Sensorineural hearing loss and mild cardiac phenotype caused by an EYA4 mutation.

EYA4 is a member of the vertebrate eya gene family of transcriptional activators and plays several roles in both embryonic and inner ear development. The majority of EYA4 gene mutations are associated with autosomal dominant non-syndromic hearing loss (DFNA10). In addition, some mutations in this gene cause autosomal dominant syndromic hearing loss with dilated cardiomyopathy. EYA4 is a rare cause of sensorineural hearing loss, and only a limited number of papers regarding mutations in this gene have been published. Thus, detailed clinical features remain unclear. We conducted next-generation sequencing of a Japanese individual with progressive sensorineural hearing loss and identified an EYA4 pathogenic variant. Pure-tone audiometry revealed bilateral, nearly symmetric, moderate sensorineural hearing loss in the low and middle frequencies. Minor abnormalities were observed on the patient's electrocardiogram and echocardiography without any apparent symptoms. Next-generation sequencing is effective in elucidating the etiology of hearing loss, and the present findings suggested the possible phenotypic expansion of deafness caused by EYA4 gene mutations.

Hearing loss is the most frequent sensory defect in humans, demonstrating different patterns of inheritance and involving a multitude of different genes. To date, ~180 non-syndromic hereditary sensory hearing loss loci and more than 100 corresponding genes have been identified[1].

EYA4 is a member of the vertebrate eya gene family of transcriptional activators that interact with other proteins, such as the sine oculis homeobox (SIX)  protein family, to ensure normal embryologic development[2]. Moreover, EYA4 also plays several roles in the mature inner ear system[2, 3]. The majority of EYA4 gene mutations are associated with autosomal dominant non-syndromic hearing loss (DFNA10) (OMIM:# 601316)[4-6]. In addition, some mutations in this gene cause autosomal dominant syndromic hearing loss with dilated cardiomyopathy (OMIM:# 605362)[7]. EYA4 is a rare causative gene of sensorineural hearing loss and only a limited number of papers regarding mutations in this gene have been published. Thus, the complete picture with regard to the clinical features associated with these gene mutations remains unclear.

Remarkable recent advances in molecular genetics technology, particularly in the clinical applications of next-generation sequencing technology, have made it easier to identify disease-causing genes in a relatively short period and at low cost. Here, we report a Japanese individual with progressive sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) in whom an EYA4 pathogenic variant was identified.

A 43-year-old Japanese male from a non-inbred family presented to our hospital to clarify the cause of his hearing loss. His maternal grandmother, mother, maternal uncle, and sister also have late-onset hearing loss (after acquisition of language) (Fig. 1a). The proband’s family inheritance matches both autosomal dominant and maternal modes of inheritance. This study was approved by the local ethics committee, and written informed consent was obtained from each participating individual.

Fig. 1

a Pedigree and b audiometric configurations of the proband (P). Closed symbols indicate affected individuals. The high frequency hearing thresholds of this patient progressed over the follow-up period and eventually showed flat-type moderate hearing loss

The patient’s hearing loss was first noticed during a checkup at age 26. He began wearing a hearing aid at age 36. Further deterioration in his hearing was recognized subjectively at 40 years of age due to loud noises associated with his work as a carpenter. At the age of 41, his tinnitus and hearing loss further worsened after exposure to loud firework explosions. No noticeable effects were observed upon treatment with various medications, including steroids. Clinically, he has no accompanying disease or disorder, but abnormalities in his electrocardiograms have been observed since his second decade of life.

Pure-tone audiometry revealed bilateral, nearly symmetric, moderate SNHL with hearing loss in the low and middle frequencies. The hearing loss was progressive, and an audiogram at age 43 showed hearing loss at all frequencies with a flat pattern (Fig. 1b). He has normal verbal function and experiences few problems with regard to linguistic communication when wearing hearing aids. He has no complaints of vestibular symptoms.

There was insufficient power in the kindreds to perform linkage studies, and we could not obtain consent from any of his family members. Thus, molecular diagnosis was performed using genomic DNA extracted from the peripheral blood of the proband alone. In the primary screening using the Invader assay[8], no mutations were observed upon examination of 46 known mutations in 13 deafness genes. Secondary screening using comprehensive next-generation sequencing analysis for 63 genes reported to cause hearing impairment was performed as described previously[9].

