| Literature DB >> 30189633 |
Md Zulfiker Mahmud1,2, Mohammad Tariqul Islam3,4, Norbahiah Misran5, Ali F Almutairi6, Mengu Cho7.
Abstract
Globally, breast cancer is reported as a primary cause of death in women. More than 1.8 million new breast cancer cases are diagnosed every year. Because of the current limitations on clinical imaging, researchers are motivated to investigate complementary tools and alternatives to available techniques for detecting breast cancer in earlier stages. This article presents a review of concepts and electromagnetic techniques for microwave breast imaging. More specifically, this work reviews ultra-wideband (UWB) antenna sensors and their current applications in medical imaging, leading to breast imaging. We review the use of UWB sensor based microwave energy in various imaging applications for breast tumor related diseases, tumor detection, and breast tumor detection. In microwave imaging, the back-scattered signals radiating by sensors from a human body are analyzed for changes in the electrical properties of tissues. Tumorous cells exhibit higher dielectric constants because of their high water content. The goal of this article is to provide microwave researchers with in-depth information on electromagnetic techniques for microwave imaging sensors and describe recent developments in these techniques.Entities:
Keywords: antenna sensor; breast phantom; breast tumor; dielectric properties; high gain; microwave imaging; ultra-wideband (UWB)
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30189633 PMCID: PMC6165197 DOI: 10.3390/s18092951
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Sensors (Basel) ISSN: 1424-8220 Impact factor: 3.576
Comparison of Diagnostic Performance of different breast tumour detection techniques [14].
| Modality | Sensitivity | Specificity | Positive Predictive Value | Accuracy | Advantages | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mammography | 67.8% (120/177) | 75% (61/81) | 85.7% (120/140) | 70.2% (181/258) | Low cost | False positive and negative diagnoses |
| Mammography and clinical examination | 77.4% (137/177) | 72% (58/81) | 58.6% (137/160) | 75.6% (195/258) | Low cost | Lower accuracy |
| Clinical examination | 50.3% (89/177) | 92% (75/81) | 94% (89/95) | 63.6% (164/258) | Simple and easy process | Small tumor cannot detect |
| Ultrasound | 83% (147/177) | 34% (28/81) | 73.5% (147/200) | 67.8% (175/258) | Better than X-ray | Difficult to detect deep-lying or solid tumor |
| Mammography and ultra sound | 91.5% (162/177) | 23% (19/81) | 72.3% (162/224) | 70.2% (181/258) | Cost effective | Exists unwanted compression |
| Mammography ultrasound and clinical examination | 93.2% (165/177) | 22% (18/81) | 72.4% (165/228) | 70.9% (183/258) | Good candidate for detection | Complex signal processing |
| MRI | 94.4% (167/177) | 26% (21/81) | 73.6% (167/227) | 72.9% (188/258) | Provide high resolution images | Higher cost and time-consuming process |
| Mammography, clinical examination, and MRI | 99.4% (176/177) | 7% (6/81) | 70.1% (176/251) | 70.5% (182/258) | Best solution ever found | Complex procedure, higher cost and time-consuming process |
Figure 1Basic microwave imaging problem (a) Reflected waves from breast without a tumor (b) Reflected waves from breast with a tumor. Changes indicate differences from tumor-free breast [15].
Figure 2Microwave Imaging system at Dartmouth College [37].
Figure 32D microwave tomography (MWT) system for soft tissue imaging and physiological activity detection [44].
Figure 4(a) Simulation setup of the antenna in a dielectric medium with microwave absorbing sheet on top surface (b) Imaging setup with compressed phantom and two antennas [55].
Figure 5Schematic block diagram of microwave imaging [59].
Figure 6Photograph of the 3D imaging system [59].
Figure 7Block diagram of the array radar [60].
Figure 8The system configuration of an ultra-wideband (UWB) radar [61].
Figure 9Experimental setup of working prototype [63].
Summarized Table of UWB imaging.
| Origin | Imaging Domain | Antenna Configuration | Targets | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dartmouth College [ | Cylindrical tank (agar gel, corn syrup, water mixer) | 16 antennas Mechanical scanning | Detecting malignant tumors | 2D and 3D images |
| University of Bristol [ | Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene plastic half sphere | UWB radar | Measure the symptomatic patients | First real breast phantom but limitations in terms of resolution and clutter rejection |
| Carolinas medical center [ | Metallic tank 21.5 cm in diameter | 24 waveguide antennas | Detection of physiological activity of soft tissues | 2D and 3D tomographic images of swine torso obtained |
| University of Calgary [ | Tank with canola oil | Single balanced antipodal antenna with mechanical scanning | Pilot clinical experiment | Consistent imaging results |
| University of Manitoba [ | Plexiglass tank with canola oil | Single Vivaldi antenna | Pre-clinical UWB prototype | Improvements to quantitative dielectric image |
| University Rovira [ | Water filled Cylindrical glass tank | UWB disc monopole antenna | Working prototype for microwave imaging | Tumor position was detected |
| University of Queensland [ | Plastic container filled with canola oil | 12 UWB antennas | UWB biomedical imaging | Mutual coupling and fidelity |
| McGill University [ | Hemispherical ceramic (Al2O3) radome | 16 elements antenna array | Clinical testing | First study of microwave time domain with actual volunteers |
| Politecnico di Torino [ | Metallic Cylinder | Monopole 8 element antenna array | Design and construction of imaging prototype | 2D imaging at MiMed cost meeting |
| Duke University [ | Rectangular tub filled with fluid | Two dipole antennas | 3D imaging system prototype | 5 mm diameter dielectric objects detected |
| Toyohashi University of Technology [ | Rectangular tub with cooking oil | UWB Vivaldi antennas | Breast cancer tumor detection | 9 mm metallic ball detected |
| Technical University of Denmark [ | Water filled spheres | 32 monopole antennas | 20 to 40 mm target objects detection | 3D images are obtained with consuming more than 100 min |
| McMaster University [ | Glycerin based flat artificial phantom | 2 TEM horn antenna | 3D model and phantom analysis where antenna directly contacted imaged body | Image de-blurred using blind deconvolution algorithm |