| Literature DB >> 30187008 |
Anina du Toit1, Chrisma Pretorius1.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Countries in sub-Saharan Africa are plagued by poor healthcare facilities, lack of specialist care, and limited financial resources. People with seizures often rely on the help of traditional health practitioners (THPs). Traditional health practices are not acknowledged in Namibia and remain unregulated and open to exploitation. We conducted a qualitative study to gain an understanding of THPs' perceptions and experiences in delivering seizure care in Namibia.Entities:
Keywords: Epilepsy; Namibia; Qualitative; Seizures; Sub‐Saharan Africa; Traditional healers
Year: 2018 PMID: 30187008 PMCID: PMC6119750 DOI: 10.1002/epi4.12240
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Epilepsia Open ISSN: 2470-9239
Demographic information of participants
| P | Age | Gender | Ethnicity | Type of healer | Years in practice |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 69 | F | Damara/Nama | Traditional | 39 |
| 2 | 72 | F | Oshivambo | Traditional | 51 |
| 3 | 59 | F | Afrikaans | Religious | 7 |
| 4 | 66 | F | Herero | Traditional | 39 |
| 5 | 73 | M | Oshivambo | Herbalist/Spiritualist | 26 |
| 6 | 42 | M | Herero | Spiritualist | 21 |
| 7 | 40 | M | Herero | Traditional | 30 |
| 8 | 46 | M | Herero | Traditional | 27 |
| 9 | 50 | M | Herero | Traditional | 35 |
| 10 | 30 | M | Nyanja | Diviner | 8 |
| 11 | 65 | F | Afrikaans | Spiritualist/Diviner | 12 |
| Mean 55.6 | M: 55% | 6B;2M;7W | Median 27 |
P, participant; F, female; M, male.
Questions that were used to guide the interviews
| Number | Questions |
|---|---|
| 1 | What do you classify as a seizure and what do you think are the possible causes? |
| 2 | How do you explain the seizures to the patient and what is their reaction? |
| 3 | How do you treat seizures? How successful is it? |
| 4 | What kind of contact do you have with Western doctors or hospitals and do you think Western medicine can work for seizures? |
| 5 | In your opinion, what problems do people with seizures experience? |
Figure 1A graphical illustration of the main themes and subthemes according to the different levels of the Ecological Systems Theory.
Emergent main themes and illustrative quotes
| Main theme | Illustrative quote |
|---|---|
| Diagnosis | “I ask for their medical history and I also look to the Bible for guidance. Once it has been revealed that it is epilepsy I tell them the revelations given to me by the Holy Spirit. I explain to them what it is and that it is an evil spirit not sent from God and how I will be treating them.” (Q1) |
| “It can be spiritual or it can be medical. If it is medical, it means that the individual is able to go for treatment and then the doctors are able to heal the person through medication. By spiritual I mean, it's a demonic occurrence depending on a person's background.” (Q2) | |
| “If the epilepsy is from a car accident it is treated by the medical doctors.” (Q3) | |
| “If the epilepsy is from the witchcraft it is not for Western medicine.” (Q4) | |
| “Some people come from families where there is deep demonic involvement like witchcraft, where somebody is maybe jealous of a person and they get bewitched.” (Q5) | |
| “The doctors can't see any problem with them, so they've been lying in a hospital for such a long time without having been helped because doctors can only treat people when they know what exactly happened with this person. If the doctor doesn't know exactly what happened they evict them from the hospital and then they tell them to go to the traditional healer.” (Q6) | |
| “Doctors are doing their best, but there are some cases which are beyond medical science which now becomes spiritual.” (Q7) | |
| Treatment | “The treatment is not purely for each and every person the same, it depends on the guidance of the spirit.” (Q8) |
| “Steaming with some herbs that I put in the water or I normally induce vomiting by giving them some herbs from the field.” (Q9) | |
| “Whether it is the one where it is biting the tongue, or for one that was nearby the fire, or for children up to 10 years.” (Q10) | |
| “Oh yes it really, really works. I know because the patients come back to tell me that the treatment worked and they normally stop having seizures. All of those that I treated do come back and tell me.” (Q11) | |