As a result of this genetic analysis, a heterozygous variation EYA4:NM_004100.4:c.1177 C > T:p.Q393X (in exon13) (hg19:chr6:g.133804239 C > T) was identified in the eyes absent 4 gene (EYA4, OMIM: *603550) in this patient. This result was confirmed by Sanger sequencing. This variation was previously reported as a pathogenic variant in a non-syndromic SNHL Korean pedigree[10]. This variant was absent in the 1,000 Genomes Project; 6,500 Exome Variant Server; 333 healthy controls in the Shinshu University Project; Human Genetic Variation Database and 2KJPN for the Japanese population databases; and the 1,000 controls of Iowa University. Only one case carrying this variant was present in the Exome Aggregation Consortium database (1/121,170 alleles, allele frequency = 0.000008). According to the pathogenicity classification based on the Association College of Medical Genetics (ACMG)[11], we regard the p.Q393X variant as “pathogenic”.

Most patients harboring EYA4 mutations present with non-syndromic SNHL, but some also experience dilated cardiomyopathy and heart failure accompanied by SNHL[7]. We, therefore, performed a detailed cardiac examination to confirm whether the patient had a non-syndromic phenotype. His electrocardiogram revealed an abnormal Q wave at V1 and V2 (Fig. 2a); however, the cardiologist evaluated it to be within the normal range. Echocardiography revealed mild mitral valve regurgitation from the left ventricle to the left atrium (Fig. 2b), but this was judged not to affect cardiac function. No problems were observed with the left ventricular dilatation or contractility. At present, the patient suffers subclinical heart disease not related to dilated cardiomyopathy.

Fig. 2

Results of the proband’s a electrocardiogram and b echocardiograph. The electrocardiogram revealed a minor abnormality in the Q wave at V1 and V2, while the echocardiography revealed mild mitral valve regurgitation from the left ventricle to the left atrium

Allele variants in EYA4 cause inherited autosomal dominant hearing loss linked to the DFNA10 locus[4-6] and are also associated with dilated cardiomyopathy in some cases[7]. Up to 13 mutations in EYA4 have been reported in several autosomal dominant inherited hearing loss families with a similar phenotype worldwide[12-14]. Of the reported EYA4 mutations, five are located in the eya-homologous region (HR), and eight are located in the variable region of the EYA4 transcripts. The affected individual in this study carrying p.Q393X showed a similar progression of hearing deterioration to that observed in DFNA10 patients[15]. Further, the audiometric configuration of the previously reported Korean SNHL pedigree with the same mutation resembles that of the patient in this study[10]. It is therefore possible that both a mutational hot spot and founder effect are involved.

The dilated cardiomyopathy caused by EYA4 gene mutations is a rare associated symptom. However, it should be noted that some cardiac abnormalities (such as aortic regurgitation, tricuspid regurgitation, inferior wall hypokinesis, or mild concentric hypertrophy) were detected by echocardiography in three of nine cases with EYA4 mutations[6]. In terms of gene expression, EYA4 is expressed in the heart and the inner ear[16]. Normal cardiac gene expression is sensitive to the concentration of EYA4-SIX complexes;[5] therefore, a partial EYA4 deficiency may induce small cardiac abnormalities despite a clinically normal status. Even in asymptomatic patients, it is possible to avoid overlooking potential cardiac degradation leading to more serious conditions, such as heart failure, by cardiac examination. The present data suggest that EYA4-associated hearing loss possibly exhibits an extensive spectrum of conditions ranging from minor abnormalities showing clinically normal heart function to dilated cardiomyopathy. It is hypothesized that the susceptibility to cardiomyopathy may be determined by the mutational position on the EYA4 transcripts;[6] however, no information of any genotype–phenotype correlation is currently available. Any such correlation will become clearer as data are accumulated in the future.

Next-generation sequencing is an effective strategy for elucidating the etiology of hearing loss with high genetic heterogeneity, and our findings will provide a basis for further exploration of the pathological mechanisms and appropriate counseling for patients with EYA4 mutations.

In this paper, we report a Japanese patient with progressive sensorineural hearing loss carrying a rare autosomal dominant EYA4 gene mutation. Minor abnormalities were observed on the patient’s electrocardiogram and echocardiography without any apparent symptoms. The present findings suggested the possible phenotypic expansion of deafness caused by EYA4 gene mutations.