beglan Accuhaler® | 50 mcg × 60 doses | €35.61 | |
| Inaspir® | 25 mcg × 120 doses | €36.98 | |
| Inaspir Accuhaler® | 50 mcg × 60 doses | €38.70 | |
| Formoterol | Neblik® | 12 mcg × 60 doses | €28.33 |
| Formoterol Aldo®/Formoterol Stada® | 12 mcg × 60 doses | €22.54 | |
| Foradill Aerolizer® | 12 mcg × 60 doses | €28.33 | |
| Foradil Neo® | 12 mcg × 50 doses | €23.62 | |
| Formatris Novolizer® | 12 mcg × 60 doses | €26.01 | |
| 6 mcg × 60 doses | €14.17 | ||
| Oxis Turbuhaler® | 4.5 mcg × 60 doses | €10.63 | |
| 9 mcg × 60 doses | €21.26 | ||
| Indacaterol | Onbrez Breezhaler® | 150 mcg × 30 doses | €50.13 |
| 300 mcg × 30 doses | €50.13 | ||
| Olodaterol | Striverdi Respimat® | 2.5 mcg × 60 doses | €41.68 |
| Tiotropium | Spiriva Handiler® | 18 mcg × 30 doses | €49.06 |
| Spiriva Respimat® | 2.5 mcg × 60 doses | €47.61 | |
| Aclidinium | Eklira Genuair® | 322 mcg × 60 doses | €47.61 |
| Glycopirronium | Seebri Breezhaler® | 44 mcg × 30 doses | €47.61 |
| Umeclidinium | Incruse Ellipta® | 55 mcg × 30 doses | €45.27 |
| Propionate Fluticasone/ | Seretide® | 25/50 mcg × 120 doses | €41.28 |
| Salmeterol | 25/125 mcg × 120 doses | €41.28 | |
| 25/250 mcg × 120 doses | €41.28 | ||
| Seretide Accuhaler® | 50/100 mcg × 60 doses | €41.28 | |
| 50/250 mcg × 60 doses | €41.28 | ||
| 50/500 mcg × 60 doses | €41.28 | ||
| Airflusal Forspiro® | 50/250 mcg × 60 doses | €41.28 | |
| 50/500 mcg × 60 doses | €41.28 | ||
| Budesonide/Formoterol | Symbicort Turbuhaler® | 80/4.5 mcg × 120 doses | €51.39 |
| 160/4.5 mcg × 120 doses | €51.39 | ||
| Symbicort Forte Turbuhaler® | 320/9 mcg × 60 doses | €51.39 | |
| DuoResp Spiromax®/Bufomix Easyhaler® | 160/4.5 mcg × 120 doses | €51.39 | |
| 320/9 mcg × 60 doses | €51.39 | ||
| Beclometasone/ | Foster® | 100/6 mcg × 120 doses | €51.52 |
| Formoterol | 200/6 mcg × 120 doses | €51.52 | |
| Foster Nexthaler® | 100/6 mcg × 120 doses | €51.52 | |
| 200/6 mcg × 120 doses | €51.52 | ||
| Propionate Fluticasone/ | Flutiform® | 50/5 mcg × 120 doses | €32.86 |
| Formoterol | 125/5 mcg × 120 doses | €45.79 | |
| 250/10 mcg × 120 doses | €71.81 | ||
| Glycopirronium/ | Ultibro Breezhaler® | 85/43 mcg × 30 doses | €86.02 |
| Indacaterol | |||
| Umeclidinium/Vilanterol | Anoro Ellipta® | 55/22 mcg × 30 doses | €70.25 |
| Aclidinium/Formoterol | Duaklir Genuair® | 340/12 mcg × 60 doses | €70.25 |
| Tiotropium/Olodaterol | Spiolto Respimat® | 2.5/2.5 mcg × 30 doses | €81.49 |
Abbreviations: ICS, inhaled corticosteroids; LABA, long-acting beta-agonists; LAMA, long-acting muscarinic antagonist; PTP + VAT, Price to Public plus Value Added Tax.
Deterministic sensitivity analyses performed
| Parameters modified | Base-case value/s | Alternative value/s |
|---|---|---|
| Adherence to drug treatments (measured with PDC), % | 100 (assumption) | 80–60 (assumptions) |
| % of moderate- to-very-severe COPD patients with a history of exacerbations | With ≥1 exacerbations in the previous year 20.44 | With ≥2 exacerbations in the previous year 12.62 |
| % of COPD- diagnosed patients under drug treatment | 45.3 | 78.8 |
| Increased usage of FF/VI 92/22 mcg on alternative scenario, % | Usage on alternative scenario: FF/VI =10 UC =90 (assumption) | Usage on alternative scenario: FF/VI =20–30 UC =80–70 (assumptions) |
Abbreviations: PDC, proportion of days covered; FF/VI, fluticasone furoate/vilanterol; UC, usual care.
Economic model results
| Scenario assessed | Estimated COPD patients for model calculations | Current scenario | Alternative scenario | Potential cost savings obtained with FF/VI | Impact vs base-case results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base case | 50,522 | €67,749,536 | €67,395,913 | €353,623 | NA |
| PDC to 80% | 50,522 | €60,734,844 | €60,423,782 | €311,062 | –12% |
| PDC to 60% | 50,522 | €53,720,151 | €53,451,650 | €268,501 | –24% |
| % of COPD patients having ≥2 exacerbations in the previous year | 31,193 | €41,829,704 | €41,611,371 | €218,333 | –38% |
| % of COPD patients under drug treatment | 87,884 | €117,851,290 | €117,236,158 | €615,132 | +74% |
| FF/VI usage up to 20% on alternative scenario | 50,522 | €67,749,536 | €66,806,541 | €942,995 | +167% |
| FF/VI usage up to 30% on alternative scenario | 50,522 | €67,749,536 | €66,217,170 | €1,532,366 | +333% |
Abbreviations: PDC, proportion of days covered; FF/VI, fluticasone furoate/vilanterol 92/22 mcg; NA, not applicable.