| Literature DB >> 30177615 |
Yang Liu1,2,3, Terry L Erwin4, Xingke Yang5.
Abstract
Mordellidae (tumbling flower beetles) is a globally distributed family of Coleoptera; it is among the most species-rich families (containing 115 genera and 2308 species described). It is important because of its agroforestry significance and its ecosystem-sustaining attributes. However, the past and current status of Mordellidae research remains unclear. A comprehensive literature review of Mordellidae articles published over the period of 1864⁻2013 based on the Zoological Record was conducted for the first time. A total of 863 articles were used for analysis after a strict literature search using screening protocols. These articles were then assigned to four categories based on the year of publication, topics/themes, primary authors, and frequently utilized journals for publication of Mordellidae-related articles. The results reveal that: (1) there are three prosperous research periods (1876⁻1898, 1922⁻1957, and 1977⁻2012) for Mordellidae during 1864⁻2013 that are associated with the active period of three generations of the main taxonomists. However, it is unfortunate that it also demonstrates there is a lack of upcoming researchers to continue the work after the retirement of the current generation, thus action should be taken immediately to promote research on Mordellidae; (2) on average, each primary author published 3.1 papers, but ~35% of the Mordellidae articles were published by less than 3% of the primary authors; (3) researchers tended to mostly publish their articles in local journals of their home countries; (4) more than 90% of the articles pertain to traditional taxonomy, with those of early times generally containing only simple descriptions of the species and the holotypes chosen are sparsely deposited with the researchers or amateurs around the world, thus making them difficult to be checked; (5) nearly half of the studies described Mordellidae species from Palaearctic realm, about one-third of the studies described species in other areas rather than in the fauna in which the authors lived, and about two-fifths of the studies described species from countries outside of the authors' country of origin. Therefore, the in-depth systematic study of worldwide Mordellidae is required to reconstruct Mordellidae phylogeny and a revision of its classification system with modern methods of comparative morphology, molecular biology, zoogeography, and cladistics. In order to better understand the life stages and biology of Mordellidae insects, more work on Mordellidae ecology should be undertaken to develop strategies for pest control. We hope that this review will provide information to the novice and expert alike in Mordellidae research pertaining to its past and current status, possible future research areas, and attract more attention from the scientific world and renew an interest in Mordellidae research.Entities:
Keywords: Mordellidae; Zoological Record; academic literature review; classification framework; list of generic taxa with citation
Year: 2018 PMID: 30177615 PMCID: PMC6165378 DOI: 10.3390/insects9030113
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Insects ISSN: 2075-4450 Impact factor: 2.769
Figure 1Annual number of articles on Mordellidae over the period from 1864 through 2013.
The distribution of articles by journals.
| Journals | Article Number |
|---|---|
| Vestnik Zoologii | 54 |
| Bulletin de la Societe Entomologique de France | 52 |
| Elytra | 50 |
| Entomologist’s Monthly Magazine | 46 |
| Entomological Review of Japan | 34 |
| L’Echange, Revue Linnéenne | 28 |
| Acta Entomologica Bohemoslovaca | 26 |
| Canadian Entomologist | 26 |
| Deutsche Entomologische Zeitschrift | 26 |
| Entomologische Blaetter Krefeld | 26 |
| Reichenbachia | 26 |
| Bollettino della Societa Entomologica Italiana | 24 |
| Entomologische Blaetter fuer Biologie und Systematik der Kaefer | 24 |
| Melanges Exotico–Entomologiques Moulins | 24 |
| Transactions of the Entomological Society of London | 24 |
| Notulae Entomologicae | 22 |
| Coleopterists’ News | 20 |
| Annales de la Societe Entomologique de France | 18 |
| Coleopterists Bulletin | 18 |
| Entomologische Berichten | 18 |
| Entomologist’s Record and Journal of Variation | 18 |
| Proceedings of the Linnean Society of New South Wales | 18 |
| Annales de la Societe Entomologique de Belgique | 15 |
| Acta Societatis Zoologicae Bohemicae | 14 |
| Berliner Entomologische Zeitschrift | 14 |
| Memorie della Societa Entomologica Italiana | 14 |
| Annali del Museo Civico di Storia Naturale “Giacomo Doria” | 12 |
| Annals & Magazine of Natural History | 12 |
| Bulletin of the Osaka Museum of Natural History | 12 |
| Coleopterist | 12 |
| Environmental Entomology | 12 |
| Insecta Matsumurana Sapporo | 12 |
| Kaefer Europas | 12 |
| Pan–Pacific Entomologist | 12 |
| Proceedings of the Royal Entomological Society of London | 12 |
| Special Bulletin of the Japanese Society of Coleopterology | 12 |
| Studies and Reports of District Museum Prague–East Taxonomical Series | 12 |
| Transactions of the Royal Society of South Australia | 12 |
| Annals of Natural History | 10 |
| Arkiv for Zoologi Stockholm | 10 |
| Bulletin of the Brooklyn Entomological Society | 10 |
| Ecological Entomology | 10 |
| Revue Francaise d’Entomologie | 10 |
| Total | 863 |
Figure 2The distribution of articles by journal.