| “Treatment depends on how long this sickness took to get into the body. Up to 2 weeks or 2 months, depending on the person.” (Q12) | |
| “If it is difficult for the epilepsy to be removed by us, then hospital is a priority or for proper verification that a person is really healed.” (Q13) | |
| “Doctors and the traditional healers work in conjunction. We work together so the patient will tell the doctor that I am coming from a traditional healer or that I am going to go to a traditional healer. It is no secret.” (Q14) | |
| “This of witchcraft and inherited cannot be treated by hospital medicines because the hospital gives tablets and medicines, but they don't help 100 per cent and the tablets are not for curing. It's just to make it better.” (Q15) | |
| “The medication they get usually just subsides the symptoms, but they don't totally heal the disease.” (Q16) | |
| Patients | “The person is the only one that will know how he got that epilepsy. Maybe it is an inherited disease from ancestors.” (Q17) |
| Disobeying of the commandments, so the person is punished by God, thinking too much or magic powers passed from people.” (Q18) | |
| “Epilepsy comes from witchcraft, to be bewitched. Or when the baby falls down from the bed, swelling in the brain. The other sort come from depression. Once you have overloaded with many problems. Boyfriends, girlfriends, lifestyle and these type of things, so you become depressed. The other type comes from the environment like evil spirits. When we face years of drought or rain, those years you can get more people that has epilepsy during a particular year.” (Q19) | |
| “The black community are not living in a conducive environment in terms of food and the water that we are drinking and sanitation. It is something that people should avoid for them to get rid of the disease. If people are hungry or thirsty, or if they drink too much it also brings the epilepsy.” (Q20) | |
| “I think it does affect their progress in life. People are not able to get job interviews and are not able to work for a long time because of such seizures.” (Q21) | |
| “When they get this attack during the night when they are sleeping and they are maybe alone, they may die due to respiratory problems.” (Q22) | |
| Knowledge | “I got it at birth because I came out feet first and I was wrapped up in the placenta, but it was not my placenta. It was just a cover. So it was a special birth because I came out feet first, I was protected and I have a twin. So in our tribe that is a very strong spiritual kind of birth. Once a person is born like that that it is obvious that he is a healer, that he has a spiritual gift.” (Q23) |
| “A seizure is like a fit which a person can get and it can become so bad that the person even urinates and falls down. They don't know where they are and what happened. There is crying and they make a noise and one can see it in the eyes.” (Q24) | |
| “Such as ones that occur when you are sleeping, others occur when you are hungry and thirsty. Some occur while you are walking down the street and you fall down and have a fit. Another one is when the person is under heat (fever) or finally, a person is born with it.” (Q25) | |
| “There must be a kind of referral system from the healer to the hospital because sometimes this disease is for the medical doctors. The healers also need to be trained and told that they refer them back to the hospital if it is difficult to treat the epilepsy.” (Q26) | |
| “Some of the medicine from the Western doctors also work for epilepsy because the spirit says so.” (Q27) | |
| “Your doctor has to tell you to stop the medicine” and “We encourage them to go to the doctor for the follow‐ups.” (Q28) | |
| “The only thing that can rectify this epilepsy from the community is if the hospital or the hygienic medical doctors can acknowledge that here in the black communities, our people can heal the disease and then refer those people to the black healers. It will most probably help.” (Q29) | |
| “They don't have papers. They scramble the people's heads and they ask a lot of money. They take everything that the people own like TVs and furniture. It's a robbing business that.” (Q30) | |
| “Some of these healers are not entirely honest and sometimes they hurt the people. Some are really bad. It's a money problem but there are lot of impostors.” (Q31) |