The distribution of articles by primary authors, years, and countries.
| Name | Period | Article Number | Country |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pic, M. | 1899–1954 | 64 | France |
| Ermisch, K. | 1940–1972 | 58 | Germany |
| Franciscolo, M. | 1942–2001 | 57 | Italy |
| Horak, J. | 1978–2012 | 41 | Czech |
| Takakuwa, M. | 1976–2010 | 38 | Japan |
| Odnosum, V.K. | 1983–2009 | 33 | Ukraine |
| Champin, G.C. | 1890–1927 | 23 | Britain |
| Fairmaire, L. | 1891–1906 | 18 | France |
| Batten, R. | 1976–1990 | 15 | The Netherlands |
| Ray, E. | 1930–1947 | 15 | USA |
| Blair, K.G. | 1915–1942 | 13 | Britain |
| Nomura, S. | 1957–1967 | 11 | Japan |
| Lea, A.M. | 1895–1931 | 11 | Australia |
| Nakane, T. | 1949–1960 | 10 | Japan |
| Kolbe, H. | 1910–1934 | 10 | German |
| Chobaut, A. | 1892–1924 | 10 | France |
| Kangas, E. | 1976–1988 | 9 | Finland |
| Schilsky, J. | 1895–1910 | 9 | Germany |
| Tsuru, T. | 2002–2012 | 8 | Japan |
| Shiyake, S. | 1994–2001 | 8 | Japan |
| Allen, A.A. | 1975–2007 | 8 | Britain |
| Chujo, M. | 1935–1964 | 8 | Japan |
| Roubal, J. | 1921–1935 | 7 | German |
| Kiyoyama, Y. | 1875–2010 | 7 | Japan |
| Lu, W. | 1997–2009 | 6 | America |
| Kubisz, D. | 2000–2010 | 5 | Poland |
| Liljeblad, E. | 1917–1945 | 5 | USA |
| Wickham, H.F. | 1909–1914 | 5 | USA |
| Xambeu, V. | 1893–1908 | 5 | France |
| Blackburn, T. | 1891–1893 | 5 | Australia |
List of Mordellidae Generic Taxa.
| Family | Subfamily | Tribe | Genus | Sugenus | Citation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mordellidae | Latreille, 1802 | ||||
| Ctenidiinae | Franciscolo, 1951a: 56 | ||||
|
| Laporte de Castelnau in Brullé, 1840 | ||||
| Mordellinae | Latreille, 1802 | ||||
| Conaliini | Ermisch, 1956 | ||||
|
| Mulsant & Rey, 1858: 313 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968c: 225 | ||||
|
| LeConte, 1862: 47–48 | ||||
|
| Liljeblad, 1945: 18 [North America] | ||||
|
| Horak, 2010: 558 [Indonesia: West Papua] | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968: 33–34 | ||||
|
| Horak, 2008: 78–79 [Madagascar] | ||||
|
| Emery, 1876: 13 | ||||
|
| Horak, 2007: 60 [Vietnam] | ||||
|
| Horak, 2007: 66 [Philippines] | ||||
|
| Horak, 2010: 549 [Malaysia: Malayan Peninsula: Perak; Sabah; Indonesia: Kalimantan, Sumatra, Ambon, Seram Island, Tanimbar Archipelago: Yamdena] | ||||
|
| French, 1933: 33–35 | ||||
|
| Emery, 1876: 13 | ||||
|
| Chujo, 1957: 11 | ||||
|
| Chujo, 1957: 14–16 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968: 268 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969: 312 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968c: 237 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 73 | ||||
|
| Sharp & Muir, 1912: 555 | ||||
| Pseudoconalia | Ermisch, 1950: 72 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 73 [Indonesia: Sumatra] | ||||
|
| Nakane, 1957: 49–50 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 24 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1952: 56 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968 | ||||
|
| Quedenfeldt, 1886: 128 | ||||
|
| Horak, 1994: 191 | ||||
|
| Xambeu, 1908: 284 | ||||
|
| Mulsant, 1856: 39, 426 | ||||
|
| Horak, 2007: 78 [China] | ||||
|
| Liljeblad, 1945: 206 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1967: 130 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1952: 100 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 87 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1942 | ||||
| Mordellini | Siedlitz, 1875 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1965 | ||||
|
| Hong, 2002: 126 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 63 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1943: 1297 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1985: 79 [Ecuador] | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1943: 297, 298 | ||||
|
| Blair, 1922: 222 | ||||
|
| Pic, 1932: 30 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1952: 350 [New Guinea Island] | ||||
|
| Emery, 1876: 8, 10 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1987: 225 | ||||
|
| Huang & Yang, 1999: 125 | ||||
|
| Méquignon, 1946: 58 | ||||
|
| Leconte, 1862: 43 | ||||
|
| LeConte, 1859: 17 | ||||
|
| Nakane, 1960: 17 | ||||
|
| Nomura, 1967: 7 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1952: 347 [New Guinea Island] | ||||
|
| Kono, 1928: 30 | ||||
|
| Kônô, 1935: 124 | ||||
|
| Méquignon, 1946: 59 [Europe] | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 2000: 395 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968: 279 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968: 263 | ||||
|
| Wang, 1993: 87 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1943: 34 | ||||
|
| Píc, 1922: 208 | ||||
|
| Mequignon, 1946 | ||||
|
| Liu, Lu & Ren, 2007 | ||||
|
| Linnaeus, 1758: 420 | ||||
|
| Mequignon, 1946: 62 | ||||
|
| Mequignon, 1946: 60 | ||||
|
| De Bone, 1865: 278 | ||||
|
| Mequignon, 1946: 63 | ||||
|
| Mequignon, 1946: 62 | ||||
|
| Ray, 1930a: 143 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 69 | ||||
|
| Schilsky, 1908 [ | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1958: 386 | ||||
|
| Ray, 1939 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1955: 179 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1949: 1 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1952 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1952: 332 [New Guinea Island] | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1952: 344 [New Guinea Island] | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 10 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1952: 353 [New Guinea] | ||||
|
| Takakuwa & Masatoshi, 2000: 64 | ||||
|
| Píc, 1936: 259 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968: 265 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969: 4 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 60 [Brazil: Brasilien] | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 5 | ||||
|
| Chujo, 1957: 1 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1954 | ||||
|
| Píc, 1922: 15, 17 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1954: 170 | ||||
|
| Shchegoleva-Barovskaya, 1929: 27 | ||||
|
| Shchegoleva-Barovskaya, 1929: 27 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 52 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1950 | ||||
|
| Ermisch & Chûjô, 1968 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 17 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1941: 115 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 57 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1954: 92 | ||||
|
| Kubisz & Daniel, 2001: 273 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 69 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 13 | ||||
|
| Costa, 1854: 8 | ||||
|
| Chujo, 1957: 1 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 53 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1950: 130 | ||||
|
| Méquignon, 1946 | ||||
|
| Horak, 1985: 15 | ||||
|
| Batten, 1977: 167 | ||||
|
| Mequignon, 1946 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1952: 69 | ||||
|
| Kônô, 1935: 124 [Japan] | ||||
|
| Broun, 1886: 84 | ||||
| Mordellistenini | Ermisch, 1941 | ||||
|
| Shiyake, 2000: 26 | ||||
|
| Champion, 1891: 307 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969: 304 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969: 307 | ||||
|
| Normand, 1916: 284 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969: 301 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1941: 724 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1953: 316 | ||||
|
| Nomura, 1966: 44 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1941: 715, 725 | ||||
|
| Lu, 2009: 119 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950a: 85 | ||||
|
| Kubisz, 2003: 185 (Eocene Fossil) | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1965 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1941: 715, 723 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 81 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1950: 7 | ||||
|
| Schilsky, 1908: 137 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1967: 133 | ||||
|
| Nomura, 1966: 49 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1952a: 145 | ||||
|
| Linne, 1758: 420 | ||||
| Franciscolo, 1955: 1062 | |||||
|
| Blair, 1921: 281 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1942:133 | ||||
|
| Schilsky, 1908: 137 | ||||
|
| Costa, 1854 | ||||
|
| Stshegoleva-Barovskaja, 1930: 56 | ||||
|
| Emery, 1876: 80 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1952: 47 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1951(1952): 143, 145 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1958: 376 [Congo] | ||||
|
| Horák, 1982 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1941: 589 | ||||
|
| Stchegoleva-Barowskaja, 1930 | ||||
|
| Emery, 1876: 80 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969: 311 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1950b: 6 | ||||
|
| Emery, 1876 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 52 | ||||
|
| Batten, 1981: 348 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969: 312 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1969 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 73 | ||||
|
| Píc, 1922 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1955: 184 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1941: 714, 720 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1950: 86 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1956: 227 | ||||
|
| Horak, 2008: 67–68 [Madagascar] | ||||
|
| Horak, 2008: 72 [Madagascar] | ||||
|
| Mulsant, 1856 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1951 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1942: 674 | ||||
|
| Kiyoyama & Yoshimi, 1991: 53 | ||||
|
| Kiyoyama & Yoshimi 1991: 54 | ||||
|
| Horák, 1990: 141 | ||||
|
| Ermisch, 1968 | ||||
| Reynoldsiellini | Franciscolo, 1957: 237 | ||||
|
| Ray, 1930: 164 | ||||
| Stenaliini | Franciscolo, 1955: 1056 | ||||
|
| Horák, 1989: 37 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1950: 130 | ||||
|
| Mulsant, 1856: 83, 387 | ||||
|
| Franciscolo, 1956: 219 |